G5: define start-closure/1 and pass full-asset closure check

[seathatflowsinourveins]

Qualify the G5 compact evidence and START closure sampler, apply the adjudicated four-row and 90-note corrections, and verify the OpenHands registry placement against pinned source bytes. The current manifest recomputes from its unpublished archive; native qualification and exact manifest/asset binding run before sampling or packet writes. The refresh documentation uses the current origin-map pin, the current J8 summary matches its42-test sampler result, and a narrowly scoped native gitleaks exception distinguishes the two population-receipt digest fields from credentials. The current forward fix also separates native stratum records with blank lines: gitleaks file fragments then retain complete digest fields, while parsed populations and the exact digest exception remain unchanged.

Scope

• Lane: lane:shared; trading acknowledgement remains a landing gate.
• Row baseline: 503c470149069caaf2bf9c87f24caa38091ce3a6; latest class-fix parent: b5c215ac53ed1705a078d2832e4458627f481025. The ONE cued landing rebase is complete on 15d82bcc8871206476dc8c4c7bf45d347e74b2b7; the reviewed rebase head was f2451f711d1ad16bbcb734f9e3b6c4bc40606b62, followed by N1 43d1bc1ad31a528b11e693d0901be50004fc7497 and the file-fragment repair ecad2a496c7a646bb05942c33d86a6c429683db8, followed by the ONE forward isolated-fixture fix fa3a72720d4cae557a98ef94c722f986aca75874.
• Owned paths: compact generator/schemas, START sampler/contract/helper, native artifact controls, G5 manifest/compact rows/origin map/receipts, scoped decision/docs and evidence registrations.
• The earlier fix changed exactly four rows: OpenHands/extensions moves from agent-sdks to instructions-skills with TRIAL retained; OpenBB, ffn and Polars notes distinguish a source-entry list revision from an unestablished candidate implementation pin.
• Native sync_source_entry_note extends that same note correction to 90 PENDING rows. Only notes change. The four affected NOT units keep their verdicts, actual null-pin notes remain intact, and every original capture is preserved. The validator rejects unsynced source-entry-pin/null-note contradictions.
• J8 F1/TA-N1..N12 and the P3 controls are included: full native asset qualification, strict explicit-pin confirmation, restored rebinding rejection, precise capture/coverage failure assertions, current 47-claim/50-row wording, refreshed J8 bindings/history and tracked compact rows.

Population digest scan

The generic API-key rule flagged 1,656 public-data digests in two G5 population receipts. An independent native in-memory verification reproduced every matched value from canonical sorted catalog keys: 414 before-population and414 after-population SHA-256 fields per receipt. No matched values were printed or included in the sanitized evidence. Both receipts remain unchanged.

The supported gitleaks8.30.1 configuration adds one generic-api-key allowlist requiring both an exact reviewed receipt path and an anchored match for before_population_key_sha256 or after_population_key_sha256 containing exactly64 lowercase hex characters. regexTarget = "match" keeps the exception on the individual finding, so a co-located api_key remains detected. The scoped exception covers the original digest lines throughout the required PR history. The subsequent native file-reader failure required safe whitespace boundaries between stratum objects; current byte bindings are refreshed with previous bindings retained, and all parsed receipt values remain identical. All inherited default rules, prior exceptions and other rules remain unchanged.

Regression coverage fails the original config in four digest-format/path cases and passes with the fix. Credential-shaped API keys on the same line in either approved path still fire, as do unapproved paths, non-lowercase-hex values and the GitHub PAT rule. All native test scans now use --redact; assertions use field names and locations, and drop full finding lines that may contain adjacent values. The real-history test now scans the actual PR merge-base..HEAD range and rejects unbounded or unrelated overrides.

Current head 2e3a8f42d4643bea01189b996025db81c083f176 is the ONE cued native landing rebase of fa3a7272 onto main 0a053e1e5861a5522dcbbeea1c5006c4d8937b95, pushed with the exact old-head lease. The isolated-fixture repair and both real receipt checks remain active; the optional bash/git skip guard is included. All 11,376 evidence file rows were regenerated through the native registration API, including the auto-merged workflow-hardening third version; its current binding is SHA256 47e8748f35d046a208e564d8eabd37f1c73d539e50adff7fdf8cdc01e9f9fe09, 175,127 bytes. Two unchanged canonical PDF review declarations are preserved with current reviewed-byte identity. FULL workflow-hardening and gitleaks modules passed: 185 tests, one existing workflow-only skip, rc0. FULL validation passed 70 components/11,376 files/4 profiles/239 receipts. Final committed PR-range gitleaks --log-opts=0a053e1e5861a5522dcbbeea1c5006c4d8937b95..HEAD returned rc0/zero findings. Native pre-push passed three registry tests and the 12,167-file host-name scan with zero locations. Compared with fa3a727, 61 owned nonregistry files are byte-identical; only workflow-hardening changes through the main auto-merge plus the optional guard. #878 takes no grants count.

