Skip to content
Merged
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from all commits
Commits
Show all changes
150 commits
Select commit Hold shift + click to select a range
99f45d1
Adding a multiple path test to confirm that expected paths are hit
wjuan-AFK Jul 15, 2020
075a4cf
fixing asan problems
wjuan-AFK Jul 17, 2020
ecbf407
Fix Format
wjuan-AFK Jul 17, 2020
8fb11b6
Removeing unused comments
wjuan-AFK Jul 17, 2020
032dbba
Removing unnecessary invoke calls for cleanliness
wjuan-AFK Jul 17, 2020
953e953
Merge branch 'master' into RequestSourceUnitTestBenchmarkMultiplePath
wjuan-AFK Jul 17, 2020
6185edb
Refactoring test to take in request generator parameter instead of using
wjuan-AFK Jul 20, 2020
cded6ad
Changing to pass by reference.
wjuan-AFK Jul 20, 2020
fbfe523
Merge branch 'master' into RequestSourceUnitTestBenchmarkMultiplePath
wjuan-AFK Jul 20, 2020
0d70179
Merge branch 'master' into RequestSourceUnitTestBenchmarkMultiplePath
wjuan-AFK Jul 21, 2020
cdb7efe
Refactoring per comments in PR. Moving helpers, renaming functions.
wjuan-AFK Jul 21, 2020
f15bb47
Adding comments and renaming testbasicfunctionality for clarity
wjuan-AFK Jul 21, 2020
59359a2
Consistent unit test naming convention using should. Clarifying comments
wjuan-AFK Jul 21, 2020
f63df91
Fix format
wjuan-AFK Jul 21, 2020
406bd6b
Adding a clarifying comment for helper function.
wjuan-AFK Jul 22, 2020
f0b697b
Fixing typo and other nits
wjuan-AFK Jul 23, 2020
8425e48
Renaming testBenchmarkClient for clarity
wjuan-AFK Jul 23, 2020
fb4f372
Replacing Flat hash map with flat hash set for simplicity.
wjuan-AFK Jul 24, 2020
c6eae6c
Comment clarification.
wjuan-AFK Jul 24, 2020
96ae38b
Small refactor for factory method for more dependency injection.
wjuan-AFK Jul 27, 2020
b17240f
Fix format.
wjuan-AFK Jul 27, 2020
5c5a146
Refactor to inject the requestsourceconstructor.
wjuan-AFK Jul 27, 2020
29591ff
Moving helper functions.
wjuan-AFK Jul 27, 2020
7d928a9
Merge branch 'RequestSourceUnitTestBenchmarkMultiplePath' into Adding…
wjuan-AFK Jul 27, 2020
ff82d95
Fix format.
wjuan-AFK Jul 27, 2020
98381a4
Adding test using the new mock requestsourceconstructor to get remote
wjuan-AFK Jul 28, 2020
83ac556
Fix format.
wjuan-AFK Jul 28, 2020
38c5084
Adding missing request source constructor files.
wjuan-AFK Jul 28, 2020
fa4e285
Changing helper functions to anonymous namespace.
wjuan-AFK Jul 28, 2020
8551c76
Changing to use a nullable pointer instead of reference for clarity.
wjuan-AFK Jul 28, 2020
437de5e
Formatting fixes per PR.
wjuan-AFK Jul 28, 2020
6cef87e
Fix format.
wjuan-AFK Jul 28, 2020
c84ba4d
Merge branch 'master' into RequestSourceUnitTestBenchmarkMultiplePath
wjuan-AFK Jul 28, 2020
77d33f9
Fix format after merge.
wjuan-AFK Jul 29, 2020
73aa686
Testing a theory.
wjuan-AFK Jul 29, 2020
ef77d65
Fix format.
