Skip to content

Complete Diff Improvements Phase B audit - #155

Merged
pandemicsyn merged 3 commits into
mainfrom
agent/final-phase-b-audit
Jul 18, 2026
Merged

pandemicsyn merged 3 commits into
mainfrom
agent/final-phase-b-audit

Conversation

@pandemicsyn

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

Outcome

  • Completes the final Diff Improvements Phase B audit across the shared review source, surface, finding, navigation, and refresh contracts and the focused GitHub PR, prepared-diff, and prepared-backed Kilo/worktree surfaces.
  • Reconciles the Phase B plan, retained static frontend report, performance record, and deviation log without deleting historical findings, measurements, sequence items, or later phases.
  • Leaves Phases C–E explicitly planned and unstarted at the user-selected Phase B stopping milestone.

Corrections

  • Keeps an already-applied prepared-diff review and its approval/recovery context mounted when a background metadata refresh fails, while surfacing the refresh error. Adds focused regression coverage and a patch changeset.
  • Updates the local GitHub route cache fixture to bind both base and head SHAs, matching the revision-v2 cache contract landed in PR feat: keep review refresh revision-safe #154.
  • Qualifies the 30-second worktree fingerprint poll truthfully: cadence and changed-path query scope are bounded, but full-file content hashing remains byte- and time-unbounded for pathological huge changed files.

Verification

All commands used Node 26.4.0.

  • Focused Phase B unit/component/API suite: 17 files passed, 178 tests passed.
  • Prepared refresh regression file: 12 tests passed.
  • Route safety/API test after the isolated fixture correction: 22 tests passed.
  • npm run typecheck:app: passed.
  • npm run lint: passed.
  • Targeted Prettier checks, git diff --check, and standalone HTML/jsdom integrity validation: passed. The HTML retains 32 findings, 26 non-performance findings, 14 sequence items, and no duplicate IDs.
  • npm run verify: run exactly once. Layer, database, TypeScript, docs, and lint gates passed. The unit stage reported 107 files passed / 1 failed and 705 tests passed / 1 failed because the pre-PR feat: keep review refresh revision-safe #154 route fixture expected two fetches without supplying the newly required base SHA. That stale fixture was then corrected and the smallest affected src/app-routes.test.ts check passed 22/22. Per the audit policy, the full suite was not rerun.

Retained performance evidence and misses

  • Lead rerun of npm run bench:review-fixtures: large committed-PR medians were 41.9 ms tree, 163.7 ms first patch, and 0 ms in-process thread projection, inside the 500/1,000/500 ms fixture budgets. This harness exercises pr-local-diffs only.
  • Exact-head 305-file worktree approximation on Node 26.4.0/arm64: repo/prepared metadata medians 140.9/137.0 ms and scoped active-patch medians 179.1/177.2 ms, all inside the 500 ms tree and 1,000 ms patch budgets. The fixture contained 120 modified, 30 deleted, 25 renamed, and 130 added files and exercised the production B5 stable-read/revision paths.
  • Historical deterministic and real-PR values remain untouched. Production tree visibility, one-time cold-object fetch, and uncached review-thread latency remain explicit retained misses, not relabeled passes.

Deviations and stopping handoff

  • Records the bounded prepared-refresh correction and the deferred byte/time-unbounded fingerprint limitation in .plans/DEVIATIONS.md.
  • No caching or hard content bound was introduced because that changes revision identity/freshness semantics and requires lead/product-owner discussion.
  • Phase B is complete. This PR intentionally stops before Phase C changeset mode, Phase D source-aware depth, and Phase E TUI reuse. It does not merge or enable auto-merge.

@pandemicsyn
pandemicsyn merged commit 0a661c9 into main Jul 18, 2026
5 checks passed
@pandemicsyn
pandemicsyn deleted the agent/final-phase-b-audit branch July 18, 2026 21:42
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant