-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 29.8k
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
test: fix flaky http-chunk-extensions-limit test #51943
test: fix flaky http-chunk-extensions-limit test #51943
Conversation
fbe9e06
to
4375a83
Compare
Replace the setInterval with a queueMicrotask to make test less flaky. Fixes: nodejs#51883 PR-URL: nodejs#51943
4375a83
to
fcc6a67
Compare
This significantly changes how the chunks are sent. What is the reason behind the flakiness of the original version? |
My analysis is that the flakiness comes from certain systems closing the socket connection between interval calls. Is there a purpose for testing how this behaves with an interval? Could we use something more deterministic like adding asynchronous events to the task queue? |
Makes sense as that is when
Maybe we can use the peer on the other side. When data is received, make the other peer send more data. |
Why? Because I think there are outstanding issues with long running connections on certain systems. @joyeecheung mentioned that to me. I'm not sure I follow your recommendation. Is using a microtask not sufficient? This at least demonstrates that the separated chunk writes over async operations behave as expected. Is this really any different from the interval test? |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
Reading the original HackerOne report, it seems making the chunks sent in 2 parts should not affect the validity of the test. Would be better if it's in 20 parts as the original test does though.
Does the test fail reliably if you revert 03a5c34?
Alternatively I think we can also just install an error handler on the client and consider it passes the test if there is a reset. For the exploit, even getting a reset is a failure. It doesn't really have to be a proper 413 (although technically getting a reset instead of a friendly 413 can also be considered a bug, but a known bug is better than a flake I guess)
Actually looking closer at the test I think the interval seems to be less of the problem. The problem is that in the interval callback, there is no mechanism to stop the client from writing even after it already receives the 413 and closes the server. It just keeps trying until it finishes that 20 writes, and if before it finishes it already got the 413 and closes the server, it will get a reset. It doesn't matter we use queueMicrotask or not, what matters is that this only send it in two parts, thus reducing the likelihood of getting a 413 before all the write finishes. But if before the microtask runs, the client gets the 413 and closes the server, it can flake again. I think what we should do is to make sure that after the client gets the 413, no more writes will be attempted. |
Hmm actually, the key here is to not send more bytes after the limit is reached, so I think this should not flake, not because of queueMicrotask but because we split the data in just two parts, and only the second write would reach the limit and encounter the 413. The original test writes it in 20 parts and it would get 413 on any of the 17-20th parts, then any subsequent writes can get the reset if the server is already closed when the write happens. Perhaps simply reducing the remaining value to 17000 is already enough to deflake it... |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
