feat(taxonomy): #498 Fallacies AIF — serialize scaleup phase 1-3 (47 leaves, MODE 2)

[jsboige]

Summary

GO jsboige (interactif, relayé par ai-01 dispatch 6eo7cb, 2026-07-09 12:06) — D1 LEVÉE + D2 OVERRIDE = MODE 2. Serialize the 47 scaleup phase 1-3 generative leaves into the 2 AIF columns (AIF_attackType + AIF_attackedNode): 45 NEW + 834/847 override → undercut. 3rd prod write of the AIF Fallacies contract (#498), after #753 (§7 cluster docs) and #755 (Virtues mirror).

This is the execution PR of the prep PRs #756 (audit, merged) + #757 (apply script + verifier, merged b666ed6e). The gate is lifted; this PR does the byte-exact cell-fill.

DoD (ai-01 byte-check surface)

$ python tools/498-phase13-apply.py --write --with-overrides
apply_set: 47 PKs  ->  27 undermine / 17 undercut / 3 rebut
  (NEW=45, conflict-overridden=2 [834/847], CONFIRM no-op=3 [826/844/855])
PHASE_MAP re-verified 50/50 vs annotation CSVs: OK
pre-state check: all 47 apply_set PKs empty (fill, no overwrite): OK
byte-preservation mismatches: 0
CSV filled total: 46 -> 93
>>> WRITTEN (47 cells filled). Backup saved to tmp/Fallacies-backup-pre-phase13.csv

$ python tools/498-phase13-verify.py --with-overrides
PHASE_MAP PKs filled in CSV: 50  ->  {'undermine': 27, 'undercut': 20, 'rebut': 3}
empty PHASE_MAP PKs: none
byte-preservation mismatches: 0 (must be 0)
CRLF: backup=1409, prod=1409   BOM: backup=True, prod=True   delta: 696 bytes
  spot pk 1282/1313/1361: [rebut,CA-node] -> OK  (FIRST Fallacies rebut)
  spot pk 698/889/340: [undermine,I-node] -> OK
  spot pk 707/974/1345: [undercut,RA-node] -> OK
  spot pk 826/844/855: [undercut,RA-node] -> OK  (CONFIRM, unchanged from #753)
  D2 pk 834/847: ['undercut','RA-node'] -> OK  (MODE 2 override)
  non-phase pk 2: unchanged -> OK
>>> VERIFY PASSED

$ dotnet test ...Tests.csproj
échec: 1, réussite: 594, ignorée(s): 5, total: 600
  (1 fail = #133 OWL pre-existing round-trip bug, unrelated)

DoD distribution 93 = 61 undercut / 29 undermine / 3 rebut — pre 46 [44u/2m from #753] + 47 written [27m/17u/3r].

git diff = 47 insertions / 47 deletions — each row changes ONLY the 2 AIF cells; every other field byte-identical. This is the byte-exact guarantee (memory [[csv-byte-exact-column-insertion]]): the git diff 47/47 is expected, NOT a regression.

The 47 leaves (scaleup phase 1-3)

Phase	Family	Count	Detail
Phase 1	Abus langage + Erreur raisonnement	13	incl. 834/847 (override → undercut), 826/844/855 (CONFIRM no-op)
Phase 2	Erreur math + Insuffisance	12	incl. 3 rebut firsts? — no, rebut are phase 3
Phase 3	Influence + Tricherie + Obstruction	22	incl. 3 rebut (1282 Relativisme abusif, 1313 Évasion, 1361 Procès en incohérence = FIRST Fallacies rebut)

3 rebut = structural tail case — all in Obstruction family, all → rebut/CA-node (counter-conclusion). First rebut in the Fallacies taxonomy (Virtues had 3 rebut via #755).

Technique = byte-exact cell-fill (load-bearing guarantee)

Post-#753 the 2 columns already exist (104 cols). Apply = cell-fill in place. The 50-leaf PHASE_MAP is verbatim from the phase doc tables (proposal docs docs/taxonomy/498-aif-scaleup-phase{1,2,3}.md) and re-verified 50/50 vs the 3 machine-readable annotation CSVs (docs/taxonomy/498-scaleup-phase{1,2,3}-annotations.csv) as a load-bearing assertion — independent of #756. NODE is the deterministic ASPIC+ map ratified #707§4 Option (a): undercut→RA-node, undermine→I-node, rebut→CA-node.

• ✅ 0 byte-preservation mismatch — only AIF_attackType/AIF_attackedNode of the 47 apply_set PKs change; every other field byte-identical.
• ✅ CRLF + BOM + embedded-LF preserved, 1409 rows × 104 cols, delta 696 B.
• ✅ Pre-state safety check confirmed all 47 PKs empty (fill, never overwrite).
• ✅ Independent verifier re-declares PHASE_MAP + FAIL_LOUD_753 (NOT imported from apply script — independence guarantee).

Metadata-only invariant (0 impact)

The 2 AIF columns are a relational metadata layer, additive and orthogonal to the render path (CardPen templates, harvesting, PDF assembly). 0 impact on rendered cards/PDFs → verdicts #140/#632 unchanged, bundle v3 stays the release reference. This is why jsboige's GO is orthogonal to the visual GO for the tag (sem. 13/07).

Discipline

• ✅ Read body before action — ai-01 dispatch 6eo7cb read in full before execution; HOLD honored until the gate lifted this tick.
• ✅ 0 fabrication docs(taxonomy): #141 crossLink enrichment sample run (real output curated from #626) #677 (50-leaf map verbatim, re-verified 50/50).
• ✅ Branche feature + PR (jamais push direct master). Gated byte-check review ai-01 (comme feat(taxonomy): #498 Fallacies AIF — serialize §7 I/RA/CA into 2 new columns (AIF_attackType + AIF_attackedNode) [reassigned from po-2023] #753/feat(taxonomy): #499 Virtues AIF — apply mirror back-fill (plan #750 v2) into 2 columns [206 undercut/13 undermine/3 rebut] #755).
• ❌ [runtime pending] feat(dnn): #649 RulesExplorer i18n — mirror loc() culture cascade #674/[HOLD post-tag] fix(cardpen): #629 convert relative /Cards paths to raw-master URLs (Option 1) #666/chore(dnn): #131 migrate 12 RazorComponent templates to Razor14 (source-level, runtime pending) #596 NOT touchés. Pas de self-merge.

🤖 Worker po-2024 — execution GO jsboige MODE 2 (dispatch ai-01 6eo7cb).