You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
Opening Repository view (IceTipRepositoryBrowser) on a repo with tags and clicking the disclosure triangle to view them gives IceTipTagModel DNU #branchName, from IceTipResetBranchToThisCommitCommand>>defaultNameFromContext. If you close the debugger and try to right-click in the commit list, it happens again. If you explicitly select a branch, the error goes away.
Looking at #defaultNameFromContext, the sibling IceTipBranchModel does understand this message, and clearly the code was written assuming selectedBranch would return one of those. It seems like self selectedBranch is whatever is selected in the sidebar, and selectedCommitish is what's selected in the main panel. But the sidebar selection might not be a branch, and then we have a problem.
I think the problem here is that it isn't really valid/reasonable to say "reset to ". You can do something like it, but you wouldn't use git reset on the command-line, you'd use git tag -f. And indeed IceTag has no ability to modify what commit it points to, and creating one is done externally by IceGitCommit>>createTag:. So the command should just be disabled or absent from the menu when a tag is selected instead of a branch. If we wanted to have a separate "move tag to ", we could, but it would need to be written basically from scratch using a call to createTag:targetId:force: true.
After some poking around I think I figured out the right way to do this, PR incoming.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
daniels220
added a commit
to shoshanatech/pharo-iceberg
that referenced
this issue
Dec 16, 2023
Opening Repository view (
IceTipRepositoryBrowser
) on a repo with tags and clicking the disclosure triangle to view them givesIceTipTagModel
DNU#branchName
, fromIceTipResetBranchToThisCommitCommand>>defaultNameFromContext
. If you close the debugger and try to right-click in the commit list, it happens again. If you explicitly select a branch, the error goes away.Looking at
#defaultNameFromContext
, the siblingIceTipBranchModel
does understand this message, and clearly the code was written assumingselectedBranch
would return one of those. It seems likeself selectedBranch
is whatever is selected in the sidebar, andselectedCommitish
is what's selected in the main panel. But the sidebar selection might not be a branch, and then we have a problem.I think the problem here is that it isn't really valid/reasonable to say "reset to ". You can do something like it, but you wouldn't use
git reset
on the command-line, you'd usegit tag -f
. And indeedIceTag
has no ability to modify what commit it points to, and creating one is done externally byIceGitCommit>>createTag:
. So the command should just be disabled or absent from the menu when a tag is selected instead of a branch. If we wanted to have a separate "move tag to ", we could, but it would need to be written basically from scratch using a call tocreateTag:targetId:force: true
.After some poking around I think I figured out the right way to do this, PR incoming.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: