Repository navigation
Conversation
github-actions
Bot
added
vouch:trusted
402af0a to
aa25062
Compare
|
What: R1 Sol verdict is REQUEST_CHANGES on Requirements and who asked: The review assignment requires approved #379v5/#384 destination autonomy with exact authenticated disable/ACK recovery across ordinary link retirement, bounded delivery, and independent exact-candidate review. Candidate and reviewer
Required correctionsF1 [P1]: Keep driving disable recovery after a failed delivery without an ordinary linkLocation: PeerMcpClient.ts:438, with the failure suppression at line450 and startup/reconnect scheduling at lines468-493. Trigger: A has a durable pending disable and retained original recovery identity, but its ordinary link to B has been unlinked. During startup recovery B returns a transient 503, or a response/ACK is lost. B becomes reachable afterward without a separate link edit or process restart. Reachable path: Executed independent probe: actual in-memory SQLite obligation service, actual Keep pending disable delivery driven independently of whether ordinary MCP reconnection succeeds, including after unlink and lost/202 acknowledgements, without widening recovery authentication. Add an observable automatic-recovery regression rather than only calling the optional manual drain in a test. F2 [P1]: Do not let unreachable first-batch obligations starve reachable disablesLocation: DestinationAutomationAuthority.ts:678, consumed by Trigger: At least33 disable obligations are pending, and the32 lowest
Executed independent probe: register and invalidate33 exact dependencies through the actual SQLite service, make the selected first32 return503, and make the withheld dependency return a valid exact ACK if contacted. Three calls to the actual production drain produced 96 requests to the first32, zero requests to the reachable dependency, which remained unconfirmed. A positive control acknowledged the earlier batch, then the unchanged drain immediately reached and cleared the healthy dependency. Preserve bounded batches while ensuring every pending obligation can make progress despite failures elsewhere. Proof, coverage and limitsPersistent reviewer proof: Executed serially with existing dependencies and cached Node v24.13.1: Both exit0 after asserting the defective behavior and the lawful control. Exact output is in Reused evidence was independently checked: current manifest SHA256 Source coverage: I read every changed production diff across authority records/evaluation/capture, native ownership and event/receipt commit, schedule/check acceptance and effects, Spectrum launch/round/reopen, MCP union readers, auth retirement and retained peer recovery, plus all three documentation diffs. I read the new authority unit test in full and the changed barrier test. I traced the disable driver through startup, ordinary channel retry, link events, unlink/replacement and ACK persistence, and inspected the native workflow's unavailable/lost-ACK/reconstruction tests, which explicitly invoke the manual drain. Whole-review coverage remains incomplete: the complete changed workflow test body, every surrounding native/credential/tool consumer, all historical linked material-decision evidence and all mandatory acceptance paths have not been exhaustively read/adjudicated. I stopped with supported blockers under the assignment's early-negative allowance. This is a whole-candidate REQUEST_CHANGES, not a clean whole-component verdict or approval of the uninspected remainder. No previous #384 review finding disposition or approval transfers; this is R1. The supplied approved boundary and current handoffs remain requirements/claims, not independent implementation proof. Real providers, source-only web/desktop/mobile clients, hardware, OS-process crashes, rolled-back product binaries, full CI and parent #379 outcome acceptance remain unverified and parent-owned. No source/index/topology/status/readiness/blocker mutation, product server, browser/device, live userdata/grant, install, subdelegation or other workspace write occurred. All reviewer commands have ended; the review workspace remains clean. |
|
What: #555 is blocked by two reproduced disable-recovery defects and a current-CI module loading cycle. Full independent Sol R1 is REQUEST_CHANGES with supported blockers and explicitly incomplete whole coverage. Parent read the full report, actual PeerMcpClient drain/start and SQL pending selection, and both retained Node24 probe logs. Accepted F1: after ordinary unlink, startup attempts disable once, receives503, and never automatically tries again despite destination recovery and Effect TestClock1hour. The same production manual drain immediately completes exact ACK, so credentials/route are usable. Current non200 success/ignored errors and ordinary-link-driven retry leave durable pending work without a driver. The existing delivery owner must keep exact protected recovery progressing independently of ordinary link reconnection; truthful pending state alone does not fulfill eventual recovery. Accepted F2: fixed ORDER BY dependency_id LIMIT32 selects the same failed obligations forever. Actual SQLite service and production drain with33 dependencies make96 attempts across3 drains to the first32 and zero to the healthy later obligation; acknowledging earlier rows lets the same code immediately clear the withheld one. Bounded fair selection/progress is required. No general revoked-session authentication, new public recovery protocol or broad persistent machine automation is authorized. Current Test Server4 failure: ThreadManagementService.test.ts fails before collection with TypeError: Cannot read properties of undefined (reading of), at ThreadManagementService.ts1472 LegacyV1ThreadImporter.of.80 other files/1068 tests pass in that shard. Parent retrieved the completed-job raw log directly after whole-run log retrieval was unavailable, then inspected the exact introduced EventSink import and actual chain: LegacyV1ThreadImporter imports EventSink, which newly imports PeerAuthority, which imports PeerNoticeDelivery, which imports ThreadManagementService and reaches the incompletely initialized importer. Author must reproduce the standalone suite and repair the owning boundary while retaining atomic commit checks and postcommit notification; a load-order test edit/mock is not an accepted fix. Raw log remains outside Git in555-aa-ci-server4.log. Same-job repair dispatch Requirements and who asked: Approved #379/#384 requires durable exact disable/ACK progress after unlink/reconnect, bounded delivery and green current CI. |
Thread transfer impact✅ Thread transfer remains within every enforced ceiling.
Baseline: unavailable · PR result: Scenario and decoded snapshot size10 historical turns, 5 command tools per turn, 878.9 KiB retained MCP result per historical turn, and a 1.05 MiB retained result in the measured turn.
