fix(lineage): bind dynamic evaluations to substantive criteria

[seonghobae]

Root-cause repair

Dynamic-evaluation lineage preserves what was evaluated and keeps criterion, observation, adjudication, calibration, promotion, linking, and supersession provenance auditable without absorbing foreign scoring or provider authority.

Current behavior

• criterion-bound runs retain one complete immutable criterion-set snapshot and reject mixed set/digest/rubric/blueprint semantics;
• direct item construction type-checks criterion_refs before truthiness-based binding inference;
• zero-anchor unavailable and within_run_only runs remain valid during cold start;
• calibration, promotion and linking evidence identities remain distinct;
• adjudication case/resolution identities remain distinct and source observations are never overwritten;
• in-run supersession is acyclic and bounded;
• opaque provenance references reject padding, controls/surrogates, Unicode Cf, Zl, Zp, and the 66 Unicode noncharacters without normalizing identity.

Owner boundary

LineageWeave owns the provenance/read-model projection only. contextual-orchestrator owns provider/model execution and invocation evidence; fast-mlsirm owns reusable psychometric calibration/linking arithmetic; TEPP owns temporal/drift semantics. Production integration must consume released/versioned owner artifacts and exact digests. No published fast_mlsirm_dynamic_evaluation_item/v1 contract is invented; tests use synthetic_source_contract/v1. ADR 0355 remains Proposed.

TDD repair lineage

• RED 6e83d1f8e151f91c442e20e42d28a5fef8118b46 → GREEN 1061fb316228968ece433d7f8c8848b200af7e17: calibration/promotion identity separation;
• RED 8c73220d49f429f2ce2930438fb63a5b672b246e → GREEN 9683ca64e87940d1fc7b878e4b89dd0511c2ab5d: linking-evidence identity separation;
• RED 9a78c0a2e5e7546d8211d008b699ce1e4f9412be → GREEN 3066c12eacbe86977f55b1abf3ebcf9f05e39b7a: malformed falsy criterion_refs fail the collection boundary;
• 05ce15a3f57254e73db2fd00f2e574abdf8d9f97: synthetic fixture no longer names a nonexistent fast-mlsirm contract;
• RED 79c1c32a0af9d45940b8dca12a13b7af03b89271 → GREEN 290da3a20ff76ae1a32b50166ed34bfd1679a5c7: reject line/paragraph separators;
• RED 623583464925d404f05750c841a4ca2f3b9cdeb8 → GREEN 0e1a413fd92e14f289ac648a75d621d26f0d3cb4: reject Unicode noncharacters while preserving ordinary unassigned code points; e977ba3f14b799b75b88467f2c25c04424e7299d and 958e68de450bfa2ff0a3aef54716a10ea4ce7976 keep changelog/ADR evidence current.

Current stack / merge boundary

Parent #902 moved non-force to c316bfbde8644feda7e49579d43cc162e99b0bad after #899/current-main convergence. Review 5118128121 verified this PR's 12 dynamic-evaluation lineage/evidence files are disjoint from the inherited workflow/contract repair. Two-parent convergence 8c74712f2af4acf76871c71a9fd72c6aa2912f4a preserves the lineage tree, adopts the moved parent's protected workflow contract, and joins #902 without force rewrite.

• exact parent/base: #902@c316bfbde8644feda7e49579d43cc162e99b0bad;
• exact current head: 8c74712f2af4acf76871c71a9fd72c6aa2912f4a;
• Draft/open/mechanically mergeable;
• exact-head Tests 33923173150 completed skipped under Draft admission and is not product GREEN;
• predecessor checks/reviews do not transfer and no qualifying independent approval is claimed.

Keep Draft until current-head repository/security/governance evidence is available and terminal-clean and a qualifying independent approval applies. No self-approval, force-push, bypass, fabricated owner contract, or predecessor evidence transfer.

[coderabbitai]

Important

Draft PR not reviewed

Draft PRs are not automatically reviewed by default.

• Trigger a manual review

To automatically review draft PRs, update your CodeRabbit configuration:

reviews:
  auto_review:
    drafts: true

---

Thanks for using CodeRabbit! It's free for OSS, and your support helps us grow. If you like it, consider giving us a shout-out.

❤️ Share

• X
• Mastodon
• Reddit
• LinkedIn

_{Comment @coderabbitai help to get the list of available commands.}

[seonghobae]

Parent #902 has now moved non-force to c316bfbd… after #899/current-main convergence. This branch’s 12 dynamic-evaluation lineage/evidence files are disjoint from the inherited workflow/contract repair. Keeping the old #902 ancestry is therefore a wrong-base finding, not a reason to close or rewrite history. Preserve the lineage delta exactly, adopt the moved parent’s protected workflow contract, and advance with a two-parent non-force convergence commit; predecessor checks/reviews remain non-transferable.