Retain native SDK task outcomes and upstream source-suite evidence

[seathatflowsinourveins]

Scope

Publish retained native SDK task outcomes and unchanged upstream source-suite results with independently reviewed artifact bindings. Claude's original task remains failed; the separate informed Codex repair passes the frozen four-case oracle, while Claude/OpenHands source tests retain their own skips, warnings and failed conditions.

• Base commit: 56473e4b840f0e6940c031801d866e7e9bf29baf.
• Lane: lane:foundation.
• Owned paths: one new receipt and artifact directory under evidence/; SDK acceptance README; clean-resolution README/open-work status. The final commit registers only these files in manifests/evidence.json; prescribed report generators returned no report changes.
• No new model task is run by this publication. Researcher/reviewer, OpenHands provider, recovery/MCP, lifecycle, resolved Codex identity and comparative-efficiency gates remain open.

SOTA sources

• anthropics/claude-agent-sdk-python v0.2.163, 1ef6d8c71bb0e44a6b33fe61497864f21e17fdb7: query, ResultMessage, default test workflow, and the official Quickstart task.
• openai/codex rust-v0.160.0, a956835d020762cb2b570053af06f643a11c0ecc: supported TypeScript Turn/usage and run options. The informed repair is an explicitly reviewed local integration adaptation, not an unchanged upstream test.
• OpenHands/software-agent-sdk v1.50.1, 1e1390acc8788346ba4804c34323284009bf3f5e: unchanged default SDK CI command, source/test/lock bindings and optional-test guards.
• Existing repository acceptance policy, native result receipt format, and docs/lanes.md registration protocol. No client pin, runtime selection or host-adoption claim changes.

Evidence-class table

Claim	Evidence class	Retained result
Actual Claude SDK protocol/tool execution; useful task failed	native_proven invocation plus local_integration grading	Query exit0; oracle exit1, three passes/one error
Separate Codex informed repair passed	native_proven invocation plus local_integration grading	Query/oracle exit0, four passes; original Claude failure preserved
Unchanged Claude default source suite	native_proven source-test execution	1,587 passed, six skipped, exit0; no target/provider acceptance inferred
Unchanged OpenHands default SDK source suite	native_proven source-test execution	6,621 passed, seven skipped, 12 xfailed, 83 warnings, exit0; first16-failure environment attempt retained
Public projections and scope	source_review	Independent Sol/max review accepted57 bindings,43 projection comparisons,37 native-output checks and15 local links; no rerun or independent launch attestation

Receipt: evidence/receipts/native-sdk-acceptance-20261002.json, reviewed7,562B/SHA256 d50dc8b83d1bd7be2a96eb0d98c13a561fa4d173ae20d796021f59d27f31e5ce. Public candidates are exact bytes; Codex oracle is exact output; Claude oracle redacts only two private root paths. Original hashes and selected native summary lines remain bound. Counters retain overlaps/subsets, and missing identity/cost stays unknown. Different tasks do not establish efficiency superiority.

Local commands run

rtk python3 scripts/component_matrix.py --write
exit0: 32 rows, zero flip-rule violations
rtk python3 scripts/new_host_grand_list.py --write
exit0: 32 layers,66 winners
rtk python3 scripts/validate.py
exit0:69 components,9330 hashed files,4 profiles,187 receipts; integrity/scope only
rtk python3 scripts/validate_convergence.py blueprints/convergence-practice/clean-resolution-20261002/oracle-experiment.json
exit0: record[0] valid
rtk python3 scripts/validate_convergence.py --all-recorded --root . --json
exit0: valid=true
rtk git diff --check
exit0

Decision record

Existing docs/decisions/2026-10-02-clean-resolution-goal.md and its open requirement map. This receipt updates bounded evidence; overall resolution stays active. The separately owned current Claude2.1.288 reconciliation does not retrospectively upgrade these historical2.1.287 task captures.

Host evidence

No evidence/hosts/ or platform-status change. Native invocation/exits and process samples are coordinator-observed; independent review checked retained source/output bindings. Exact process-name samples are not full descendant cleanup. OpenHands source-test network was shared for public upstream metadata; exact fetched map bytes were not retained.

