[Bug]: Call to a member function comment() on null

[cospin]

What happened?

It seems that when an .mp3 file only has ID3v2 information and no v1, the following error is generated:

[30-Oct-2023 21:08:56 UTC] PHP Fatal error:  Uncaught Error: Call to a member function comment() on null in site\vendor\kiwilan\php-audio\src\Models\AudioCore.php:430
Stack trace:
#0 sitet\vendor\kiwilan\php-audio\src\Audio.php(395): Kiwilan\Audio\Models\AudioCore::fromId3(NULL, Object(Kiwilan\Audio\Models\Id3AudioTagV2))
#1 site\vendor\kiwilan\php-audio\src\Audio.php(98): Kiwilan\Audio\Audio->parse()
#2 site\upload.php(112): Kiwilan\Audio\Audio::get('site/...')
#3 site\upload.php(407): newMetadata('site/...', 'Miss K8 - Infin...')
#4 {main}
  thrown in site\vendor\kiwilan\php-audio\src\Models\AudioCore.php on line 430

The relevant line is:

php-audio/src/Models/AudioCore.php

Line 430 in 327e76d

comment: $v2->comment() ?? $v1->comment(),

In this case, the function is being called as: fromId3(NULL, Object). Replacing the line with: comment: $v2 ? $v2->comment() : $v1->comment(), works.

How to reproduce the bug

For now I think it happens when a .mp3 file only has only ID3v2 information and no v1.

Package Version

3.0.02

PHP Version

8.2.11

Which operating systems does with happen with?

Windows

Notes

Really nice work, thank you!

[ewilan-riviere]

Thanks, I will fix this today 👍

[ewilan-riviere]

Can you check latest version?

[cospin]

@ewilan-riviere unfortunately, I found another file that gives a similar error, but this time it's Call to a member function genre() on null. I suppose we need to make sure that $v2 exists in every field, not just in the comment field.

To be honest, it's somewhat unusual, and without looking at the code a bit, I wouldn't know why it's happening. It's supposed to be the case that $v2 should never be null in fromId3(?Id3AudioTagV1 $v1, Id3AudioTagV2 $v2), and the trace shows that it's called with $v2: fromId3(NULL, Object(Kiwilan\Audio\Models\Id3AudioTagV2))

This time, it happened with a Tag ID3v2.4 (ID3v2.4), which has several empty fields, including the genre.

Checking for $v2 as we do with comment works, but seems weird to have to check $v2 on every field.

[ewilan-riviere]

I will fix this, if you have a sample to provide for tests (if you can share it), it would be great!

[ewilan-riviere]

Thanks! Can I let these files into tests files?

[cospin]

No, they are not mine and have copyright 🙃
Let me know if you have downloaded them so I can remove the link.

[ewilan-riviere]

No problem, I will create sample from their metadata.
Yes, you can remove it

[ewilan-riviere]

Can you test with latest version?

[cospin]

Yep, seems to work fine. Thank you! 🙏

[ewilan-riviere]

No problem, tell me if you find another bug!