Improve messaging to display clear warning when missing snogrb file#3317
Conversation
- Add INFO echo to state which snogrb file will be used in log - Also fix bug with res setting in exgdas_enkf_sfc.sh Resolves bugzilla 1373 Refs NOAA-EMC#2500
- Add "FATAL ERROR" message if either snogrb file is missing. - Update COMIN/COMOUT variable settings (needed) Refs NOAA-EMC#2500
Combine the INFO and FATAL ERROR messaging for snogrb files into the same if-block. Refs NOAA-EMC#2500
CoryMartin-NOAA
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
one suggestion in several places just to make things clearer in the logs
|
After looking at the script logic more closely, I think there is a way to avoid a FATAL error. Note this logic. New snow is only created once per day (around 00z), but there are snow files every six hours. In most cases, these are simply copies of the 00z file with a new file name. Snow is only applied in the cycling if there is new snow. Hence, the check here on the internal date/time stamp. If FNSNOA and FNSNOG contain the same time stamp, the snow update is shut off by setting FNSNOW="" and CYCLVARS to 99999. If FNSNOA or FNSNOG are missing, the same settings could be done and a WARNING message be printed. The script will continue, and the cycling will not update snow. The snow data is created by an upstream job which has a logic to always populate FNSNOA and FNSNOG files. So I can't envision this ever happening. But if it does, we can continue running and have the SPA investigate the warning. |
|
If I understand the discussion above, we don't want to |
Yes, print a warning, but these variables also must be set: |
Gotcha. Set those for both the missing current cycle and previous cycle snogrb files? Should these if-blocks get merged for any reason? Like: |
|
Something like (not sure the syntax is exactly correct): I think that will work. There may be a way to combine the first two branches. Also, how is $snoprv set when GETGES is called? Can we do a '-f' check on it? |
When If I tried that by hardcoding |
|
@GeorgeGayno-NOAA checking in on your thoughts from my last comment. Thanks! |
If |
JessicaMeixner-NOAA
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Approve these changes to the wave related files, did not look at others.
@GeorgeGayno-NOAA please see the updated changeset in this PR. I removed the usage of |
|
@KateFriedman-NOAA - we can avoid a FATAL error and instead issue a warning. On Hera, see my updates to How can we test this? |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Looking through @GeorgeGayno-NOAA's suggestions in /scratch2/NCEPDEV/stmp1/George.Gayno/global-workflow/scripts/exglobal_atmos_sfcanl.sh, I think I am OK with issuing a warning instead of a FATAL ERROR. I've added suggestions from his script (please check my suggestions, George). Thoughts @KateFriedman-NOAA?
Similar changes would need to be added to exgdas_enkf_sfc.sh.
|
@GeorgeGayno-NOAA I think we could test this locally in a one-off test case by adding an |
Sounds good. I am happy to look at test results. |
|
@GeorgeGayno-NOAA Please see the following log on Hera: I added the suggested file removal from @DavidHuber-NOAA and it worked to show some of the logic. 1) The t1534 snow file was removed from the obs folder, 2) the lower res file isn't available so it set it for the t1534 file, 3) the t1534 file isn't available (since we removed it), so it kicked off the WARNING message. |
The logic is working. Do you want to test the other possible permutations? |
Yep, rerunning with the prior file also missing. Will share log and snippet when run. |
|
Logic works when both current and previous snow files are missing. See log: Any other condition to test? |
If we want to be thorough, we should test the case when the current data is available, but the previous cycle data is missing. |
|
Good thinking...see this rerun with the current file in place but not the prior: |
Looks good. The logic is working. So, did we satisfy the bugzilla? |
Yes, the bugzilla asked us to "produce a clear warning if the file is missing". I believe that has been achieved in this PR. @GeorgeGayno-NOAA Please proceed with approving if you're good with the changes and we'll update the bugzilla to let NCO know it has been resolved in GFSv17. Thanks for your help with this @GeorgeGayno-NOAA and @DavidHuber-NOAA ! |
DavidHuber-NOAA
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Looks good to me! Thanks for the work on this @KateFriedman-NOAA @GeorgeGayno-NOAA!
