Conversation
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Code Review
This pull request refactors process group utilities by moving GroupInfo to a new module miles.utils.process_group_utils and introducing GeneralPGUtil and MultiPGUtil to support both native PyTorch and torchft process groups. The feedback identifies two critical issues: first, _NativePGUtil methods will crash if group is None because dist.get_global_rank does not support None groups, so the source/destination rank should default to 0. Second, collective_bool_and creates a tensor on the CPU by default, which will cause a runtime error when used with an NCCL process group; the tensor should be placed on the appropriate device (e.g., CUDA).
Important
The consumer version of Gemini Code Assist on GitHub is being sunset. Starting June 18, 2026, new organization installations will be blocked, and all code review activity will officially cease on July 17, 2026.
For more details on the timeline and next steps, please review the Help Documentation.
| def reduce(self, tensor: torch.Tensor, group: dist.ProcessGroup, op: dist.ReduceOp) -> None: | ||
| dist.reduce(tensor, dst=dist.get_global_rank(group, 0), op=op, group=group) | ||
|
|
||
| def broadcast(self, tensor: torch.Tensor, group: dist.ProcessGroup) -> None: | ||
| dist.broadcast(tensor, src=dist.get_global_rank(group, 0), group=group) | ||
|
|
||
| def barrier(self, group: dist.ProcessGroup) -> None: | ||
| dist.barrier(group=group) | ||
|
|
||
| def all_gather( | ||
| self, output_tensors: list[torch.Tensor], input_tensor: torch.Tensor, group: dist.ProcessGroup | ||
| ) -> None: | ||
| dist.all_gather(output_tensors, input_tensor, group=group) | ||
|
|
||
| def gather( | ||
| self, | ||
| input_tensor: torch.Tensor, | ||
| gather_list: list[torch.Tensor] | None, | ||
| group: dist.ProcessGroup, | ||
| ) -> None: | ||
| dist.gather(input_tensor, gather_list=gather_list, dst=dist.get_global_rank(group, 0), group=group) | ||
|
|
||
| def gather_object(self, obj: Any, object_gather_list: list[Any] | None, group: dist.ProcessGroup) -> None: | ||
| dist.gather_object(obj, object_gather_list, dst=dist.get_global_rank(group, 0), group=group) |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
In _NativePGUtil, several methods (reduce, broadcast, gather, gather_object) call dist.get_global_rank(group, 0). If group is None (which is a common fallback in parallel states when certain parallelisms like pipeline or expert parallel are disabled), dist.get_global_rank(None, 0) will raise an AttributeError or TypeError and crash.
Since the global rank for group=None (the default WORLD group) is simply the group rank itself, we can safely default the destination/source rank to 0 when group is None.
def reduce(self, tensor: torch.Tensor, group: dist.ProcessGroup, op: dist.ReduceOp) -> None:
dst = 0 if group is None else dist.get_global_rank(group, 0)
dist.reduce(tensor, dst=dst, op=op, group=group)
def broadcast(self, tensor: torch.Tensor, group: dist.ProcessGroup) -> None:
src = 0 if group is None else dist.get_global_rank(group, 0)
dist.broadcast(tensor, src=src, group=group)
def barrier(self, group: dist.ProcessGroup) -> None:
dist.barrier(group=group)
def all_gather(
self, output_tensors: list[torch.Tensor], input_tensor: torch.Tensor, group: dist.ProcessGroup
) -> None:
dist.all_gather(output_tensors, input_tensor, group=group)
def gather(
self,
input_tensor: torch.Tensor,
gather_list: list[torch.Tensor] | None,
group: dist.ProcessGroup,
) -> None:
dst = 0 if group is None else dist.get_global_rank(group, 0)
dist.gather(input_tensor, gather_list=gather_list, dst=dst, group=group)
def gather_object(self, obj: Any, object_gather_list: list[Any] | None, group: dist.ProcessGroup) -> None:
dst = 0 if group is None else dist.get_global_rank(group, 0)
dist.gather_object(obj, object_gather_list, dst=dst, group=group)| def collective_bool_and(*, value: bool, group: dist.ProcessGroup) -> bool: | ||
| """Make a bool `and` operation on all ranks in this process group""" | ||
| tensor = torch.tensor([1.0 if value else 0.0], dtype=torch.float32) | ||
| GeneralPGUtil.create(group).all_reduce(tensor, group, op=dist.ReduceOp.MIN) | ||
| return tensor.item() > 0.5 |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
In collective_bool_and, the tensor is created on the CPU by default. If the provided group is an NCCL process group (which is standard for GPU training), calling all_reduce on a CPU tensor will result in a runtime crash (e.g., RuntimeError: Tensors must be CUDA tensors).