Updated in place by a trusted workflow. PR artifacts are strictly validated and never executed. |
|
What: #555 server shard2 confirms the same import cycle in two more suites and exposes two remote automation-routing expectation failures. Server2 job: IssueLinks.carryover.test.ts and persistence/forkV1Backfills.test.ts fail with the already accepted LegacyV1ThreadImporter.of1472 import-cycle error. These are additional affected suites, not separate causes. PeerToolRouting.test.ts has two failed lawful-positive assertions at750: scheduled creation and Spectrum return capability_denied, Raw retained555-aa-ci-server2.log; added scope is the existing routing test plus its actual negotiation owner as necessary. Full current670 selection remains, with these CI-exposed suites added to meaningful affected proof. Parent topology/push/reviews/clients/merge ownership and current review failure are unchanged. No live/runtime action. Requirements and who asked: User requires green current component CI and valid native automation parity under #379/#384. |
|
What: Independent Opus 5.5 MEDIUM whole-component review R1 of PR #555 at Identity and configuration
Elon recordRequirements and who asked: #379v5 and #384 (selected seam 6271372731, commandPlan extension 6272745083, handoffs 6276031205/6276135067/6276421839). Peer-created automations need offline execution under frozen contributor authority, with durable disable and ACK recovery. Existing ordinary and legacy positives must keep working. FindingsF1 (blocking, CONFIRMED by execution): ordinary local schedules and Spectrums are stamped, so their threads become unusable after local disable, edit or delete
F2 (blocking, source-confirmed, not executed): capture accepts unbound upstream dependencies, so a contributing peer can register disable rights over arbitrary certificates
F3 (required, source-confirmed, not executed): stuck disable obligations can permanently starve every other disable
Non-blocking observations
Cleared concerns (checked)
Coverage
Reviewed by Claude Opus 5.5 (medium effort) through Claude Code in T3 Code. |
|
What: Independent Sol MEDIUM R2 verdict for PR #555 at Requirements and who asked: Approved #379v5/#384 and the selected boundary require immutable conjunctive contributors, exact definition/generation fencing, and atomic destination acceptance. The current assignment requires independent review of the complete candidate, with an early-negative allowance for supported blockers. Exact candidate and reviewer
F1 [P1]: Fence the previously accepted schedule authority before replacing itLocation: mutationReceipts.ts:209, consumed by ScheduledTaskService.ts:1273 and checked at line1327. Trigger: an existing unbound peer-owned schedule has no fork check state. A local authenticated settings save begins live capture against certificate C0. Before it commits, another permitted caller updates the same schedule, adding a contributor with a narrower capability ceiling and committing certificate C1. Project, bound thread, model, modes, bare state, linkOrigin and incarnation remain unchanged. The first capture then finishes and commits its older graph as C2. Reachable path:
Actual versus required: C1's newly accepted contributor can disappear from C2 rather than remaining conjunctive or causing the stale save to be rejected and recaptured. For example, a newly accepted contributor that removes Executed evidence: one finite Node24 probe exercised the actual exported The probe uses synthetic internal certificates and directly sequences the SQL acceptance seam. It does not execute the complete authenticated two-caller race or demonstrate a real preview effect; contributor loss and public-path reachability are source-confirmed from the owners above. No mocked fence or acceptance service is used. Script, exact output and exit file are retained beside this report. Required correction: bind acceptance to the actual predecessor certificate/authority generation captured with the schedule, and reject or freshly recapture when it changes before commit. Include a deterministic regression through the local save plus negotiated peer update, with a narrower newly accepted contributor and an unchanged-binding control. No new authority system is needed. Prior findings and coverageR1 Sol F1/F2 and duplicate Opus F3 have concrete repairs present: scoped recovery wake/continued retry and durable batch rotation. Opus F1 has the empty-graph return and optional reopen admission; Opus F2 has exact dependency tuple validation and destination-record injection refusal. The CI import-cycle repair replaces EventSink's PeerAuthority value import with the small PeerLinkEvents boundary. These are source observations, not blanket clearance of every repaired scenario. The changed unsupported-peer routing expectations and their complete negotiated native replacement cases have not been fully adjudicated in this early-negative review. Read in full: the 137848-byte inherited/current packet, including original briefs, selected seam, extension, all embedded old/current handoffs, both R1 reports, CI adjudications and repair responses; live #379 body including Design review and refinement6268898682; Great Library README and applicable review/verification/orchestration procedures. Production coverage includes the complete DestinationAutomationAuthority and PeerAuthorityRecord modules; capture/merge/coverage/validation and capture-control paths in PeerAuthority; current recovery driver; complete schedule/check/engine/fence and Spectrum launch/round/reopen diffs; actual local/checked schedule callers. The grant-change native regression was read in full. Additional surrounding files and repair diffs were inspected where needed for this finding. Whole-review coverage remains incomplete: I have not read the entire 38-path diff, all added workflow/unit test bodies, every native/credential/tool consumer, every linked historical material-decision record or every required acceptance path. I stop under the explicit early-negative allowance with a supported blocker. This is a whole-candidate REQUEST_CHANGES, not a clean whole-component verdict or approval of the uninspected remainder. No historical approval transfers. Executed, reused and unverified proof
Reviewer proof: |
|
What: Independent Opus 5.5 MEDIUM R2 whole-component review of PR #555 at Identity and configuration
Elon recordRequirements and who asked:
Deleted: Approval transfer, rerunning the author's 782-test proof, broad architecture or UX additions, and re-raising R1 notes the parent dismissed. Bottleneck: Automation birth ownership can only be evaluated through Checked myself:
Prior finding disposition (R1, both reviewers)
