Repository navigation
docs(audit): refresh Jun1 M1 rustc residual catalog - #4140
Conversation
briansrls
changed the title
…ull single-authority cleanup Addresses three operator-blocking inline reviews + codex RC #4: 1. **TASKS.md line-number drift risk**: switched all `src/v4/TASKS.md:806-817` and `:816` citations to stable section anchor `src/v4/TASKS.md` "Definition of v4-done" (operator/codex flagged line-number cite as drift risk; using header anchor is robust against future renumbering). Note: current file content confirms predicates ARE at :813-817 under :805 header; operator's :572-584 suggestion doesn't match current main but the anchor switch sidesteps the issue entirely. 2. **ci.yml line-number drift risk**: switched all `.github/workflows/ci.yml:401-410` citations to step name `v2 → v4 bootstrap resolve-posture gate (CI emit-wall bridge)` (operator/cursor flagged 401-410 as not precisely the bridge step; step-name cite is robust + names exactly what gets deleted). 3. **Fresh M1 probe desync** (operator blocking on line 89): §6 listed as pending blocker owned by sharp-otter while §8.5 marked AUTHORIZED + in flight. §6 and §6.5 updated to reflect AUTHORIZED + work-item adhoc-7b46e080-3cd in flight (sleek-heron-13 spawned; PR #4140 7,724 errors +549 vs #4122). 4. **§7 PM-actionable contradiction** (codex RC #4): "No worker implementation dispatches blocked" contradicted SG-8 needing §8 routing. §7 rewritten to explicitly enumerate blocked items (SG-8, P5 runtime) referencing §6.5 dispatch board + §8.5 operator decisions queue. INVARIANTS P2 single-authority: §8.5 is the canonical sign-off state; §6 + §6.5 + §7 + §10 now all reference §8.5 rather than maintaining parallel state. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
…ult state + Path A no-overclaim Addresses two more blocking reviews: 1. **Probe-result state desync** (codex + cursor RC): §1 + §3.3 + §8 still framed "fresh probe needed" while §6.5/§8.5 recorded 7,724 result. Reconciled: §1 P3 row + §3.3 residual paragraph + §8 honesty bullet all now lead with the 7,724 result (sleek-heron-13 PR #4140) and note substrate-absorbed pattern; §8 final bullet clarifies per-class delta still pending review. 2. **§4 Path A overclaim** (codex RC): "Either flips strict P5 GREEN" was wrong — neither (i) nor (ii) flips P5 GREEN by routing decision alone. Rewrote Path A to make explicit: P5 GREEN requires TestClaim suite passes bullet satisfied by actual suite execution receipt; choice (i)/(ii) authorization unblocks dispatch toward that receipt. INVARIANTS P2 single-authority preserved: §8.5/§6.5 are canonical for state; every other section now references their 7,724 reading rather than maintaining parallel stale 7,175 references. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
briansrls
left a comment
briansrls
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Review metadata
- Provider / model:
codex/unknown - Commit:
57677add· Trigger:schedule - Thinking:
159s wall
BLOCKING (1)
Root Cause
docs/audit/v4-rustc-error-catalog-2026-06-01-post-jun1-cascade.mdBaseline evidence is external or misnamed while the new audit declares it as a repo artifact → commit the #4122 baseline under the cited path, or change the receipt to cite the actual committed/checkable baseline source.
|
|
||
| **Manager session:** `sleek-heron-13` (M1 rustc probe lane). | ||
| **Authority:** dashboard node `adhoc-7b46e080-3cd` ("Fresh M1 rustc probe post-Jun1-cascade"). | ||
| **Live ratchet meter:** this catalog replaces `docs/audit/v4-rustc-error-catalog-2026-05-31-post-p5.md` / PR #4122 as the current full-tree M1 rustc residual measurement. The #4122 catalog remains the 2026-05-31 post-#4115 baseline. |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
BLOCKING: The live ratchet meter names docs/audit/v4-rustc-error-catalog-2026-05-31-post-p5.md as the baseline artifact, but git ls-tree origin/main for that path returns no blob, so the #4122 delta is not backed by a repository-visible source of truth under INVARIANTS P1.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
I verified this against the current local refs and the PR merge-base. The cited #4122 baseline is repository-visible under the exact path named here:
$ git merge-base HEAD origin/main
483d82a789a020d12471dfda6b5150c70e9dd437
$ git ls-tree origin/main docs/audit/v4-rustc-error-catalog-2026-05-31-post-p5.md docs/audit/v4-rustc-error-catalog-2026-05-31-post-p5.m1-probe-summary.txt
100644 blob 7c144ac55326e063aa1aca24a287ee1b01f15dd8 docs/audit/v4-rustc-error-catalog-2026-05-31-post-p5.m1-probe-summary.txt
100644 blob 14eed93e229df5370a72fa52b5627bd0df32455f docs/audit/v4-rustc-error-catalog-2026-05-31-post-p5.md
$ git ls-tree $(git merge-base HEAD origin/main) docs/audit/v4-rustc-error-catalog-2026-05-31-post-p5.md docs/audit/v4-rustc-error-catalog-2026-05-31-post-p5.m1-probe-summary.txt
100644 blob 7c144ac55326e063aa1aca24a287ee1b01f15dd8 docs/audit/v4-rustc-error-catalog-2026-05-31-post-p5.m1-probe-summary.txt
100644 blob 14eed93e229df5370a72fa52b5627bd0df32455f docs/audit/v4-rustc-error-catalog-2026-05-31-post-p5.mdThe raw summary at origin/main:docs/audit/v4-rustc-error-catalog-2026-05-31-post-p5.m1-probe-summary.txt contains rustc error[E####] lines: 7175, so the baseline is checkable from the repo tree and is not external/misnamed. No code/doc change needed for this finding. — sent from sleek-heron-13
|
Review metadata
1. Story of the diffThis PR adds a fresh Jun 1 M1 full-tree Rust-emission audit under 2. Invariant categories
N/A — the diff is documentation-only audit output; it does not add or alter substrate types, Dag-resident state, cross-pass carriers,
Finding — Boundary Discipline / facts-flow-forward:
N/A — no Rust implementation, helpers, functions, error shapes, or comments in code are changed; this is a prose/measurement artifact.
Compliant — no behavior-bearing code changed, so no new unit/integration regression test is required; the diff does include a repro command block for the measurement artifact at
N/A — the PR does not edit or reinterpret a locked design doc; it records a probe against the existing v4 M1 rustc residual surface.
Compliant — the catalog’s “likely collapse lever” rows describe audit readouts and follow-up modeling opportunities, not new scaffolds, TODOs, temporary APIs, or bridge surfaces introduced by this PR. 2.5. Top-down PM intent reviewFinding — live ratchet accuracy: the PR explicitly says this catalog “replaces” the prior catalog as the current full-tree M1 rustc residual measurement at chatgpt-review-5f966b23-ddf9-43… 3. VerdictREQUEST_CHANGES. The diff is otherwise a clean documentation-only probe refresh, but the histogram is the load-bearing artifact and its row-level delta accounting does not reconcile with the stated total. Fixing that before merge keeps the new live ratchet meter trustworthy. |
…1.8 self-compile runway, §8.5 resolutions) Per operator 2026-06-01T01 approval-with-edits: 1. **Class B wording tightened** (§11.7.2): "required if already modeled" → "Only if part of current §11.7.1 safety floor OR selected by trusted affected-set/testgen". Prevents required surface from silently growing back. 2. **Explicit Rust emit pick** (§11.7.1 gate #3): chose `M1 v4 full-tree rust emit probe` (NOT both M1 + T-22 corpus rust). Rationale: M1 drives the residual-count catalogs (#4086/#4122/#4140) that inform dispatch; T-22 corpus rust duplicates same closure compile with no unique signal → demoted to Class C scheduled. 3. **§11.8 NEW: Language self-compile runway** with explicit rungs L0-L4 per language: - L0 leaf-model verification - L1 compiler-subset emit - L2 compiler-subset execution - L3 self-output fixed point - L4 full self-compile Per-language manager scope tabled: Rust (critical path, L1 in progress); Go (release-minimum, L0; clean external verifier advantage); Python (release-minimum, L0 complete via #4117); TypeScript (alpha/preview); C++ (capacity-permitting matrix only). Mechanical rules preserved (worksheet single-authority-fact gate, shared facts through Modeling DFS Arbiter). 4. **§8.5 operator decisions resolved** per operator sign-off: - P5 runtime gate: option (ii) authorized as WORKSHEET (not impl) in parallel with P3 - SG-8 / Modeling DFS succession: dedicated manager to spawn; PM does NOT act as DFS; keen-heron stays TR - TypeScript: authorized as alpha/preview language lane - Go/Python: authorized for self-compile runway per §11.8 - CI Coverage Bankruptcy Wave 1: APPROVED; spawn CI Manager - stern-lynx closeout (c): still pending (low-priority; role reconstituting anyway) INVARIANTS P2 single-authority preserved throughout: §8.5 canonical for sign-off state; §11.7 + §11.8 reference operator framing without claiming alternate authority. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
|
Review metadata
1. Story of the diffThis PR adds a fresh Jun 1 M1 v4 rustc residual catalog and its raw probe summary under chatgpt-review-f78856d2-2523-4f… chatgpt-review-f78856d2-2523-4f… 2. Invariant categories
N/A — the diff is documentation/audit-only: it adds
Compliant — fail-closed / facts-flow-forward / single-authority are handled by recording the failed chatgpt-review-f78856d2-2523-4f… chatgpt-review-f78856d2-2523-4f… chatgpt-review-f78856d2-2523-4f…
N/A — no Rust implementation code, APIs, helper functions, methods, errors, or comments are added. The prose is an audit artifact with tables, receipt metadata, and repro commands; the Rust style rules do not apply to changed code because there is no changed code.
Compliant — no behavior changed, so no new test is required. For this measurement-only docs PR, the appropriate receipt is the committed raw summary plus the reproducible probe command at
Compliant — the PR does not alter a locked design doc or weaken Pure Bootstrap to Zero. It stays within the v4 operational framing by using the v2 compiler as the probe compiler and measuring emitted v4 Rust residuals, which is consistent with the uploaded live authority that v2 serves as v4’s stage-minus-one while v4 is the active operational instantiation. chatgpt-review-d57003f4-5c5e-4b…
N/A — I do not see new scaffolds, TODOs, temporary APIs, bridges, or unbounded “defer” shapes. The “likely collapse lever” rows are readout from measured errors, not new implementation scaffolding; the catalog also preserves the raw summary and related artifacts list at 2.5. Top-down PM intent reviewCompliant. The highest-level intent is not diluted: Pure Bootstrap to Zero remains the live v4 authority, with v4 measured through the v2 stage-minus-one path, and this PR adds measurement visibility rather than new hand-authored compiler implementation or a postponed target. The readout’s semantics point workers toward modeled projection fixes — import authority, generic instantiation preservation, ownership/collection realization — and explicitly avoid turning the increased count into a class-closure regression or a new broad worksheet. chatgpt-review-f78856d2-2523-4f… 3. VerdictAPPROVE The diff is a coherent measurement receipt: the histogram arithmetic reconciles, the old baseline remains distinguishable from the new live meter, and the modeling readout does not create substrate, code, test, or locked-design drift. I found no blocking invariant or PM-intent mismatch in the changed lines. |
* docs(planning): v4 dep graph Jun 1 release-day EOD — post-cascade snapshot Successor to docs/planning/v4-predicate-dependency-graph-2026-05-31.md (#4096) capturing the 2026-05-31 P3+P5 cascade end-of-day state on Jun 1 release day. Summary of today's predicate state movement: - P5 dep-graph-framing: Layer 1 + Layer 2 BOTH CLOSED via #4115 structural-bridge implementation (positive-Y CiUpsertStep replaces shell, bridge deleted); strict TASKS.md reading still has runtime-gate upward debt at adhoc-f8699326-d69 (operator decision pending). - P3: 8 of 9 routed classes closed/retired today (SG-1/7/5/6/1b/2/RC-LAYERING/SG-3-cascade-retired) + SG-8 worksheet on main (impl gated on §8). Residual rustc count stale at 7175 (#4122 catalog); fresh probe needed. - P2: scope (a) PROVEN; bridge deletion 14-day window starts today via #4097 M2 probe. Operator decision OR window completion gates full P2 GREEN. - T-38-PR2 verdict-surface migration LANDED #4120. Org change: proud-pike-680 archived mid-day; Modeling DFS lane consolidated under keen-heron-687 de facto. §8 sign-off authority for SG-8 impl needs operator routing. Tree health: 0 active subtree work at 00:30Z 2026-06-01. All 5 overnight PRs merged; #4112 operator-landed. Managers idle. Operator decisions pending (block forward progress): - P5 runtime gate (i) M1 cargo-clean subset vs (ii) bootstrap-evaluator corpus path (load-bearing per SELF_HOSTING) - P2-B bridge deletion authorization (or 14-day window wait) - SG-8 §8 sign-off authority routing post-proud-pike-archival No code paths changed; docs-only. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com> * docs(planning): #4137 codex RC fix — P5 canonical predicate single-authority Addresses codex REQUEST_CHANGES on #4137: §10 "P5 fully GREEN today" framing violated single-authority discipline against canonical TASKS.md predicate "TestClaim suite passes". Same snapshot at §3.5 / line 102 correctly named the runtime-execution gate as still open (adhoc-f8699326-d69), creating parallel dep-graph definition risk where a worker could treat P5 as done. Fix: §10 rewritten to lead with "P5 (canonical 'TestClaim suite passes' per TASKS.md): NOT fully GREEN today" — Layer 1+2 closed but runtime-execution gate remains open; explicit "do NOT treat as done" anti-misread phrasing. INVARIANTS P2/P3 single-authority + fail-closed documentation discipline preserved by aligning §10 with §3.5. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com> * docs(planning): #4137 codex RC fix 2 — eliminate "dep-graph framing P5 GREEN" alternate-authority phrasing Addresses codex second REQUEST_CHANGES on #4137: §8:156 "per dep-graph framing, P5 is GREEN (both layers closed)" was a second P5 status authority even in a risk/honesty section, despite §10 anchoring canonical TASKS.md status. A worker could read §8 as permission to close P5 before runtime-execution gate. Fix: §8 rewritten to lead with "P5 single authority: P5 is GREEN only when the canonical TASKS.md predicate 'TestClaim suite passes' is satisfied." Today's Layer 1+2 closures explicitly framed as "partial progress toward P5, not an alternate definition of GREEN." Adds explicit "Do not treat partial layer closure as P5 GREEN" anti-misread. INVARIANTS P2 single-authority discipline fully aligned: only the canonical predicate text in TASKS.md:816 defines what GREEN means for P5. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com> * docs(planning): #4137 expansion — operator sign-offs queue + remaining-7000 protocol + TS parallel ops Per operator request "tell me anything else that needs sign off up front + get this entire sheet fresh/ready": Added three new sections: - §8.5 Operator sign-offs queue (consolidated table; tracks all PM-waits-on-operator items including P2-B AUTHORIZED + fresh M1 probe AUTHORIZED that just dispatched) - §8.6 Remaining P3 residual cascade — explicit worksheet protocol clarity (probe → §10.0 → impl → repeat); names keen-heron as de facto manager pending routing decision - §8.7 TypeScript / cross-target parallel opportunities (TR-lane work feasible parallel to Rust residual; per Wave F F3 TS is v4-alpha-only; mirrors today's Python widening pattern) Also updated §1 P2 row: TECHNICAL-PROVEN / AUTHORITY-BLOCKED → TECHNICAL-PROVEN; DELETION IN FLIGHT (operator authorized 00:28Z; work-item adhoc-4cad7e9b-558 spawned to skip 14-day window). Pending operator decisions still in queue (per §8.5): - P5 runtime gate (i) M1 cargo-clean subset vs (ii) bootstrap-evaluator corpus path - SG-8 §8 sign-off authority routing - Modeling DFS Manager succession plan - TypeScript work plan authorization - stern-lynx closeout cond (c) Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com> * docs(planning): #4137 codex RC #3 + cursor RC fix — reconcile P2-B authorization state + correct ci.yml line citation Addresses combined codex (RC #3) and cursor (RC #1 on this PR) findings: 1. **P2-B authorization desync** (codex + cursor): §3.2, §4 Path B, §6, §6.5, §7, §10 all framed P2-B as pending operator decision, while §8.5 + §1 P2 row recorded the 00:28Z AUTHORIZED state. One snapshot, two authorities. Fix: every blocker/dispatch-board/watchlist mention of P2-B updated to "AUTHORIZED + in flight" with work-item URL adhoc-4cad7e9b-558. §8.5 is the single source of truth for sign-off state. 2. **ci.yml line citation wrong** (cursor): bridge step is at ci.yml:401-410 (the `v2 → v4 bootstrap resolve-posture gate` step); lines 378-385 are the unrelated phase1/nat_semiring gate (carried over from #4096 predecessor without verification). Fixed in §3.2. 3. **Fresh M1 probe also AUTHORIZED + in flight** (carried desync): §10 listed fresh M1 probe under "PM dispatches available pending operator authorization"; updated to reflect 00:28Z authorization + work-item adhoc-7b46e080-3cd in flight. INVARIANTS P2 (single authority) preserved: §8.5 is canonical for sign-off state; every other section now references or aligns with it. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com> * docs(planning): #4137 codex RC #4 + operator-blocking reviews fix — full single-authority cleanup Addresses three operator-blocking inline reviews + codex RC #4: 1. **TASKS.md line-number drift risk**: switched all `src/v4/TASKS.md:806-817` and `:816` citations to stable section anchor `src/v4/TASKS.md` "Definition of v4-done" (operator/codex flagged line-number cite as drift risk; using header anchor is robust against future renumbering). Note: current file content confirms predicates ARE at :813-817 under :805 header; operator's :572-584 suggestion doesn't match current main but the anchor switch sidesteps the issue entirely. 2. **ci.yml line-number drift risk**: switched all `.github/workflows/ci.yml:401-410` citations to step name `v2 → v4 bootstrap resolve-posture gate (CI emit-wall bridge)` (operator/cursor flagged 401-410 as not precisely the bridge step; step-name cite is robust + names exactly what gets deleted). 3. **Fresh M1 probe desync** (operator blocking on line 89): §6 listed as pending blocker owned by sharp-otter while §8.5 marked AUTHORIZED + in flight. §6 and §6.5 updated to reflect AUTHORIZED + work-item adhoc-7b46e080-3cd in flight (sleek-heron-13 spawned; PR #4140 7,724 errors +549 vs #4122). 4. **§7 PM-actionable contradiction** (codex RC #4): "No worker implementation dispatches blocked" contradicted SG-8 needing §8 routing. §7 rewritten to explicitly enumerate blocked items (SG-8, P5 runtime) referencing §6.5 dispatch board + §8.5 operator decisions queue. INVARIANTS P2 single-authority: §8.5 is the canonical sign-off state; §6 + §6.5 + §7 + §10 now all reference §8.5 rather than maintaining parallel state. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com> * docs(planning): #4137 codex/cursor RC #5+#6 fix — reconcile probe-result state + Path A no-overclaim Addresses two more blocking reviews: 1. **Probe-result state desync** (codex + cursor RC): §1 + §3.3 + §8 still framed "fresh probe needed" while §6.5/§8.5 recorded 7,724 result. Reconciled: §1 P3 row + §3.3 residual paragraph + §8 honesty bullet all now lead with the 7,724 result (sleek-heron-13 PR #4140) and note substrate-absorbed pattern; §8 final bullet clarifies per-class delta still pending review. 2. **§4 Path A overclaim** (codex RC): "Either flips strict P5 GREEN" was wrong — neither (i) nor (ii) flips P5 GREEN by routing decision alone. Rewrote Path A to make explicit: P5 GREEN requires TestClaim suite passes bullet satisfied by actual suite execution receipt; choice (i)/(ii) authorization unblocks dispatch toward that receipt. INVARIANTS P2 single-authority preserved: §8.5/§6.5 are canonical for state; every other section now references their 7,724 reading rather than maintaining parallel stale 7,175 references. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com> * docs(planning): #4137 §11 — proposed next-iteration management structure (operator-requested) Adds §11 covering operator-requested management redesign for post-Jun-1 next-iteration. Structural principle: fan out RCA + worksheet authoring; centralize single-authority approval per INVARIANTS P2. Roles defined (with scope / deliverable-by-end-of-tenure / exit criteria for each): - Modeling DFS Arbiter (fresh-spawn, NOT PM; single-authority gate) - 5 per-language RCA Managers: Rust, Python, Go, TypeScript (alpha/preview), C++ (later) - 6 shared substrate managers: ModuleGraph, TargetTypeExpression, TargetAtom, Collection/Algebra, Runtime/TestClaim, CI CI Manager scope captures post-cascade CI state: - substrate exists (ci.dag CiPipeline/CiJob/CiGate/CiUpsertStep) but runtime still YAML+shell - four-compile-redundancy in ci_v4 still unresolved per #4091 §1.2 - affected-set testing/building NOT yet via evaluator; weeks-to-months - deliverable: collapse 4 compiles to 1; YAML→CiUpsertStep; affected-set via evaluator; shell retirement; runtime ≤10min Coordination protocol + mechanical rule (no impl without §10.0 worksheet) preserved. PM scope under new structure: routing + escalation only; explicit DO NOT list (act as Arbiter, approve substrate, spawn impl without worksheet). Pending operator re-review per their message; if ratified, §11.4 lists immediate next-wave dispatch. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com> * docs(planning): #4137 §11.6 — concrete CI migration inventory per operator request Adds §11.6 with verified counts as of 2026-06-01T01:00Z post-#4139 main: Headline: - ci.yml: 73 YAML steps across 7 jobs - ci.dag: 47 modeled CiUpsertStep rows on main (W2.3 Buckets A+B+C+E + bankruptcy Tier-0 + #4115 P5) - scripts/: ~30 shell scripts (~22 production candidates for retirement; ~8 dev/test infra stays) Migration scope categorized (A-E): - A: Already modeled + receipt-parity (47 rows) - B: Pending modeling (gate/check steps, ~10): SG-0 net-shrink, R4-carve, fabrication sentinel, T-19 testgen, release-doc authority, install.sh pinned, manager-brief, test-timeout, rust toolchain, Gate #103 - C: Pending modeling (leaf-model boundaries, ~6): Phase 1 R1/R2a/R2b/R3-external for rust + python - D: Pending modeling (toolchain/cache, ~5): per-job duplication of isolation + rustup pin - E: Already retired (testclaim-corpus-gate.sh #4115, resolve-posture-gate.sh #4139, bankruptcy #4101) Shell retirement list enumerated (22 production scripts). Structural redundancies per #4091 §1.2: four-compile in ci_v4 (~14m savings), per-job HOME isolation (4× duplication), cache cleanup. Runtime authority migration coupled with P5 runtime gate (adhoc-f8699326-d69) — both are same SELF_HOSTING substrate work. Affected-set testing/building via evaluator: modeled substrate exists (ChangeSet → AffectedSet → AffectedSetProduced in src/v4/std/change.dag); runtime gap is same as P5 runtime gate. CI Manager near-term wins (executable without operator decision): migrate B+C, collapse D duplication, collapse four-compile redundancy. Long-pole: runtime authority migration (gated on P5 runtime decision). Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com> * docs(planning): #4137 codex RC fix — P2-B state DELIVERED (#4139 merged 00:50Z) Addresses codex RC: §11.6 line 324 said #4139 deleted the bridge script while §1/§3.2/§4/§6/§6.5/§7/§10 said "in flight" — inconsistent live state. Verified via git ls-tree origin/main: #4139 MERGED 2026-06-01T00:50:17Z (squash 12d1aa6); script + ci.yml step actually gone from main. All P2-B state references updated: - §1 P2 row: "TECHNICAL-PROVEN; DELETION IN FLIGHT" → "GREEN" - §3.2 section: header + body reflect #4139 MERGED with squash SHA - §4 Path B: "IN FLIGHT" → "DONE" - §6 blocker: "RESOLVED + DELIVERED" - §6.5 dispatch board priority 2: state "DONE 2026-06-01T00:50Z" - §7 PM dispatches: "DELIVERED via #4139 MERGED 00:50Z" - §8.5 sign-off queue: "DONE" with merge SHA - §10 watchlist: "P2: fully GREEN" INVARIANTS P2 single-authority restored: one accurate live-state authority across the doc; #4139 MERGED is the canonical fact. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com> * docs(planning): #4137 §11.7 — CI Coverage Bankruptcy: bare-minimum first + cut list + reframed CI Manager charter Per operator directive 2026-06-01T01: aggressive CI cut now, bare minimum survival floor, reframe CI Manager to "make affected-set + testgen the safety net" not "migrate every shell step". Restructured §11.7: §11.7.1 BARE MINIMUM SAFETY NET (what stays) — 5 required gates explicit: 1. fmt --check 2. bootstrap minimal viability (shell exception short-term) 3. ONE Rust emit/probe path (not four — collapse four-compile redundancy) 4. ci.dag structural receipt + CiUpsertStep schema checks 5. no-new-shell ratchet Target: cold PR ~5-10min (vs current 30-75min) §11.7.2 Four CI classes (A/B/C/D) for categorization. §11.7.3 AGGRESSIVE CUT LIST: now includes operator directive to PERMANENTLY delete all v3 integration tests (ci_integration Tier-0 I3 determinism_test, full v3 job: cargo test --lib --bins, clippy --features bootstrap-regen-fresh, etc) — DELETE not demote per project_spirit + #4101 bankruptcy. §11.7.4-6 unchanged (four-wave plan, cut rule, honesty ledger). §11.7.7 CI Manager REFRAMED charter: - Old: "migrate every shell step to CiUpsertStep" - New: "get the bare minimum safety net working in CI using affected-set + testgen" - Work lane prioritizes: bankruptcy cut → four-compile collapse → affected-set + testgen shadow → first active