cargo test builds binaries without panic

[ehuss]

If you have panic="abort" set in the dev profile and run cargo test, the binaries (and examples) are built without panic set (assuming you have an integration test which triggers the inclusion of binaries). This doesn't seem correct to me.

Repro:

cargo new --lib foo
cd foo

cat > src/main.rs <<EOL
extern crate foo;
fn main() { foo::f(); }
EOL

echo "pub fn f() { panic!(\"xxx\"); }" >> src/lib.rs

mkdir tests
touch tests/t1.rs

cat >> Cargo.toml <<EOL
[profile.dev]
panic = "abort"
EOL

cargo test -v
target/debug/foo   # <- NOTE this does not abort!

Fixing this is not entirely simple. If you build the lib.rs dependency twice (once with panic, once without), then rustdoc (for doctests) will pick up both and fail to run. The code that collects the libraries to link (in Compilation.libraries) would probably need to be adjusted to collect only the libs that are needed for doctests.

I can tackle this if you'd like. One idea I had to approach this would be:

• Fix doctests to not be over-eager in what it links with:
  • Ensure a Doctest unit is always created. (This might be helpful for fixing other bugs, such as cargo test --doc overriding all other command-line options.)
  • In run_doc_tests, instead of iterating over Compilation.libraries, grab the actual dependencies of the Doctest unit.
• Remove the global test flag from BuildConfig.

I also wanted to double-check. This would result in lib.rs being compiled three times with cargo test when you have panic set (once with panic for bins, once without for tests, and once as a unit-test). Is that OK?

[alexcrichton]

Yeah this is one of those things I'm not entirely sure about. On one hand this definitely seems like a bug and would possibly be good to fix. On the other hand though it's really subtle and unlikely to really bring up any otherwise existing bugs (and can also increase compile times as we have to compile the library twice).

I think I'd be somewhat tempted to lean towards fixing this though if we can. It may be surprising to users using cargo test to compile everything twice, but there's unfortunately not a lot we can do about that :(