docs(noema): converge #670 health cancellation authority

[seonghobae]

Purpose

Converge protected Noema #670 into the canonical product/technical gap and release history without promoting source integration to immutable release, deployment, performance, or foreign-owner authority.

RED → repair

Test-only exact a986d9df0cf3febc5137234ac323a11e489a99b4 required protected feature exact 14b4c9a46692df0084a03b9a3b2ae4acf1178a83, normal merge identity main@d42dcf5c39401de0614bed1f5ee38f9143c702be, both health-response cancellation-liveness paths, explicit release/service-authority separation, CHANGELOG traceability, and executable source semantics. Hosted CI 34687156934 passed exact checkout, base/lock control, install and typecheck, then recorded the expected documentation failure at test/orchestrator-health-cancellation-authority.test.ts:10: 1 failed / 4734 passed.

Exact 8e00d75ad22bc85b150ae93d23dd3bdd6539885e was the first GREEN candidate: it updates the dated protected observation and protected-history exact, adds #670 to the existing bounded-reader lifecycle paragraph with the service/foreign-authority and release boundary intact, and adds one Unreleased CHANGELOG entry. Runtime, dependency, provider/model, release, and foreign-owner implementation remain unchanged.

Hosted CI 34687469445 exposed a shared documentation-authority regression after the first GREEN candidate: 2 failed / 4733 passed. Adding #670 had replaced the older cross-lineage sentence immutable release and deployed heap/p95 evidence remain separate, so the independent #650 retained-memory and #668 external-reader authority tests both failed. Exact 564c8a4bc5021aafb549efc4a8320b92d0d3b1cb restores that shared invariant as a separate sentence while retaining #670's distinct deployed availability/p95 boundary; no source, runtime, dependency, or test oracle was weakened.

Hosted successor CI 34687881905 confirmed those two predicates were repaired (4734 passed) and exposed one independent false-positive oracle: documentation-architecture-contract.test.ts used substring PR #67, so valid PR #670 was classified as the retired owner. Exact a314a268e41b11e885c691cc8153ec84339c7bb9 changes only that stale-owner assertion to Unicode word-bounded regular expressions. Exact stale PR #67/#407/Active PR #426 remain forbidden; numeric successors such as #670 no longer collide.

Direct exact-tree predicates are true for protected-history identity, cancellation-liveness semantics, immutable-release/deployed-availability separation, foreign-authority separation, CHANGELOG traceability, both non-awaiting cleanup sites, and absence of the two historical awaited cleanup forms. Base→head was behind 0 before merge. The final delta contains exactly four files: CHANGELOG.md, docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md, the stale-owner executable documentation contract, and the #670 cancellation-authority executable contract.

Exact-head gates

Unchanged exact head a314a268e41b11e885c691cc8153ec84339c7bb9 reached terminal SUCCESS on all four required lanes:

• ci 34688433523
• reviewer-ci 34688433487
• Security Scan 34688433639
• patch-validator-image 34688433486

The Security lane temporarily had trivy-fs queued with runner_id=0, empty runner identity and no steps. That was retained as runner-assignment evidence rather than treated as source/scanner failure; no rerun, runs-on change, synthetic status, or gate weakening was used. The same unchanged Security run later completed SUCCESS.

Authority

#671 was automatically marked merged only because its RED exact is an ancestor of #670's normally merged head; merge_commit_sha equals its own head and no separate production delta entered protected main. Its valid test delta remains protected through #670 and its hosted RED run remains evidence, not release or merge authority.

Fresh exact-head COMMENT review found no actionable finding and unresolved inline threads were zero. Protected base remained d42dcf5c39401de0614bed1f5ee38f9143c702be. Expected-head normal merge produced GitHub-verified main@31c5ca87a907c08a124e23d4ec6ebd0339a873f2, preserving d42dcf5c39401de0614bed1f5ee38f9143c702be and #672 exact a314a268e41b11e885c691cc8153ec84339c7bb9 as its two parents.

This integration is source/documentation authority only. It does not establish immutable release, production deployment, availability/p95, contextual-orchestrator service/provider/model routing, credential/outbound authority, quarantine/security authority, or foreign-domain truth.

[coderabbitai]

Caution

Review failed

The pull request is closed.

ℹ️ Recent review info

⚙️ Run configuration

Configuration used: Organization UI

Review profile: CHILL

Plan: Advanced

Run ID: 01508c6d-2240-4ec5-9057-7ae167de644e

📥 Commits

Reviewing files that changed from the base of the PR and between d42dcf5 and a314a26.

📒 Files selected for processing (4)

• CHANGELOG.md
• docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md
• test/documentation-architecture-contract.test.ts
• test/orchestrator-health-cancellation-authority.test.ts

---

📝 Walkthrough

Walkthrough

PR #670의 cancellation-liveness 동작을 changelog와 protected baseline에 기록했습니다. 관련 문서와 gateway 소스의 invariants를 검증하는 테스트를 추가하고, stale owner 검사를 단어 경계 정규식으로 변경했습니다.

