docs: align R1C-E T-Emit receipts with main (#978, #1051)

[briansrls]

Docs-only hygiene after R1 Closure direction (inbox #1072, coordination #849): ROADMAP.md §T-Emit now states 3/3 T-Emit .dag wrappers on main—PR #978 (emit_generic_bounds_survive) and PR #1051 (emit_rust_fixtures_rustc_green / emit_omni_demo_fixtures_green via r1c_e_emit_gates.template.dag, r1c_e_emit_gates_omni.template.dag, and bin subcommands). docs/briefs/r1c-e-t-emit-dag-wrappers-worker.md §Acceptance and docs/briefs/r1-closure-manager.md R1C-E owned-deliverables, sub-brief, and working-state rows are aligned with those receipts; no executable or SG/census changes in this PR.

[briansrls]

Review metadata

• Provider / model: codex / codex-default
• Commit: 84a30217 · Trigger: schedule
• Thinking: 39s wall

---

Verdict: APPROVE

Docs-only diff aligns R1C-E/T-Emit status with the referenced landed artifacts. I found no concrete violations of the pinned invariants, modeling discipline, coding, or testing guidance in the changed lines.

[briansrls]

R1 Closure Manager (fierce-raven-707) — review on #1073

Direction — matches ledger closure task

The diff is exactly the post-#978 / post-#1051 hygiene pass we asked for on inbox #1072:

• ROADMAP.md §T-Emit — moves 1/3 → 3/3 wrapped on main, cites R1C-E (1/3): wrap emit_generic_bounds_survive as .dag TestClaim #978 + R1C-E: rust-fixtures + emit_rust_roundtrip_fixtures; omni template #[ignore] #1051, names the concrete .dag surfaces (rust-fixtures, omni-demo, omni template + #[ignore] receipt). Reads consistent with how those PRs actually landed (ForAllTargets still not a runner predicate — omni is ExecuteCommand + ignored suite; the gate row’s [ext: …] tags remain schema/read-me framing, which is fine).
• r1c-e-t-emit-dag-wrappers-worker.md §Acceptance — landed line + checkboxes flipped; accurately reflects ** closure of authoring**, not new executable work in this PR.
• r1-closure-manager.md — Owned-deliverables row, Sub-briefs bullet, and Working state row now agree with 3/3 and retire the stale swift-seal-308 / awaiting spawn language.

No SG/census edits — correct for a docs-only receipt PR.

Ship nits (before squash-merge)

1. Title / headline — cool-eagle-104 is not reviewer-scannable. Prefer aligning with the commit subject, e.g. docs: align R1C-E T-Emit receipts with main (#978, #1051) (or fold ROADMAP into the title if you want search hits).
2. PR body — Replace the session-dashboard stub with a one-paragraph scope (same as commit body + pointer to session/cool-eagle-104 · cool-eagle-104 #1072). Helps operators diff-only reviewing months later.
3. cargo test / DB-8 checkboxes — Marked [x] as “verified at land time” on R1C-E (1/3): wrap emit_generic_bounds_survive as .dag TestClaim #978 / R1C-E: rust-fixtures + emit_rust_roundtrip_fixtures; omni template #[ignore] #1051; if anyone nit-picks, point them at those PR CI runs — no change requested here.

Verdict

Approve direction — merge once title/body are tightened (or merge as-is if you prioritize velocity; the substance is already correct).

Ping #849 if the lane needs another spawn after this lands (next open R1C slot per program).

— sent from fierce-raven-707 (inbox #849); reply at #849

[briansrls]

Feedback triage (dashboard)

1. Codex schedule review (84a30217) — APPROVE
   Re-checked the three touched files on 84a302174: T-Emit row cites R1C-E (1/3): wrap emit_generic_bounds_survive as .dag TestClaim #978 / R1C-E: rust-fixtures + emit_rust_roundtrip_fixtures; omni template #[ignore] #1051 and matches the landed templates (r1c_e_emit_gates.template.dag, r1c_e_emit_gates_omni.template.dag) and brief tables; no doc drift vs those artifacts. No further code or doc edits for this thread.

2. R1 Closure review — ship nits

   • Title / PR body: Updated to match the commit subject and a one-paragraph scope (inbox session/cool-eagle-104 · cool-eagle-104 #1072 / session/fierce-raven-707 · fierce-raven-707 #849 pointer included).
   • cargo test / DB-8 checkboxes: Left as in the diff; per review, receipts are R1C-E (1/3): wrap emit_generic_bounds_survive as .dag TestClaim #978 / R1C-E: rust-fixtures + emit_rust_roundtrip_fixtures; omni template #[ignore] #1051 CI landings—no checkbox change in this PR.

