Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Add alternative titles metadata field for Series #878

Closed
4 tasks done
ArnaudPiroelle opened this issue Apr 30, 2022 · 11 comments
Closed
4 tasks done

Add alternative titles metadata field for Series #878

ArnaudPiroelle opened this issue Apr 30, 2022 · 11 comments
Labels
enhancement New feature or request released

Comments

@ArnaudPiroelle
Copy link

Describe your suggested feature

Many manga have one or more alternative titles depending on the publishing country, editor or edition name.

Example:

EN: Attack on Titan
FR: L'Attaque des Titans
JP: Shingeki no Kyojin / 進撃の巨人

To properly manage my collection, I would like to have the ability to edit the metadata and so retrieve a manga from any of its titles in the search engine.

Other details

No response

Acknowledgements

  • I have searched the existing issues and this is a new ticket, NOT a duplicate or related to another open issue.
  • I have written a short but informative title.
  • I have updated the app to the latest version.
  • I will fill out all of the requested information in this form.
@ArnaudPiroelle ArnaudPiroelle added the enhancement New feature or request label Apr 30, 2022
@gotson
Copy link
Owner

gotson commented Apr 30, 2022

That's not alternative titles, but titles in different languages.

There shouldn't be any reason to have the English title for a Japanese Manga published in French for instance.

@gotson
Copy link
Owner

gotson commented Apr 30, 2022

To properly manage my collection, I would like to have the ability to edit the metadata and so retrieve a manga from any of its titles in the search engine

That's not very clear. You want to be able to search by all those titles, is that it?

@gotson gotson added consider Not sure yet if this makes sense or not and removed enhancement New feature or request labels Apr 30, 2022
@ArnaudPiroelle
Copy link
Author

Yes.

For example, if I have set a manga with the name Attack on Titan with an alternative name Shingeki no Kyojin, I should be able to search both of these names in the search field an retrieve the manga Attack on Titan.

If possible these alternative names should be available from the /api/v1/series and /api/v1/series/{seriesId} enpoints.

@ArnaudPiroelle
Copy link
Author

And there is a reason to ask this feature, I want to be able to retrieve from my collection all missing informations on online manga databases like myanimelist, kitsu or nautiljon.

To search a manga or a book on these databases, I need to have all alternative titles.

@gotson
Copy link
Owner

gotson commented May 1, 2022

And there is a reason to ask this feature, I want to be able to retrieve from my collection all missing informations on online manga databases like myanimelist, kitsu or nautiljon.

To search a manga or a book on these databases, I need to have all alternative titles.

Can you expand on that?

@ArnaudPiroelle
Copy link
Author

Depending on how you manage your collection, you should choose the title you set for a series.

Personnally, I like to use the most appropriate name.
In my collection, I use original title for a manga that is not already translated officially and the translated name when is published under license in my country.
But these two titles represent the same series.

When you want to search for metadatas or purchase link for a manga, you should search with different names to find the best matches.
For example:
When I use MyAnimeList, I search only with english or original title.
When I use Nautiljon, I search only with french title.

On MyAnimeList, when I search "L'attaque des titans", they return 4 pages of result, and no one have the translated title.
I have to search in results the manga with name "Shingeki no Kyojin".
On Nautiljon, I have the same issue when I search with original name, they returns only the translated titles.

So you have to choose which title to use according to the database you are using for your search.

@gotson
Copy link
Owner

gotson commented May 1, 2022

Not sure to understand, do you them have some scripts that would perform that search?

If yes, searching with each of the titles will give you even more results..

@ArnaudPiroelle
Copy link
Author

ArnaudPiroelle commented May 1, 2022

Currently, I does'nt have scripts but I want to make an application to synchronize metadatas.
Even without scripts or applications, I can't remember all translated titles for each mangas when I search a manga in online databases.

For each mangas, I will search with the title that I set in komga, but if no result match the name, i want to compare with alternatives names to find the best match.

@gotson gotson changed the title Add alternative titles metadata field Add alternative titles metadata field for Series May 2, 2022
@gotson gotson added enhancement New feature or request and removed consider Not sure yet if this makes sense or not labels May 2, 2022
@ispaure
Copy link

ispaure commented Dec 29, 2022

For those who might not know, if you edit the metadata in ComicRack (ComicInfo.XML file within .CBZ archives), you can set an alternate series title and it will show in the "Read Lists" tab of Komga. Searching then works by either the main title or alternative title.

For instance, within ComicInfo.XML:

<Series>A Certain Scientific Railgun</Series>
<AlternateSeries>To Aru Kagaku no Railgun</AlternateSeries>

This limits you to two titles but it should already be enough. You can use English Title as default and Japanese Title as alternate for example (this is what I do).

@gotson
Copy link
Owner

gotson commented Jan 13, 2023

For those who might not know, if you edit the metadata in ComicRack (ComicInfo.XML file within .CBZ archives), you can set an alternate series title and it will show in the "Read Lists" tab of Komga. Searching then works by either the main title or alternative title.

For instance, within ComicInfo.XML:

<Series>A Certain Scientific Railgun</Series>
<AlternateSeries>To Aru Kagaku no Railgun</AlternateSeries>

This limits you to two titles but it should already be enough. You can use English Title as default and Japanese Title as alternate for example (this is what I do).

The purpose of that field is not to store an alternative title of the series, but to reflect the fact that the book is part of 2 different series, usually for cross-overs.

@gotson gotson closed this as completed in 8e0655f Jan 16, 2023
github-actions bot pushed a commit that referenced this issue Jan 17, 2023
# [0.159.0](v0.158.0...v0.159.0) (2023-01-17)

### Bug Fixes

* **api:** include Z in datetime formats ([bb7b7fd](bb7b7fd))
* **api:** some dates were not returned as UTC ([cdfb8e3](cdfb8e3))
* translated using Weblate ([6ad0188](6ad0188))

### Features

* add links field in series metadata ([f9f02a3](f9f02a3)), closes [#938](#938)
* series metadata supports alternate titles ([8e0655f](8e0655f)), closes [#878](#878)
* **webui:** display datetime when hovering date on item card ([4d97172](4d97172))
* **webui:** display number of pages left on book details view ([77424b1](77424b1)), closes [#1012](#1012)
* **webui:** display read date on book details view ([c30c755](c30c755)), closes [#757](#757)
* **webui:** increment/decrement numberSort in bulk ([e7fbe57](e7fbe57)), closes [#628](#628)
@gotson
Copy link
Owner

gotson commented Jan 17, 2023

🎉 This issue has been resolved in version 0.159.0 🎉

The release is available on:

@github-actions github-actions bot locked as resolved and limited conversation to collaborators Feb 17, 2023
Sign up for free to subscribe to this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in.
Labels
enhancement New feature or request released
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging a pull request may close this issue.

3 participants