The real shard-4 isolated-fixture failure is repaired here. Inherited shard-5 reruns remain with the CC. N1 added one evidence registration row; this follow-up adds zero rows. #878 adds no grants-selected path under scripts/local_pages_policy_grants.py:46-65 and takes no grants count. Evidence-registry rows are a separate denominator. Designated micros and final CI remain pending. Landing order remains #923, #706, #943, #878; G5 stays NOT MET and the archive stays unpublished.

Rebased integration before the forward scan fix

The ONE cued rebase onto 15d82bcc8871206476dc8c4c7bf45d347e74b2b7 is pushed at f2451f711d1ad16bbcb734f9e3b6c4bc40606b62 with an exact lease on 597f11af389ef7f100ddd9c2fff45231c892fe5c. All 57 owned non-registry files match their reviewed Git blob identities at 597f11af; the production rows, original source facts, code, fixtures, documentation and receipts retain their reviewed bytes. One documentation auto-merge was restored to those exact reviewed bytes before the final check.

Both shared-registry conflicts used the rebased base registry followed by native scripts/host_receipts.py:register_file calls for the incoming file-binding changes. The restored documentation binding was also updated natively. No registry rows were hand-merged. Non-file registry fields equal the fetched main revision, and every current registered file binding is valid.

FULL python3 scripts/validate.py on the completed registered tree returned rc0: 70 components, 11,334 hashed files, four profiles and 239 receipts. The native verdict gate against 15d82bcc returned rc0 with zero changed verdict rows and zero violations. Cached whitespace, native pre-commit and all three native pre-push registry tests passed; the native host-name scan reported zero matching locations across 12,129 files. The exact-lease push succeeded and the remote head was independently verified. Prior 95-test compact and 42-test sampler results retain their unchanged-source/input scope; this rebase did not execute a new draw, model, provider or broker run.

Earlier reads remain historical. The original co-op GPT micro continues, and the CC delta read passed with P3s and the long GPT micro repeats the already-fixed shard-4 finding. The co-op per-file same-change check and fresh hosted CI on the landing-rebase head remain separate gates. G5 stays NOT MET and the archive stays unpublished.

Source bindings and placement regression

The current refresh instructions in both G5 documents bind the 3,064,963-byte origin map to SHA256 50a577cb25fc0650355c3ddf9b709b18d0fadb5a426415b6f497c1e78fe83e7a. The historical b5 receipt retains its older hash. Both corrected instructions pass the unchanged native pinned_bytes check.

The complete 21,348-byte openhands/extensions@ba3f165139cd3705c5d56a4ca26293d11a464c7b:AGENTS.md body is retained in evidence/artifacts/g5-start-closure-1-20261009/openhands-slot-regression/AGENTS-ba3f1651.txt, SHA256 d71111c39c773c9c238e32e517c074b8b7ab6115592440bf6c0d243b331326c9. The same source-bound placement assertion fails on exact retained pre-fix agent-sdks data and passes on current instructions-skills/TRIAL data. Separate assertions preserve the complete workers row and immutable original claim-member bindings. This is a local data regression, with source review evidence; it does not assert runtime adoption.

Only the current J8 TA_N7 summary changes to 42 tests. Its nested historical 41-test statement stays intact, and note-class-fix.json binds the updated current receipt. The manifest, origin map, selector, archive and historical four-row receipt remain unchanged. The pre-rebase content micro-fix was ONE commit 597f11af389ef7f100ddd9c2fff45231c892fe5c on 3ed3f6ff73f2392f22e81e248f26c767c45346bc, without rebase. evidence/artifacts/g5-start-closure-1-20261009/micro-fix-3ed3f6ff.json retains the source, before/after and preservation evidence.

Pre-rebase content verification: the exact old-data placement test fails as intended (rc1); the current three-test placement class passes (rc0); the whole compact module passes 95 tests with the two named external-fixture skips (rc0). Native registration of eight changed/new files and registry ordering pass. FULL python3 scripts/validate.py passes 70 components, 10,920 hashed files, four profiles and 237 receipts (rc0). Cached whitespace, native pre-commit and all three native pre-push registry tests pass. Exact-lease push against 3ed3f6ff succeeded. Earlier 42-test sampler and 414-population results retain their unchanged-input scope; neither was repeated or relabeled by this micro fix. The co-op GPT micro acknowledged the content at 597f11af. Current-head CC review and full hosted CI remain pending.

