docs(e2e): E2E Completion Master Registry (Phase 0 of Master Continuation) - #151
Conversation
…ontinuation) User-mandated FIRST step in the E2E Master Continuation. Reconciles every existing audit / registry / matrix / handoff / merged PR into a single source of truth. Inputs reconciled - E2E_BLOCKER_REGISTRY_2026-05-09.md (PR #142) - REMAINING_SKIPPED_BLOCKERS_WAVE_2026-05-09.md (PR #146) - 60_APP_UPDATE_READINESS_AUDIT_2026-05-09.md (PR #135) - 60-apps-batch2/* (Bonus 12, Bonus 13, agent7-11, bonus14) - Images-GUI/ reference pack (PR #128/#134) - All 15 merged PRs #136-#150 today - Wave 1 (20-agent Blocker Elimination Swarm) receipts - Wave 2 (10-agent Remaining/Skipped Wave) receipts Sections 1. PR ledger: 15 PRs today, all squash, no fake passes 2. Reconciled blocker matrix: closed (13), partial (2), upstream-blocked (1), open (7), deferred-by-lock (1) 3. E2E Definition of Done: 14 items checklist with status 4. Hard gates: v0.13 retry CLOSED, GUI Playwright OPEN (dashboard-advanced), RC v2 resume OPEN, OpenCode/Hands OPEN 5. Open by category: P0 (none), P1 (4), P2 (4) 6. Hard external blockers (cannot fix in code): BLK-009 server, BLK-011 upstream, license / repo-identity / Hunyuan reviews needed from user 7. Provenance: 30+ research receipts banked, MCP evidence chain unbroken, 1 honest 1-loop escalation, 0 fake passes, 0 secret values exposed Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
![gemini-code-assist[bot]](https://avatars.githubusercontent.com/in/956858?s=60&v=4){kind=small}
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Code Review
This pull request introduces a comprehensive Master Registry document to consolidate E2E completion status for Hermes3D OS, including PR ledgers, blocker matrices, and Definition of Done tracking. Feedback focuses on improving the document's consistency and completeness, specifically addressing mismatched issue IDs between tables, adding missing entries for verified blockers, and ensuring all open tasks mentioned in the summary are represented in the detailed matrices.
| | #148 | 4c94342 | MiniMax env-KeyError parity (mirrors PR #145) | Wave Agent 7 | | ||
| | #149 | b130b6e | RC v2 commits 1+2 (`freeze_run` + `thaw_run` + saga compensation) | BLK-012 partial | | ||
| | #150 | ba4194d | 7 broad-except observability cleanups | Wave Agent 7 | |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
In the PR ledger, the Closes column for PR #148 and PR #150 lists Wave Agent 7. However, the Verified (closed) matrix in Section 2 identifies these as Squad G #2 and Squad G #3 respectively. The ledger should use the blocker/issue ID for consistency with other entries (like PR #145 closing Squad G #1).
| | #148 | 4c94342 | MiniMax env-KeyError parity (mirrors PR #145) | Wave Agent 7 | | |
| | #149 | b130b6e | RC v2 commits 1+2 (`freeze_run` + `thaw_run` + saga compensation) | BLK-012 partial | | |
| | #150 | ba4194d | 7 broad-except observability cleanups | Wave Agent 7 | | |
| | #148 | 4c94342 | MiniMax env-KeyError parity (mirrors PR #145) | Squad G #2 | | |
| | #149 | b130b6e | RC v2 commits 1+2 (`freeze_run` + `thaw_run` + saga compensation) | BLK-012 partial | | |
| | #150 | ba4194d | 7 broad-except observability cleanups | Squad G #3 | |
| | BLK-017 | Active-UI no-fake re-sweep | already verified `ACTIVE_UI_NO_FAKE_SWEEP.md` 2026-05-08 | | ||
| | Squad G #1 | DeepSeek bare-`KeyError` env disclosure | #145 | | ||
| | Squad G #2 | MiniMax bare-`KeyError` env disclosure | #148 | | ||
| | Squad G #3 | 7 broad-except silent fallbacks | #150 | |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
The Verified (closed) table is missing BLK-010, which is listed in the PR ledger (Section 1) as closed by PR #144.
| | Squad G #3 | 7 broad-except silent fallbacks | #150 | | |
| | Squad G #3 | 7 broad-except silent fallbacks | #150 | | |
| | BLK-010 | Bonus 13 docs errata follow-up | #144 | |
| | BLK-016 | Printer safety end-to-end drill | A10 | ~330 LoC (drill + Moonraker shim) | | ||
| | BLK-018 | Continuous CI secret-leak scan (Gitleaks) | A7 | ~50 LoC in `.github/workflows/` | | ||
| | BLK-019 | GHA `hermes-agent-proof.yml` workflow | Agent 13 (W1) | ~60 LoC YAML — DEFERRED until BLK-011 unblocks (else permanent red CI) | | ||
| | BLK-020 | `desktop_updates.py` same redaction asymmetry as #140 | Agent 7 (W1) | ~10 LoC | |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
The Open blocker matrix is missing the JSON Schema validator task mentioned in Section 5 (P2 open items). For consistency as a "single source of truth", all tracked open items should be present in the matrix.
1 participant
Summary
User-mandated Phase 0 deliverable. Reconciles every existing audit / registry / matrix / handoff / merged PR into a single source of truth.
Inputs reconciled
Sections
Test plan
🤖 Generated with Claude Code