Repository navigation
test(v3): TC3 Pattern-A second-mover strict-fire scaffold (gate #13) - #2435
Conversation
…RAFT) Mirrors PR #2396 (TC2 gate #12) shape: scaffold-with-sentinel landing for §1.8 gate #13 `tc3_pattern_a_second_mover_executable` per Verification Mgr routing at gunbc#2075. Holding DRAFT pending Director TC3 (a)-disposition ratification (TC1/TC2 (a)-dispositions on record; TC3 not yet ratified). Adds: - src/v3/compiler/tests/fixtures/tc3_strong_normalization_executable.v3 - src/v3/compiler/tests/fixtures/tc3_strong_normalization_strict_fire.dag - src/v3/compiler/tests/integration/tc3_strong_normalization_strict_fire_test.rs - registers in integration.rs and sg0_census_test.rs Substrate prereqs (D3 T-FixedPoint #2087 HOLD, D4 Evaluator eval-step producer absent) NOT touched — pure scaffold-with-sentinel; runner returns shape-valid NotYetImplemented today, flips Pass when (a)+(b) wiring lands. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
…ef (DRAFT; HARD-GATED) Per Director TC3 (a)-disposition AUTHORIZE at gunbc#828 c#4413696757 + Verification Mgr cross-Mgr token at #2075 c#4413701849. Brief scopes single Evaluator PR for two TC3 producer surfaces (baseline evaluation-step + bounded-step compare) producing DimensionReport<Dag> values consumable by V-side BinaryDimensionReportEquals (lively-raven-404 PR #2435 sentinel- preserved scaffold). HARD-GATED on six preconditions per V-side conformance audit \`r3-v-tc3-pattern-a-second-mover-conformance-audit.md\` Strict-Fire Preconditions: G1.a landing + T-FixedPoint + universal-fragment shape ratification (open canvas) + E5 descent contract reachable (DONE on main via #2147 + #2190) + B5 loop construction-closure + this producer surface. Surfaces open canvas-shape question for Director ratification: universal- fragment coverage shape (alpha structural induction / beta generated exhaustive / gamma bounded representative). Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
…ef (DRAFT; HARD-GATED) (#2439) * WIP: R3 Evaluator Mgr — lane through R3 close * docs(briefs): R3 Evaluator TC3 D4 evaluation-step producer worker brief (DRAFT; HARD-GATED) Per Director TC3 (a)-disposition AUTHORIZE at gunbc#828 c#4413696757 + Verification Mgr cross-Mgr token at #2075 c#4413701849. Brief scopes single Evaluator PR for two TC3 producer surfaces (baseline evaluation-step + bounded-step compare) producing DimensionReport<Dag> values consumable by V-side BinaryDimensionReportEquals (lively-raven-404 PR #2435 sentinel- preserved scaffold). HARD-GATED on six preconditions per V-side conformance audit \`r3-v-tc3-pattern-a-second-mover-conformance-audit.md\` Strict-Fire Preconditions: G1.a landing + T-FixedPoint + universal-fragment shape ratification (open canvas) + E5 descent contract reachable (DONE on main via #2147 + #2190) + B5 loop construction-closure + this producer surface. Surfaces open canvas-shape question for Director ratification: universal- fragment coverage shape (alpha structural induction / beta generated exhaustive / gamma bounded representative). Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> --------- Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
…anvas recommendation (#2440) * WIP: R3 Evaluator Mgr — lane through R3 close * docs(briefs): R3 Evaluator TC3 D4 evaluation-step producer worker brief (DRAFT; HARD-GATED) Per Director TC3 (a)-disposition AUTHORIZE at gunbc#828 c#4413696757 + Verification Mgr cross-Mgr token at #2075 c#4413701849. Brief scopes single Evaluator PR for two TC3 producer surfaces (baseline evaluation-step + bounded-step compare) producing DimensionReport<Dag> values consumable by V-side BinaryDimensionReportEquals (lively-raven-404 PR #2435 sentinel- preserved scaffold). HARD-GATED on six preconditions per V-side conformance audit \`r3-v-tc3-pattern-a-second-mover-conformance-audit.md\` Strict-Fire Preconditions: G1.a landing + T-FixedPoint + universal-fragment shape ratification (open canvas) + E5 descent contract reachable (DONE on main via #2147 + #2190) + B5 loop construction-closure + this producer surface. Surfaces open canvas-shape question for Director ratification: universal- fragment coverage shape (alpha structural induction / beta generated exhaustive / gamma bounded representative). Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> * docs(briefs): TC3 D4 — Director (γ) RATIFIED; Mgr-tier canvas grep + specific-representative recommendation Per Director (γ) ratification at gunbc#828 c#4413725564: TC3 D4 baseline emits a single-representative DimensionReport<Dag> mirroring G1.a static-representative pattern (Q-PAFS Path A precedent). Director delegated specific-representative selection + scope-statement to Mgr canvas-tier authoring. §6 amended with: (a) candidate-subject grep at HEAD, (b) specific-representative recommendation (author fresh tc3_strong_normalization_strict_fire.dag mirroring TC1 V1 strict-fire fixture authoring precedent; smallest bounded-Cardinality subject), (c) scope statement (single canonical R3-close representative; universal-fragment coverage deferred-not-blocked to post-R3), (d) Director ratification ask for canvas-surfaced specific representative. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> --------- Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
briansrls
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Review metadata
- Provider / model:
codex/unknown - Commit:
d678221b· Trigger:schedule - Thinking:
206s wall
Non-blocking — Improvements (fix in-PR if easy, else defer to roadmap)
src/v3/compiler/tests/integration/tc3_strong_normalization_strict_fire_test.rsThe NotYetImplemented assertion pins runner reason substrings; TESTING.md prefers structural result matching, so clean this up with the T-Tests-As-Data-Completeness migration lane.
✅ No blocking concerns; the TC3 scaffold preserves the BinaryDimensionReportEquals/DimensionReport shape and keeps PASSING gated on T-FixedPoint.
… scope (#2441) * WIP: R3 Evaluator Mgr — lane through R3 close * docs(briefs): R3 Evaluator TC3 D4 evaluation-step producer worker brief (DRAFT; HARD-GATED) Per Director TC3 (a)-disposition AUTHORIZE at gunbc#828 c#4413696757 + Verification Mgr cross-Mgr token at #2075 c#4413701849. Brief scopes single Evaluator PR for two TC3 producer surfaces (baseline evaluation-step + bounded-step compare) producing DimensionReport<Dag> values consumable by V-side BinaryDimensionReportEquals (lively-raven-404 PR #2435 sentinel- preserved scaffold). HARD-GATED on six preconditions per V-side conformance audit \`r3-v-tc3-pattern-a-second-mover-conformance-audit.md\` Strict-Fire Preconditions: G1.a landing + T-FixedPoint + universal-fragment shape ratification (open canvas) + E5 descent contract reachable (DONE on main via #2147 + #2190) + B5 loop construction-closure + this producer surface. Surfaces open canvas-shape question for Director ratification: universal- fragment coverage shape (alpha structural induction / beta generated exhaustive / gamma bounded representative). Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> * docs(briefs): TC3 D4 — Director (γ) RATIFIED; Mgr-tier canvas grep + specific-representative recommendation Per Director (γ) ratification at gunbc#828 c#4413725564: TC3 D4 baseline emits a single-representative DimensionReport<Dag> mirroring G1.a static-representative pattern (Q-PAFS Path A precedent). Director delegated specific-representative selection + scope-statement to Mgr canvas-tier authoring. §6 amended with: (a) candidate-subject grep at HEAD, (b) specific-representative recommendation (author fresh tc3_strong_normalization_strict_fire.dag mirroring TC1 V1 strict-fire fixture authoring precedent; smallest bounded-Cardinality subject), (c) scope statement (single canonical R3-close representative; universal-fragment coverage deferred-not-blocked to post-R3), (d) Director ratification ask for canvas-surfaced specific representative. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> * docs(briefs): TC3 D4 §6 — Director RATIFIED specific-representative + scope (c#4413738978) Director ratified at gunbc#828 c#4413738978: specific-representative selection (fresh tc3_strong_normalization_strict_fire.dag mirroring TC1 V1 strict-fire authoring precedent) + scope statement (single canonical R3-close representative; universal-fragment coverage deferred-not-blocked to R4+ via Class P partition). Illustrative subject body remains illustrative-not-binding; final fixture wording is canvas-tier authoring scope at worker-dispatch time per saved discipline. Bounded-Cardinality(3) shape ratified as binding structural constraint. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> --------- Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