wjuan-AFK Jul 29, 2020
b9182a0
Merge branch 'RequestSourceUnitTestBenchmarkMultiplePath' into Adding…
wjuan-AFK Jul 29, 2020
e38dd80
Merge branch 'master' into RequestSourceUnitTestBenchmarkMultiplePath
wjuan-AFK Jul 29, 2020
21734e4
Merge branch 'RequestSourceUnitTestBenchmarkMultiplePath' into Adding…
wjuan-AFK Jul 29, 2020
7cda9d2
Merge branch 'master' into AddingTestForRequestSourceFactory
wjuan-AFK Aug 17, 2020
f827aca
Adding initial protos and stubs.
wjuan-AFK Aug 19, 2020
d194736
Adding impl for Dummy request source plugin.
wjuan-AFK Aug 19, 2020
7820cf9
Adding test for request source factory creation.
wjuan-AFK Aug 19, 2020
bee7805
Adding some more protos.
wjuan-AFK Aug 19, 2020
3db68ce
Merge branch 'master' into AddingTestForRequestSourceFactory
wjuan-AFK Aug 19, 2020
c0ec4dd
Merge branch 'AddingTestForRequestSourceFactory' into AddingConfigFac…
wjuan-AFK Aug 19, 2020
a1dd3f2
Fixing mockrequestsourcefactory impacted by the refactor.
wjuan-AFK Aug 20, 2020
0b25261
Adding more factories to the impl.h
wjuan-AFK Aug 20, 2020
c3fa23c
Fixing clang tidy.
wjuan-AFK Aug 20, 2020
547977e
Updating the impl.cc with a stub for the new factories.
wjuan-AFK Aug 20, 2020
c300203
Adding test for file based request source plugin
wjuan-AFK Aug 26, 2020
8f4d4d9
Adding test yaml file.
wjuan-AFK Aug 26, 2020
5ae2d51
Merge branch 'AddingTestForRequestSourceFactory' into AddingConfigFac…
wjuan-AFK Aug 26, 2020
fe74b6d
First try getting requests working.
wjuan-AFK Aug 27, 2020
6d87aea
Switching to using multiple requestOptions instead of one.
wjuan-AFK Sep 1, 2020
ca7a0c2
Removing unused comments.
wjuan-AFK Sep 2, 2020
967e3f8
Adding api dependency injection.
wjuan-AFK Sep 2, 2020
14b7d79
Getting the multiple paths parsing into the test.
wjuan-AFK Sep 3, 2020
c4985bb
Comment clean up and using loadfromfile instead of reading the file and
wjuan-AFK Sep 3, 2020
922639a
Switching to using iterators in a vector instead of a smart pointer.
wjuan-AFK Sep 9, 2020
81dfece
Removing unused comments.
wjuan-AFK Sep 9, 2020
bf08661
Small cleanup.
wjuan-AFK Sep 10, 2020
34900c5
Merge branch 'master' into AddingTestForRequestSourceFactory
wjuan-AFK Sep 10, 2020
768fa81
Merge branch 'AddingTestForRequestSourceFactory' into AddingConfigFac…
wjuan-AFK Sep 10, 2020
e93bb58
Reverting changes to RequestSourceConstructor.
wjuan-AFK Sep 10, 2020
f47cbd4
Removing RPCRequestSourcePlugin
wjuan-AFK Sep 10, 2020
7c5c6b2
Fix format.
wjuan-AFK Sep 10, 2020
1b02cec
Fix format.
wjuan-AFK Sep 10, 2020
4d75602
Fixing clang problems.
wjuan-AFK Sep 11, 2020
c74f535
Fixing clang.
wjuan-AFK Sep 11, 2020
9949fb8
Fix format.
wjuan-AFK Sep 11, 2020
fcf10d3
Fixing clang tidy.
wjuan-AFK Sep 11, 2020
fd9744d
Fix Format
wjuan-AFK Sep 11, 2020
68c1037
Rename requestOptionses to requestOptionsList.
wjuan-AFK Sep 14, 2020
883ee30
Renaming proto.
wjuan-AFK Sep 15, 2020
8c34b25
Updating to take a number of requests.