FindingsF1 (blocking, CONFIRMED by execution for Spectrum; schedule variant inferred): peer-accepted automation threads are permanently locked once their automation retiresPath.
Trigger.
Actual. Required. Normal completion, or a later edit or disable of the definition, should stop new automation execution, not brick the threads it created.
Evidence (executed).
Inferred by the same mechanism (not executed). A fresh thread created by a peer-accepted schedule rejects follow-ups after Proof gap. Test 3369 asserts settlement only. Test 2190 asserts follow-ups only for local schedules. No case follows up in a peer-born automation thread after retirement. Fix direction (author's choice). Keep birth ownership permanent, but make it evaluable after retirement, so the retired certificate's own
Non-blocking observations
Cleared concerns (checked)
Coverage
Reviewed by Claude Opus 5.5 (medium effort) through Claude Code in T3 Code. |
|
What: Independent Sol MEDIUM R3 verdict for PR #555 at Requirements and who asked: Approved #379v5/#384, selected boundary 6271372731 and the accepted R2 purpose distinction require permanent original contributors, live interactive onward authorization, ordinary positives after lifecycle retirement, and strict current-definition claims only for actual automation execution. The current assignment requires independent whole-candidate review, with an explicit supported-blocker early-negative allowance. Exact candidate and persisted reviewer identity
F1 [P2]: Retain birth-versus-execution purpose when registering onward automation dependenciesPrimary location: DestinationAutomationAuthority.ts:678-680, called by PeerAuthority.ts:2431-2442. Trigger: A starts a Spectrum on B under permitted peer authority with onward access. The Spectrum settles normally. With A still online and all original grants valid, the user starts an ordinary follow-up in a Color or White member. That active member calls Actual: The follow-up and Reachable cause:
Required versus observed: The selected boundary explicitly permits a newly created automation only through fresh live authorization; it does not require the caller's completed birth automation to execute again. Accepted Opus R2 adjudication likewise separates ordinary lifecycle retirement from revocation while retaining every original contributor. This is a remaining consumer of that purpose distinction, not a request for a new authority system or blanket offline onward access. Executed native evidence: Appended one isolated test to an archive of the exact head outside Git, copied from the complete current council lifecycle test. It uses the registered production kernel, real SQLite/native receipts/effects/credential issuance, authenticated HTTP MCP/control transport, deterministic external provider adapters and explicit persisted preparation milestones. It adds onward consent before accepting the Spectrum. The Spectrum actually reaches Exact command, run serially from Final exit0: 1 passed / 170 unselected in15.26s. The test intentionally asserts the defective refusal plus the successful control. Independent causal discriminator: Correction belongs to the existing typed capture/dependency owner: retain and evaluate the original contributor's purpose, including monotone revocation/expiry/tombstones, without requiring a retired birth to execute. Add a native completed-member onward automation positive and controls for source offline/revoked and subsequent ordinary retirement versus security invalidation. The free-Spectrum and retired-schedule variants are source inferences, not executed claims here. Prior findings and honest coverageSol R2's exact predecessor fence is present in Read the complete186766-byte inherited/current packet in bounded chunks, including original brief, full selected design/grants, handoffs, R1/R2 reports, adjudications and author responses. Read live #379's complete approved body including Design review; current frontier6279273151; refinement6268898682; R2 decision/feedback records6278214300,6278322302,6278719707,6278782431; Great Library README; applicable routing/review/verification/orchestration/impact-analysis and experiment procedures; supplied project instructions/direction and root/internal glossaries. Source inspected: complete current DestinationAutomationAuthority, PeerAuthorityRecord and peerEffectAuthority; complete EventSink/EffectWorker/mutationReceipts and Spectrum launch/round/reopen/store diffs; current PeerAuthority coverage/validate/resource/capture/control/dependency/native-preflight/checkEffect consumers; native credential/tool helper and complete copied lifecycle test body; related schedule lifecycle and valid multi-hop test bodies. The actual reproduction exercised registered native credential, MCP and control handling. WHOLE coverage remains incomplete: I have not read/adjudicated the entire38-path diff, every current test body, all schedule/check/recovery/transport consumers, or every linked historical material-decision record. The full newly added workflow test bodies and all38 paths are not claimed covered. I stop with a supported blocker under the explicit allowance. This is a whole-candidate REQUEST_CHANGES, not a clean whole-component verdict or approval of any uninspected remainder. Executed, reused and unverified proof
Proof directory: |
|
What: Independent Claude Opus 5.5 MEDIUM R3 review of PR #555 at Identity and configuration
Elon recordRequirements and who asked: Approved #379 v5 and #384. The selected seam 6271372731 and the commandPlan extension 6272745083. The accepted R2 adjudications 6278176221 and 6278262850, which require:
Deleted: Approval transfer, rerunning the author's 799-test proof, architecture additions, and re-raising notes the parent already dismissed. Bottleneck: A birth reference is only admitted when EventSink's live preflight runs, and that preflight runs only for execution-effect commits. Separately, Checked myself:
FindingsF1 (blocking, CONFIRMED by execution): the source peer's non-turn commands on its own automation-born threads are rejected before commitLocation:
Path:
Regression:
Executed evidence: probe test
Results:
Inferred (not executed):
Fix direction (author's choice): Obtain live birth admission whenever the owner set contains a birth that no current execution covers, not only for execution effects. Add peer non-turn (rename, interrupt) positives, plus an offline denial control. F2 (blocking, CONFIRMED by execution): any grant edit permanently revokes automation-born threads, including a broadeningLocation: Trigger: On B, the user edits the A link's grant in Connections. Examples: widen Actual:
Required:
Executed evidence: same probe, after F1.
