Skip to content

[chore] Revert the switch over githubgen to the one built with our tools#37409

Merged
andrzej-stencel merged 1 commit into
open-telemetry:mainfrom
douglascamata:revert-37397-switch_over_githubgen
Jan 22, 2025
Merged

[chore] Revert the switch over githubgen to the one built with our tools#37409
andrzej-stencel merged 1 commit into
open-telemetry:mainfrom
douglascamata:revert-37397-switch_over_githubgen

Conversation

@douglascamata

@douglascamata douglascamata commented Jan 22, 2025

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Member

Reverts #37397.

PRs started to fail after #37397 got merged because of the codeowners check action, because it runs make githubgen-install then calls the githubgen tool.

I tried first fixing the CI check to run the new tool and it's giving errors, which is already starting to affect new PRs and old ones that get rebased:

/Users/douglas/code/opentelemetry-collector-contrib/.tools/githubgen
2025/01/22 11:43:55 codeowners are not members: Erog38, Frapschen, IbraheemA, JonathanWamsley, MovieStoreGuy, Mrod1598, NassimBtk, RichieSams, StefanKurek, VihasMakwana, adrielp, ag-ramachandran, akats7, alexvanboxel, ankitpa
tel96, antonblock, armstrmi, atingchen, atoulme, avadhut123pisal, bertysentry, braydonk, bryan-aguilar, carsonip, chan-tim-sumo, chrroberts-pure, codeboten, cparkins, cpheps, dashpole, dehaansa, dgoscn, edmocosta, eedorenko, 
erichsueh3, evan-bradley, fatsheep9146, fchikwekwe, gjanco, greatestusername, hughesjj, jacobmarble, jade-guiton-dd, jamesmoessis, jaronoff97, jmacd, joker-star-l, jsuereth, kasia-kujawa, khyatigandhi6, kongluoxing, liustanle
y, lquerel, mapno, mar4uk, marctc, martin-majlis-s1, mcardy, michalpristas, moh-osman3, mrsillydog, narcis96, nslaughter, pavankrish123, pcwiese, pjanotti, portertech, povilasv, psx95, pxaws, qiansheng91, rapphil, rnishtala-s
umo, rogercoll, samiura, schmikei, shabicheng, shalper2, sinkingpoint, smithclay, splunkericl, srprash, swiatekm, tamir-michaeli, tomaz-s1, wangzlei, yotamloe, zdaratom-s1
make: *** [gengithub] Error 1

I suggest that the new tool is introduced more gradually and is not used in CI yet until it behaves exactly like the old one.

@andrzej-stencel andrzej-stencel merged commit a151d16 into open-telemetry:main Jan 22, 2025
@github-actions github-actions Bot added this to the next release milestone Jan 22, 2025
chengchuanpeng pushed a commit to chengchuanpeng/opentelemetry-collector-contrib that referenced this pull request Jan 26, 2025
…ols (open-telemetry#37409)

Reverts open-telemetry#37397.

PRs started to fail after open-telemetry#37397 got merged because of the codeowners
check action, because it runs `make githubgen-install` then calls the
`githubgen` tool.

I tried first fixing the CI check to run the new tool and it's giving
errors, which is already starting to affect new PRs and old ones that
get rebased:

```
/Users/douglas/code/opentelemetry-collector-contrib/.tools/githubgen
2025/01/22 11:43:55 codeowners are not members: Erog38, Frapschen, IbraheemA, JonathanWamsley, MovieStoreGuy, Mrod1598, NassimBtk, RichieSams, StefanKurek, VihasMakwana, adrielp, ag-ramachandran, akats7, alexvanboxel, ankitpa
tel96, antonblock, armstrmi, atingchen, atoulme, avadhut123pisal, bertysentry, braydonk, bryan-aguilar, carsonip, chan-tim-sumo, chrroberts-pure, codeboten, cparkins, cpheps, dashpole, dehaansa, dgoscn, edmocosta, eedorenko, 
erichsueh3, evan-bradley, fatsheep9146, fchikwekwe, gjanco, greatestusername, hughesjj, jacobmarble, jade-guiton-dd, jamesmoessis, jaronoff97, jmacd, joker-star-l, jsuereth, kasia-kujawa, khyatigandhi6, kongluoxing, liustanle
y, lquerel, mapno, mar4uk, marctc, martin-majlis-s1, mcardy, michalpristas, moh-osman3, mrsillydog, narcis96, nslaughter, pavankrish123, pcwiese, pjanotti, portertech, povilasv, psx95, pxaws, qiansheng91, rapphil, rnishtala-s
umo, rogercoll, samiura, schmikei, shabicheng, shalper2, sinkingpoint, smithclay, splunkericl, srprash, swiatekm, tamir-michaeli, tomaz-s1, wangzlei, yotamloe, zdaratom-s1
make: *** [gengithub] Error 1
```

I suggest that the new tool is introduced more gradually and is not used
in CI yet until it behaves exactly like the old one.
zeck-ops pushed a commit to zeck-ops/opentelemetry-collector-contrib that referenced this pull request Apr 23, 2025
…ols (open-telemetry#37409)

Reverts open-telemetry#37397.

PRs started to fail after open-telemetry#37397 got merged because of the codeowners
check action, because it runs `make githubgen-install` then calls the
`githubgen` tool.

I tried first fixing the CI check to run the new tool and it's giving
errors, which is already starting to affect new PRs and old ones that
get rebased:

```
/Users/douglas/code/opentelemetry-collector-contrib/.tools/githubgen
2025/01/22 11:43:55 codeowners are not members: Erog38, Frapschen, IbraheemA, JonathanWamsley, MovieStoreGuy, Mrod1598, NassimBtk, RichieSams, StefanKurek, VihasMakwana, adrielp, ag-ramachandran, akats7, alexvanboxel, ankitpa
tel96, antonblock, armstrmi, atingchen, atoulme, avadhut123pisal, bertysentry, braydonk, bryan-aguilar, carsonip, chan-tim-sumo, chrroberts-pure, codeboten, cparkins, cpheps, dashpole, dehaansa, dgoscn, edmocosta, eedorenko, 
erichsueh3, evan-bradley, fatsheep9146, fchikwekwe, gjanco, greatestusername, hughesjj, jacobmarble, jade-guiton-dd, jamesmoessis, jaronoff97, jmacd, joker-star-l, jsuereth, kasia-kujawa, khyatigandhi6, kongluoxing, liustanle
y, lquerel, mapno, mar4uk, marctc, martin-majlis-s1, mcardy, michalpristas, moh-osman3, mrsillydog, narcis96, nslaughter, pavankrish123, pcwiese, pjanotti, portertech, povilasv, psx95, pxaws, qiansheng91, rapphil, rnishtala-s
umo, rogercoll, samiura, schmikei, shabicheng, shalper2, sinkingpoint, smithclay, splunkericl, srprash, swiatekm, tamir-michaeli, tomaz-s1, wangzlei, yotamloe, zdaratom-s1
make: *** [gengithub] Error 1
```

I suggest that the new tool is introduced more gradually and is not used
in CI yet until it behaves exactly like the old one.
@douglascamata douglascamata deleted the revert-37397-switch_over_githubgen branch February 12, 2026 13:41
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

3 participants