To prevent this, we should place the tensor on the appropriate device (e.g., using cuda if CUDA is available).
| def collective_bool_and(*, value: bool, group: dist.ProcessGroup) -> bool: | |
| """Make a bool `and` operation on all ranks in this process group""" | |
| tensor = torch.tensor([1.0 if value else 0.0], dtype=torch.float32) | |
| GeneralPGUtil.create(group).all_reduce(tensor, group, op=dist.ReduceOp.MIN) | |
| return tensor.item() > 0.5 | |
| def collective_bool_and(*, value: bool, group: dist.ProcessGroup) -> bool: | |
| """Make a bool `and` operation on all ranks in this process group""" | |
| device = torch.device("cuda" if torch.cuda.is_available() else "cpu") | |
| tensor = torch.tensor([1.0 if value else 0.0], dtype=torch.float32, device=device) | |
| GeneralPGUtil.create(group).all_reduce(tensor, group, op=dist.ReduceOp.MIN) | |
| return tensor.item() > 0.5 |
18589ad to
b3d9c10
Compare
10b39c7 to
99ca854
Compare
b3d9c10 to
d363d93
Compare
99ca854 to
4828875
Compare
d363d93 to
940e7e7
Compare
4828875 to
58be551
Compare
| ) -> None: | ||
| # AllgatherOptions is not re-exported by torch.distributed (unlike | ||
| # AllreduceOptions, BroadcastOptions, GatherOptions). PyTorch omission. | ||
| from torch._C._distributed_c10d import AllgatherOptions |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Please hoist this import to the beginning
| else: | ||
| assert object_gather_list is None | ||
|
|
||
| from torch.distributed.distributed_c10d import _get_object_coll_device |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Please hoist this import to the beginning
Shi-Dong
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Posted a couple of nits, but please also apply Gemini's suggestions as they look valid.
| from ...training_utils.parallel import GroupInfo, ParallelState | ||
| from miles.utils.process_group_utils import GroupInfo | ||
|
|
||
| from ...training_utils.parallel import ParallelState |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Please switch relative import to absolute import.
| from ..training_utils.parallel import GroupInfo, ParallelState, get_parallel_state | ||
| from miles.utils.process_group_utils import GroupInfo | ||
|
|
||
| from ..training_utils.parallel import ParallelState, get_parallel_state |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Please switch relative import to absolute import.
| def reduce(self, tensor: torch.Tensor, group: dist.ProcessGroup, op: dist.ReduceOp) -> None: | ||
| dist.reduce(tensor, dst=dist.get_global_rank(group, 0), op=op, group=group) | ||
|
|
||
| def broadcast(self, tensor: torch.Tensor, group: dist.ProcessGroup) -> None: | ||
| dist.broadcast(tensor, src=dist.get_global_rank(group, 0), group=group) | ||
|
|
||
| def barrier(self, group: dist.ProcessGroup) -> None: | ||
| dist.barrier(group=group) | ||
|
|
||
| def all_gather( | ||
| self, output_tensors: list[torch.Tensor], input_tensor: torch.Tensor, group: dist.ProcessGroup | ||
| ) -> None: | ||
| dist.all_gather(output_tensors, input_tensor, group=group) | ||
|
|
||
| def gather( | ||
| self, | ||
| input_tensor: torch.Tensor, | ||
| gather_list: list[torch.Tensor] | None, | ||
| group: dist.ProcessGroup, | ||
| ) -> None: | ||
| dist.gather(input_tensor, gather_list=gather_list, dst=dist.get_global_rank(group, 0), group=group) | ||
|
|
||
| def gather_object(self, obj: Any, object_gather_list: list[Any] | None, group: dist.ProcessGroup) -> None: | ||
| dist.gather_object(obj, object_gather_list, dst=dist.get_global_rank(group, 0), group=group) |
| def collective_bool_and(*, value: bool, group: dist.ProcessGroup) -> bool: | ||
| """Make a bool `and` operation on all ranks in this process group""" | ||
| tensor = torch.tensor([1.0 if value else 0.0], dtype=torch.float32) | ||
| GeneralPGUtil.create(group).all_reduce(tensor, group, op=dist.ReduceOp.MIN) | ||
| return tensor.item() > 0.5 |
940e7e7 to
2980130
Compare
58be551 to
aa46de3
Compare
2980130 to
9d6a573
Compare
aa46de3 to
51bc303
Compare
Add a `deterministic_random` reward that hashes the sample tokens + response to produce a stable pseudo-random 0/1 reward, used for reproducible fault-tolerance / CI tests. - rm_hub/__init__.py (+ test).
