Things to do for Qt port

[Digitalone1]

• Add decimals to input/output gain spinbuttons in all plugin UI.
• Add top and bottom margins to the row containing the input/output spinbuttons and levels.
• Allow the effects list to be shown and hidden like in Libadwaita (with arrow buttons to move between plugin UI).
• Implement plugin bypass/enable button.
• Implement the presets manager.
• Implement the pipewire manager.
• Implement each plugin preset class.
• Silence the warning about recursive calls in community presets lookup code.
• Implement the presets UI (local and community).
• Making presets autoloading functional.
• Implement the spectrum.
• Implement excluded apps manager.
• Add/remove app names to/from excluded apps list when Exclude checkbox is clicked in app info card.
• Implement the shortcuts window.
• Bring back all the command line options and add --gapplication-service for compatibility with old autostart files.
• Implement command line options to get the last active input/output preset.
• Add something useful to the system tray icon menu.
• Implementing the test signals window.
• Bring back shortcuts like the ones for fullscreen, to close the window and to quit the application.
• Sort the effects list by the locale strings.
• Add a configuration option that allows the microphone monitor output to be sent to the output effects pipeline input.
• Remove "util" functions that are not needed anymore.
• Add a new Autogain parameter that allows the output level to be forced to zero when the input level is below the silence threshold.
• Fixing our symbolic icon so it does not look as bad as it is does now when showing our tray icon. For some reason it is almost completely black. I have no idea about how to fix this. Help is needed.
• Preset autoloading: show the current device routing together with the device name.
• Add more modes to our test signal generator [Feature Request] Bring back pink noise into testing signals #3789,
• Complete the XDG Global Shortcuts implementation (D-Bus related stuff is already done, but we need to add the operations in the Activated signal callback) [Feature Request] Implement XDG Global Shortcuts #3834.
• Improve how preferred trigger are stored for XDG Global Shortcuts (maybe in an external XML database).
• Track preferred trigger changes from the user for Global Shortcuts (maybe listening to ShortcutsChanged D-Bus signal).
• Solve the _LIBCPP_VERSION warning shown on the first compilation.
• Add the "Input Monitoring" functionality recently added to the GTK4 code.
• Add a debug mode. As things are right now Easy Effects always prints debug messages.
• Make the "autostart on login" functional.
• Update our desktop file. DBus activatable isn't used anymore.
• Find an alternative way to handle our manual that does not involve using yelp.
• Try to improve our level meters. See [Feature Request] Implement "Maximum history" for Level Meters #3809
• Implement an autosave timer for the database. Right now it saves data only when our window is closed or when quitting the app.
• Add a "Reset History" button to the Pitch plugin.
• Copy the current translation file for each language to the proper places in the Qt branch.
• LSP 1.2.23: Add audio channel pre-mixing controls for Compressor, Expander, Gate, Limiter, Multiband Compressor, and Multiband Gate.
• LSP 1.2.23: Add M/S Link and S/C Link buttons for the Parametric Equalizer.
• Make sure that when an empty preset is loaded no plugin widgets remain visible in our window and the "no plugins" page is shown.
• Check missing lv2 bindings, preset entries and UI controls with AI.
• Our Github Action that updates the translation files probably needs to be updated.
• The current approach used to set the OverlaySheets height is not the best (e.g., the inline message in the presets menu is partially covered by the footer).
• Find a better way to select the next/previous plugin when an effects is removed (right now the code resets to the first plugin in the list).
• EeSpinBoxes in Autogain, Bass Enhancer, Bass Loudness, Crossfeed, DN Remover, Echo Canceller, Exciter, Filter, Maximizer, RNNoise, Pitch end Reverberation need a maximum width to avoid excessive reduction of the left label (as we did in the Limiter in commit 25d0b18).
• Convolver chart needs a minimum width otherwise the graph overflows the right boundary.
• Deesser, Delay, Expander, Level Meters, Loudness, Speech Processor and Stereo Tools cards need a minimum width (in certain cases the spinboxes values overflows their boundaries). We need to replicate what we did in the MB Compressor.
• Gate cards do not switch to a 2 columns layout when the window width is reduced. But, oddly, the 2 columns layout is used when we switch from another effect (having the window in low width mode).

[103sbavert]

Is the GTK version going away or is this just a separately maintained port?

[wwmm]

Is the GTK version going away or is this just a separately maintained port?

The gtk version will be replaced by the one in the qt branch.

[103sbavert]

Is that you saying the GTK version is being killed?

[wwmm]

Is that you saying the GTK version is being killed?

Yes. I do not have time to maintain both branches. And on a personal level I am not pleased by the direction things went on gtk's side. So even if I had the time the desire to keep coding with gtk is gone.

[AlexKristo]

how can I try the QT version? I am on Fedora Kinoite 'Atomic'

[wwmm]

how can I try the QT version? I am on Fedora Kinoite 'Atomic'

As I still did not port all plugins I did not put a guide for this anywhere. But the branch is this one https://github.com/wwmm/easyeffects/tree/eeqt. The workflow is the same of most apps based on cmake build tools:

mkdir build
cd build
cmake ..
make
cd src
./easyeffects

Assuming you have all the required dependencies installed it should work. No need to uninstall the gtk4 version because they do not share the same configuration database. But you can't have both running at the same time because one will undo the routing done by the other.

The core functionality is already in place. What is missing is porting the few plugins that were not yet. And as usual some polishing.

[AlexKristo]

The core functionality is already in place. What is missing is porting the few plugins that were not yet. And as usual some polishing.

Nice, I'm looking forward to a flatpak release when the software is fully polished!

[wwmm]

Nice, I'm looking forward to a flatpak release when the software is fully polished!

Under normal circumstances it would be possible to test the development branch through Flatpak. But right now the build fails because the Qt compiled for the runtime does not have QtGraphs enabled for some reason. @violetmage do you know if there is way to have that? I tried my best to adapt our current flatpak scripts but maybe there is something obvious I am missing https://github.com/wwmm/easyeffects/blob/eeqt/util/flatpak/com.github.wwmm.easyeffects.Devel.json.

[violetmage]

AFAICT the only option is to compile a custom qt, unless someone makes an sdk extension or baseApp or something on flathub. There's a baseApp thing for qtwebengine, but not much else.

[wwmm]

AFAICT the only option is to compile a custom qt, unless someone makes an sdk extension or baseApp or something on flathub. There's a baseApp thing for qtwebengine, but not much else.

I see. As there is still a lot of work to be done in the Qt branch I think it is not worth the effort of trying this now. Let's wait a little more for people to build Qt with QtGraphs by default. Arch is already doing that. I wonder why other maintainers have decided to disable it. It is not like it causes any conflict with QtCharts.

[ramdomPTM]

Hi all! I saw the icon problem and thought maybe I could offer some thoughts, though I am not a designer. 16px icons should have 1px line width and 2px margins, if I recall it right. I did a draft which looks like

KDE's new design system is worth looking into. I'll paste the link here: https://www.figma.com/design/F38rWWFmFRcyolDk07xxKw/Icons

[wwmm]

Thanks for the suggestion @ramdomPTM. Feel free to do a pull request if you take your draft ahead. Drawing icons properly is out of my capabilities.

For reference I will attach here an image that shows an obvious problem with the colors of the current tray icon

It is the one barely visible on the left side.