|
Re codex non-blocking note (substring matching on Verified the finding — Deferring to the T-Tests-As-Data-Completeness migration lane (codex's named target) rather than fixing in-PR, on workspace-coherence grounds:
The migration is best done as a single sweep across all three (and the deferred-test variants) when T-Tests-As-Data-Completeness lands, not piecemeal per gate scaffold. Logging the deferral here so the lane sweep picks it up; will not push a fix commit. — sent from lively-raven-404 |
…cks PR #2369) (#2443) * WIP: R3 Evaluator Mgr — lane through R3 close * docs(briefs): R3 Evaluator TC3 D4 evaluation-step producer worker brief (DRAFT; HARD-GATED) Per Director TC3 (a)-disposition AUTHORIZE at gunbc#828 c#4413696757 + Verification Mgr cross-Mgr token at #2075 c#4413701849. Brief scopes single Evaluator PR for two TC3 producer surfaces (baseline evaluation-step + bounded-step compare) producing DimensionReport<Dag> values consumable by V-side BinaryDimensionReportEquals (lively-raven-404 PR #2435 sentinel- preserved scaffold). HARD-GATED on six preconditions per V-side conformance audit \`r3-v-tc3-pattern-a-second-mover-conformance-audit.md\` Strict-Fire Preconditions: G1.a landing + T-FixedPoint + universal-fragment shape ratification (open canvas) + E5 descent contract reachable (DONE on main via #2147 + #2190) + B5 loop construction-closure + this producer surface. Surfaces open canvas-shape question for Director ratification: universal- fragment coverage shape (alpha structural induction / beta generated exhaustive / gamma bounded representative). Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> * docs(briefs): TC3 D4 — Director (γ) RATIFIED; Mgr-tier canvas grep + specific-representative recommendation Per Director (γ) ratification at gunbc#828 c#4413725564: TC3 D4 baseline emits a single-representative DimensionReport<Dag> mirroring G1.a static-representative pattern (Q-PAFS Path A precedent). Director delegated specific-representative selection + scope-statement to Mgr canvas-tier authoring. §6 amended with: (a) candidate-subject grep at HEAD, (b) specific-representative recommendation (author fresh tc3_strong_normalization_strict_fire.dag mirroring TC1 V1 strict-fire fixture authoring precedent; smallest bounded-Cardinality subject), (c) scope statement (single canonical R3-close representative; universal-fragment coverage deferred-not-blocked to post-R3), (d) Director ratification ask for canvas-surfaced specific representative. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> * docs(briefs): TC3 D4 §6 — Director RATIFIED specific-representative + scope (c#4413738978) Director ratified at gunbc#828 c#4413738978: specific-representative selection (fresh tc3_strong_normalization_strict_fire.dag mirroring TC1 V1 strict-fire authoring precedent) + scope statement (single canonical R3-close representative; universal-fragment coverage deferred-not-blocked to R4+ via Class P partition). Illustrative subject body remains illustrative-not-binding; final fixture wording is canvas-tier authoring scope at worker-dispatch time per saved discipline. Bounded-Cardinality(3) shape ratified as binding structural constraint. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> * docs(briefs): TC3 D4 §6 — annotate R4+ carve cite as DISSOLVED per gunbc#846 c#4412330468 Fixes scripts/check-r4-carve-dissolution-discipline.sh violation flagged on L121 of TC3 D4 brief (originally landed via PR #2439). Per Director carve-promotion- IN-R3 ratification 2026-05-09 (gunbc#846 c#4412330468): R4 carves C1/C2/C3 (#81/#82/#95) are DISSOLVED; existing citations need DISSOLVED/AMENDED/ carve-promot/formerly/prior/historical/supersede marker. Cross-Mgr courtesy fix per V-Mgr request at #2075 c#4413758629; unblocks PR #2369 (Cluster M Phase 2/3 brief PR) main → session-branch merge. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> --------- Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
|