Add `inplace_modify_args`, a context manager that temporarily overrides args attributes and restores them on exit (asserting they weren't clobbered), used to scope per-attempt argument overrides in the fault-tolerant trainer. - argparse_utils.py (+ test).
Small shared-utility additions used by the fault-tolerant trainer: hash non-contiguous tensors safely (reshape before viewing as bytes), an `enable_experimental_ft_trainer` env flag, forward NCCL_DEBUG/NCCL_DEBUG_FILE to worker environments, and a `filter_keys` helper. - ci_utils.py / environ.py / external_utils/command_utils.py / misc.py.
Thread the original backend through ReloadableProcessGroup so that, when a process group is rebuilt (e.g. after a reconfigure/heal), it is recreated with the same backend instead of hard-coding NCCL. - reloadable_process_group.py: carry `backend` in the reload group info.
Add small foundation utilities used across the fault-tolerance trainer: a strict pydantic base model, a retry helper, a tensor checksum helper, a per-cell megatron world-size computation, the TrainStepOutcome enum, and the IndepDPInfo dataclass describing a cell's independent-DP identity. - pydantic_utils.py / retry_utils.py / checksum_utils.py / megatron_args_utils.py / types.py / indep_dp.py and tests.
Add a `log_structured` helper that emits logfmt-style key/value log lines, used by the fault-tolerance components for greppable structured logs. - structured_log.py (+ test).
Add a small `Clock` interface (`RealClock` plus a controllable fake clock) so time-dependent fault-tolerance code (health checks, heartbeats) can be driven deterministically in tests. - miles/utils/clock.py and tests.
Add a fault-injector test utility used to deterministically exercise fault-tolerance code paths. - miles/utils/test_utils/fault_injector.py.
Add the shared data models for the fault-tolerance control server (e.g. the `TriState` health value), used by the health checker and later by the HTTP control server. - miles/utils/control_server/models.py.
Add the periodic health checker (debounced TriState status driven by a Clock) and heartbeat utilities used to monitor train-cell liveness. - miles/utils/health_checker.py, miles/utils/heartbeat_utils.py and tests.
Add the nvidia-resiliency-ext dependency, the "ft" CI test label, the FT test fixtures in the rollout conftest, and route startup logging through configure_logger_raw. The fault-tolerance CLI arguments themselves now live with the features that consume them (distributed across the per-feature commits).
Unconditionally disconnect-then-reconnect the model-update process group when (re)connecting rollout engines, guarding the destroy against a missing group, so a reconfigured/healed engine set can rebuild the NCCL group from scratch. - broadcast.py: drop the "only disconnect if group exists" short-circuit; guard `destroy_process_group` against None.
Expose an `inject_fault` Ray method on TrainRayActor (in its own concurrency group) that triggers a configured failure mode via the fault injector, so fault-tolerance tests can crash/hang specific actors on demand. - train_actor.py: `inject_fault` RPC.
Extract the DP split into a witness-aware split_train_data_by_dp_raw helper (with unit tests; the key list also carries seq_witness_ids) and use it to split the training data on the actor side when delay_split_train_data_by_dp is set, deferring the DP split from the rollout side to actor-side processing. split_train_data_by_dp stays a thin wrapper that ray.puts each partition. - miles/ray/rollout/train_data_conversion.py (+ tests), miles/utils/data.py, actor_group.py, rollout_manager.py.
