MSC3244: Room version capabilities

proposals/3244-room-version-capabilities.md

@@ -0,0 +1,148 @@
+# MSC3244: Room version capabilities
+
+When a new room version is introduced there is a delay before it becames the default
+version. This delay is related to support of this new room version across the federation.
+If a Home Server were to switch the new version as default to early, it will lock out all other users
+that are on Home Servers that do not understand this version.
+
+But however the new room version might add an interesting feature that some client on some Home
+Servers might want to use earlier. One solution might be for the client to explicitly request a
+version when creating a room but it's a bad practice to force a room version.
+
+If the client is forcing a room version, and server side a new version is added (that support the needed
+feature) the client will still use the old one until it's updated.
+
+As an example v7 is introducing `knock` but it's not default yet, it would be nice for client to 
+start using it until it is supported by the default version and to also use the latest stable version that
+supports this feature in the future.
+
+The goal of this MSC is to give the client a way to have more information on the supported features of room
+versions available on a given server, to give more feedback to users during room creation as well as
+in the room settings section.
+
+## Proposal
+
+The __m.room_versions capability__  [`/_matrix/client/r0/capabilities`]([https://matrix.org/docs/spec/client_server/r0.6.1#m-room-versions-capability])
+endpoint could be decorated to provide more information on room version capabilities.
+
+Actual capabilities response:
+````
+{
+  "capabilities": {
+    "m.room_versions": {
+      "default": "6",
+      "available": {
+        "1": "stable",
+        "2": "stable",
+        "3": "stable",
+        "4": "stable",
+        "5": "stable",
+        "6": "stable",
+        "org.matrix.msc2176": "unstable",
+        "org.matrix.msc3083": "unstable"
+      }
+    },
+    "m.change_password": {...}
+  }
+}
+````
+
+Proposed modification.
+In the following hypothetical sample, 3 new versions has been introduced (7, 8 and 9) but 6 is still the default.
+
+````
+{
+  "capabilities": {
+    "m.room_versions": {
+      "default": "6",
+      "available": {
+        "1": "stable",
+        "...,
+        "6": "stable",
+        "7": "stable",
+        "8": "stable",
+        "9": "stable",
+        "org.matrix.msc6789": "unstable",
+      },
+      "room_capabilities": {
+          "knock" : {
+              "preferred": "7",
+              "support" : ["7"]
+          },
+          "restricted" : {
+              "preferred": "9",
+              "support" : ["8", "9"]
+          }
+      }
+    }
+  }
+}
+````
+
+A new object is added under `room_capabilities`, each key is the name of a capability.
+This object provides the list of room versions supporting this capability as well as the preferred version to use.
+
+`preferred` should never point to an unstable version. When a feature is only supported by an unstable version, `preferred`should be set to null, and the unstable versions would be listed in `support`.
+
+````
+"restricted": {
+    "preferred": null,
+    "support": [
+        "org.matrix.msc3083"
+    ]
+}
+````
+
+
+As part of this MSC, two capabilities are defined:
+- `knock` for knocking join rule support [MSC2403](https://github.com/matrix-org/matrix-doc/pull/2403)
+- `restricted` for restricted join rule support [MSC3083](https://github.com/matrix-org/matrix-doc/pull/3083)
+
+## Client recommendations:
+
+__Notice__: In real world usage most of the time clients should not specify a room version when creating
+a room, and should let the Home Server select the correct one (via their knowledgeable server admin).
+This is an advanced mechanism to start using feature early.
+
+When presenting room settings, clients should use capabilities in order to display the correct UI. 
+
+For example if the room support knocking, the client should add this option in the join rule chooser
+(and if not only show `Invite Only` and `Public` for example).
+
+When creating a room, the client could check if the needed feature is supported by the server before creating.
+
+If the feature is not supported, the client could inform the user that this type of room can't be created
+as well as an information message explaining how to contact the home server admin.
+
+If the feature is supported by the default room version, then just continue as usual.
+
+If the feature is supported but by a stable room version that is not the default one, the client should
+then request to use the preferred version (`preferred`) that supports the feature, in the create room call:
+
+````
+POST /_matrix/client/r0/createRoom HTTP/1.1
+Content-Type: application/json
+
+{
+  "preset": "....",
+  "name": "....",
+  "topic": "....",
+  "creation_content": { ... }
+  "room_version": "8"
+}
+````
+
+In the hypothetical scenario where multiple capabilities would be needed (e.g mscXX1 and mscXX2), and have different `preferred` versions, clients can then pick one of the stable version that appears in both `support` arrays.
+
+Notice that, it is not recommended to use an unstable room version even if it's the only one supporting a given feature.
+It should be reserved for development. This MSC is only about default version not about unstable.
+
+
+## Unstable prefix
+
+The following mapping will be used for identifiers in this MSC during development:
+
+
+Proposed final identifier       | Purpose | Development identifier
+------------------------------- | ------- | ----
+`room_capabilities` | event type | `org.matrix.msc3244.room_capabilities`