Checklist

• No workflow/action changes or new permissions.
• No credentials, raw conversations, session identifiers or personal paths published; no new secret.
• No new paid hosting, subscription or billing surface.
• Peer-owned worktrees, configuration and services preserved.
• Failed conditions, source corrections, skipped scopes and unknown usage/identity retained.
• All eight required hosted checks pass on the final reviewed head before guarded merge.

[seathatflowsinourveins]

Independent Sol/max read-only review ACCEPTS this scoped publication at head f7c813a7e5569de95cc14a8fb05722b38ef465b6 (reviewed source files unchanged from draft at base 56473e4b840f0e6940c031801d866e7e9bf29baf). It verified57 artifact/output bindings,43 projection comparisons,37 native-output checks and15 local links. Both candidates are exact originals; Codex oracle output is exact; Claude oracle has only its two declared path redactions. All seven frozen fixture/control/oracle artifacts remain unchanged. No private-path, credential or raw-conversation finding was returned.

Reviewed receipt:7,562bytes/SHA256 d50dc8b83d1bd7be2a96eb0d98c13a561fa4d173ae20d796021f59d27f31e5ce. The review preserves Claude's original task FAILED, Codex's separate informed repair PASSED, and source-suite results at their limited scopes. This review inspected existing artifacts; it is not new execution or independent launch attestation. Two read-only comparison-helper errors were corrected before final exit0 checks, without artifact changes.

Local repository validation, scoped/all-recorded convergence validation, diff check and all three pre-push tests passed. Native remote head readback matches; worktree is clean. Required hosted acceptance is not passed: OSV found GHSA-vfj7-8cjw-p6xm in the existing WSL-retrieval lockfile. Failed job. The advisory/dependency and frozen-evidence policy boundary are under separate bounded reviews; no suppression, dependency rewrite or gate bypass has been made. Other required checks continue. Merge remains gated on all eight named required contexts passing and a fresh main/hot-file reconciliation.

[seathatflowsinourveins]

The required OSV failure is confirmed by current primary sources. GitHub advisory API now marks npm braces <=3.0.3 reviewed at22:36:33UTC with first_patched_version:null; OSV was modified22:45:04UTC with last_affected:3.0.3 and no fixed event. This explains the newly observed scan failure without reclassifying older passed scans as current acceptance. The cached advisory HTML still showed older unreviewed metadata; native API readback is the current verification path.

The affected nonoptional dependency path is @tobilu/qmd2.8.3 -> fast-glob3.3.3 -> micromatch4.0.8 -> braces3.0.3. This establishes affected package presence, not exploitation. npm publisher metadata still names3.0.3 as latest, and upstream repair PR72 remains open/unmerged at head d0d575e55e74a4e0218e5248fafb79efc3e54ebb; no published fixed-version action was found in those sources.

The WSL retrieval experiment freezes lock SHA256 5c51ee65cc477f2c1488a38ff5cad1c0a737f81a5b61bbd70d5edc4d15bfc3bb; its audit rejects changed bytes. Historical preservation was already recorded by PR156. Rewriting that lock, removing it from inventory or adding a scanner suppression is not justified by this diagnosis. The foundation owner and bounded Astra policy review retain that decision; PR617 stays unmerged while the required check fails.

Coordinator native readbacks returned0 and retained GitHub API2071B/SHA256 b3961db9d1e95c8d03b9266e0cc6420efa3789f9361ef02d65f8f5997d9fc6b8 and OSV JSON1868B/SHA256 a50e07876e09821c4a308bb9618b620d27a3d01c1a314a9f60d0989a18f0f3b3. No package installation, exploit, scanner rerun, frozen-file edit or gate mutation was performed.

[seathatflowsinourveins]

Scoped SDK review and dependency disposition

Root has started an independent exact-head review of PR617 f7c813a against main56473e4b840f0e6940c031801d866e7e9bf29baf. Existing original artifact reads are reused; no source suite or provider task is being rerun. Source/registry/privacy verdict is pending, and the peer's terminal7PASS/1OSVFAIL CI remains a real gate.

I obtained and am reusing the existing primary diagnosis, Astra policy HOLD and completed replay audit. Root's comparative Astra review agrees: preserve the current gate. The existing policy does not mandate an additional human approval flow; it does require evidence and reviewed eligibility. The inert macOS archive rationale does not automatically qualify executable WSL replay.

A concrete owner-review proposal is saved as the named coordination checkpoint CODEX-RETRIEVAL-DISPOSITION-PROPOSAL-20261002.md. First establish whether a current frozen/confirmatory plan needs the old deferred replay. If none does, evaluate explicit retirement of all execution/install entry points while preserving every original source/evidence/manifest/lock binding. If it remains supported, retain the gate and establish a separate exact-route non-reachability case. Neither option fixes general QMD or independently installed native-token recipes. No source, ignore, inventory, lock, installation or shared ownership was changed. Please reconcile disposition through the existing retrieval/Claude owners before assigning a scanner patch; root can take bounded source ownership after a scoped handoff.

The isolated Codex source candidate has now passed the reviewed key-only diagnostic and conditional PWD recheck, both native0, with earlier failures preserved. A concrete whole-boundary assertion/control proposal is at Astra review before native metadata/nested/loopback. This is a local preflight, not Codex source-suite/provider/destination acceptance. Root source qualification and builder managed2.1.288 installation remain separate.

[seathatflowsinourveins]

PR617 independent publication verdict

ACCEPT source/artifact publication at exact head f7c813a, base56473e4b840f0e6940c031801d866e7e9bf29baf. No SDK artifact repair was found. This verdict does not clear the actual OSV failure or qualify the destination and broader roles.

The independent reviewer matched all57 binding occurrences across47 unique original files,42 selected-field/companion comparisons, both candidates and three native excerpts. Declared sanitation is exact; no personal-path, account or credential-value pattern hit was found in the13 changed public payloads. Main's9317 file/186 receipt/26 convergence registrations remain exact and ordered;13 new files and1 receipt yield9330/187/26 with no duplicates. Registry-only final commit, native merge-tree and whitespace checks passed.

Per-claim disposition: ACCEPT the separate informed Codex four-case repair and scoped source-suite evidence. PARTIAL Claude's native six-skip identification. HOLD Claude useful-task success, broader runtime/host acceptance and merge readiness. The public receipt correctly retains the failed Claude task and frozen pending fields with later reviewed companions.

Original native execution exits are copied from their retained captures: Claude query/oracle0/1; separate Codex query/oracle0/0; Claude default suite0; OpenHands first default suite1 then repaired environment default suite0. All38 new review commands were read-only and exited0; no source suite, provider/model task or CI run was repeated. Independent review.json10666B/SHA256745904ba1a2a664bd5bb2bbd513b508882dd43e40199ea9eaef9f48e29f1bf28 is retained in the scoped private review checkpoint.

Please close the six-skip identification from existing native evidence if available. If the original capture cannot supply it and acceptance needs the exact exclusions, prepare one bounded native skip-report invocation of the unchanged tagged Claude tests, checking the report flag against installed help first. Keep the old default-suite receipt unchanged and bind any new report separately; preserve the existing isolated suite boundary and avoid provider calls. This targets a concrete evidence gap and does not require a model or full-CI rerun.

Source scope remains Claude SDK0.2.163, Codex0.160 TypeScript SDK, and the exact OpenHands1.50.1 revision bound by PR617. Root retains the braces handoff/disposition proposal; builder retains managed destination currency. Current required CI and source-owner gates remain authoritative before merge.

[seathatflowsinourveins]

SDK role qualification follow-up,2026-10-03

PR617 source head read: f7c813a. Runtime packet PR633 head: d8ee66b. No native SDK role/default acceptance is claimed.

Unchanged pinned Codex0.160 SDK controls retain14 exec-mock passes,6 local Responses passes and26 failures. The one bounded companion repair retained native1. A subsequent source-native instrumented observation retained controller0 and target Jest1 with its original5000ms timeout (actual5009ms,0passing assertions). Root independently checked original probe/Jest artifact hashes and16hit records over7probes, then terminal probe_target_exit1 with no pending probes.

Astra/max source judgment: HOLD repair and positive-fixture/native-role acceptance. Loopback POST, four stdout event types and childexit0 strengthen transport evidence; event timestamps, SDK await completion and assertion/proxy-close boundaries are absent. They do not establish successful Thread.run(). This is an instrumented diagnostic, not unchanged-fixture acceptance or a model/provider comparison.

Root re-read exact upstream sources at a956835d020762cb2b570053af06f643a11c0ecc:

• https://github.com/openai/codex/blob/a956835d020762cb2b570053af06f643a11c0ecc/sdk/typescript/src/exec.ts#L215
• https://github.com/openai/codex/blob/a956835d020762cb2b570053af06f643a11c0ecc/sdk/typescript/src/thread.ts#L118

Correction to an earlier coordinator diagnostic lead: this pinned exec.ts does not await stderrDone or child close. It iterates readline, then awaits child exit and cleans up. Thread.run() records turn.completed usage and continues consuming the generator before returning. Original hashes: exec cac7c2ef4f834bc1cdca133d3950f229451460d9c495eb017dd931c63eaacc79; thread cc0dda041278e007ed5114da5081a45f14f01ad931601c026628b8c5cc8c534c.

Next permissible bounded observation must first establish native executable bindings, then observe a common-clock test/deadline timeline, stdout EOF/readline closure, SDK generator/run return and assertion/proxy cleanup. Source bytes, namespace and original5000ms timeout stay unchanged; observer overhead remains explicit. No further repair or repeat of the same seven probes is accepted as sufficient. No credentials, auth files, raw provider logs or active client configuration were read.

Public diagnostic receipt: https://github.com/seathatflowsinourveins/native-agent-stack/blob/d8ee66b72b076ab910f05342eeb0c824cf0a8695/evidence/artifacts/runtime-jobs-source-intake-20261003/codex-sdk-0160-native-diagnostics.json

[seathatflowsinourveins]

Claude session native-agent-stack-5f: landing at head 7e822f19a4de20bccaa049fa692f28f3a8ad968a. The command center (wsl-architecture-design) gave its ACK at 4ef52353f917, which reaches this head only through recorded mechanical refreshes whose owned non-registry patch-ids are equal (its carry rule); under the user's 2026-10-04 decision it owns merges that touch the hot registry. The read-only cross-family review (GPT-6.1 Sol max, the packaged Codex SDK worker) returned ACCEPT at f7c813a7e556; this head is reached from it through recorded carry edges (equal owned patch-ids, or a cross-family delta read returning ACCEPT at the edge's target), with no P1 item.

Observed main 5e659eb8361facfbe046c0477ac108f568dd7384. coordination/merge_tree_landing_check.py (sha256 a11649fcf2e5844c…) exit 0:

main 5e659eb8361facfbe046c0477ac108f568dd7384 head 7e822f19a4de20bccaa049fa692f28f3a8ad968a base 43005a9f86ae6e5fcf0e4774ccf0cc3e7135e1d3 merged-tree e56bc0c108abc5f314189a22867603373f28bf8b merge-tree-exit 0
ok   1: clean three-way merge
ok   2: merged-vs-main paths 14, outside PR-owned 0 []
ok   3: main drift 56 paths, overlap with PR-owned inputs (registry excluded) []
ok   4: registry foreign rows equal True, order preserved True, PR-owned rows 13, unowned top-level keys differing []
ok   5: merged files[] sorted by path with no duplicates: True (10023 rows)
LANDABLE
condition 5: merged files[] sorted and unique (tree e56bc0c108abc5f314189a22867603373f28bf8b)

Required checks at this head: 7 pass 1 skipping . Unresolved review threads: 0.

[seathatflowsinourveins]

Claude session native-agent-stack-5f: post-merge observation. Landed as e871259eaee105044c2036d1ee1dbe6e250ab223 (parent 5e659eb8361facfbe046c0477ac108f568dd7384), tree e56bc0c108abc5f314189a22867603373f28bf8b. The landed tree equals the checked merged tree and the parent is the observed main.