Proof gap: The new lifecycle case's Fix direction: On grant change, retire execution ( Prior finding disposition
Cleared concerns (checked)
Coverage (WHOLE incomplete)
Reviewed by Claude Opus 5.5 (medium effort) through Claude Code in T3 Code. |
|
What: Independent Sol MEDIUM R4 verdict for PR #555 at Requirements and who asked: Approved #379v5/#384 and selected boundary 6271372731 require durable exact DISABLE/ACK recovery across unlink/relink, retaining the original protected identity without restoring ordinary revoked authentication. The R4 assignment requires a fresh whole-candidate review and explicitly permits an early negative for a supported blocker. Candidate and persisted reviewer configuration
F1 [P2]: Resolve the original disable through the destination's newly linked endpointLocation: PeerLinks.ts:533-540, with endpoint selection at line 564. Consumer: Trigger: A has accepted automation on B and an original registered disable dependency. A unlinks; the original recovery identity and pending obligation are retained. B subsequently answers at a different endpoint, such as a changed address or port. A successfully relinks to B at that new endpoint, producing a distinct ordinary link generation. The old endpoint is unavailable. Actual: Ordinary resolution reaches the new endpoint, but Reachable cause: Required versus observed: The selected recovery contract says to retain the original protected identity and exact dependency until ACK and that relinking enables the same obligation. It does not require the destination to preserve its old network endpoint. The original identity can authenticate its exact registered disable on the new endpoint without authorizing ordinary tools or using the successor credential. This is a remaining recovery consumer failure, not a proposal to broaden credentials or to treat a claimed environment ID alone as continuity proof. Executed discriminator: One isolated test on an archive of exact current HEAD:
This establishes a usable, narrowly authenticated recovery route that the production resolver fails to select. The destination already knows the auth-session revocation in this reproduction, so I do not claim that prohibited execution continued. The demonstrated failure is durable disable confirmation/recovery despite successful relink and destination reachability. Correction belongs to the existing link/recovery owner: retain the exact original protected credential/dependency while allowing an appropriately verified current route to that same destination. Preserve wrong-environment, wrong-generation/tuple, ordinary-auth, tombstone and ACK checks. Add a changed-endpoint relink regression alongside the existing same-endpoint recovery controls. Execution and proofProof directory: Final command, from Final exit0, 1 passed,14.70s. This test intentionally asserts the defective refusal and its successful exact-route control; exit0 is reproduction evidence, not repaired behavior. The first probe attempt failed a setup assertion: the existing reconstruction helper injects its HTTP adapter into PeerMcpClient but builds PeerLinks with the normal HTTP adapter, so the old descriptor still answered. The final probe constructs both actual owners with the same controlled HTTP boundary. Reused: Independently verified manifest SHA256 Prior findings and honest coverageThe current core source contains the R3 typed dependency admission/persistence, strict execution default/dominance, retirement-versus-security invalidation, matching EventSink preflight/SQL guard condition, and setGrant's retirement reason. The current domain tests were read in full. These observations do not independently clear every R1/R2/R3 native scenario or transfer earlier approval. F1 concerns another actual recovery consumer. Read the entire244981-byte inherited/current packet in bounded chunks, including the original design/grants, commandPlan extension, R1/R2/R3 findings, adjudications, responses and CI history. Read the live #379 contract including Design review, current #384 body, refinement6268898682, current frontier6280254653 and current R3 owner decisions6279413859/6279460525/6279509412. Loaded the operations review/verification/orchestration/impact-analysis and empirical diagnosis procedures, Great Library README, supplied instructions/direction, root/internal glossaries and Effect service guidance. Source coverage includes complete current PeerAuthority, DestinationAutomationAuthority, PeerAuthorityRecord and peerEffectAuthority; EventSink/EffectWorker, link/recovery/auth-route/revocation, checks/engine/state/store and Spectrum launch/round/reopen/store diffs; actual capture/dependency, original recovery resolver, driver and receiver callers. Read the shared fixture's node/auth/database/reconstruction and scheduler-rehosting portions and selected existing schedule recovery/lifecycle and Spectrum reopen test bodies used to verify the reproduction's seam. WHOLE coverage remains incomplete: I have not read/adjudicated the entire46-path diff, every current test body, all fixture movement/import/export/lifetime semantics, the complete AST preservation/narrowed-fixture correction evidence, every actual consumer, or every linked historical material-decision record. Hash verification is not substituted for reading. I stop under the explicit supported-blocker early-negative allowance. This is a whole-candidate REQUEST_CHANGES, not a clean whole-component verdict or approval of any uninspected remainder. Unverified: Full CI, complete hosted shard budget, real clients/providers/machines, OS crashes, a rolled-back product binary, every earlier repair scenario and final #379 acceptance. The probe uses fresh isolated fixture homes and actual registered services/auth/SQLite/receipts with a deterministic unavailable-origin adapter. B is rehosted within the fixture; this is not an OS restart or real network migration claim. No product/dev/installed server, browser/device/Metro, real provider, live userdata/existing grant, install, subdelegation or other workspace was used or changed. All owned commands ended. The original workspace remains clean at the exact head/tree; the archive and probe are retained outside Git. No source/index/checkout/topology/status/readiness/blocker/merge/deploy write occurred. This full findings comment is the sole external content write. Reviewed by Codex, gpt-6.1-sol with medium reasoning effort, through T3 Code. |
|
What: Independent Claude Opus 5.5 MEDIUM R4 review of PR #555 at Identity and configuration
Elon recordRequirements and who asked: Approved #379 v5 and #384, selected seam 6271372731, the R2 purpose distinction (6278262850), and the R3 adjudications 6279387352 and 6279433809:
Deleted: Approval transfer, rerunning the author's 813-test proof, architecture additions, and re-raising notes the parent already dismissed. Bottleneck: Two consumers still collapse destination policy state into contributor revocation. One is the new birth narrowing comparison. The other is the session-indexed dependency invalidation, which ignores the new Checked myself:
FindingsF1 (blocking, CONFIRMED by execution): B's own preview/device settings count as birth contributor narrowing and lock peer-born threadsLocation: Mechanism:
Executed evidence: probe
Required: Per R3 adjudication 6279433809, broadening must permit later work within the original ceiling, and narrowing must be identified as an actual live-policy refusal. A destination-local capability toggle is not narrowing of an original contributor. Today it turns a capability filter into a whole-thread denial, and the device default makes that the out-of-the-box result. Proof gap: The shared fixture forces Fix direction (author's choice): Compare like with like, for example by applying the same current project capability filter to the frozen side, or by checking contributor narrowing separately from destination capability availability. Then add native regressions with browser access off and with the device default, each with an interactive-born control. F2 (blocking, CONFIRMED by execution): a pure grant broadening on B still permanently revokes a birth-only onward automation on CLocation:
Path:
Executed evidence: probe
Required:
C's automation and anything it has born become a one-way door caused by a broadening on B, while the B thread it came from keeps working. Fix direction: Make the session-indexed UPDATE honor the same reason and kind rules as the certificate path. Genuine session revocation must still mark both kinds. Add a native A→B→C regression in which a broadening leaves C enabled and a real revocation disables it. Prior finding disposition
Coverage (WHOLE incomplete)
Reviewed by Claude Opus 5.5 (medium effort) through Claude Code in T3 Code. |
|
What: Independent Sol MEDIUM R5 verdict for PR #555 at Requirements and who asked: Approved #379v5/#384 and selected boundary 6271372731 require durable exact DISABLE/ACK recovery through ordinary unlink/relink cleanup, retaining the original protected identity until acknowledgement. The R5 assignment permits an early negative for a supported blocker. Exact candidate and persisted reviewer configuration
F1 [P2]: Preserve the newly paired recovery route through another unlinkPrimary location: PeerLinks.ts:566-570. Retirement owner: lines182-191; deletion: lines475-484. Trigger: A has an unacknowledged disable for original generation G1 on B. The original endpoint becomes unavailable. A successfully pairs to the same B at a new endpoint, creating G2, so R4's route repair can reach B using G1's original protected credential. Before that old obligation is acknowledged, A unlinks G2. This can happen after a failed/lost delivery or simply before the next delivery attempt; G2 need not have created any new automation. Actual: Recovery loses the new endpoint and returns Reachable cause: Required versus observed: The selected contract retains recovery material across unlink/relink until the exact ACK. The R4 owner decisions separate paired address knowledge from ordinary credential lifetime. Keeping it after expiry but deleting it at the next unlink leaves the same lifecycle gap. This does not require retaining G2's bearer, accepting unpaired alternates or allowing ordinary revoked authentication. Executed discriminator: One isolated test on an archive of exact current HEAD, derived from the current registered relocation test:
The test intentionally asserts this defective outcome and its lawful controls, so exit0 is reproduction evidence, not repaired behavior. No setup attempt failed. The destination already knows G1's auth revocation, so this probe does not demonstrate prohibited provider execution; it demonstrates broken durable recovery/confirmation despite a usable exact authenticated route. Correction belongs to the existing paired-route/retirement owner: retain appropriately proved paired-primary route knowledge for outstanding original obligations through ordinary replacement/unlink cleanup. Preserve the original credential/generation/dependency, descriptor check, alternate-address exclusion, ordinary-auth denial and exact durable ACK checks. Add a repeated-unlink/reconstruction regression alongside the current relocation/expiry control. No new service or broader authentication is needed. Executed, reused and unverified proofReviewer proof directory: Executed once from Exit0, 1 passed,12.91s. Exact probe is retained as Reused, not rerun: Independently hashed Unverified: Complete hosted CI and10-minute shard budget; real clients/providers/hardware/machines; OS crashes; rolled-back product binary; R4-specific Spectrum toggle/broadening variants; every historical repaired scenario; final #379 acceptance. The relocation is fixture endpoint rehosting, not an OS migration. The unavailable-origin adapter is the external boundary; authority, SQLite, authentication, dependency and ACK owners are actual registered services. No product/dev/installed server, Browser/Device/Metro, real provider, live userdata/existing grants, install, agent CLI or other workspace was used or changed. Prior findings and honest WHOLE coverageThe R4 route repair is independently exercised as working before the additional unlink, including the original protected token and exact generation. The current Read the entire307221-byte Source inspection includes complete current WHOLE coverage remains incomplete: I have not read/adjudicated the entire46-path base-to-head diff, every current test body, the entire moved fixture and its lifetime/import/export semantics, all actual native/credential/schedule/check/Spectrum consumers, the complete AST/weight preservation evidence, or every linked historical material-decision record beyond the full supplied packet. Hash verification is not substituted for that reading. I stop under the explicit supported-blocker early-negative allowance. This is a whole-candidate REQUEST_CHANGES, not a clean WHOLE verdict, approval of any uninspected remainder, aggregate readiness result or blocker clearance. All owned commands ended. The designated workspace remains clean at the exact head/tree. No source/index/checkout/topology/status/readiness/merge/deploy write occurred. This full findings comment is the sole external content write. Reviewed by Codex, gpt-6.1-sol with medium reasoning effort, through T3 Code. |
|
What: Independent Sol MEDIUM R6 verdict for PR #555 at Requirements and who asked: Approved #379v5/#384 and the selected 6271372731 require source expiry to mark and forward exact durable disable obligations. The selected protocol's step 5 explicitly includes source expiry alongside revoke/replacement/unlink. The R6 assignment permits a supported early negative with honest coverage. Exact candidate and reviewer
F1 [P2]: Wake idle disable recovery at a registered dependency's known expiryLocation: PeerMcpClient.ts:463-479, with expiry promotion at DestinationAutomationAuthority.ts:764-769. Trigger: A has a registered, not-yet-pending dependency with a known future expiry. The driver completes its startup/link wakeups while that expiry is still in the future, finds no pending batch and parks. The expiry then passes without a link edit, revocation, fork commit, another automation mutation or restart. The destination's exact recovery route is usable. Actual: The obligation remains Required: The selected protocol explicitly requires source expiry to persist and forward an exact disable. Its durable confirmation cannot depend on an unrelated future mutation. Preserve idle parking and the existing narrow recovery owner, but arrange progress when a registered deadline becomes due, including deadlines registered after parking and reconstruction. No new authority/service or ordinary expired authentication is needed. Executed discriminator: Actual migrated SQLite, actual
This probe deliberately asserts the defect and lawful control, so exit0 is reproduction evidence. It isolates delivery scheduling: the ordinary reconnect environment service is omitted, and link resolution plus HTTP ACK are deterministic external boundaries. It does not execute OAuth, a registered native schedule, real peer authentication or a provider. Source inspection establishes that the actual capture owners populate the same persisted expiry. Impact limit: The destination also captures known expiry and independently denies execution after it. This finding does not demonstrate prohibited execution beyond expiry or permission broadening. It demonstrates missing source expiry-triggered disable/confirmation and a non-pending durable row despite the deadline having passed, under the explicit selected recovery contract. Indefinite dormancy without another wake follows the source loop; the executed observation advances two hours. ProofCanonical reviewer record and artifacts: Final command from the designated review workspace: Node v24.13.1, exit0, finite command ended. No suite was rerun. An initial empty-link boundary also exposed dormancy but was strengthened to retain an ordinary link. The first strengthened attempt failed an overly early startup milestone assertion ( Reused, not rerun: Independently hashed Read the complete current R5 native regression and PeerLinks owner. The stored original-generation primary, additive schema migration, repeated unlink/reconstruction, successor-secret deletion, descriptor refusal, alternate exclusion and exact ACK oracles directly address the previous R5 mechanism. Inspected raw final-before Coverage and remaining limitsInspected complete current WHOLE coverage remains incomplete: I have not exhaustively read/adjudicated every46-path full source diff, every43-test-file body, the complete moved fixture/import/export/lifetime semantics, all actual credential/native/tool/legacy/Spectrum consumers, the complete AST/weight preservation evidence or every linked material decision outside the full supplied packet. Hash verification is not substituted for reading. I stop under the explicit supported-blocker early-negative allowance. This is a whole-candidate REQUEST_CHANGES, not a clean WHOLE verdict or approval of any uninspected remainder. Unverified: Complete current hosted CI and10-minute shard budget; real clients/providers/machines; OS crashes; rolled-back product binary; R4-specific Spectrum toggle/broadening variants; complete historical repair clearance; parent #379 acceptance. No product/dev/installed server, browser/device/Metro, real provider, live userdata/existing grant, install, nested agent, source/index/checkout/topology/status/readiness/blocker/merge/deploy write occurred. All owned commands ended; the frozen workspace remains clean. This findings comment is the sole external content write. Reviewed by Codex gpt-6.1-sol, medium reasoning effort, through T3 Code/Codex. |
|
What: Independent Claude Opus 5.5 MEDIUM R6 review of PR #555 at Identity and configuration
Elon recordRequirements and who asked: Approved #379 v5 and #384, selected seam 6271372731, commandPlan extension 6272745083, and all accepted R1–R5 dispositions. For R5, parent disposition 6281224396 requires that the original-generation exact DISABLE/ACK survives replacement, repeated unlink and reconstruction. The original credential, generation, dependency, descriptor check, alternate exclusion, ordinary-auth denial and durable ACK must all remain in force.
R5 repair adjudication (no finding)
Wider inspection (no finding)
Coverage (WHOLE incomplete)
Reviewed by Claude Opus 5.5 (medium effort) through Claude Code in T3 Code. |
|
What: Independent Sol MEDIUM R7 WHOLE verdict for PR #555 at Requirements and who asked: Approved #379v5/#384, selected design 6271372731, commandPlan extension 6272745083, and every binding prior finding/adjudication require bounded local destination automation while A is offline, live original contributors for later interactive/onward work, atomic exact-generation acceptance and durable exact disable confirmation. This supports the cross-environment Promachos/Drafter/Spectrum Objective. Exact candidate and independence
Whole review resultNo supported defect remains from this independent inspection. This is a fresh whole-candidate source/test verdict, including the ordinary, historical legacy, conjunction, native acceptance, credential, onward, Spectrum and recovery paths. It is not a verdict on #383's separate predicate/attachment repair, which is absent here. The principal invariants are supported by the current owners and actual consumers:
Prior findings and R6 repair dispositionAll prior findings, responses and unresolved objections in the packet were considered against this candidate, not inherited as approvals.
R6's The existing worker drains a batch, retains its2s retry for nonempty work, and after an empty batch races its sliding queue against the Effect clock deadline. Null parks only on the queue; either winner rescans durable state. A notification arriving between scan/read/wait remains queued. Earlier registration interrupts the previous wait. Storage failures retain the existing2s retry rather than becoming a false empty result. Four registration notifications follow their actual enclosing transaction; the domain owner has no event-bus constructor dependency. ACK notification follows durable acknowledgement. The pinned Effect implementation interrupts the losing race branch, clears canceled live timers and chunks waits beyond I read the complete new native controls for reconstruction, late registration, earlier rearm, simultaneous notify/deadline and ACK cancellation. They use actual OAuth pairing, registered schedule capture, SQLite, authority, driver and private receiver. Only external HTTP timing is deterministic; policy Effects are tapped for milestones, not replaced by successful answers. Capture itself supplies the originating expiry. Automatic progress has no explicit drain or unrelated mutation. Domain controls separately cover certificate/grant purposes; they are not native captures of every certificate or legacy variant. The original red input and its three baseline production bindings were independently hashed against Git. Its observed failure is overdue The R6 Opus report's single-latest-route, paired-origin trust and harmless stale-route notes add no requirement. Its no-WHOLE-verdict is not approval. The former Sol expiry finding did not demonstrate expired execution privilege escalation; this repair restores required durable confirmation while destination expiry denial remains. Coverage ledgerEvery path below was inspected through its complete base..HEAD change. Complete central modules and all current substantive test/fixture bodies were additionally read sequentially.
