docs(dnn): #682 Rule field-model decision-input (Path A) + provisioning list (49 fields) - #694
Merged
Merged
Conversation
…ng list (49 fields) Decision-input for #682 (step 2 of the #669 portage plan). Triggered by ai-01 dispatch 0hbg9t (primary). Analysis only — no DB write. Recommendation: Path A (lang-suffixed fields + loc() cascade, mirror #490/#674). - Provision 7 translatable fields x 7 non-FR langs = 49 new suffixed fields on the Rule content-type (EntityTitle/Summary/Material/Installation/Content/ Variants/Memo x en/ru/pt/es/ar/fa/zh). - FR stays canonical (unsuffixed) — no data migration. - Path B (EAV dimensions) rejected: prod EAV is FR+EN only (#687), Path B would block on enabling 5 cultures + their dimensions; Path A needs none of that. Exact field-list derived from #669 Sec 2c (view-template audit) + #687 (binary scan) + PR #674 Loc() cascade (7 fields routed). The 4th-fallback design (generic = FR canonical) preserves current FR rendering during transition. Open (gated): exact 2sxc attribute types (String/Hyperlink/...) remain gated on the sysadmin unblocker (#687 Sec 3 — jsboi has no server role, not mapped in ArgumentumGames DB). Best-effort inference provided; jsboige confirms via live 2sxc editor. Re-verified the sysadmin blocker this tick (still active). Co-Authored-By: Claude-Code <noreply@anthropic.com>
Open
3 tasks
jsboige
added a commit
that referenced
this pull request
Jul 9, 2026
…nfirms Path A, 3 deltas corrected (#759) Revision of #682 (PR #694, 2026-07-05) in light of the live 2sxc v21 export (#681, delivered by web1, read-only SQL Method B). Addendum/supersede-note, NOT a rewrite — the original Path A decision (49 suffixed fields, FR canonical) is confirmed correct. 3 deltas corrected (the binary scan #687 could not see these): 1. Schema family: ToSIC_SexyContent_* (2sxc 15.02) -> ToSIC_EAV_* (2sxc v21). Spec §4 outdated. 2. app-id: app=31 (debate/fallacies) was wrong-app probed -> Argumentum game = app=60 (ZoneID=3). 3. Attribute types: previously gated on sysadmin unblocker -> RESOLVED. All 7 translatable fields are Type:String (Wysiwyg/rich-HTML). Full 15-attribute schema enumerated (AttributeSet 377). Key clarifications: - "7->15 attrs" dispatch wording = 15 = TOTAL attrs on content-type, not 15 translatable. Translatable count stays 7 (Title/Summary/Material/Installation/Content/Variants/Memo). The 8 extra attrs (Parent/Date/Author/Licence/Original + Min/MaxNbPlayers + UrlKey) are all non-localizable. Provisioning list (49 suffixed fields) is UNCHANGED. - "49 suffixes" = content-type attributes (this scope), NOT res.* label resources. The res.* rail (9 res.Rule* keys, eid=10340) is the separate #490/#457 localization lane. - #684 translation scope corrected: export confirms 5 published rules (not 24-30) — DB in seed/pre-migration state. - res.Rule* live FR values captured for #490 (next): 5 confirmed + 4 divergent/gap to reconcile. Added banner to the original 682-field-model-decision-input.md pointing to this revision. Analysis-only. No DB write. No prod interaction (export = read-only SELECT). No #674 merge. Co-authored-by: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>
Merged
3 tasks
jsboige
added a commit
that referenced
this pull request
Jul 11, 2026
… B) (#774) The live DNN Argumentum site 2sxc export (delivered 2026-07-07 by myia-web1 via Method B read-only SQL SELECT, zero mutation) is now committed to the repo so the DNN i18n lane (#490/#682/#684) has a stable, reviewable ground truth — previously it lived only in GDrive shared-state attachments. 