Repository navigation
docs: add W1 output producer contract blocker - #1485
Conversation
|
Manager pass: this matches the W1 STOP+PING disposition. It documents the exact missing authorities separately: producer identity for rust_emit_output/dag_eval_output and typed observation normalization for Rust output into ProgramObservation. It also keeps the implementation fences intact: no test_runner.rs change, no fixture rewrites, no substrate shape, no new TestPredicate, and no stdout/name-key bridge smuggled in. Please mark ready for review/CI if this is the intended blocker deliverable. No code should be added to this PR. — sent from snappy-moth-795 |
|
Review metadata
FindingsNone. The diff only adds/links a brief that records a W1 producer-contract gate, names transitional vs durable paths, requires fail-closed behavior and dissolution targets, and explicitly avoids runner/fixture/substrate changes — consistent with INVARIANTS (fail-closed, progress as dissolution, no fabricated authority) and docs/modeling-discipline (tracked scaffold with named dissolution). CODING.md and TESTING.md do not apply here (no Rust or tests). VerdictAPPROVE — Narrowly scoped documentation; the new note supports the modeling rubric rather than bending it, and there is nothing in the diff that contradicts the pinned rubric. |
briansrls
left a comment
briansrls
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Review metadata
- Provider / model:
codex/unknown - Commit:
351c81a7· Trigger:schedule - Thinking:
160s wall
Non-blocking — Strengths
docs/briefs/r3-pr-e8-w1-output-producer-contract-blocker.mdThe blocker stays docs-only, preserves existing verification surfaces, and keeps W1 runner authority bounded with fail-closed gates and named dissolution paths.
✅ No blocking issues found.
…er-contract-blocker
|
Review metadata
Findings None. The change is documentation only: a new brief plus cross-links. It reinforces fail-closed behavior, explicit producer identity, observation normalization, and named dissolution targets, which matches the spirit of P3 (fail-closed) and P2 (single authority / boundary discipline) in Verdict APPROVE — Narrow, coherent docs-only gate for W1; no rubric violations observed in the diff. |
…er-contract-blocker
|
Review metadata
Verdict: APPROVE Docs-only diff is narrowly scoped and adds a blocker/proposal that preserves the existing STOP+PING: no runner code, no new predicate/substrate shape, and any transitional name/stdout carve-out is documented, bounded, and tied to a dissolution target. I don’t see a concrete violation of the pinned invariants, coding, or testing guidance in the changed lines. No builds or tests run, per review instructions. |
…er-contract-blocker
|
Review metadata
Verdict: APPROVE — docs-only diff is narrowly scoped and reinforces the rubric: it keeps W1 blocked until producer identity, typed observation normalization, fail-closed errors, and dissolution targets are explicit. No concrete invariant, coding, or testing-discipline violations observed in the changed lines. Tests were not run per review instructions. |
|
Review metadata
1. Story of the diffThis PR turns the W1 The new blocker document records the live state, then narrows the future implementation choices: either use a deliberately transitional declaration-name contract or add a durable substrate producer role/marker, and either use a typed observation-channel carrier or a tightly scoped Int-only stdout carve-out ( 2. Invariant categories
3. VerdictAPPROVE. The PR does not implement the risky runner path; it strengthens the review boundary by making producer identity, observation normalization, fail-closed behavior, and dissolution requirements explicit before code can land. The only transitional debt it authorizes is documented, bounded, and tied to named dissolution triggers. |
briansrls
left a comment
briansrls
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Review metadata
- Provider / model:
codex/unknown - Commit:
8511ae31· Trigger:schedule - Thinking:
113s wall
✅ No blocking concerns; the docs-only blocker keeps W1 runner authority fail-closed until producer identity, observation normalization, and dissolution triggers are explicit.
…er-contract-blocker
|
Review metadata
Verdict: APPROVE Docs-only diff, narrowly scoped. It records W1 as blocked, keeps the proposed name/stdout shortcuts explicitly transitional, bounded, fail-closed, and tied to dissolution targets. I don’t see a concrete violation of the pinned invariants, coding, or testing guidance in the changed lines. No builds or tests run, per review instructions. |
|
Review metadata
1. Story of the diffThis PR is a docs-only guardrail for the W1 2. Invariant categories
Compliant — the diff does not add substrate types,
Compliant — fail-closed and single-authority are handled directly: unknown producer pairs, unsupported value shapes, failed Rust execution, parse failures, and evaluator errors must remain typed runner errors at
N/A — this patch changes no Rust implementation, helper placement, method/free-function shape, error carrier code, or module organization; it is limited to brief documentation and explicitly avoids
N/A — no executable behavior changes, fixture rewrites, or corpus execution are introduced; the brief says this slice does not execute the L4 corpus at
N/A — the diff does not edit or override a locked design decision; it links parent authority docs at
Compliant — the temporary paths are documented and bounded. The DeclarationRef-name contract is limited to 3. VerdictAPPROVE The PR strengthens the W1 boundary instead of landing runner authority prematurely. The only transitional shapes it permits are bounded, fail-closed, and tied to dissolution rather than being normalized as permanent producer semantics. |
1 participant
Summary
DifferentialEquals(rust_emit_output, dag_eval_output, ProgramOutputBind).dag_eval_outputis plausibly available through no-memo eagerevaluate_body, whilerust_emit_outputremains blocked on explicit producer identity plus typed observation normalization.Scope
Docs-only. No
test_runner.rschanges, fixture rewrites, substrate shapes,TestPredicatechanges, runner implementation, L5 corpus execution, or E6/E7 witness work.Verification
git diff --checkcargo fmt --all --check