Add an opt-in deterministic NCCL process-group backend (`--debug-deterministic-collective`) that folds order-sensitive SUM/AVG reductions into a fixed order so training collectives are bit-reproducible, registering it as the training world's distributed backend and requiring synchronous grad sync. - det_process_group.py (+ GPU test, dist test helper). - train_actor.py: register the backend and select it when enabled. - initialize.py: assert synchronous grad reduce under the deterministic backend.
Add a per-process identity helper that uniquely keys each training process, used to attribute structured fault-tolerance events to their originating process. - miles/utils/process_identity.py and tests.
Add the structured event models (Event / EventBase hierarchy) for the fault-tolerance event log, each tagged with the originating ProcessIdentity. - miles/utils/event_logger/models.py and tests.
Add the structured event logger that records typed events keyed by per-process identity, wire it through the logging helper and CLI argument, and start it from the train entrypoints. - miles/utils/event_logger/logger.py, logging_utils.py, arguments.py and entrypoint wiring, with tests.
Add snapshot/restore for the structured event log so the event history survives cell restarts during fault-tolerant training. - miles/utils/event_logger/checkpoint.py and tests.
Add the `MetricEvent` model (a discriminated-union member) and emit every
tracking metric into the structured event log: `tracking_utils.log` now forwards
`{metrics}` to `get_event_logger().log(MetricEvent, ...)` when the event logger
is initialized.
Add the witness id allocator and `WitnessInfo` carrier used to assign and track witness ids for fault-tolerance verification. - miles/utils/witness/allocator.py and tests.
Thread witness ids through the model by injecting witness parameters, so the event log can later verify they propagate correctly. - miles/utils/witness/module.py, model_provider.py and tests.
Add the first event-analyzer rules that replay the structured event log and flag
weight-checksum inconsistencies: a `checksum_compare` helper (flatten nested
dicts, diff flat checksum maps) plus two rules built on it — cross-replica weight
checksum consistency and inference-engine weight checksum consistency — with unit
tests.
- miles/utils/event_analyzer/rules/{checksum_compare,cross_replica_weight_checksum,inference_engine_weight_checksum_consistency}.py and tests.
Add the witness-tracing rule for the event analyzer: it follows witness ids through the replayed event log to verify they are propagated correctly across the training pipeline, with unit tests. - miles/utils/event_analyzer/rules/witness.py and tests.
Add the analyzer that replays the structured event log and applies the analysis rules (checksum-consistency and witness tracing) to verify fault-tolerance behaviour offline, with unit tests. - miles/utils/event_analyzer/analyzer.py and tests.
Add comparison helpers used by fault-tolerance tests to compare dumped tensors and
inference-engine checksums offline (generic comparators, dump comparison, and an
inference-engine checksum comparison built on the event-analyzer checksum rule).
- miles/utils/test_utils/comparisons/{comparators,dumps,inference_engine_checksums}.py and tests.
Add the metric comparison helpers used by fault-tolerance tests to compare logged training metrics offline. - miles/utils/test_utils/comparisons/metrics.py.
Add reusable reconfiguration assertions used by fault-tolerance tests to verify cell reconfigure / healing behaviour, with unit tests. - miles/utils/test_utils/reconfigure_assertions.py and tests.
Move the GroupInfo dataclass out of training_utils/parallel.py into a shared process_group_utils module that also provides multi-process-group helpers (GeneralPGUtil / MultiPGUtil) for collectives over single or hierarchical process groups, used by the cross-replica / effective-DP code paths. - process_group_utils.py: GroupInfo + GeneralPGUtil / MultiPGUtil (+ tests). - training_utils/parallel.py: import GroupInfo from the shared module. - megatron / fsdp parallel.py: import GroupInfo from the shared module. - distributed_utils.py: use GeneralPGUtil for masked-whiten all-reduce.
9d6a573 to
c043ccf
Compare
51bc303 to
932660e
Compare
…ft/dev_revert_reversed/relocate-groupinfo-into-shared-process-group-utilities
Move the GroupInfo dataclass out of training_utils/parallel.py into a shared
process_group_utils module that also provides multi-process-group helpers
(GeneralPGUtil / MultiPGUtil) for collectives over single or hierarchical
process groups, used by the cross-replica / effective-DP code paths.