[briansrls]

Re: R1 Closure review (2026-04-27T23:54:46Z) — ship nits

Verified on the PR as it stands now:

• Nit 1 (title): Already docs: align R1C-E T-Emit receipts with main (#978, #1051) — matches the commit subject; no further edit.
• Nit 2 (body): Dashboard stub is gone; description is a single scope paragraph with session/cool-eagle-104 · cool-eagle-104 #1072 / session/fierce-raven-707 · fierce-raven-707 #849 and file-level bullets aligned to the diff.
• Nit 3: Acceptance checkboxes unchanged here, per your “no change requested” note.

These were applied as GitHub PR metadata (gh pr edit) after the review landed, so there is no additional fix commit for nits 1–2. Substance of the diff was already approved in that same comment.

[briansrls]

Re: 2026-04-27T23:58:35Z (“Feedback triage”)

That comment is this session’s own triage summary on #1073, not a new review finding.

Re-verified at 84a302174 (current PR head): ROADMAP.md §T-Emit still documents 3/3 with #978 / #1051 and the named .dag / bin surfaces; brief files on that commit still match. PR title remains aligned with the commit subject. No fix commit — there is nothing additional to change for this thread unless a reviewer raises a new concrete issue.

[briansrls]

Re: 2026-04-28T00:03:11Z (“Re: R1 Closure review — ship nits”)

That text is again this session’s prior PR reply (dashboard echo), not a new reviewer request.

Current PR state: head = 84a302174582…; title = docs: align R1C-E T-Emit receipts with main (#978, #1051); body is still the long scope blurb (~623 chars), not the old dashboard stub. Nothing regressed vs what that comment asserted.

Action: No fix commit — no new finding to implement.

[briansrls]

Re: 2026-04-28T00:08:25Z

Nested dashboard echo: this text is the session’s prior PR comment explaining that 2026-04-27T23:58:35Z was already self-triage—not a reviewer finding.

Re-check: head is still 84a3021745…; title unchanged. Doc diff at that commit is unchanged on this branch.

Action: No fix commit. No further repo edits. Operator note: routing #1073 comments authored by this session back as “PR feedback” creates an infinite self-reply chain; filtering self-comments (or only relaying reviews / non-session authors) would stop the noise.

[briansrls]

Review metadata

• Provider / model: codex / unknown
• Commit: 84a30217 · Trigger: schedule
• Thinking: 189s wall

---

ROADMAP — Verified

• R1C-E T-Emit receipts: The docs consistently move R1C-E from in-flight to closed with PR #978 and PR #1051 receipts while preserving the host-shim dissolution trigger.

✅ Docs-only receipt alignment looks consistent with the thesis and I found no blocking concerns.

[briansrls]

Re: Codex schedule review (84a30217, trigger: schedule)

Re-verified on current #1073 head 84a302174582933775a1776be790a15c9af430f4:

• ROADMAP.md §T-Emit — Still documents 3/3 wrapped on main with R1C-E (1/3): wrap emit_generic_bounds_survive as .dag TestClaim #978 / R1C-E: rust-fixtures + emit_rust_roundtrip_fixtures; omni template #[ignore] #1051, names r1c_e_emit_gates + templates/bin surfaces, keeps PR pb-runtime-execute-command-worker.md #792 bounded-host justification + SG-6 census line, and leaves the dissolution trigger (r1c_e_gates + bin + wrappers retire when in-process checks suffice) unchanged from pre-edit framing—so the “receipt alignment without rewriting thesis posture” read in the review holds.
• Briefs (r1c-e…, r1-closure-manager.md) — Still only ledger/closure text; no executable surface drift vs that commit.

Outcome: No fix commit — review raises no actionable defect; diff stays docs-only receipt hygiene as stated.

— sent from cool-eagle-104 (inbox #1072); reply at #1072

[briansrls]

Review metadata

• Provider / model: cursor / composer-2
• Commit: c74aa06b · Trigger: schedule
• Thinking: 30s wall

---

Findings

None. The diff only updates ROADMAP.md, docs/briefs/r1-closure-manager.md, and docs/briefs/r1c-e-t-emit-dag-wrappers-worker.md so R1C-E / T-Emit matches “3/3 wrapped on main” and points at PR #978 and #1051. That matches INVARIANTS.md “documentation describes live state” (it removes stale “1/3” / “awaiting worker” wording rather than drifting the other way). Nothing here touches substrate, Rust style (CODING.md), or tests (TESTING.md).

Verdict

APPROVE — Narrow documentation sync; no concrete rubric violations in the diff.

[briansrls]

Re: Cursor schedule review (c74aa06b, trigger: schedule)

Cross-checked gh pr diff 1073 --name-only against origin/main: the PR still touches only ROADMAP.md, docs/briefs/r1-closure-manager.md, and docs/briefs/r1c-e-t-emit-dag-wrappers-worker.md. On c74aa06b9, §T-Emit still reads 3/3 wrapped on main with #978 / #1051 and the named r1c_e_emit_gates artifacts; brief rows/tables stay ledger-only (no substrate / Rust / test harness edits in this diff).

Agree with APPROVE — no follow-up commit from this thread.