SOTA sources

• gitleaks/gitleaks v8.30.1, commit 83d9cd684c87d95d656c1458ef04895a7f1cbd8e: config/gitleaks.toml generic-api-key rule, native rule-specific allowlists in config/allowlist.go/detect/detect.go, and report/finding.go:Finding.Redact. The installed release and actual context-restriction controls agree. Native file fragmentation is settled by sources/file.go:21,166-246 and sources/common.go:16,56-125; actual receipt and synthetic boundary regressions exercise those supported safe separators.

• Native G5 decision and refresh procedure at b5c215ac53ed1705a078d2832e4458627f481025: docs/decisions/2026-10-08-g5-compact-evidence.md, compact_manifest.py, start_closure_sampler.py and the sealed stratum contract. START profile and the CC class addendum govern counted residue; non-action table codes are not blanket defects.

• Sealed R3 helper SHA256 759facff52170f452290077b71d328f299b2c763df0358d126973c60886515c7, with retained historical R3 SHA256 80e69ff94f97fffdf906583fa280f2a60a7487a54f0b58b05342264a5adf9627. Native population_key_sha256 and stratum definitions supply every population comparison.

• CPython 3.14.4 random.py, exact sealed runtime source hash checked by the native loader; GNU tar and facebook/zstd supply supported archive construction, with exact executed arguments retained in the class-fix receipt.

• OpenHands/extensions AGENTS.md establishes the corrected instructions/skills slot; its historical workers row and original claims remain unchanged.

• Native unittest controls reuse tests.test_compact_manifest.CompactManifestTests; native registration uses scripts.host_receipts.register_file and the FULL publication checker. No alternate sampler, population hash or qualification runner was introduced.

Evidence-class table

Claim	Evidence class	Evidence
Four confirmed row corrections and 90-note class	source_review / local artifact comparison	CC adjudication/ruling, retained pinned sources, exact row deltas
Complete asset qualification and source preservation	local_integration	Native write/check PASS, exact archive-member hashes and full manifest recomputation
Sampler rejection and row-note invariants	synthetic	Existing native compact fixtures; 92 compact tests with two explicit external-fixture skips; fresh 42 sampler tests with zero skips
Unchanged sampling populations	local_integration	All 414 native population hashes equal at 503c470, b5c215a and the latest correction; native replay selected-key equality

Current artifact bindings

• Unpublished archive: 0aeb16e1142a22a69d2e1bcded70a74df2db3e81fe6c01d42771d00589d3d35a, 56,463,125 bytes.
• Manifest: afb38c9427d7a344792b5ddcfa7cab64e9613a2fda64d1cecb30e2b0eae825bb.
• Origin map: 50a577cb25fc0650355c3ddf9b709b18d0fadb5a426415b6f497c1e78fe83e7a.
• Latest archive changes only compact/rows.json and SHA256SUMS across 13,486 file members. Every original capture and the coverage member remain byte-identical.
• note-class-population-receipt.json records all 414 membership/disposition hashes and native selected-key equality. No production redraw, new seed, sampled-stratum re-read or re-adjudication is required by the CC population rule.

Local commands run

Native explicit note sync over immutable archive rows
90 PENDING notes changed / 4,516 other rows identical / all other row fields identical
compact_manifest.py --profile start-closure/1 --asset $G5_NOTE_CLASS_ASSET --manifest catalogs/landscape/grand-catalog-20261008.json --write
compact_manifest.py --profile start-closure/1 --asset $G5_NOTE_CLASS_ASSET --manifest catalogs/landscape/grand-catalog-20261008.json --check
rc0 / PASS / zero blockers
Native derive_origin_map and sealed select/population_key_sha256 replay
414 unchanged strata / 414 selected-key equalities / zero redraws
/usr/bin/python3 -m unittest -v tests.test_compact_manifest
92 tests, rc0, two named external immutable-fixture skips
G5_R3_GENERATOR=tools/sota-convergence/sealed_r3_generator.py /usr/bin/python3 -m unittest -v tests.test_start_closure_sampler
42 tests, rc0, zero skips, sealed CPython3.14.4
New validator regression on unchanged b5 generator
one test / two expected failing subtests before implementation; corrected module passes
/usr/bin/python3 scripts/validate.py
FULL rc0 / 70 components / 10,917 hashed files / 4 profiles / 237 receipts
returned stdout SHA256 66829ef2f1e88f505d34b84a364e14a37c12e6df0b09cc7349e49f63bb54e913
stderr zero bytes
git diff --check
rc0

Historical failures and limits

The retained complete CI3.13.16 discovery remains a failed broad suite: 11,834 tests, 22 failures, 1,187 skips. The strict comparison is 21 pre-existing / 0 introduced proven / 1 unresolved. A separately documented source analysis attributes the sole two-line diagnostic ordering difference to unchanged set output; it does not replace the strict comparison or claim a broad PASS. The broad run lacked jsonschema and skipped sampler controls; the current 42-test native sampler run is fresh and uses the required generator/runtime.

Earlier incomplete runs, fixture setup failures, the unpinned runtime refusal and initial directory-metadata sync refusal remain recorded. The J8 receipt preserves its original historical preparation and separates current bindings. No native test or generated packet establishes a new model read or upstream runtime acceptance.

Earlier branch CI failed on historical population digests. Run38019766374 later passed the git-history and allowlist-test steps but failed its native working-tree step with two findings; the same two public receipt fixtures reproduced that failure and now return zero findings. A 55-second FULL-validation carrier timeout and a pre-push scratch-capacity failure were retained as failed attempts; the same FULL validation completed with a larger carrier timeout, and the unchanged native pre-push gate passed with its supported TMPDIR outside the full tmpfs. Shared scanner policy ownership has been routed to the co-op; no policy bypass is part of this fix. Any repository scan is restricted to the actual merge-base..HEAD range under the current standing rule.

Decision record and gates

docs/decisions/2026-10-08-g5-compact-evidence.md links the four-row receipt, current class-fix receipt, complete population tables and archive construction evidence. The local completeness critic verified scope, original captures, all 414 native hashes and actual sampler output; its two receipt/doc wording findings are corrected. This critic is separate from designated acceptance.

G5 remains NOT MET; G5-F1 through G5-F4, designated GPT/CC micros, trading acknowledgement, final-head CI, pre-cue and explicit CC landing/release remain open. The archive remains unpublished. The 07:39Z cued landing rebase onto0a053e1e is complete; the CC controls readiness, landing after #962/#961, and release. Standard-tier relaunch follows landing at the task boundary before the wave catalog PR.

Checklist

• Current native asset/manifest/origin bindings and compact rows agree.
• Exactly the authorized four-row plus 90-note scopes; NOT verdicts preserved.
• All 414 populations unchanged; no new redraw seed.
• Fresh 42/0-skip sampler controls, compact module and FULL validation passed.
• Credentials, protected lanes and peer-owned paths preserved; native hooks intact.
• Co-op GPT micro ACK at 597f11af; all 57 reviewed non-registry files are byte-identical at the rebased head.
• CC micro, trading acknowledgement and final-head CI.
• ONE CC-cued landing rebase onto 15d82bcc with native registry reconstruction.
• CC-controlled readiness/landing and archive release.

[socket-security]

No dependency changes detected. Learn more about Socket for GitHub.

👍 No dependency changes detected in pull request

[seathatflowsinourveins]

Shared-lane ACK from landscape-live-trading for the source-catalog scope of commit 54e7ea6430244e802b37ddc8d295eec9f883d5e9.

• The trading supplement matches the lane's frozen source bytes: SHA256 8ff57e830e36e483efe850b16f1a4af4ddce20232a7fce42d6a7dbb3049d4b6f, 60 unique decision IDs across 58 repository identities. Dispositions remain 17 NO-GAP, 8 TRIAL, 27 WATCH, 1 REJECT and 7 OUT-OF-SCOPE. Source-review, review-depth and trading-scope qualifications are preserved.
• The decision index includes each of the 60 supplement pointers exactly once with matching identity, ID and disposition. The evidence registry binds the supplement's actual hash and 34,450-byte size. The runtime-target Git blob is unchanged relative to the reviewed API base 1222838cbdbadc4bb08d0c7be51c5e51bfbdbd1b.
• The portable source-record publication matches its publication binding: SHA256 1ba922c7fbd370209dfeb114f94577902b88e918f33dee237d40615d353e3130. It retains the original trading sidecar/ledger digests. The later r2 correction restoring 13 searched notes remains separately sealed; its four return/manifest/sidecar/ledger digests are absent from this commit's source-record artifact. Immutable correction intake and publication remain pending.

This acknowledgment covers the requested commit's trading source registration and preserved boundaries. Public index completion, the complete input union, two-family evidence, saturation/evidence qualification, final hosted checks, connector-thread triage and the CC landing cue remain open as stated in the draft. No strategy, paper, broker, runtime-adoption or START acceptance is asserted. This review ran bounded artifact and Git-object checks; it did not run a full suite.

[chatgpt-codex-connector]

You have reached your Codex usage limits for code reviews. You can see your limits in the Codex usage dashboard.
To continue using code reviews, add credits to your account and enable them for code reviews in your settings.