7 files under docs/dnn-localization/release-validation/exports/ DNN-Argumentum-export-2026-07-07/: - manifest.json — provenance, schema family, findings (self-documenting) - 10-app60-content-types.json — app=60 all 13 content-types - 11-game-rule-schema.json — Game Rule schema (id=377, 15 attrs) — #682 unblocker - 12-game-rule-content-items.json — 5 Game Rule entities + field values FR/EN - 13-app60-resources.csv — App-Resources §6 CSV (key/fr/en), includes res.Rule* - 13-app60-resources.json — App-Resources raw (entities + attributes + values) - 14-res-rule-dictionary.json — res.Rule* FR dictionary (9 keys) Key manifest findings (load-bearing for downstream work): - schemaFamily = ToSIC_EAV_* (2sxc v21) — NOT ToSIC_SexyContent_* (spec §4 written for 2sxc 15.02 is outdated, needs doc correction). - argumentumAppId=60, ZoneId=3 (app=31 was wrong-app: debate/fallacies). - gameRuleCount=5 (NOT 24-30 as dispatch estimated) — DB in seed/pre-migration state. - res.Rule* = 9 keys on eid=10340, stored as ATTRIBUTES of one resource entity, FR dimensionless default (site default), enUS dimensionId=3. Byte-fidelity: all 7 files md5-verified identical to GDrive source (offload GDrive #2797 resolved by po-2025, re-readable). Secret scan clean (dbInstance = local .\SQLExpress, no credentials in export). Gate: 0 prod write (Method B read-only SELECT). QA verdict = ai-01. Relates: #681, #458, #490, #682, #684, #694, dispatch 5mhn2r. Co-authored-by: Claude-Code <noreply@anthropic.com>
This was referenced Jul 11, 2026
docs(dnn-i18n): #682 Path A provisioning manifest (49 fields) + 2sxc-export-spec v21 correction
#777
Merged
This file contains hidden or bidirectional Unicode text that may be interpreted or compiled differently than what appears below. To review, open the file in an editor that reveals hidden Unicode characters.
Learn more about bidirectional Unicode characters
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
1 participant
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.This suggestion is invalid because no changes were made to the code.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is closed.Suggestions cannot be applied while viewing a subset of changes.Only one suggestion per line can be applied in a batch.Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.Applying suggestions on deleted lines is not supported.You must change the existing code in this line in order to create a valid suggestion.Outdated suggestions cannot be applied.This suggestion has been applied or marked resolved.Suggestions cannot be applied from pending reviews.Suggestions cannot be applied on multi-line comments.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is queued to merge.Suggestion cannot be applied right now. Please check back later.
What
Decision-input for #682 (step 2 of the #669 DNN i18n portage plan) — the Rule field-model decision. Dispatch
0hbg9t(ai-01, primary). Analysis only — no DB write.New doc:
docs/dnn-localization/682-field-model-decision-input.md(+196 lines, docs-only).Decision: Path A (lang-suffixed fields +
loc()cascade)Recommendation: Path A — mirror FallacyExplorer (#490) / PR #674. Provision 7 translatable fields × 7 non-FR langs = 49 new suffixed fields on the Rule content-type.
EntityTitle,Summary,Material,Installation,Content,Variants,Memo(the 7 fields routed throughLoc()in PR [runtime pending] feat(dnn): #649 RulesExplorer i18n — mirror loc() culture cascade #674)._en/_ru/_pt/_es/_ar/_fa/_zh.Loc()(<field>_<lang>→<field>_en→<field>_fr→<field>generic) preserves current FR rendering during the transition.Path B (2sxc EAV language dimensions) rejected: prod EAV is FR+EN only (#687), so Path B would block on enabling 5 new cultures + their dimensions before any translation can attach. Path A needs none of that —
loc()reads suffixed fields independent of EAV dimensioning. Decision is effectively forced by #687.The exact field-list (jsboige execution input)
49 fields (doc §2 has the full grid):
jsboige: create these in the 2sxc content-type editor, matching each field's type to its generic counterpart. This makes the DB provisioning a trivial mechanical step.
Open (gated) — honest
The exact 2sxc attribute types (String/Hyperlink/Wysiwyg) remain gated on the sysadmin unblocker (#687 §3:
jsboihas no server role + is not mapped inArgumentumGamesDB → no SELECT onToSic_EAV_Attribute). Re-verified this tick — blocker still active. Best-effort type inference provided (all 7 = String/rich-HTML, high confidence from@Html.Rawusage); jsboige confirms via the live 2sxc editor.Docs-only, no test/build impact.
Relates: #682, #681, #669, #687, #674, #490, #684, #683, #458.