LGTM if reverting the original commit can make the new test fail reliably.
Fails after revert 😄 |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
LGTM!
Landed in a8f281f |
Replace the setInterval with a queueMicrotask to make test less flaky. Fixes: #51883 PR-URL: #51943 Reviewed-By: Joyee Cheung <[email protected]> Reviewed-By: Luigi Pinca <[email protected]> Reviewed-By: Marco Ippolito <[email protected]> Reviewed-By: Paolo Insogna <[email protected]>
Replace the setInterval with a queueMicrotask to make test less flaky. Fixes: #51883 PR-URL: #51943 Reviewed-By: Joyee Cheung <[email protected]> Reviewed-By: Luigi Pinca <[email protected]> Reviewed-By: Marco Ippolito <[email protected]> Reviewed-By: Paolo Insogna <[email protected]>
Replace the setInterval with a queueMicrotask to make test less flaky. Fixes: #51883 PR-URL: #51943 Reviewed-By: Joyee Cheung <[email protected]> Reviewed-By: Luigi Pinca <[email protected]> Reviewed-By: Marco Ippolito <[email protected]> Reviewed-By: Paolo Insogna <[email protected]>
Replace the setInterval with a queueMicrotask to make test less flaky. Fixes: #51883 PR-URL: #51943 Reviewed-By: Joyee Cheung <[email protected]> Reviewed-By: Luigi Pinca <[email protected]> Reviewed-By: Marco Ippolito <[email protected]> Reviewed-By: Paolo Insogna <[email protected]>
Replace the setInterval with a queueMicrotask to make test less flaky. Fixes: nodejs#51883 PR-URL: nodejs#51943 Reviewed-By: Joyee Cheung <[email protected]> Reviewed-By: Luigi Pinca <[email protected]> Reviewed-By: Marco Ippolito <[email protected]> Reviewed-By: Paolo Insogna <[email protected]>
This PR contains the following updates: | Package | Update | Change | |---|---|---| | [node](https://nodejs.org) ([source](https://github.com/nodejs/node)) | minor | `18.19.1` -> `18.20.0` | --- ### Release Notes <details> <summary>nodejs/node (node)</summary> ### [`v18.20.0`](https://github.com/nodejs/node/releases/tag/v18.20.0): 2024-03-26, Version 18.20.0 'Hydrogen' (LTS), @​richardlau [Compare Source](nodejs/node@v18.19.1...v18.20.0) ##### Notable Changes ##### Added support for import attributes Support has been added for import attributes, to replace the old import assertions syntax. This will aid migration by making the new syntax available across all currently supported Node.js release lines. This adds the `with` keyword which should be used in place of the previous `assert` keyword, which will be removed in a future semver-major Node.js release. For example, ```console import "foo" assert { ... } ``` should be replaced with ```console import "foo" with { ... } ``` For more details, see - [#​50134](nodejs/node#50134) - [#​51622](nodejs/node#51622) Contributed by Nicolò Ribaudo in [#​51136](nodejs/node#51136) and Antoine du Hamel in [#​50140](nodejs/node#50140). ##### Doc deprecation for `dirent.path` Please use newly added `dirent.parentPath` instead. Contributed by Antoine du Hamel in [#​50976](nodejs/node#50976) and [#​51020](nodejs/node#51020). ##### Experimental node-api feature flags Introduces an experimental feature to segregate finalizers that affect GC state. A new type called `node_api_nogc_env` has been introduced as the const version of `napi_env` and `node_api_nogc_finalize` as a variant of `napi_finalize` that accepts a `node_api_nogc_env` as its first argument. This feature can be turned off by defining `NODE_API_EXPERIMENTAL_NOGC_ENV_OPT_OUT`. Contributed by Gabriel Schulhof in [#​50060](nodejs/node#50060). ##### Root certificates updated to NSS 3.98 Certificates added: - Telekom Security TLS ECC Root 2020 - Telekom Security TLS RSA Root 2023 Certificates removed: - Security Communication Root CA ##### Updated dependencies - ada updated to 2.7.6. - base64 updated to 0.5.2. - c-ares updated to 1.27.0. - corepack updated to 0.25.2. - ICU updated to 74.2. Includes CLDR 44.1 and Unicode 15.1. - npm updated to 10.5.0. Fixes a regression in signals not being passed onto child processes. - simdutf8 updated to 4.0.8. - Timezone updated to 2024a. - zlib updated to 1.3.0.1-motley-40e35a7. ##### vm: fix V8 compilation cache support for vm.Script Previously repeated compilation of the same source code using `vm.Script` stopped hitting the V8 compilation cache after v16.x when support for `importModuleDynamically` was added to `vm.Script`, resulting in a performance regression that blocked users (in particular Jest users) from upgrading from v16.x. The recent fixes allow the compilation cache to be hit again for `vm.Script` when `--experimental-vm-modules` is not used even in the presence of the `importModuleDynamically` option, so that users affected by the performance regression can now upgrade. Ongoing work is also being done to enable compilation cache support for `vm.CompileFunction`. Contributed by Joyee Cheung in [#​49950](nodejs/node#49950) and [#​50137](nodejs/node#50137). ##### Commits - \[[`c70383b8d4`](nodejs/node@c70383b8d4)] - **build**: support Python 3.12 (Shi Pujin) [#​50209](nodejs/node#50209) - \[[`4b960c3a4a`](nodejs/node@4b960c3a4a)] - **build**: fix incorrect g++ warning message (Richard Lau) [#​51695](nodejs/node#51695) - \[[`8fdea67694`](nodejs/node@8fdea67694)] - **crypto**: update root certificates to NSS 3.98 (Node.js GitHub Bot) [#​51794](nodejs/node#51794) - \[[`812b126dd9`](nodejs/node@812b126dd9)] - **deps**: V8: cherry-pick [`d90d453`](nodejs/node@d90d4533b053) (Michaël Zasso) [#​50077](nodejs/node#50077) - \[[`9ab8c3db87`](nodejs/node@9ab8c3db87)] - **deps**: update c-ares to 1.27.0 (Node.js GitHub Bot) [#​51846](nodejs/node#51846) - \[[`c688680387`](nodejs/node@c688680387)] - **deps**: update c-ares to 1.26.0 (Node.js GitHub Bot) [#​51582](nodejs/node#51582) - \[[`9498ac8a47`](nodejs/node@9498ac8a47)] - **deps**: compile c-ares with C11 support (Michaël Zasso) [#​51410](nodejs/node#51410) - \[[`8fb743642f`](nodejs/node@8fb743642f)] - **deps**: update c-ares to 1.25.0 (Node.js GitHub Bot) [#​51385](nodejs/node#51385) - \[[`7bea2d7c12`](nodejs/node@7bea2d7c12)] - **deps**: update zlib to 1.3.0.1-motley-40e35a7 (Node.js GitHub Bot) [#​51274](nodejs/node#51274) - \[[`57a38c8f75`](nodejs/node@57a38c8f75)] - **deps**: update zlib to 1.3.0.1-motley-dd5fc13 (Node.js GitHub Bot) [#​51105](nodejs/node#51105) - \[[`b0ca084a6b`](nodejs/node@b0ca084a6b)] - **deps**: update zlib to 1.3-22124f5 (Node.js GitHub Bot) [#​50910](nodejs/node#50910) - \[[`4b43823f37`](nodejs/node@4b43823f37)] - **deps**: update zlib to 1.2.13.1-motley-5daffc7 (Node.js GitHub Bot) [#​50803](nodejs/node#50803) - \[[`f0da591812`](nodejs/node@f0da591812)] - **deps**: update zlib to 1.2.13.1-motley-dfc48fc (Node.js