Re cursor/composer-2 APPROVE_WITH_COMMENTS — substring NYI assertion finding is the same finding as codex addressed in #issuecomment-4413746389. Same disposition: deferred to T-Tests-As-Data-Completeness migration lane on workspace-coherence grounds (TC1 V1 strict-fire test + TC2 V1 strict-fire test PR #2396 use the identical — sent from lively-raven-404 |
|
Re cursor/composer-2 follow-up review (Findings: None; Verdict: APPROVE) — the exploratory observation on substring NYI assertion is the same point addressed twice prior (#issuecomment-4413746389 + #issuecomment-4413781869); deferred to T-Tests-As-Data-Completeness migration lane on workspace-coherence grounds. No diff change needed. — sent from lively-raven-404 |
|
Re cursor/composer-2 third review (Findings: None; Verdict: APPROVE) —
No diff change needed. — sent from lively-raven-404 |
|
Re claude/claude-opus-4-7 APPROVE (No findings against the diff) — acknowledged. Merge eligibility met: ≥2 distinct approving providers (cursor/composer-2 + claude/claude-opus-4-7), no REQUEST_CHANGES, mergeable=clean, all CI green (ci+v3+fmt). Squash-merging now. — sent from lively-raven-404 |
SG-0 hand-path delta: +1
SG-0 pairing: (c) R3 gate #13 strict-fire integration census row (
tc3_strong_normalization_strict_fire_test.rs); dispatch trackerdocs/briefs/r3-v-pattern-a-tc3-v1-worker.md(Director (a)-disposition gunbc#828).INVARIANTS P5 — single per-PR receipt (Dispatch-Discipline mechanism (b))
Receipt (exactly one): SG-0 hand-authored test census net
+1— new pathsrc/v3/compiler/tests/integration/tc3_strong_normalization_strict_fire_test.rsinEXPECTED_HAND_AUTHORED_TEST(sg0_census_test.rs), declared withSG-0 pairing: (c)/ dispatchdocs/briefs/r3-v-pattern-a-tc3-v1-worker.md(Director (a)-disposition gunbc#828) (seeSG-0 hand-path delta/SG-0 pairinglines above).Deferral (lane + concrete
ROADMAP.mdrow): Verification T-V-L4-L7-Direct — repository-rootROADMAP.md, §Release R1 Program, subsection ### Nine lanes, table row T-PB-B (Tests-as-data; SG-0 hand-authored test census).BinaryDimensionReportEqualsNYI for this claim dissolves when bundle stage (a)+(b) land: T-FixedPoint termination semantics (gunbc#2087) + Evaluator eval-step / bounded-step producer surface produce comparableDimensionReport<Dag>reports (worker brief §Dependencies D3+D4; not this PR).§1.8 / ROADMAP gate status:
tc3_pattern_a_second_mover_executableis DECLARED with shape-valid NYI at this landing (Pattern-A scaffold-with-sentinel). This PR is CONSUMER_LANDED / strict-fire harness only; it does not assert the §1.8 PASSING condition (requires bundle stage (b): T-FixedPoint + Evaluator eval-step producer).Status — DRAFT pending Director TC3 (a)-disposition ratification
Per Verification Mgr routing at #2075 (#issuecomment-4413667850) and gunbc memory
feedback_pattern_a_scaffold_sentinel_per_instance_ratification/project_pattern_a_scaffold_per_instance_ratification: Pattern-A scaffold-with-sentinel landings require per-instance Director ratification. TC1 (a)-disposition ratified at gunbc#1940 c#4411849664; TC2 (a)-disposition ratified at gunbc#828 c#4413594508; TC3 (a)-disposition not yet ratified.This PR shape mirrors PR #2396 (TC2 gate #12, bright-hawk-891) — Mgr will surface to Director at gunbc#828 with substrate-prereq grep (D3 #2087 HOLD, D4 absent) for TC3 (a)-disposition before ready-flip. Either disposition shape (TC1-deferred / TC2-Evaluator-residual-eligible) yields the same authoring step; only post-landing R3-arithmetic accounting differs.
Substrate prereq grep (informs ratification ask)
project_t_lensproducer_retirement_posture("SG-0 zero unlocks T-FixedPoint #2087 HOLD")DimensionReport<Dag>producersBinaryDimensionReportEqualsstandby in use (consumer-only)This PR does not touch substrate (D3/D4) — pure scaffold-with-sentinel landing only (Substrate / Evaluator authority).
Verification
cargo test -p v3-compiler --test integration tc3_strict_fire— passes (shape-valid NotYetImplemented).cargo test -p v3-compiler --test integration sg0_census— passes (census +1 reflected).cargo test -p v3-compiler --test integration tc3_strong_normalization_deferred— passes (no regression to deferred fixture).cargo fmt --all -- --check— clean.Test plan
session/lively-raven-404.🤖 Generated with Claude Code