Fix #1815, add retroactive CFE status asserts

Add a set of macros that decouple the function call from the
expected status:

- CFE_UtAssert_STATUS_STORE
- CFE_UtAssert_STATUS_MAY_BE
- CFE_UtAssert_STATUS_MUST_BE

The first will make the function call and put the status into
a temporary holding area, but will not assert on any particular
result.

The may/must macros then check the value of the holding area.

modules/cfe_assert/inc/cfe_assert.h

@@ -151,6 +151,101 @@ typedef void (*CFE_Assert_StatusCallback_t)(uint8 MessageType, const char *Prefi
     UtAssert_GenericUnsignedCompare(CFE_SB_MsgIdToValue(mid1), UtAssert_Compare_EQ, CFE_SB_MsgIdToValue(mid2), \
                                     UtAssert_Radix_HEX, __FILE__, __LINE__, "MsgId Check: ", #mid1, #mid2)
 
+/*****************************************************************************/
+/**
+** \brief Calls a function that returns CFE_Status_t with deferred validation
+**
+** \par Description
+**        The typical method of using #UtAssert_INT32_EQ to validate the result of a CFE call
+**        will both invoke the function and check the result in a single macro.  However, this
+**        requires advance knowledge of what the result is supposed to be, before the call is made.
+**
+**        This macro does invokes the function like the other macros do, but does _not_ check the
+**        return value.  Rather, it  stores the return the value in a local buffer for later checking,
+**        using the #CFE_Assert_STATUS_MAY_BE or #CFE_Assert_STATUS_MUST_BE macros.
+**
+** \par Assumptions, External Events, and Notes:
+**        In some functional test circumstances, particularly where the test is not being run
+**        in a clean/isolated environment, it may not always be feasible to predict the correct
+**        return code from an API call.
+**
+**        In these cases, the test program will need to check the result of the call itself,
+**        typically by storing the result on the stack and checking it for correctness by
+**        reading system state as necessary.
+**
+**        While the normal UtAssert_INT32_EQ assertion macro can still be used to retroactively check
+**        any status variable value (including a value on the stack from a previous API call), this
+**        will not include the "full text" of the API call, and so the test log will not reflect the
+**        full call details.
+**
+**        The pair of macros (CFE_Assert_STATUS_STORE and CFE_Assert_STATUS_WAS) can be used in these
+**        circumstances, to call an API function and record the full text of the call, when the expected
+**        status is not fully known, but still confirm the status was correct once it is known.
+**
+** \sa #CFE_Assert_STATUS_MAY_BE, #CFE_Assert_STATUS_MUST_BE
+**
+** \returns Actual CFE_Status_t value from the call
+*/
+#define CFE_Assert_STATUS_STORE(FN) CFE_Assert_Status_Store(FN, __FILE__, __LINE__, #FN)
+
+/*****************************************************************************/
+/**
+** \brief Retroactively check for an acceptable status value from CFE_Assert_STATUS_STORE
+**
+** \par Description
+**        The typical method of using #UtAssert_INT32_EQ to validate the result of a CFE call
+**        will both invoke the function and check the result in a single macro.  However, this
+**        requires advance knowledge of what the result is supposed to be, before the call is made.
+**
+**        This retroactive macro does _not_ invoke any function, but rather checks the stored status
+**        from a previous call to #CFE_Assert_STATUS_STORE.  It should be used for each status
+**        code that should be considered acceptable from the previous function call.
+**
+** \par Assumptions, External Events, and Notes:
+**
+**        While the normal UtAssert_INT32_EQ assertion macro can still be used to check any
+**        status variable value (including a value on the stack from a previous API call), this
+**        will not include the "full text" of the API call.  This macro is intended for those cases
+**        where it is desired to log the full text (function + arguments) of the API call, but
+**        when the call has already been made and the status value is stored in a local variable.
+**
+** \sa #CFE_Assert_STATUS_STORE, #CFE_Assert_STATUS_MUST_BE
+**
+** \returns Boolean pass/fail status
+**
+******************************************************************************/
+#define CFE_Assert_STATUS_MAY_BE(expected) \
+    CFE_Assert_Status_DeferredCheck(expected, UTASSERT_CASETYPE_NA, __FILE__, __LINE__, #expected)
+
+/*****************************************************************************/
+/**
+** \brief Retroactively check for a required status value from CFE_Assert_STATUS_STORE
+**
+** \par Description
+**        The typical method of using #UtAssert_INT32_EQ to validate the result of a CFE call
+**        will both invoke the function and check the result in a single macro.  However, this
+**        requires advance knowledge of what the result is supposed to be, before the call is made.
+**
+**        This retroactive macro does _not_ invoke any function, but rather checks the stored status
+**        from a previous call to #CFE_Assert_STATUS_STORE.  This should be used as the final
+**        assertion, after checking for other acceptable values via #CFE_Assert_STATUS_MAY_BE.
+**
+** \par Assumptions, External Events, and Notes:
+**
+**        While the normal UtAssert_INT32_EQ assertion macro can still be used to check any
+**        status variable value (including a value on the stack from a previous API call), this
+**        will not include the "full text" of the API call.  This macro is intended for those cases
+**        where it is desired to log the full text (function + arguments) of the API call, but
+**        when the call has already been made and the status value is stored in a local variable.
+**
+** \sa #CFE_Assert_STATUS_STORE, #CFE_Assert_STATUS_MAY_BE
+**
+** \returns Boolean pass/fail status
+**
+******************************************************************************/
+#define CFE_Assert_STATUS_MUST_BE(expected) \
+    CFE_Assert_Status_DeferredCheck(expected, UTASSERT_CASETYPE_FAILURE, __FILE__, __LINE__, #expected)
+
 /*************************************************************************
 ** Exported Functions
 *************************************************************************/
@@ -276,4 +371,44 @@ void CFE_Assert_CloseLogFile(void);
 bool CFE_UtAssert_StatusCheck(CFE_Status_t Status, bool ExpectSuccess, UtAssert_CaseType_t CaseType, const char *File,
                               uint32 Line, const char *Text);
 