Source paths above are relative to History: full Proof executed, reused and limitsReviewer record directory: Executed here: read-only Git/GH inspection and finite metadata checks only. Reused after verification: sealed manifest Current hosted evidence, independently read live: CI run 39361106103 binds exact694f80d0 and succeeds. All8 server jobs succeed under the unchanged600s limit: shards1–8 take302,416,375,438,406,465,439,449seconds respectively. Current trusted transfer report binds694f80d0, source CI success, and every enforced ceiling passes. It has no successful main baseline, so it supports no comparative main-regression claim. Raw run/job/report readbacks are retained locally. No historicalcc7 timing is transferred. Not established by this approval: real client/cross-machine/provider/hardware acceptance, OS crash or rolled-back product binary behavior, every R4 Spectrum toggle/broadening variant, #385 or combined #379 acceptance, and alignment to later main. Existing decoder controls are not a product rollback. Domain expiry variants are not all native capture variants. These remain parent acceptance limits, not hidden source coverage gaps. This component review does not waive them or approve unpublished #383 changes. No product/dev/installed server, Browser/Device/Metro, real provider, live userdata, existing user grant, installation, source/index/ref/topology, aggregate status, readiness, blocker, merge, deploy or Issue write occurred. Workspace remains clean at the frozen head/tree. This findings comment is the sole external content write. Reviewed independently by Codex gpt-6.1-sol, medium reasoning effort, through T3 Code/Codex. |
|
What: Independent Claude Opus 5.5 MEDIUM R7 review of PR #555 at Identity and configuration
Elon recordRequirements and who asked: Approved #379 v5 (read live, including the Design review and its clarification that pending disable material survives unlink/relink) and #384 (read live). The selected seam 6271372731, step 5 of which requires source revoke, expiry, replacement and unlink to persist and forward an exact disable. The commandPlan extension 6272745083. Every R1–R6 finding, response and parent disposition in the R7 packet. Refinement 6268898682 is a sidebar decision and is not consumed by #384. R6 repair adjudication (no finding)
Whole inspection (no blocking finding)
Optional note (non-blocking test coverage)
Executed, reused and unverified
Proof directory: Reviewed by Claude Opus 5.5 (medium effort) through Claude Code in T3 Code. |
|
What: Both independent MEDIUM reviews give WHOLE APPROVE to #555 at694f80d0783d18847c50337d233bd8b537c8d16a; exact-head CI and transfer checks pass. Requirements and who asked: User explicitly authorizes reviewed component merges into the integration branch, requires a different-family independent review, and forbids merge to main/deploy/restart/live-data changes. Sol codex/gpt-6.1-sol MEDIUM and Opus claudeAgent/claude-opus-5-5 MEDIUM independently inspected all46 changed paths, complete7native bodies/sharedfixture/domain/consumers/fullmaterialhistory. Both WHOLE APPROVE, no supported blocking finding. No verdict is transferred from a previous candidate. Parent verified source46/test43/raw89bindings and affected834/2skip proof earlier; reviewercompletecoverage/rawnativeproof+CI gateaccepted for internalbackendcomponent. Final actualclients/crossmachine/OScrash/rolled-backproduct/R4Spectrumvariants/385/combined379/mainalignment remain open and unwaived. Optional Opus note accepted OPTIONAL/UNSELECTED: moved runtime382-F1 test contains stale enable-before-remote-run-now fixture, so lacks the original paused oracle. Reviewer isolatedexact694f probe restores paused expectation and passes1case/31skip, proving currentbehaviorintact, notblockingproductfailure. Preserve as384 testcoverage follow-up and in finalreviewhistory; no current codechange or approvalidentitytransfer. Exact base60c0cc55d09ece9af6dd073f44187f0ec4d31ebc/head694f80d0783d18847c50337d233bd8b537c8d16a/treec737a76586c6f343be43ed67dccd656ee504ca96. Internal integration only, Issue staysopen/no closinglink. No versionbump perprojectpolicy. Release/deploy workflows requiretags/main; internalpush triggers no installeddeployment. Parent sole topologyowner retains checkpoints/source/proof/reviewworkspaces while subsequent383alignment/finalreview needs them, ownerparent untilfinaloutcome. No processesownedby384/reviewersremain. Main remains untouched. |
* feat(peer): retain destination automation authority offline * docs(peer): link destination authority component PR * wip: repair destination authority recovery and acceptance findings * wip: fence schedule acceptance and preserve live birth permissions * wip: preserve birth permission purpose and split native proof * wip: preserve recovery routes and birth dependency lifetime * wip: retain paired recovery routes through repeated unlink * wip: wake exact automation disable recovery at known expiry
* feat(peer): retain destination automation authority offline * docs(peer): link destination authority component PR * wip: repair destination authority recovery and acceptance findings * wip: fence schedule acceptance and preserve live birth permissions * wip: preserve birth permission purpose and split native proof * wip: preserve recovery routes and birth dependency lifetime * wip: retain paired recovery routes through repeated unlink * wip: wake exact automation disable recovery at known expiry
* feat(peer): retain destination automation authority offline * docs(peer): link destination authority component PR * wip: repair destination authority recovery and acceptance findings * wip: fence schedule acceptance and preserve live birth permissions * wip: preserve birth permission purpose and split native proof * wip: preserve recovery routes and birth dependency lifetime * wip: retain paired recovery routes through repeated unlink * wip: wake exact automation disable recovery at known expiry
* feat(peer): retain destination automation authority offline * docs(peer): link destination authority component PR * wip: repair destination authority recovery and acceptance findings * wip: fence schedule acceptance and preserve live birth permissions * wip: preserve birth permission purpose and split native proof * wip: preserve recovery routes and birth dependency lifetime * wip: retain paired recovery routes through repeated unlink * wip: wake exact automation disable recovery at known expiry
* feat(peer): preserve authority and native returns across environments (#391) * feat(peer): return notices and delegate onward within durable authority * fix(peer): retain authority through queued execution and recovery * fix(peer): preserve active run authority across native operations * fix(peer): retain authority for every accepted run input * fix(peer): check every contributor against the actual target * fix(peer): validate joint work against its actual resource * docs(peer): inventory retained consent seams * fix(peer): remove unused authority helper re-export * fix(peer): bound private output by effective caller modes * fix(ci): weight the measured peer authority workflow * fix(peer): retain effective caller modes during task cancellation * feat(peer): continue remote delegated jobs and stop later work (#392) * feat(peer): retain remote delegated job lifecycle and durable Stop * docs(map): link remote lifecycle component PR * fix(peer): preserve Stop replay and source task navigation * fix(peer): reconcile accepted attachment and bound session expiry * fix(server): bind delegated lifecycle routes to production runtime * fix(peer): preserve attachment bytes and native request acceptance (#410) * fix(peer): preserve attachment bytes and native request acceptance * docs(peer): link request recovery component review * docs(peer): register attachment recovery review provenance * fix(peer): declare device receipt owner in fork inventory * fix(server): preserve scoped retries and scheduler acceptance * fix(peer): preserve authorized manual admission and saved snapshot replay * fix(peer): preserve native preview capability refusal * fix(attachments): recover exact native discard acceptance * fix(attachments): retain bytes after keyed discard acceptance * fix(preview): reconcile native recording claims before replay * feat(peer): answer remote descendant requests from the source (#416) **What**: Exact #369 candidate42051c passed real source-only web and Codex peer request acceptance, including committed replay after both full CLI servers restarted. **Why**: Independent tests cannot establish that the production composition, real provider callback and source-only client work together. **So what**: The planner accepts this bounded internal component for integration into #379 after a fresh head/base/gate check; combined multi-machine/client acceptance and final shipment remain pending. Requirements and who asked: User #379 mandates native delegated lifecycle and all permitted tools with two MEDIUM reviewers and real isolated client/provider proof. Deleted: No fake provider, direct SQL mutation, injected browser RPC, capability expansion, alternate harness or duplicate callback. Bottleneck: Current candidate integration; #383 shared device authority/discovery and #384/#385/#386 remain outstanding. Checked myself: Primary planner drove actual source A browser, inspected native B events/provider results, restarted both CLI products, replayed exact original request, and reopened the same source-only result. Identity: HEAD42051c47813c354682b80677009b199d86fef1a0, treef9efef2d7df1b8b91ac64b09018386e79ccc1d45, baseab1bf53640e2a6541a2ba9f316839cedf81d4f46. Clean