|
I don't think additional testing is required for this PR and it is ready to merge. |
* develop: Delete DATAROOT when running generate_workflows.sh (NOAA-EMC#3504) Fix 3244 garbled change (NOAA-EMC#3492) Enable ensemble archiving via Globus (NOAA-EMC#3479) Update MSU FIX_DIR paths (NOAA-EMC#3488) Updates for AOWCDA and hybatmaerosnowDA cases on Gaea C6 (NOAA-EMC#3487) Update GOCART path for GDAS/GFS/GCAFS implementations (NOAA-EMC#3455) Make RUN Variables Explicit in `config.resources` (NOAA-EMC#3478) Remove unused key from enkfgdas_earc_vrfy (NOAA-EMC#3473) Bug fix to the failing early cycle marine DA ensemble re-centering (NOAA-EMC#3454) Make marine LETKF optional (NOAA-EMC#3462) When sourcing for RUN=enkf*, use CASE_ENS (NOAA-EMC#3475) Updates for Gaea: verif-global tag, tracker tag, Fit2Obs tag, and C768 analysis resources (NOAA-EMC#3463) Update gefswave glo_025 mesh file with new mask (NOAA-EMC#3457) Update MSU glopara paths to new role-global space (NOAA-EMC#3443) Enable CI testing on AWS (NOAA-EMC#3459) Enable Gaea C5 Jenkins CI (NOAA-EMC#3447) Job reference removal from WMO product names (NOAA-EMC#3460) Turn off aerosol prognostic radiative feedback for GDAS NOAA-EMC#2926 (NOAA-EMC#3445) Add DO_GEMPAK check to postsnd subtask (NOAA-EMC#3451) Add a force option to setup_xml to ignore unwritable directories (NOAA-EMC#3448) Remove the eomg job (NOAA-EMC#3331) Migration to role account for Jenkins on Orion (NOAA-EMC#3440) Eliminate `_gfs`, `_gdas`, etc, variables and add necessary if blocks (NOAA-EMC#3420) Update workflow staging for sfcanl tiles and waveinit (NOAA-EMC#3429) Improve messaging to display clear warning when missing snogrb file (NOAA-EMC#3317) JEDI-based ensemble recentering and analysis calculation (NOAA-EMC#3312) Enable HPSS archiving on C5/6 (NOAA-EMC#3437) Check if HOMEDIR STMP and PTMP are writable (NOAA-EMC#3430) Update UFS_Utils and GFS-utils hashes to update Gaea support and ocean/ice post products (NOAA-EMC#3433) Enable C1152 forecasts on gaea C6 (NOAA-EMC#3438) Migration to role account for Jenkins on Hercules (NOAA-EMC#3423) Remove Direct Linking to COM from DATA for `extractvars` Job (NOAA-EMC#3379) Enable HPSS via Globus on Hercules and Orion Remove job name from product files & update GEMPAK module. (NOAA-EMC#3415) `link` instead of `copy` in staging jobs (NOAA-EMC#3410) Migrate CI Jenkins to role account on Hera (NOAA-EMC#3414) Add rocotorc documentation when using scrontab (NOAA-EMC#3417) Update jgdas atmos verfozn and verfrad with COMIN/COMOUT prefix instead of COM (NOAA-EMC#3342) Add configuration for empirically-corrected ozone parameters (NOAA-EMC#3386) Enable global-workflow to run C768C384 GSI on Gaea-C6 (NOAA-EMC#3412) Move logical checks into if blocks (NOAA-EMC#3339) Adding Jenkins CI to GaeaC6 using role account (NOAA-EMC#3389) Enable GDASApp g-w CI cases to run on wcoss2 (NOAA-EMC#3399) CI/CD Test on Gaea C5- And update config.gaea under ci/platform (NOAA-EMC#3280) Enable cycling support for Gaea C6 (NOAA-EMC#3323) Update enkf archive jobs to use COMIN/COMOUT (NOAA-EMC#3393) Copy marine ensemble output observation diags and spread (NOAA-EMC#3407) Ci testing on aws 2 (NOAA-EMC#3408) Disable METplus jobs on Hera (NOAA-EMC#3403) Add the mean EnKF soil increment to the deterministic member (NOAA-EMC#3295) Add mpich/8.1.19 to the WCOSS2 LD_LIBRARY_PATH for GDASApp jobs (NOAA-EMC#3396) Change order of RUNs (NOAA-EMC#3335) CI testing on aws (NOAA-EMC#3391) Rename