Changes

Cancellation liveness 기록 및 검증

Layer / File(s)	Summary
Protected baseline 및 변경 기록 docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md, CHANGELOG.md	PR #670의 merge identity와 protected history를 갱신했습니다. /healthz oversized-response cancellation 동작과 Noema authority 비이전 범위를 기록했습니다.
문서 및 소스 계약 검증 test/documentation-architecture-contract.test.ts, test/orchestrator-health-cancellation-authority.test.ts	stale owner 검사를 단어 경계 정규식으로 변경했습니다. baseline, changelog, gateway의 비동기 cancellation 계약을 검증하는 테스트를 추가했습니다.

Estimated code review effort: 2 (Simple) | ~10 minutes

Change: Other

✨ Finishing Touches

📝 Generate docstrings

• Create stacked PR
• Commit on current branch

🧪 Generate unit tests (beta)

• Create PR with unit tests
• Commit unit tests in branch docs/orchestrator-health-cancel-liveness-authority-20260912

---

Thanks for using CodeRabbit! It's free for OSS, and your support helps us grow. If you like it, consider giving us a shout-out.

❤️ Share

• X
• Mastodon
• Reddit
• LinkedIn

_{Comment @coderabbitai help to get the list of available commands.}

[seonghobae]

Exact-head review of 8e00d75ad22bc85b150ae93d23dd3bdd6539885e: reviewed the complete three-file delta against protected main@d42dcf5c39401de0614bed1f5ee38f9143c702be. The executable authority test binds #670's protected exact head, both non-awaiting cancellation forms, and the absence of the superseded awaited forms. Baseline and CHANGELOG distinguish protected source from immutable release/deployed availability/p95 evidence and do not transfer contextual-orchestrator/provider/model/credential/outbound/quarantine/security/foreign-domain authority. No actionable finding. This COMMENT records review evidence only; it is not self-approval or merge authority. Merge still requires unchanged-head terminal exact-head gates and a fresh main/thread re-fetch.

[seonghobae]

Exact-head review of 564c8a4bc5021aafb549efc4a8320b92d0d3b1cb: reviewed the complete three-file delta against protected main@d42dcf5c39401de0614bed1f5ee38f9143c702be and the intermediate hosted failure. The final one-line repair restores the pre-existing cross-lineage invariant immutable release and deployed heap/p95 evidence remain separate without weakening #670's distinct deployed availability/p95 boundary, runtime semantics, test oracle, or foreign-owner separation. CHANGELOG and baseline record #670 as protected Noema-side consumer hardening only; contextual-orchestrator/provider/model/credential/outbound/quarantine/security/foreign-domain authority remains external. No actionable finding. This COMMENT is exact-head review evidence only, not self-approval or merge authority; merge still requires unchanged-head terminal required gates, zero unresolved threads, and a fresh protected-base re-read.

[seonghobae]

Exact-head review of a314a268e41b11e885c691cc8153ec84339c7bb9: reviewed all four changed files against protected main@d42dcf5c39401de0614bed1f5ee38f9143c702be. The documentation convergence records #670's protected cancellation-liveness source semantics without promoting immutable release, deployed availability/p95, contextual-orchestrator service/provider/model routing, credential/outbound, quarantine/security, or foreign-domain authority. The executable authority test binds the exact #670 source identity and both non-awaiting cleanup forms. The stale-owner repair narrows exact retired identifiers with Unicode word boundaries so PR #67 remains forbidden while valid numeric successors such as PR #670 no longer collide. No actionable finding in the current four-file delta. This COMMENT is review evidence only, not self-approval or merge authority; merge still requires unchanged-head terminal required gates, zero unresolved threads, and a fresh protected-base re-read.

[seonghobae]

Post-gate exact-head review of a314a268e41b11e885c691cc8153ec84339c7bb9: the unchanged head now has terminal SUCCESS on application CI 34688433523, reviewer-ci 34688433487, required Security Scan 34688433639, and patch-validator-image 34688433486. Re-read confirms protected base remains main@d42dcf5c39401de0614bed1f5ee38f9143c702be, the PR is mergeable, and unresolved inline threads are zero. The four-file delta remains documentation/executable-authority convergence for #670 plus the stale-owner false-positive repair; it does not grant Noema contextual-orchestrator service/provider/model routing, credential/outbound, quarantine/security, immutable-release, deployment, or production-outcome authority. No actionable finding. COMMENT only; not self-approval.

[seonghobae]

Final exact-head integration record: a314a268e41b11e885c691cc8153ec84339c7bb9 reached terminal SUCCESS on application CI 34688433523, reviewer-ci 34688433487, required Security Scan 34688433639, and patch-validator-image 34688433486. The Security lane briefly showed trivy-fs queued with runner_id=0, empty runner identity, and no steps; it was treated as runner-assignment wait, not source/scanner failure, and no rerun or gate weakening was used. Fresh exact-head COMMENT review found no actionable finding, unresolved inline threads were 0, and the protected base remained d42dcf5c39401de0614bed1f5ee38f9143c702be. Expected-head normal merge produced GitHub-verified main@31c5ca87a907c08a124e23d4ec6ebd0339a873f2, preserving base d42dcf5... and #672 exact a314a268... as its two parents. This is source/documentation authority only, not immutable release, deployment, availability/p95, or foreign-owner authority.