+/*****************************************************************************/
+/**
+** \brief Helper function for nominal CFE calls with deferred check
+**
+** \par Description
+**        This helper function will store the status into a temporary holding area,
+**        but _not_ assert on any specific value.
+**
+** \par Assumptions, External Events, and Notes:
+**        This facility should only be used by one task at a time.  Normally tests
+**        are single-threaded, and CFE assert will serialize test apps, so this is
+**        not a concern in the typical test environment.
+**
+**        However, if a particular test case uses child tasks, then the programmer must
+**        explicitly ensure that only one task uses this facility at a time.
+**
+** \returns Status value (pass through)
+*/
+CFE_Status_t CFE_Assert_Status_Store(CFE_Status_t Status, const char *File, uint32 Line, const char *Text);
+
+/**
+** \brief Helper function for nominal CFE calls with deferred check
+**
+** \par Description
+**        This helper function will assert on the status previously stored to a
+**        temporary holding area.
+**
+** \par Assumptions, External Events, and Notes:
+**        This facility should only be used by one task at a time.  Normally tests
+**        are single-threaded, and CFE assert will serialize test apps, so this is
+**        not a concern in the typical test environment.
+**
+**        However, if a particular test case uses child tasks, then the programmer must
+**        explicitly ensure that only one task uses this facility at a time.
+**
+** \returns Test pass status, returns true if status was successful, false if it failed.
+*/
+bool CFE_Assert_Status_DeferredCheck(CFE_Status_t Status, UtAssert_CaseType_t CaseType, const char *File, uint32 Line,
+                                     const char *Text);
+
 #endif /* CFE_ASSERT_H */

modules/cfe_assert/src/cfe_assert_priv.h

@@ -136,6 +136,28 @@ typedef struct
      */
     char CurrentTestName[CFE_MISSION_MAX_API_LEN];
 
+    /* The following members support the "Deferred" assert feature */
+
+    /**
+     * Actual CFE status value from a previous function call
+     */
+    CFE_Status_t StoredStatus;
+
+    /**
+     * Full text of previous function call that produced "StoredStatus"
+     */
+    char StoredText[CFE_ASSERT_MAX_LOG_LINE_LENGTH];
+
+    /**
+     * File name of source file that produced "StoredStatus"
+     */
+    char StoredFile[CFE_MISSION_MAX_PATH_LEN];
+
+    /**
+     * Line number of source file that produced "StoredStatus"
+     */
+    uint32 StoredLine;
+
 } CFE_Assert_Global_t;
 
 extern CFE_Assert_Global_t CFE_Assert_Global;

modules/cfe_assert/src/cfe_assert_runner.c

@@ -89,6 +89,54 @@ bool CFE_UtAssert_StatusCheck(CFE_Status_t Status, bool ExpectSuccess, UtAssert_
     return UtAssertEx(Result, CaseType, File, Line, "%s (0x%lx) is %s", Text, (unsigned long)Status, MatchText);
 }
 