Gulf of Mexico in bufr station list in GFSv17 (NOAA-EMC#3384) Enabling AWS CI/testing (NOAA-EMC#3383) Update issue templates to use new issue type field (NOAA-EMC#3369) Replace WAVECUR_DID variable with "rtofs" (NOAA-EMC#3337) Allow for C1152 ATM-Aero cycled DA to run on WCOSS2 (NOAA-EMC#3309) Remove Direct Linking to COM from DATA for `wavepostsbs` Job (NOAA-EMC#3303) Update jgdas enkf update job with COMIN or COMOUT prefix instead of COM (NOAA-EMC#3333) Add capability to run diff resolutions for marine anl and background (NOAA-EMC#3238) Update high resolution tests and fix minor wave issues (NOAA-EMC#3289) Add sfs as valid system (NOAA-EMC#3243) Add missing arch_tars dependencies (NOAA-EMC#3319) Fix the empty aerosol DA aerostat tar file issue (NOAA-EMC#3332) Add missing file safeguard for IMS prep in snow analysis tasks (NOAA-EMC#3329)
* develop: Update GSI hash and GSI fix version to resolve bugs (NOAA-EMC#3626) Add missing marine DA files to archiving (NOAA-EMC#3596) Add a low resolution test to mimic GFSv17 cycling as much as possible (NOAA-EMC#3617) Add the setting to use the reject list for station t/q observations in GSI based soil DA (NOAA-EMC#3599) GitLab CI Framework for schedule PR cases and ctests on multi hosts (NOAA-EMC#3603) Avoid parallel restart I/O on WCOSS2 (NOAA-EMC#3615) Enables user toggling of GDASApp g-w ctests (NOAA-EMC#3587) COM variable updates for prep and some external downstream jobs (NOAA-EMC#3608) Remove MOS from system (NOAA-EMC#3612) Updates to enable soil DA (NOAA-EMC#3452) Unexport SHELLOPTS when running htar (NOAA-EMC#3601) Fix check for netcdf wave restart (NOAA-EMC#3594) Call err_chk/err_exit for fatal errors in post JJobs/ex-scripts (NOAA-EMC#3571) Remove support for Jet and S4 (NOAA-EMC#3572) Hotfix in GitLab pipline for Nightly (env MACHINE breaks build on head node) (NOAA-EMC#3578) [hotfix] Missed a path during merging develop (NOAA-EMC#3577) Prepare for ops readiness - part 1 (NOAA-EMC#3557) Update UFS weather-model to 20250328 hash (NOAA-EMC#3528) Fix SFS fcst config (NOAA-EMC#3574) Use err_chk in GDAS j-jobs (NOAA-EMC#3570) Perform compute builds on Gaea head nodes (NOAA-EMC#3560) Add initial capability to produce JEDI-based observation space summary stat files (NOAA-EMC#3471) Spread epos over more nodes on Hera to increase allocated memory (NOAA-EMC#3567) Create separate gists when multiple files are published on GitHub (NOAA-EMC#3551) Use err_chk in GSI J-Jobs and scripts (NOAA-EMC#3549) Add unified jinja obs list to marine DA (NOAA-EMC#3530) Save snow and aerosol analysis increments (and logs and YAMLs) every cycle (NOAA-EMC#3537) Add Dependencies to SFS Cleanup Job (NOAA-EMC#3559) Updates archiving to reflect current naming of marine anl output (NOAA-EMC#3541) Temporarily disable compute builds on C6 (NOAA-EMC#3558) Update gdas.cd hash to resolve msu prod_util failure (NOAA-EMC#3556) COMIN/COMOUT updates for enkf chgres and downstream product jobs (NOAA-EMC#3518) Call err_chk in forecast scripts for fatal errors (NOAA-EMC#3515) Add Rocoto Jobs for the Missing Products of GEFS (NOAA-EMC#3466) Download subset fix data with python script (NOAA-EMC#3400) Check that partition should be set (NOAA-EMC#3543) Rename wave output and refactor some wave scripts to use MPMD, and fix some bugzillas along the way (NOAA-EMC#3517) Add support for dual batch partitions on AWS NOAA-EMC#3483 Update CI build and run directories for GitLab Nightlies on C6 and added GitLab support on Hera (NOAA-EMC#3536) Hotfix path for CI in Jenkins on Gaea C6 to it's world-share path (NOAA-EMC#3532) Create single ocean grib2 product file (NOAA-EMC#3529) Scheduled Nightly CI/CD Pipeline Script in GitLab on Gaea C6 (NOAA-EMC#3493) make sure cold starts are handled correctly when DOIAU=YES (issue NOAA-EMC#3516) (NOAA-EMC#3520) Add check for DO_AERO_FCST before copying fv_tracer files (NOAA-EMC#3485) Use jinja templates instead of `@VARNAME@` in config files (NOAA-EMC#3411) Replace "status" (or comparable) with "err" in preparation for moving to err_chk/err_exit (NOAA-EMC#3507) Error in Java launch script for CI (NOAA-EMC#3465) Delete DATAROOT when running generate_workflows.sh (NOAA-EMC#3504) Fix 3244 garbled change (NOAA-EMC#3492) Enable ensemble archiving via Globus (NOAA-EMC#3479) Update MSU FIX_DIR paths (NOAA-EMC#3488) Updates for AOWCDA and hybatmaerosnowDA cases on Gaea C6 (NOAA-EMC#3487) Update GOCART path for GDAS/GFS/GCAFS implementations (NOAA-EMC#3455) Make RUN Variables Explicit in `config.resources` (NOAA-EMC#3478) Remove unused key from enkfgdas_earc_vrfy (NOAA-EMC#3473) Bug fix to the failing early cycle marine DA ensemble re-centering (NOAA-EMC#3454) Make marine LETKF optional (NOAA-EMC#3462) When sourcing for RUN=enkf*, use CASE_ENS (NOAA-EMC#3475) Updates for Gaea: verif-global tag, tracker tag, Fit2Obs tag, and C768 analysis resources (NOAA-EMC#3463) Update gefswave glo_025 mesh file with new mask (NOAA-EMC#3457) Update MSU glopara paths to new role-global space (NOAA-EMC#3443) Enable CI testing on AWS (NOAA-EMC#3459) Enable Gaea C5 Jenkins CI (NOAA-EMC#3447) Job reference removal from WMO product names (NOAA-EMC#3460) Turn off aerosol prognostic radiative feedback for GDAS NOAA-EMC#2926 (NOAA-EMC#3445) Add DO_GEMPAK check to postsnd subtask (NOAA-EMC#3451) Add a force option to setup_xml to ignore unwritable directories (NOAA-EMC#3448) Remove the eomg job (NOAA-EMC#3331) Migration to role account for Jenkins on Orion (NOAA-EMC#3440) Eliminate `_gfs`, `_gdas`, etc, variables and add necessary if blocks (NOAA-EMC#3420) Update workflow staging for sfcanl tiles and waveinit (NOAA-EMC#3429) Improve messaging to display clear warning when missing snogrb file (NOAA-EMC#3317) JEDI-based ensemble recentering and analysis calculation (NOAA-EMC#3312) Enable HPSS archiving on C5/6 (NOAA-EMC#3437) Check if HOMEDIR STMP and PTMP are writable (NOAA-EMC#3430) Update UFS_Utils and GFS-utils hashes to update Gaea support and ocean/ice post products (NOAA-EMC#3433) Enable C1152 forecasts on gaea C6 (NOAA-EMC#3438) Migration to role account for Jenkins on Hercules (NOAA-EMC#3423) Remove Direct Linking to COM from DATA for `extractvars` Job (NOAA-EMC#3379) Enable HPSS via Globus on Hercules and Orion Remove job name from product files & update GEMPAK module. (NOAA-EMC#3415) `link` instead of `copy` in staging jobs (NOAA-EMC#3410) Migrate CI Jenkins to role account on Hera (NOAA-EMC#3414) Add rocotorc documentation when using scrontab (NOAA-EMC#3417) Update jgdas atmos verfozn and verfrad with COMIN/COMOUT prefix instead of COM (NOAA-EMC#3342) Add configuration for empirically-corrected ozone parameters (NOAA-EMC#3386) Enable global-workflow to run C768C384 GSI on Gaea-C6 (NOAA-EMC#3412) Move logical checks into if blocks (NOAA-EMC#3339) Adding Jenkins CI to GaeaC6 using role account (NOAA-EMC#3389) Enable GDASApp g-w CI cases to run on wcoss2 (NOAA-EMC#3399) CI/CD Test on Gaea C5- And update config.gaea under ci/platform (NOAA-EMC#3280) Enable cycling support for Gaea C6 (NOAA-EMC#3323) Update enkf archive jobs to use COMIN/COMOUT (NOAA-EMC#3393) Copy marine ensemble output observation diags and spread (NOAA-EMC#3407) Ci testing on aws 2 (NOAA-EMC#3408) Disable METplus jobs on Hera (NOAA-EMC#3403) Add the mean EnKF soil increment to the deterministic member (NOAA-EMC#3295) Add mpich/8.1.19 to the WCOSS2 LD_LIBRARY_PATH for GDASApp jobs (NOAA-EMC#3396) Change order of RUNs (NOAA-EMC#3335) CI testing on aws (NOAA-EMC#3391) Rename Gulf of Mexico in bufr station list in GFSv17 (NOAA-EMC#3384) Enabling AWS CI/testing (NOAA-EMC#3383) Update issue templates to use new issue type field (NOAA-EMC#3369) Replace WAVECUR_DID variable with "rtofs" (NOAA-EMC#3337) Allow for C1152 ATM-Aero cycled DA to run on WCOSS2 (NOAA-EMC#3309) Remove Direct Linking to COM from DATA for `wavepostsbs` Job (NOAA-EMC#3303) Update jgdas enkf update job with COMIN or COMOUT prefix instead of COM (NOAA-EMC#3333) Add capability to run diff resolutions for marine anl and background (NOAA-EMC#3238) Update high resolution tests and fix minor wave issues (NOAA-EMC#3289) Add sfs as valid system (NOAA-EMC#3243) Add missing arch_tars dependencies (NOAA-EMC#3319) Fix the empty aerosol DA aerostat tar file issue (NOAA-EMC#3332) Add missing file safeguard for IMS prep in snow analysis tasks (NOAA-EMC#3329) Fix memory unsetting on Gaea (NOAA-EMC#3325) Fix error log parsing in compute build CI (NOAA-EMC#3301) Remove marineanlvrfy task from global-workflow (NOAA-EMC#3314) Add `gfs_wavepostpnt` dependencies to gfs_cleanup (NOAA-EMC#3313) Increase the GDASApp build wallclock (NOAA-EMC#3298) Capture build fail in Jenkins pipeline when no error logs are produced (NOAA-EMC#3297) Add/update config files for Gaea and check existence before sourcing config files in generate_workflows.sh (NOAA-EMC#3286) Fix ocean restarts when cold starting with DOIAU=YES (NOAA-EMC#3278) Splitting up the archive task (NOAA-EMC#3242) CTests extended validation for C48_ATM and staged C48_S2SW for gfs_fcst and gfs_atmos (NOAA-EMC#3256) Add esnowanl to enkfgfs cycle (NOAA-EMC#3283) Add gfs cycles to C48mx500_3DVarAOWCDA (NOAA-EMC#3249) Add fetch job and update stage_ic to work with fetched ICs (NOAA-EMC#3141) Remove WAFS files and references from `develop` (NOAA-EMC#3263) fix intel stack version number on c5 (NOAA-EMC#3258) Update gsi_monitor and ufs_utils hashes to recent hashes for C5/C6 build and run (NOAA-EMC#3252) Enable DA cycling on gaea C5/C6 (NOAA-EMC#3255) Copy post-processed sea ice increment for diagnostics (NOAA-EMC#3235)
Description
This PR resolves bugzilla 1373 (Display clear warning when missing snogrb file). The following changes are included in this PR to resolve the bugzilla:
exitif soAlso included in this PR are a related bug fix uncovered during work to resolve bugzilla and needed COMIN/COMOUT updates, which are part of a larger initiative. Those changes are:
resvariable setting inscripts/exgdas_enkf_sfc.shAlso included in this PR is the removal of
getges.shfrom the related scripts and removal ofGETGESmention in some wave job scripts. Full removal ofgetges.shwill be done in a separate PR.Refs #2451
Refs #1041
Resolves #2500
Type of change
Bugzilla resolution and bug fix
Change characteristics
Error handling and messaging updates in related workflow scripts.
How has this been tested?
Ran C96_atm3DVar CI test on Hercules.