fix: address voice-cross-guardian review feedback (5 issues)#7550
Conversation
1. Pass broadcast/assistantId to CallOrchestrator from RelayConnection via
module-level setRelayBroadcast wired in lifecycle.ts, so mac desktop
receives guardian_request_thread_created IPC events and multi-assistant
deployments use the correct assistant ID.
2. Thread bearer token through guardian dispatch deliverToExternalChannel
so gateway /deliver/{channel} calls include Authorization header.
3. Swap resolve/answerCall ordering in channel-routes guardian answer
interception: call answerCall first, resolve only on success, so
failed answers leave the request pending for retry.
4. Use content block array format for addMessage calls in
guardian-dispatch.ts and guardian-action-sweep.ts to match codebase
convention (JSON.stringify([{type:'text',text:'...'}])).
5. Expire deliveries in 'sent' status (not just 'pending') in
expireGuardianActionRequest using inArray.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com>
There was a problem hiding this comment.
🟡 cancelGuardianActionRequest only cancels 'pending' deliveries, missing 'sent' deliveries
The PR correctly fixed expireGuardianActionRequest to use inArray(['pending', 'sent']) so that deliveries already in 'sent' status are expired. However, cancelGuardianActionRequest at guardian-action-store.ts:293-300 has the exact same pre-existing bug that was not fixed: it only cancels deliveries with status = 'pending', leaving deliveries in 'sent' status untouched.
Root Cause and Impact
When a guardian action request is cancelled, cancelGuardianActionRequest updates delivery rows but only those with eq(guardianActionDeliveries.status, 'pending'). In the dispatch flow (guardian-dispatch.ts:139-140), mac deliveries are immediately set to 'sent' via updateDeliveryStatus(delivery.id, 'sent'), and external channel deliveries are set to 'sent' after successful HTTP POST. This means most active deliveries will be in 'sent' status by the time a cancellation occurs.
As a result, cancelling a guardian action request leaves sent deliveries in 'sent' status instead of 'cancelled'. Any logic that checks delivery status to determine if a response should still be accepted would incorrectly treat these as active deliveries. The same reasoning that motivated the inArray(['pending', 'sent']) fix for expireGuardianActionRequest applies equally here.
(Refers to lines 293-300)
Was this helpful? React with 👍 or 👎 to provide feedback.
#7539) * refactor: rename ASK_USER marker to ASK_GUARDIAN (#7507) Co-authored-by: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com> * feat: add voice channel identity and per-call voice conversations (#7512) Co-authored-by: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix: address M2 review feedback — call session lookup + voice probe (#7524) Co-authored-by: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com> * feat: voice event projection, pointer messages, and bridge removal (#7529) Co-authored-by: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com> * feat: DTMF callee verification for outbound voice calls (#7533) Co-authored-by: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com> * feat: cross-channel guardian data model, store, and dispatch (#7534) Co-authored-by: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com> * feat: cross-channel guardian answer resolution (#7535) When a guardian action request is dispatched to telegram/sms/mac channels during a voice call, replies on any of those channels are now intercepted, validated, and used to resume the call: - Channel inbound (telegram/sms): intercept guardian answers early in handleChannelInbound(), with identity verification, single/multi-delivery disambiguation via request codes, and first-writer-wins resolution - Mac thread: intercept in session-process processMessage() before the agent loop, routing the user message as a guardian answer - Guardian dispatch: create mac conversations server-side with getOrCreateConversation() and seed them with the question text - Store: add getPendingDeliveryByConversation() for mac channel routing Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com> * feat: guardian action expiry sweep, voice thread visibility, and voice settings card (#7536) Add periodic sweep (60s interval) for expired cross-channel guardian action requests. When a request expires: marks request+deliveries as expired, expires pending questions, and sends expiry notices to external channels and mac threads. Allow voice-channel threads to appear in the desktop thread list by updating the session filter in both ThreadSessionRestorer and ThreadManager to pass through sessions with sourceChannel == "voice". Add a Voice (Phone Calls) card to the Settings Connect tab showing Twilio credential and phone number readiness for voice calls. Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com> * docs: update SKILL.md and ARCHITECTURE.md for voice-cross-guardian M1-M7 changes (#7538) Reflect the cross-channel guardian architecture in documentation: - SKILL.md: add DTMF callee verification section, update answering questions to describe ASK_GUARDIAN cross-channel dispatch with first-response-wins semantics, note mid-call steering via desktop chat is no longer supported, add accepted regressions section - ARCHITECTURE.md: update outgoing calls intro to describe voice as first-class channel with per-call conversations, replace bridge-based Mermaid diagram flow with guardian dispatch flow, replace call-bridge key component with guardian-dispatch/guardian-action-store/guardian- action-sweep, replace Call Bridge section with Cross-Channel Guardian Consultation, add guardian_action_requests and guardian_action_deliveries SQLite tables, add guardian modules to Channel Guardian Security table Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix: address voice-cross-guardian review feedback (5 issues) (#7550) 1. Pass broadcast/assistantId to CallOrchestrator from RelayConnection via module-level setRelayBroadcast wired in lifecycle.ts, so mac desktop receives guardian_request_thread_created IPC events and multi-assistant deployments use the correct assistant ID. 2. Thread bearer token through guardian dispatch deliverToExternalChannel so gateway /deliver/{channel} calls include Authorization header. 3. Swap resolve/answerCall ordering in channel-routes guardian answer interception: call answerCall first, resolve only on success, so failed answers leave the request pending for retry. 4. Use content block array format for addMessage calls in guardian-dispatch.ts and guardian-action-sweep.ts to match codebase convention (JSON.stringify([{type:'text',text:'...'}])). 5. Expire deliveries in 'sent' status (not just 'pending') in expireGuardianActionRequest using inArray. Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix: address round-2 voice-cross-guardian review feedback (#7552) 1. Fix mac channel guardian-answer ordering: call answerCall before resolveGuardianActionRequest so failed delivery leaves request pending for retry from another channel (mirrors channel-routes.ts). 2. Persist voice transcripts directly to conversation_store alongside notifier fires so transcript history survives without a live daemon Session listening on the voice thread. 3. Fix SKILL.md codeLength default documentation (4 → 6) to match the actual schema default. Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix: make voice transcript/completion persistence session-independent * fix voice call transcript handling and close review gaps --------- Co-authored-by: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>
Summary
setRelayBroadcastin lifecycle.ts and pass{ broadcast, assistantId }opts toCallOrchestratorfromRelayConnection.handleSetup(), so mac desktop receivesguardian_request_thread_createdIPC events and multi-assistant deployments use the correct assistant ID.deliverToExternalChannelviareadHttpToken()so gateway/deliver/{channel}calls include theAuthorizationheader in secure setups.answerCallfirst and onlyresolveGuardianActionRequeston success. Failed answers leave the request pending for retry from another channel.[{type:'text',text:'...'}]) foraddMessagecalls inguardian-dispatch.tsandguardian-action-sweep.tsto match codebase convention.inArray(['pending','sent'])inexpireGuardianActionRequestso deliveries in'sent'status are also expired (not just'pending').Test plan
guardian_request_thread_createdIPC when a voice call triggers ASK_GUARDIAN🤖 Generated with Claude Code