[master ticket] Integrating MapRoulette in other Editors

[tordans]

The general idea is, to integrate MapRoulette in other editors.
This ticket is meant to track the status of discussions within other tickets.
Please create separate tickets for discussions.

Editor	Tickets	Status	Main UseCase |
GoMap	Add MapRoulette-"Quests" similar to the StreetComplete-Quest-Idea bryceco/GoMap#240 MR GoMap!! integration #1108	zzZ; (?)	Solve challenges with local knowledge while walking down the street. Organized efforts by local community (of a city; district) but also discovery of other challenges that happen to be around the corner."
StreetComplete SC	Website: https://streetcomplete.app/ Search MR in SC Repo; no focussed ticket, yet MR no focussed ticket, yet	tbd	Same as GoMap
MapComplete MC	Search MR in SC Repo; no focussed ticket, yet MR no focussed ticket, yet	tbd	Same as GoMap; Interaction of themes is different. Might be a MC-theme for all MR challenges; might be and integration of specific MR challenges in specific MC-themes; might be a separate ("layer") from the themes… MC does have a review-and-import-process based on special OSM notes already (Blogpost). That process could maybe be updated to use MapRoulette.
iD	Search MR in iD Repo MR no focussed ticket, yet	zzZ; (?)	Same workflow and use case as with Notes- and QA-Layers in iD: MR data can be made visible and edited/solved from within iD while editing a specific area.
RapID	Ticket Add Map Roulette Integration to Rapid facebook/Rapid#1150 PR MapRoulette Integration facebook/Rapid#1221	Actively being worked on	Right now the focus seems to be on getting the MR data into Rapid. There might be potential to go further to improve the editing experience.
JOSM	JOSM Repo: ? MR: ?	?	Same as iD
Vespucci	Vespucci Repo: editing MapRoulette tasks? MarcusWolschon/osmeditor4android#690 MR: Prerequisites for full support are Please make life simpler for everybody using the maproulette API (Question wrt client authentication) maproulette-backend#476 and MR tasks in bounding box is missing task property information, mustache tags are not displayed correctly #955	Implemented but limited	Same as GoMap
MapRoulette MR mobile	MR was not discussed, yet (Github Repo search)	?	Same as StreetComplete and GoMap. But EveryDoor is Cross Plattform (Android + iPhone).
EveryDoor	Github: https://github.com/Zverik/every_door/ Website: https://every-door.app/ MR Mobile support #856	?	Using MR as a separate app to solve local tickets; needs integration with GoMap and Vespucci to solve the given tasks; or only for quick-edit-challenges that do not require an external editor.

---

Updates to this ticket

• 2022-06-22: MapComplete: Add comment and link
• 2023-02-10: Add EveryDoor.
• 2023-12-25: Split iD <> Rapid because there is active work to integrate into Rapid 🥳

[mvexel]

Vespucci does already have MR integration, see MarcusWolschon/osmeditor4android#690

Edited the original ticket.

[joostschouppe]

Thinking more about features than specific editors, it would be nice to have a mobile app showing tasks that are "too hard, can't see" tasks.

[mvexel]

See also https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-ca/2022-May/010428.html - someone is seeking a StreetComplete equivalent for iOS.

[mvexel]

@joostschouppe Agree. The idea being that some tasks could be done remotely and some would need verification in the field.

There is already a flag you can set when you create a challenge indicating that a challenge needs local knowledge. This could be used as a filter in mobile apps that want to integrate MapRoulette challenges. With some work we could enable this flag being attached to a task as well.

[mvexel]

The Vespucci integration is currently limited by #1737 and maproulette/maproulette-backend#476 as mentioned here: #955

[mvexel]

This is not about editor integrations strictly, but I am starting to think more deeply about integrating with other QA signal sources. I wrote up a page about Mapillary here.

[tordans]

Update: I added EveryDoor to the list of possible integrations. This is also a ping to Ilya's ticket on the question of funding features.

[pietervdvn]

Since this summer, MapComplete has some MapRoulette support.

First of all, you can see all tasks in MapRoulette on MapComplete.

Furthermore, it is possible to use a maproulette-challenge to do a guided import (to add new points or to add tags to an already existing points); but this needs some preparation to setup for thematic that want to do imports. I'm busy documenting the process here

[mvexel]

@tordans would it make sense to distill this into a MapRoulette project board?

[tordans]

Update/FYI: I just split the table lines for "iD/Rapid" since there is an active PR in Rapid working on an integration.

[bhousel]

Update on this, as of Rapid v2.3 we've built a layer to allow users to work with MapRoulette tasks directly from Rapid.
https://github.com/facebook/Rapid/blob/main/CHANGELOG.md#230

Some more details on social media:

• Twitter/𝕏: https://twitter.com/bhousel/status/1790060093733499259
• Mastodon: https://mastodon.social/@bhousel/112434802439881843
• Threads: https://www.threads.net/@houselb/post/C66uo9yRUaQ

[pietervdvn]

I'd like to bump maproulette/maproulette-backend#1037 which would make my life easier