GitHub Bot) [#​50456](nodejs/node#50456) - \[[`16d28a883a`](nodejs/node@16d28a883a)] - **deps**: update base64 to 0.5.2 (Node.js GitHub Bot) [#​51455](nodejs/node#51455) - \[[`13a9e81cb6`](nodejs/node@13a9e81cb6)] - **deps**: update base64 to 0.5.1 (Node.js GitHub Bot) [#​50629](nodejs/node#50629) - \[[`b4502d3ac5`](nodejs/node@b4502d3ac5)] - **deps**: update simdutf to 4.0.8 (Node.js GitHub Bot) [#​51000](nodejs/node#51000) - \[[`183cf8a74a`](nodejs/node@183cf8a74a)] - **deps**: update simdutf to 4.0.4 (Node.js GitHub Bot) [#​50772](nodejs/node#50772) - \[[`11ba8593ea`](nodejs/node@11ba8593ea)] - **deps**: update ada to 2.7.6 (Node.js GitHub Bot) [#​51542](nodejs/node#51542) - \[[`73a946d55c`](nodejs/node@73a946d55c)] - **deps**: update ada to 2.7.5 (Node.js GitHub Bot) [#​51542](nodejs/node#51542) - \[[`cc434c1a39`](nodejs/node@cc434c1a39)] - **deps**: update ada to 2.7.4 (Node.js GitHub Bot) [#​50815](nodejs/node#50815) - \[[`3a3808a6ae`](nodejs/node@3a3808a6ae)] - **deps**: upgrade npm to 10.5.0 (npm team) [#​51913](nodejs/node#51913) - \[[`c8876d765c`](nodejs/node@c8876d765c)] - **deps**: upgrade npm to 10.3.0 (npm team) [#​51431](nodejs/node#51431) - \[[`5aec3af460`](nodejs/node@5aec3af460)] - **deps**: update corepack to 0.25.2 (Node.js GitHub Bot) [#​51810](nodejs/node#51810) - \[[`a593985326`](nodejs/node@a593985326)] - **deps**: update corepack to 0.24.1 (Node.js GitHub Bot) [#​51459](nodejs/node#51459) - \[[`d1a9237bf5`](nodejs/node@d1a9237bf5)] - **deps**: update corepack to 0.24.0 (Node.js GitHub Bot) [#​51318](nodejs/node#51318) - \[[`adac0c7a63`](nodejs/node@adac0c7a63)] - **deps**: update corepack to 0.23.0 (Node.js GitHub Bot) [#​50563](nodejs/node#50563) - \[[`4a6f83e32a`](nodejs/node@4a6f83e32a)] - **deps**: escape Python strings correctly (Michaël Zasso) [#​50695](nodejs/node#50695) - \[[`c13969e52a`](nodejs/node@c13969e52a)] - **deps**: V8: cherry-pick [`ea996ad`](nodejs/node@ea996ad04a68) (Nicolò Ribaudo) [#​51136](nodejs/node#51136) - \[[`6fbf0ba5c3`](nodejs/node@6fbf0ba5c3)] - **deps**: V8: cherry-pick [`a0fd320`](nodejs/node@a0fd3209dda8) (Nicolò Ribaudo) [#​51136](nodejs/node#51136) - \[[`68fd7516e1`](nodejs/node@68fd7516e1)] - **deps**: update timezone to 2024a (Michaël Zasso) [#​51723](nodejs/node#51723) - \[[`f9b229ebe1`](nodejs/node@f9b229ebe1)] - **deps**: update icu to 74.2 (Michaël Zasso) [#​51723](nodejs/node#51723) - \[[`90c73d2eb4`](nodejs/node@90c73d2eb4)] - **deps**: update timezone to 2023d (Node.js GitHub Bot) [#​51461](nodejs/node#51461) - \[[`2a2bf57028`](nodejs/node@2a2bf57028)] - **deps**: update icu to 74.1 (Node.js GitHub Bot) [#​50515](nodejs/node#50515) - \[[`425e011e52`](nodejs/node@425e011e52)] - **deps**: add v8::Object::SetInternalFieldForNodeCore() (Joyee Cheung) [#​49874](nodejs/node#49874) - \[[`58c70344a2`](nodejs/node@58c70344a2)] - **deps**: V8: cherry-pick [`705e374`](nodejs/node@705e374124ae) (Joyee Cheung) [#​51004](nodejs/node#51004) - \[[`b0e88899e1`](nodejs/node@b0e88899e1)] - **deps**: V8: cherry-pick [`1fada6b`](nodejs/node@1fada6b36f8d) (Joyee Cheung) [#​51004](nodejs/node#51004) - \[[`d87a810b81`](nodejs/node@d87a810b81)] - **deps**: V8: cherry-pick [`3dd9576`](nodejs/node@3dd9576ce336) (Joyee Cheung) [#​51004](nodejs/node#51004) - \[[`6d50966876`](nodejs/node@6d50966876)] - **deps**: V8: cherry-pick [`94e8282`](nodejs/node@94e8282325a1) (Joyee Cheung) [#​51004](nodejs/node#51004) - \[[`fafbacdfec`](nodejs/node@fafbacdfec)] - **deps**: V8: cherry-pick [`9a98f96`](nodejs/node@9a98f96b6d68) (Joyee Cheung) [#​51004](nodejs/node#51004) - \[[`d4a530ed8d`](nodejs/node@d4a530ed8d)] - **deps**: V8: cherry-pick [`7f5daed`](nodejs/node@7f5daed62d47) (Joyee Cheung) [#​51004](nodejs/node#51004) - \[[`1ce901b164`](nodejs/node@1ce901b164)] - **deps**: V8: cherry-pick [`c400af4`](nodejs/node@c400af48b5ef) (Joyee Cheung) [#​51004](nodejs/node#51004) - \[[`f232064f35`](nodejs/node@f232064f35)] - **doc**: fix historical experimental fetch flag (Kenrick) [#​51506](nodejs/node#51506) - \[[`194ff6a40f`](nodejs/node@194ff6a40f)] - **(SEMVER-MINOR)** **doc**: add deprecation notice to `dirent.path` (Antoine du Hamel) [#​50976](nodejs/node#50976) - \[[`0f09267dc6`](nodejs/node@0f09267dc6)] - **(SEMVER-MINOR)** **doc**: deprecate `dirent.path` (Antoine du Hamel) [#​50976](nodejs/node#50976) - \[[`8bfb8f5b2f`](nodejs/node@8bfb8f5b2f)] - **doc,crypto**: further clarify RSA_PKCS1\_PADDING support (Tobias Nießen) [#​51799](nodejs/node#51799) - \[[`c7baf7b274`](nodejs/node@c7baf7b274)] - **doc,crypto**: add changelog and note about disabled RSA_PKCS1\_PADDING (Filip Skokan) [#​51782](nodejs/node#51782) - \[[`a193be3dc2`](nodejs/node@a193be3dc2)] - **esm**: use import attributes instead of import assertions (Antoine du Hamel) [#​50140](nodejs/node#50140) - \[[`26e8f7793e`](nodejs/node@26e8f7793e)] - **(SEMVER-MINOR)** **fs**: introduce `dirent.parentPath` (Antoine du Hamel) [#​50976](nodejs/node#50976) - \[[`5b5e5192f7`](nodejs/node@5b5e5192f7)] - **lib**: fix compileFunction throws range error for negative numbers (Jithil P Ponnan) [#​49855](nodejs/node#49855) - \[[`7552de6806`](nodejs/node@7552de6806)] - **module**: fix the leak in SourceTextModule and ContextifySript (Joyee Cheung) [#​48510](nodejs/node#48510) - \[[`2e05cf1c60`](nodejs/node@2e05cf1c60)] - **module**: fix leak of vm.SyntheticModule (Joyee Cheung) [#​48510](nodejs/node#48510) - \[[`a86a2e14a3`](nodejs/node@a86a2e14a3)] - **module**: use symbol in WeakMap to manage host defined options (Joyee Cheung) [#​48510](nodejs/node#48510) - \[[`32906ddcac`](nodejs/node@32906ddcac)] - **node-api**: segregate nogc APIs from rest via type system (Gabriel Schulhof) [#​50060](nodejs/node#50060) - \[[`1aa71c26ff`](nodejs/node@1aa71c26ff)] - **node-api**: factor out common code into macros (Gabriel Schulhof) [#​50664](nodejs/node#50664) - \[[`3d0b233f52`](nodejs/node@3d0b233f52)] - **node-api**: introduce experimental feature flags (Gabriel Schulhof) [#​50991](nodejs/node#50991) - \[[`96514a8b9f`](nodejs/node@96514a8b9f)] - **src**: iterate on import attributes array correctly (Michaël Zasso) [#​50703](nodejs/node#50703) - \[[`2c2892bf88`](nodejs/node@2c2892bf88)] - **src**: set ModuleWrap internal fields only once (Joyee Cheung) [#​49391](nodejs/node#49391) - \[[`ff334cb774`](nodejs/node@ff334cb774)] - **src**: cast v8::Object::GetInternalField() return value to v8::Value (Joyee Cheung) [#​48943](nodejs/node#48943) - \[[`270b519971`](nodejs/node@270b519971)] - **stream**: do not defer construction by one microtick (Matteo Collina) [#​52005](nodejs/node#52005) - \[[`95d7a75084`](nodejs/node@95d7a75084)] - **test**: fix dns test case failures after c-ares update to 1.21.0+ (Brad House) [#​50743](nodejs/node#50743) - \[[`cd613e5167`](nodejs/node@cd613e5167)] - **test**: handle relative https redirect (Richard Lau) [#​51121](nodejs/node#51121) - \[[`40f10eafcf`](nodejs/node@40f10eafcf)] - **test**: fix `internet/test-inspector-help-page` (Richard Lau) [#​51693](nodejs/node#51693) - \[[`5e426511b1`](nodejs/node@5e426511b1)] - **test**: deflake test-vm-contextified-script-leak (Joyee Cheung) [#​49710](nodejs/node#49710) - \[[`0b156c6d28`](nodejs/node@0b156c6d28)] - **test**: use checkIfCollectable in vm leak tests (Joyee Cheung) [#​49671](nodejs/node#49671) - \[[`1586c11b3c`](nodejs/node@1586c11b3c)] - **test**: add checkIfCollectable to test/common/gc.js (Joyee Cheung) [#​49671](nodejs/node#49671) - \[[`902d8b3d4b`](nodejs/node@902d8b3d4b)] - **test**: fix flaky http-chunk-extensions-limit test (Ethan Arrowood) [#​51943](nodejs/node#51943) - \[[`1743d2bdc1`](nodejs/node@1743d2bdc1)] - **test**: test surrogate pair filenames on windows (Mert Can Altın) [#​51800](nodejs/node#51800) - \[[`1c1a7ec22d`](nodejs/node@1c1a7ec22d)] - **test**: increase platform timeout zlib-brotli-16gb (Rafael Gonzaga) [#​51792](nodejs/node#51792) - \[[`931d02fe3e`](nodejs/node@931d02fe3e)] - **test, v8**: fix wrong import attributes test (Nicolò Ribaudo) [#​52184](nodejs/node#52184) - \[[`d9ea6c1f8d`](nodejs/node@d9ea6c1f8d)] - **tls**: fix order of setting cipher before setting cert and key (Kumar Rishav) [#​50186](nodejs/node#50186) - \[[`3184befa2e`](nodejs/node@3184befa2e)] - **tools**: fix update-icu.sh (Michaël Zasso) [#​51723](nodejs/node#51723) - \[[`06646e11be`](nodejs/node@06646e11be)] - **(SEMVER-MINOR)** **vm**: use import attributes instead of import assertions (Antoine du Hamel) [#​50141](nodejs/node#50141) - \[[`fe66e9d06e`](nodejs/node@fe66e9d06e)] - **vm**: reject in importModuleDynamically without --experimental-vm-modules (Joyee Cheung) [#​50137](nodejs/node#50137) - \[[`052e095c6b`](nodejs/node@052e095c6b)] - **vm**: use internal versions of compileFunction and Script (Joyee Cheung) [#​50137](nodejs/node#50137) - \[[`9f7899ed0a`](nodejs/node@9f7899ed0a)] - **vm**: unify host-defined option generation in vm.compileFunction (Joyee Cheung) [#​50137](nodejs/node#50137) - \[[`6291c107d0`](nodejs/node@6291c107d0)] - **vm**: use default HDO when importModuleDynamically is not set (Joyee Cheung) [#​49950](nodejs/node#49950) </details> --- ### Configuration 📅 **Schedule**: Branch creation - At any time (no schedule defined), Automerge - At any time (no schedule defined). 🚦 **Automerge**: Enabled. ♻ **Rebasing**: Whenever PR is behind base branch, or you tick the rebase/retry checkbox. 🔕 **Ignore**: Close this PR and you won't be reminded about this update again. --- - [ ] <!-- rebase-check -->If you want to rebase/retry this PR, check this box --- This PR has been generated by [Renovate Bot](https://github.com/renovatebot/renovate). <!--renovate-debug:eyJjcmVhdGVkSW5WZXIiOiIwLjAuMC1zZW1hbnRpYy1yZWxlYXNlIiwidXBkYXRlZEluVmVyIjoiMC4wLjAtc2VtYW50aWMtcmVsZWFzZSIsInRhcmdldEJyYW5jaCI6Im1haW4ifQ==--> Reviewed-on: https://harton.dev/cinder/cinder-space/pulls/25 Co-authored-by: Renovate Bot <[email protected]> Co-committed-by: Renovate Bot <[email protected]>
Replace the
setInterval
with aqueueMicrotask
to make test less flaky.Fixes: #51883