feat(oxfmt): Support trailing ignore comments#19304
feat(oxfmt): Support trailing ignore comments#19304Dunqing merged 5 commits intooxc-project:mainfrom
Conversation
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Pull request overview
This PR adds support for end-of-line suppression comments (e.g. // prettier-ignore and // oxfmt-ignore) so the formatter can preserve original source text for a statement even when the suppression marker appears on the same line (matching common Prettier usage and reducing diff noise).
Changes:
- Add a comment query helper to detect suppression comments that appear as trailing end-of-line line comments.
- Preserve original source text for suppressed statements when suppression is at end-of-line (with special handling for
ExpressionStatementto remain ASI-safe). - Extend fixture-based snapshot coverage to include same-line suppression scenarios.
Reviewed changes
Copilot reviewed 10 out of 11 changed files in this pull request and generated 9 comments.
Show a summary per file
| File | Description |
|---|---|
| tasks/ast_tools/src/generators/formatter/format.rs | Updates generator to emit inline trailing-suppression handling for Statement formatting (excluding ExpressionStatement). |
| crates/oxc_formatter/src/formatter/comments.rs | Adds has_line_suppression_comment_at_end_of_line to detect same-line trailing suppression. |
| crates/oxc_formatter/src/print/mod.rs | Implements ASI-safe preservation for ExpressionStatement when a same-line suppression is present. |
| crates/oxc_formatter/src/utils/statement_body.rs | Ensures same-line suppression works for if consequents where trailing comments are handled specially. |
| crates/oxc_formatter/src/ast_nodes/generated/format.rs | Generated output reflecting the new Statement suppression logic and required imports. |
| crates/oxc_formatter/tests/fixtures/js/... | Adds/updates fixtures & snapshots to validate same-line suppression behavior. |
Merging this PR will not alter performance
Comparing Footnotes
|
|
Hi @fisker, can I know why the trailing ignore comment is undocumented? |
0e820f1 to
4828a00
Compare
I don't know, I think it's bug (but I don't think we are going to fix), I didn't know about it util few month ago. |
|
Looks like intentionally prettier/prettier#671 (comment) |
Thank you! It looks like it just forgot to add documentation. 😅 |
|
In that case, would you like to review this PR? I could also add documentation to it, if you think this is could be mergeable. I could also open a PR on prettier adding documentation for it. |
I am on holiday right now. I will review this PR when I come back. It would be better to add documentation in Prettier first! |
|
Sounds great, enjoy your holiday! |
Dunqing
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Works well! I pushed a commit to support trailing block ignore comment
e9bdad2 to
de164f6
Compare
# Oxlint ### 🚀 Features - 2e0e1d0 linter/no-unused-vars: Add experimental fix mode controls (off|suggestion|fix) (#19774) (camc314) - f34f6fa linter: Introduce typeCheck config option (#19764) (camc314) - 694be7d linter: Introduce typeAware as config options (#19614) (camc314) - 655c38f semantic: Add "did you mean?" suggestions to undefined name errors (#19102) (copilot-swe-agent) - e97a57e linter/id-length: Use serde to deserialize rule options (#19636) (camc314) - c4a3677 parser: Report error for initializer in ambient context (#19187) (camc314) - 346045a linter/id-length: Add `checkGeneric` option (#19634) (camc314) ### 🐛 Bug Fixes - 1b7a937 linter: Correct double-comparisons fix with swapped operands (#19846) (camc314) - c308857 linter/consistent_type_imports: Add missing help and notes to diagnostics (#19827) (Daniel Osmond) - 7682e5a linter/plugins: Decode escapes in identifier tokens (#19838) (overlookmotel) - f368fcd linter/consistent_type_assertions: Add missing with_help and with_note to diagnostics (#19826) (Daniel Osmond) - 04e6223 npm: Add `preferUnplugged` for Yarn PnP compatibility (#19829) (Boshen) - 86d5037 linter: Add help text to no-extend-native, no-useless-backreference (#19733) (Anthony Amaro) - 50e8eff linter: Add .with_help() to operator-assignment, no-nonoctal-decimal-escape (#19732) (Anthony Amaro) - 1417bdc linter/no-wrapper-object-types: Add help messages to missing diagnostics (#19771) (Daniel Osmond) - 0838477 linter/ban_ts_comment: Add help and notes to missing diagnostics (#19781) (Daniel Osmond) - e8c77cf linter/adjacent_overload_signatures: Add missing diagnostics (#19780) (Daniel Osmond) - 28834ac linter/ban_types: Add missing help and note to diagnostics (#19782) (Daniel Osmond) - fd938d3 linter/prefer-enum-initializers: Add help messages to missing