+CFE_Status_t CFE_Assert_Status_Store(CFE_Status_t Status, const char *File, uint32 Line, const char *Text)
+{
+    const char *BaseName;
+
+    /* All this needs to do is save the code+text, will assert later */
+    CFE_Assert_Global.StoredStatus = Status;
+    strncpy(CFE_Assert_Global.StoredText, Text, sizeof(CFE_Assert_Global.StoredText) - 1);
+    CFE_Assert_Global.StoredText[sizeof(CFE_Assert_Global.StoredText) - 1] = 0;
+
+    BaseName = strrchr(File, '/');
+    if (BaseName == NULL)
+    {
+        BaseName = File;
+    }
+    else
+    {
+        ++BaseName;
+    }
+    strncpy(CFE_Assert_Global.StoredFile, BaseName, sizeof(CFE_Assert_Global.StoredFile) - 1);
+    CFE_Assert_Global.StoredFile[sizeof(CFE_Assert_Global.StoredFile) - 1] = 0;
+    CFE_Assert_Global.StoredLine                                           = Line;
+
+    /* Status code is just passed thru so the test case can check it however it needs to */
+    return Status;
+}
+
+bool CFE_Assert_Status_DeferredCheck(CFE_Status_t Status, UtAssert_CaseType_t CaseType, const char *File, uint32 Line,
+                                     const char *Text)
+{
+    bool Result;
+    if (CFE_Assert_Global.StoredText[0] == 0)
+    {
+        /* If no status was stored, then this is a bug in the test program (need to store a result first) */
+        UtAssertEx(false, UTASSERT_CASETYPE_FAILURE, File, Line, "TEST BUG: No stored status to assert (%s)", Text);
+        Result = false;
+    }
+    else
+    {
+        /* This produces a log message similar to what UtAssert_INT32_EQ would produce.
+         * Note the file/line will reflect where the call was made, not where this assertion was done */
+        Result = UtAssertEx(Status == CFE_Assert_Global.StoredStatus, CaseType, CFE_Assert_Global.StoredFile,
+                            CFE_Assert_Global.StoredLine, "%s (%ld) == %s (%ld)", CFE_Assert_Global.StoredText,
+                            (long)CFE_Assert_Global.StoredStatus, Text, (long)Status);
+    }
+
+    return Result;
+}
+
 void CFE_Assert_StatusReport(uint8 MessageType, const char *Prefix, const char *OutputMessage)
 {
     uint16 EventType;

modules/cfe_testcase/src/es_cds_test.c

@@ -38,26 +38,44 @@ void TestRegisterCDS(void)
     CFE_ES_CDSHandle_t CDSHandlePtr;
     CFE_ES_CDSHandle_t CDSHandlePtr2;
 
-    size_t       BlockSize  = 10;
-    size_t       BlockSize2 = 15;
-    const char * Name       = "CDS_Test";
-    const char * LongName   = "VERY_LONG_NAME_CDS_Test";
-    CFE_Status_t status;
+    size_t      BlockSize  = 10;
+    size_t      BlockSize2 = 15;
+    const char *Name       = "CDS_Test";
+    const char *LongName   = "VERY_LONG_NAME_CDS_Test";
 
     UtPrintf("Testing: CFE_ES_RegisterCDS");
 
-    status = CFE_ES_RegisterCDS(&CDSHandlePtr, BlockSize2, Name);
+    /*
+     * Since this test app may be executed multiple times, or the system may have
+     * been booted from a processor reset rather than a power-on reset, it is possible
+     * that the CDS already exists at the time this test is executed.  In this case
+     * the new CDS allocation path cannot be checked in functional test, but other CDS
+     * functions can still be called.
+     */
 
-    if (status == CFE_ES_CDS_ALREADY_EXISTS)
+    CFE_Assert_STATUS_STORE(CFE_ES_RegisterCDS(&CDSHandlePtr, BlockSize2, Name));
+
+    if (CFE_Assert_STATUS_MAY_BE(CFE_ES_CDS_ALREADY_EXISTS))
     {
+        /*
+         * add an informational message that the functional test is incomplete here, due
+         * to preconditions beyond the control of this test app.  Need to clear the CDS
+         * memory and/or do a power-on reset to get full test.
+         */
         UtAssert_NA("CDS already exists. CFE_ES_RegisterCDS new allocation could not be properly tested");
     }
     else
     {
-        UtAssert_INT32_EQ(status, CFE_SUCCESS);
+        /*
+         * If not CFE_ES_CDS_ALREADY_EXISTS, then the only other acceptable status is CFE_SUCCESS,
+         * which indicates that the CDS was created and initialized from a clean slate.
+         */
+        CFE_Assert_STATUS_MUST_BE(CFE_SUCCESS);
+
+        /* In this case, calling CFE_ES_RegisterCDS() again should return the CFE_ES_CDS_ALREADY_EXISTS */
+        UtAssert_INT32_EQ(CFE_ES_RegisterCDS(&CDSHandlePtr2, BlockSize2, Name), CFE_ES_CDS_ALREADY_EXISTS);
     }
 
-    UtAssert_INT32_EQ(CFE_ES_RegisterCDS(&CDSHandlePtr2, BlockSize2, Name), CFE_ES_CDS_ALREADY_EXISTS);
     UtAssert_INT32_EQ(CFE_ES_RegisterCDS(&CDSHandlePtr2, BlockSize, Name), CFE_SUCCESS);
 
     UtAssert_INT32_EQ(CFE_ES_RegisterCDS(NULL, BlockSize, Name), CFE_ES_BAD_ARGUMENT);