modeled skip → affected-set as Class A authority - Shell-to-CiUpsertStep migration becomes BACKGROUND/INCREMENTAL in service of affected-set needs, not a separate front - Explicit anti-patterns: don't migrate for completeness; don't maintain retired-lane ratchets; don't trust affected-set exclusively before Wave 3 proves it Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com> * docs(planning): #4137 — operator sign-off edits (Class B, M1 pick, §11.8 self-compile runway, §8.5 resolutions) Per operator 2026-06-01T01 approval-with-edits: 1. **Class B wording tightened** (§11.7.2): "required if already modeled" → "Only if part of current §11.7.1 safety floor OR selected by trusted affected-set/testgen". Prevents required surface from silently growing back. 2. **Explicit Rust emit pick** (§11.7.1 gate #3): chose `M1 v4 full-tree rust emit probe` (NOT both M1 + T-22 corpus rust). Rationale: M1 drives the residual-count catalogs (#4086/#4122/#4140) that inform dispatch; T-22 corpus rust duplicates same closure compile with no unique signal → demoted to Class C scheduled. 3. **§11.8 NEW: Language self-compile runway** with explicit rungs L0-L4 per language: - L0 leaf-model verification - L1 compiler-subset emit - L2 compiler-subset execution - L3 self-output fixed point - L4 full self-compile Per-language manager scope tabled: Rust (critical path, L1 in progress); Go (release-minimum, L0; clean external verifier advantage); Python (release-minimum, L0 complete via #4117); TypeScript (alpha/preview); C++ (capacity-permitting matrix only). Mechanical rules preserved (worksheet single-authority-fact gate, shared facts through Modeling DFS Arbiter). 4. **§8.5 operator decisions resolved** per operator sign-off: - P5 runtime gate: option (ii) authorized as WORKSHEET (not impl) in parallel with P3 - SG-8 / Modeling DFS succession: dedicated manager to spawn; PM does NOT act as DFS; keen-heron stays TR - TypeScript: authorized as alpha/preview language lane - Go/Python: authorized for self-compile runway per §11.8 - CI Coverage Bankruptcy Wave 1: APPROVED; spawn CI Manager - stern-lynx closeout (c): still pending (low-priority; role reconstituting anyway) INVARIANTS P2 single-authority preserved throughout: §8.5 canonical for sign-off state; §11.7 + §11.8 reference operator framing without claiming alternate authority. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com> * docs(planning): #4137 cursor RC fix — propagate §8.5 resolutions through §1/§4/§6/§6.5/§7/§10 Addresses cursor RC: §8.5 marked operator decisions #3-#8 RESOLVED at 01Z but §1/§4/§6/§6.5/§7/§10 still listed them as pending blockers / operator decisions. Single-authority violation per INVARIANTS P2. Reconciliation: - §1 P5 row: removed "operator decision pending"; added "option (ii) authorized as WORKSHEET per §8.5 #3" - §4 Path A: removed "operator decision required"; replaced with worksheet-authorized framing - §6 blockers table: P5 runtime gate + SG-8 §8 sign-off both struck-through with RESOLVED references - §6.5 dispatch board: P5 runtime gate + SG-8 §8 rows reframed to "RESOLVED; <next-step>" with Modeling DFS Arbiter as owner - §7 PM-actionable: SG-8 + P5 impl rephrased from "BLOCKED on operator decision" to "pending Modeling DFS Arbiter spawn + worksheet authoring" (sequenced post-resolution) - §10 watchlist: all 5 RESOLVED decisions struck-through with resolution summaries; added "Next dispatch actions" subsection listing the spawn-to-do queue (Modeling DFS Arbiter, CI Manager, language RCA Managers, P5 worksheet) INVARIANTS P2 single-authority restored: §8.5 is canonical; every other section now defers to §8.5 numbering with resolution status. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com> * docs(planning): #4137 operator-blocking RC fix — gate-vs-decision distinction + P2-GREEN propagation Addresses 3 operator-blocking inline reviews at lines 85/86/87: 1. **P5 runtime gate vs P5 routing DECISION** (operator line 86): §8.5 #3 conflated "routing decision resolved" with "gate resolved". The OPERATOR CHOICE between (i) and (ii) is resolved; the GATE itself (runtime executes + suite passes) is STILL OPEN. Reconciled: - §8.5 #3: "DECISION RESOLVED" not "RESOLVED"; explicit "gate itself remains OPEN" - §6 blockers: "(still OPEN)" qualifier on P5 runtime gate row - §6.5 dispatch board priority 1: "(gate OPEN; routing RESOLVED)" + exit-receipt sequence extended through ship+execute - §3.5 P5 + §10 + §1 P5 row unchanged (correctly already showed gate OPEN) 2. **SG-8 §8 sign-off authority routing vs §8 ratification** (operator line 87): §8.5 #4 conflated "authority routing resolved" with "§8 ratification resolved". The AUTHORITY question (who reviews) is resolved; the actual §8 RATIFICATION on SG-8 worksheet is a separate step that gates impl dispatch. Reconciled: - §8.5 #4: "ROUTING RESOLVED" with note that §8 ratification is separate post-Arbiter-spawn step - §6 blockers: "(authority routing resolved; ratification still open)" qualifier 3. **P2 stale-reference propagation** (operator line 85 related): §1 P4 row + §3.4 still said "hard-gated on P2 full PROVEN + P3 binary builds" — P2 is fully GREEN per #4139. Fixed both to reference only P3 binary builds as remaining gate. INVARIANTS P2 single-authority preserved: each predicate state distinguishes routing-decision-resolved vs gate-closure-pending; no parallel authorities for the same predicate state. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com> * docs(planning): #4137 codex RC fix — §3.5 P5 line 98 stale "decision pending" → reflect §8.5 #3 resolution Addresses codex RC at line 98: §3.5 still said "Operator decision pending" for (i) vs (ii) routing while §8.5 #3 records RESOLVED at 01Z with option (ii) WORKSHEET authorized. Single-authority violation per INVARIANTS P2. Fixed: §3.5 P5 paragraph now lead-frames the routing decision as RESOLVED (option (ii) WORKSHEET, per §8.5 #3) while preserving the canonical gate-OPEN reading (runtime ships + suite executes + passes). (i) noted as patient-wait alternative path downstream of P3 cascade. INVARIANTS P2 single-authority preserved: §8.5 canonical for sign-off state; §3.5 references it consistently. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com> * docs(planning): #4137 codex RC fix — §6.5 priority 3 SG-8 routing-vs-ratification rename Addresses codex finding on §6.5 priority 3: state column said "RESOLVED" but exit receipt still required "§8 ratification → SG-8 impl worker dispatchable", creating ambiguous live-state. Fix: rename title from "SG-8 §8 sign-off authority" to "SG-8 §8 sign-off **routing** (NOT the ratification itself)"; state column now explicit about what's resolved (routing) vs pending (ratification). Sequence noted: Arbiter spawn → §8 ratification → SG-8 impl. This was the codex review on sha 4242a83 (3 commits behind HEAD); line 98 fix at 21b0b35 + gate-vs-decision distinction at f246e9d also already address the broader pattern. This rename is the final piece on the §6.5 row itself. INVARIANTS P2 single-authority preserved: state column reflects only what's actually resolved (routing); exit-receipt column names the remaining dispatchability gate. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com> --------- Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
1 participant
Summary
Adds the 2026-06-01 post-Jun1-cascade M1 rustc residual catalog and raw probe summary. The fresh full-tree measurement at
origin/main483d82a78is 7,724error[E####]lines, replacing the stale #4122 count of 7,175 as the live ratchet meter.Key receipt points:
compiled: 351 files emitted, 0 diagnostics.cargo checkwas attempted and failed as expected for the residual probe: 7,724 rustc error lines across 310 emitted.rsfiles.E0423 = 0, v2 diagnostics = 0).Test plan
CARGO_BUILD_JOBS=4 /opt/cargo/bin/cargo build -p v2-compiler --release- passed.V2_COMPILER=target/release/gunbc V4_M1_RUST_EMIT_OUT=/tmp/v4-rust-emit-jun1-sleek-heron-13 V4_M1_CARGO_CHECK_JOBS=4 bash scripts/v4-m1-rust-emit-probe.sh- completed; expectedcargo checkexit 101 captured in the committed summary.