diagnostics (#19772) (Daniel Osmond) - eb928ee linter/no-dynamic-delete: Add help messages to missing diagnostics (#19768) (Daniel Osmond) - a985666 linter/no-empty-interface: Add help messages to missing diagnostics (#19769) (Daniel Osmond) - 2dc0ceb linter/no-extra-non-null-assertion: Add help messages to missing diagnostics (#19770) (Daniel Osmond) - 95d5d66 linter/no-dupe-keys: Handle `__proto__` proto setters in (#19762) (camc314) - 24ff0db linter/exhaustive-deps: False positive for member expressions in IIFEs (#19751) (Dennis Chen) - 7243a58 linter/no-use-before-define: Honor `ignoreTypeReferences` when value and type name collisions (#19747) (Dimava) - eefd818 linter/explicit-module-boundary-types: Add help messages to missing diagnostics (#19736) (Daniel Osmond) - 0440e9a linter: Add help text to no_control_regex, no_fallthrough, no_param_reassign (#19655) (Anthony Amaro) - e84cb2f react/display-name: Handle merged type+value context symbols (#19608) (camc314) - ce7e253 linter/prefer-object-from-entries: Require exact path match in unicorn helper (#19687) (camc314) - f5694ce estree/tokens: Reverse field order of `regex` object in tokens (#19679) (overlookmotel) - b2b7a55 estree/tokens: Generate tokens for files with BOM (#19535) (overlookmotel) - 0722721 linter/jsx-curly-brace-presence: False positive with prop & mixed quotes (#19674) (camc314) - 3496acd linter: Enhance diagnostic help messages for eslint rules (#19653) (Anthony Amaro) - e384e94 linter: Enhance help diagnostic messages for more eslint rules (#19658) (Anthony Amaro) - a4d5b34 linter: Avoid non-promise catch false positives (#19574) (camc314) - 5706f38 linter: `unicorn/no-array-callback-reference` skip `Effect.*` array-like methods name. (#19633) (Said Atrahouch) ### ⚡ Performance - 05ccf9f linter/plugins: Transfer tokens via raw transfer (#19893) (overlookmotel) - 4b0611a estree/tokens: Introduce `ESTreeTokenConfig` trait (#19842) (overlookmotel) - ec88f6a estree/tokens: Serialize tokens while visiting AST (#19726) (overlookmotel) - d4dcf26 linter/plugins: Remove `typescript` from bundle (#19531) (overlookmotel) - 6a6513c linter/plugins: Use Oxc tokens in plugins (#19498) (camc314) ### 📚 Documentation - d86f59e linter: Improve docs for no-useless-concat, mark as pending fixer. (#19859) (connorshea) - caa091d linter/plugins: Correct doc comments for `initTokens` (#19530) (overlookmotel) - 2fa936f README.md: Map npm package links to npmx.dev (#19666) (Boshen) - dc0ff73 linter/no-useless-constructor: Warn for parameter properties as well (#19638) (Ole Asteo) # Oxfmt ### 🚀 Features - 5141bc2 formatter: Support trailing ignore comments (#19304) (Andreas Lubbe) - 4888a99 oxfmt/lsp: Support other schemes beside `file://` and `untitled://` (#19872) (Sysix) - 14a0181 oxfmt: Support `graphql()` variant for gql-in-js (#19703) (leaysgur) - ca68ea6 oxfmt: Support gql-in-js substitution (#19670) (leaysgur) - 035933c formatter,oxfmt: Support js-in-vue (partially) (#19514) (leaysgur) - 9e11dc6 parser,estree,coverage: Collect tokens in parser and convert to ESTree format (#19497) (camc314) ### 🐛 Bug Fixes - 8e3842d oxfmt: Avoid embedded TSFN crash by returning errors as data (take2) (#19806) (Yuji Sugiura) - 04e6223 npm: Add `preferUnplugged` for Yarn PnP compatibility (#19829) (Boshen) - e540585 oxfmt: Support tailwind sort for CSS/LESS/SCSS (#19803) (leaysgur) - 93bb861 formatter: Trim trailing whitespace before breaking line (#19740) (leaysgur) - b85f97b formatter: Drop blank line between terminal call and first chain member (#19659) (Dunqing) ### ⚡ Performance - b3b2d30 parser: Introduce `ParserConfig` (#19637) (overlookmotel) ### 📚 Documentation - 2fa936f README.md: Map npm package links to npmx.dev (#19666) (Boshen) Co-authored-by: Boshen <1430279+Boshen@users.noreply.github.com>
Summary
Prettier supports end-of-line
// prettier-ignore(undocumented but widely used), especially for long logging/debug statements.oxfmtpreviously only respected suppression comments before the node, which forced extra lines and reduced readability in these cases, see #14669 (comment).In the discussion on #16915 (comment), it was stated that the performance could be negatively impacted.
This PR is an attempt to show how it could be supported without sacrificing performance.
So you can now write lines like this, which won't be transformed:
I'm very happy to receive feedback/criticism and iterate on this PR.
Performance Notes
is_line,is_trailing, newline flags).Benchmarking
AI Disclosure
This PR was created over 2 days of trying different 5 different approaches, which both Claude Opus 4.6 and OpenAI GPT 5.3 helped with, until settling for this version of trying to combine the best parts.