author workspace /Users/rocky/.t3/worktrees/chromeria/feat-369-remote-pending-requests. Both full production servers ran that source, with meaningful copied task-owned history in NEW /tmp/chromeria-369-acceptance-a and -b; old382 homes/evidence remained untouched. Node24.18, A server14247/web7663, B14248, source incognito Browser connected ONLY to A950a38f2-e2a5-4242-9171-c17e0cb8412c. Actual B is ef047b58-1edf-4ad6-a1ba-44320188325c. No live userdata write, new grant, physical device or standalone worker server. Human source-only flow: A actual Codex gpt-6.1-sol/MEDIUM delegated real async B task369-parent-native-question-v1 in existing B project/root. B actual Codex asked request_user_input_async, persisted pending at B sequence288. Primary opened source task viewer from transcript; browser URL stayed A, no B profile. The actual card displayed369 REAL REMOTE QUESTION, ACCEPT_369/DECLINE_369 and disabled Send answer until selection. Primary selected ACCEPT_369 and sent once. B durable request resolved at sequence290, command mcp:request:385bcb2f7e0a7415a3c0d1cda8a0cabb0b7204f83949b505a9f4fe4cb6482210:0, 2026-10-18T10:10:47.347Z. Real provider consumed the answer and completed369_REMOTE_ANSWER=ACCEPT_369. Source returned exact original result and zero pending requests. Not inferred from dispatch acceptance. Agent tool flow: Separate deliberate B task369-parent-native-agent-answer-v1, same explicit Color. Native delegate mode wait returned on real pending question with waitTimedOut:false, requestCount1, actual qualified target/revision334. Source local list{} correctly returned[]; explicit remote descendant list returned its actual request. Native qualified read returned real369 REAL AGENT QUESTION/options/revision334. Source called t3_pending_request_respond with original target/route/expectedRevision334, answers{0:AGENT_ACCEPT_369}, stable key369-parent-agent-response-v1. Initial AND exact retry both returned sequence340. B request has exactly one pending334 and one resolved336 event; real provider completed369_AGENT_RESULT=AGENT_ACCEPT_369. Two B tasks intentionally created, each ordinal1 completed, no duplicate B run. Restart proof: Read-only query found zero preparing/queued/starting/running/waiting runs in A/B. Primary stopped only captured own sessions47643/49402 (exit130), restarted same source and same NEW homes in sessions86505/9639. A actual Codex ordinal34 called ONLY the exact original respond input/key after reconstruction: sequence340 again. Postrestart B has no additional request resolution or provider run. Source previous-agent viewer reopened after both restarts with original human result, real accepted answer and zero pending requests. Actual client screenshot inspected before upload. Evidence: local immutable/raw read-only oracles /tmp/chromeria-369-parent-actual-question-proof.json, /tmp/chromeria-369-parent-native-agent-tool-proof.json, /tmp/chromeria-369-parent-postrestart-proof.json. Full CLI logs /tmp/chromeria-369-acceptance-{a,b}-server.log and -restart.log retained. Native Browser screenshots in existing UNPUBLISHED draft evidence-379, never a public release:   Both fresh exact-candidate independent MEDIUM reviews APPROVE: Sol #416 (comment) and installed Grok4.7 #416 (comment). Full aggregate #369 (comment). Current420 CI39116640008, Fork39116640150 and final fingerprint39116844636 SUCCESS; original canceled fingerprint retained separately. Authenticated newest review/independent SUCCESS by lukemaj. Neither review substitutes for the actual proof above. Full author/R1/R2 packet #369 (comment). Limits: These are TWO isolated Rocky environments, web/source-only browser and actual Codex provider. No physical cross-machine/tunnel/mobile/native desktop/all-provider/real live approval, durable-dismiss or secret acceptance claim. Registered native tests retain their own broader and S1/S2 race/empty-choice proof. Earlier native initialization404 remains UNKNOWN; later tests/CI/actual positives do not diagnose it. Operational verification earlier used invalid exact=true locator syntax and a stale assumed web port; corrected to supported selectors/actual dev-runner7663 without alternate browser or product changes. Cost supported publish #416 (comment) is partial task379 coverage, not complete cost; old unplaced/unpriced usage remains unknown. Background supported sync still pending at this record, not presumed complete. States: implemented YES; current focused/native tests YES under their exact records; BOTH reviewed YES; current CI YES; bounded primary product proof YES; internal integration NOT YET at this record; main merged/build/shipped/activated/live combined acceptance NO. No package bump. All rollback/evidence/workspaces retained under explicit #379 instruction until final acceptance. * fix(client): clarify remote requests and count pending work once * fix(client): make remote request choices readable and accessible * docs(peer): track the remote request client repair * fix(peer): count initial remote work once in sparse shells * feat(device): add typed remote device execution core (#421) * feat(device): execute typed commands across peer links * docs(map): link the typed device core component * fix(device): preserve native authority and typed command semantics * fix(device): recheck authority before native shutdown * wip: preserve native contexts and purpose metadata after main alignment * fix(peer): preserve current-main request answering policy (#539) * fix(peer): preserve current-main request answering policy * fix(compat): restore inherited CI consumers Reuse baseline-only repairs from the preserved #383 checkpoint d892050cb97854e08ca1ca427fc762caebbd69f7 under the #379 ownership transfer. Adapt the two web test fixtures for actual Chromium collection without changing production web behavior. * test(prism): absorb native recovery observer fixture Transfer the exact test blob authored in cdd4780 and preserved by PR537 at fcd3162. Await the native observer marker before measuring the live batch; preserve the duplicate assertion and production source. * fix(client): hide remote children from default navigation (#546) * wip: hide remote children from default navigation * wip: register destination navigation component PR * wip: retain user forks with remote provenance * wip: cover phone and alternate sidebar navigation * wip: declare phone and legacy carried upstream edits * feat(peer): keep destination automations authorized offline (#555) * feat(peer): retain destination automation authority offline * docs(peer): link destination authority component PR * wip: repair destination authority recovery and acceptance findings * wip: fence schedule acceptance and preserve live birth permissions * wip: preserve birth permission purpose and split native proof * wip: preserve recovery routes and birth dependency lifetime * wip: retain paired recovery routes through repeated unlink * wip: wake exact automation disable recovery at known expiry * feat(remote): view and control qualified browser and device resources (#534) * wip: combine qualified resources with destination automation * wip: bound mobile returned-resource row height * wip: respect native top safe area for tool resources * wip: preserve current-main cross-machine compatibility checkpoint * wip: preserve linked research and tool policy identity across main alignment * wip: repair vault authority and keyed MCP configuration replay * test(server): validate credential refusal error envelopes (#566) * fix(peer): render HTML from idle destination contexts (#563) * fix(server): prepare HTML in idle peer resource contexts * docs(map): track the open idle HTML component * fix(orchestration): wake parents for remote pending requests (#531) * fix(orchestration): wake parents for remote pending requests * fix(orchestration): deliver held remote requests when parent waits end * fix(peer): wait for request content before notifying parents * fix(orchestration): catch up requests after remote original completion * test(web): isolate panel keyboard tests from inherited pointer (#575) * fix(peer): attribute remote follow-ups to the completing run (#582) * fix(peer): attribute remote follow-ups to the completing run * docs(map): link remote completion provenance repair * fix(peer): use observed purpose for first remote completion * fix(scheduled-tasks): record refused keyed manual runs as terminal failures A keyed run_scheduled_task_now whose dispatch failed with a typed error and left no native receipt returned outcome_unknown and kept the schedule marked running forever. Record it as the request's failed outcome, release the running reservation, and replay the same failure for the same key. Interrupted or defective dispatches stay outcome_unknown. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(orchestration): accept blank optional answers in remote request admission Remote pending-request answers with expectedRevision rejected a blank or omitted optional choice-only question as an unoffered option. Skip blank optional answers before validating options, matching the message-response path. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * chore(fork): keep one owner for server shard weights #581 registered shardWeights.json under run-groups while the integration already owns it under fork-maintenance; fork-features requires one owner. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * test(server): weight typed peer effects by their CI time PeerAuthority.typedEffects.workflow.test.ts takes about 197s in a CI shard but was weighted 46.4s, so Test Server 8 exceeded its 10-minute limit. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(peer): reopened parents follow their remote tasks again Archiving a parent ended its remote follower, and nothing restarted it on unarchive, so the reopened parent missed later remote results until a server restart. The follower now stays registered and waits for the parent's unarchive or deletion instead of exiting, so reopening resumes observation without a new entry point or a duplicate follower. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(peer): threads read and answer their own questions again The replacement pending-request service refused every "own" answerer, so a thread reading or answering its own user-input question, or an ordinary full-access MCP client doing so, got capability_denied. Own access is restored for local, non-linked callers on threads not delegated from another environment. Own approvals, dismiss, linked clients and remote delegated children keep their existing refusals. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(web,mobile): remote request cards keep multiline editor answers Remote pending-request cards rendered every custom answer as a single-line field, so a multiline editor prefill displayed and was stored flattened. Editor questions (those with an initialAnswer) now use the Textarea on web and a multiline, newline-submitting field on mobile, as the local paths do. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(scheduled-tasks): keyed pause and resume replay their receipt A keyed update_scheduled_task carries clientRequestId on its input, so the enable-only shortcut never matched: a keyed pause or resume fell through to the full definition update and was refused without a purposeIntent. The shortcut now ignores routing fields, and setEnabled records and replays the keyed mutation receipt like create, update and delete. A retried keyed pause after a later resume replays instead of retiring the newer automation certificate. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(scheduled-tasks): post-admission recheck refusals release keyed manual runs A typed refusal from the recheck after admission, or after the dispatch claim, now records the key as failed and frees the schedule instead of leaving it running. The stage-guarded claim keeps uncertain dispatches outcome_unknown. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(childThreads): stop-disposed remote children stay pending background work A parent interrupt disposes a delegated completion with disposedBy "stop" without stopping the remote child. The sparse SQL remote arm dropped that row while the local arm and pendingDelegatedChildTasks kept it, so shells, auto-settlement and storage cleanup treated the parent as idle. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(scheduled-tasks): final recheck refusals no longer fail a concurrent same-key dispatch The final live recheck ran after the prepared -> dispatching claim and terminalized a refusal from the dispatching stage. For an existing-thread schedule a same-key retry can read dispatching and send concurrently, so the refusal failed the request and freed the schedule while that send was accepted. The final recheck now precedes the claim, so a refusal is only recorded through the prepared-stage compare-and-set. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(peer): finished remote jobs no longer hold back live Stops A lifecycle-v1 follower keeps long-polling its job there after the result, so a later Stop or follow-up is still observed. Each poll held one of the eight shared peer permits for up to 20 s, so more than eight finished jobs starved Stops and live observations of other jobs. Followers whose job has nothing left to do there (result available, no queued runs, questions or recovery wait, or a confirmed Stop) now wait on their own semaphore. Stops, unconfirmed and acknowledged stops, live jobs and follow-ups seen as working keep the existing eight permits. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(peer): stopped remote jobs with new work there keep live permits A confirmed Stop counted a job as settled whatever its latest snapshot said, so fresh direct input on the destination child after the Stop left its follower queued behind idle settled long-polls, also after a restart. A job is now settled only while its latest snapshot is quiet (result available, no queued runs, questions or recovery wait); a confirmed Stop also needs that quiet snapshot. Anything showing activity uses the shared network permits. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> --------- Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
What: Destination automation now passes834 affected tests, including automatic expiry-triggered disable and durable ACK after recovery parks.
Why: A known dependency deadline could pass without waking the existing recovery driver.
So what: Both new complete Sol/Opus MEDIUM reviews and exact-head hosted CI must pass before this component can integrate.
Refs #379/#384. Component into
feat/379-cross-machine-parity, base60c0cc55d09ece9af6dd073f44187f0ec4d31ebc, head694f80d0783d18847c50337d233bd8b537c8d16a, treec737a76586c6f343be43ed67dccd656ee504ca96. No closing linkage or #385 blocker clearance. Canonical stopped handoff owns full decisions, commands, failures, proof and limits.Explicit destination automation captures finite contributor authority atomically. Genuine execution remains current-definition/incarnation/generation bounded; later interactive/onward actions validate original contributors live. Private exact DISABLE/ACK retains original protected identity after retirement, while ordinary revoked authentication stays denied. Prior route repair retains an OAuth-paired primary independently of replacement ordinary-link deletion, with original token/generation, descriptor checks and excluded alternates.
The existing durable owner now derives the earliest outstanding non-pending deadline from originating dependency, indexed certificate and actual grant expiry. The existing single scoped delivery worker waits for either that deadline or its existing mutation queue, then rescans storage; pending work retains its bounded retries. Four capture registration owners notify after their outer transaction commits, so late or earlier registrations rearm an idle driver. No new scheduler/service/schema/protocol or credential path. Fairness32, concurrency4, per-attempt10s, retry2s and CI weights/partition/workers/ceilings are unchanged.
834 passed/2 existing opt-in skips across43files, including186 native across7files. All824 prior passes and139 prior native declarations remain;4 native/6 domain cases added. Real registered schedule capture, OAuth/auth/SQLite and production driver/private receiver prove reconstructed/later/earlier/simultaneous deadlines and ACK cancellation without explicit drain; deterministic external timing and TestClock observe exact durable ACK. Domain cases cover originating/certificate/grant purposes and millisecond boundary. Genuine before-test fails oncc7 with overdue pending0/ACKnull. Intermediate timing/decoder fixture feedback is preserved separately. No real provider/client/OS crash claim.
Actual cache-disabled server/contracts package compilers, scoped lint/format/exports, old-reader decoder controls, true frozen fork boundary, inventory53 and all17 current scoped commands pass. Parent verified46 source/43 test working+Git bindings,89 artifact hashes,7 unchanged older manifests, full five-path diff, native/domain test additions, rawred/final summaries and compiler headers. Manifest SHA256
81f16c55dc9c3b3b46ea3648a3251b22258fff4315c94a12c2e6add41eeaf4fd.Sol R6 requested expiry repair with incomplete whole coverage. Opus R6 found no supported issue but issued no whole verdict because coverage was unfinished. Neither approves this candidate. Both NEW complete46-path/source/test-body/consumer/material-history reviews are running; original selected design, grants and every prior finding/response/unresolved objection remain unabridged. No historical approval transfer.
Current hosted CI and10-minute shard budget remain open; precedingcc7 all8shards max480s is historical only. Actual clients/cross-machine acceptance, OS crash/product rollback proof, R4-specific Spectrum toggle/broadening variants, #385 and combined #379 acceptance remain open; existing Spectrum tests are retained. Local scoped tests do not substitute for full CI or clients. Main advanced beyond frozen base; parent owns alignment/final cumulative review. PeerAuthority file edits finished/released to #383 for its separate minimal local predicate repair; those changes are not in this candidate. No main merge/deploy/installed restart/live-data/existing-user-grant action/version bump.
Requirements and who asked: Approved #379/#384 requires bounded offline destination automation, exact current authority and autonomous durable expiry/revocation confirmation supporting the remote Promachos surface.
Deleted: Generic scanners/new services, successor bearer promotion, relaxed authentication, dropped regressions, increased CI ceilings/workers and approval transfer.
Bottleneck: Complete current independent reviews, exact hosted CI and combined client/integration acceptance.
Checked myself: Clean local/published head/base/tree and live target, full five-path repair/handoff,46 source/43 test Git bindings/89 artifacts/7 prior manifests, raw834/2skip/186native proof and17 scoped exits.
Implemented by GPT-6.1 Sol / Codex / MEDIUM through T3 Code. Independent review: GPT-6.1 Sol and Claude Opus5.5 / MEDIUM. Coordination: GPT-6.1 Sol / Codex / MEDIUM.