wjuan-AFK Sep 16, 2020
6ce7e74
Clean up tests.
wjuan-AFK Sep 16, 2020
92927e5
Changing visibility of RequestSourcePlugin's inheritance.
wjuan-AFK Sep 16, 2020
a62f2d5
Switching to using lock_guard.
wjuan-AFK Sep 16, 2020
16f89c6
Clean up.
wjuan-AFK Sep 16, 2020
f4257e3
Fix Format.
wjuan-AFK Sep 16, 2020
d075588
Addressing comments on PR. Cleaning up formatting.
wjuan-AFK Sep 17, 2020
eb10a3b
Getting rid of RequestSourcePluginPtr, and adding comments.
wjuan-AFK Sep 17, 2020
cdbd6bf
Removing unnecessary RequestSourcePlugin interface for improved testa…
wjuan-AFK Sep 17, 2020
17acc5f
Fix format
wjuan-AFK Sep 17, 2020
55a0e62
Cleanup unintentional whitespace.
wjuan-AFK Sep 18, 2020
fa23aad
Swapping to exception instead of Release_assert.
wjuan-AFK Sep 18, 2020
b8e2447
Renaming the request_source_plugin to request_source_plugin_config_fa…
wjuan-AFK Sep 18, 2020
248f439
Using a context struct for extensability.
wjuan-AFK Sep 22, 2020
91703b5
Spacing and comments.
wjuan-AFK Sep 22, 2020
bbc0c2a
Fix format.
wjuan-AFK Sep 22, 2020
517c83d
Adding test for multiple request sources thread lock.
wjuan-AFK Sep 22, 2020
c1d0428
Additional comment
wjuan-AFK Sep 22, 2020
bc86c09
Getting rid of context object because the Register Factory mechanism …
wjuan-AFK Sep 22, 2020
33e3564
Adding option to circumvent file reading.
wjuan-AFK Sep 23, 2020
338a874
Merge branch 'master' into AddingConfigFactory
wjuan-AFK Sep 23, 2020
402ada2
Fix format.
wjuan-AFK Sep 23, 2020
017481f
Getting rid of default constructors.
wjuan-AFK Sep 23, 2020
3ed43fc
Renames for clarity.
wjuan-AFK Sep 23, 2020
247b71b
Fix format.
wjuan-AFK Sep 23, 2020
171fb2e
Splitting factory off into a separate pr.
wjuan-AFK Sep 24, 2020
5df83ed
Proto cleanup/rename
wjuan-AFK Sep 24, 2020
0af3ffd
Comment cleanup.
wjuan-AFK Sep 24, 2020
ff90e59
Proto comments and dummy -> stub clean up.
wjuan-AFK Sep 24, 2020
e57c05f
Cleaning up comments
wjuan-AFK Sep 28, 2020
55244b0
Updating class comments.
wjuan-AFK Sep 28, 2020
c710d37
Refactor to move RequestSourcePlugins to a top level RequestSource fo…
wjuan-AFK Sep 28, 2020
fbb2fdc
Refactor plugins into separate files.
wjuan-AFK Sep 28, 2020
ae0f4a8
Fix format.
wjuan-AFK Sep 28, 2020
e092de0
Merge branch 'master' into AddingConfigFactory
wjuan-AFK Sep 28, 2020
19b7aa0
Adding gmock and gtest to check_format so it stops complaining at me.
wjuan-AFK Sep 28, 2020
dae3098
Updating to prefix increment, and removing auto.
wjuan-AFK Sep 29, 2020
a4b6fb1
Removing gmock and gtest from script to avoid conflict. Add Request_s…
wjuan-AFK Sep 29, 2020
55f685e
Fixing clang-tidy
wjuan-AFK Sep 30, 2020
59c5b94
Using the test value in the stub for better testing.
wjuan-AFK Sep 30, 2020
2ea0c5e
Getting rid of auto. And updating stubplugintest.
wjuan-AFK Sep 30, 2020
d40a073
Further renaming.
wjuan-AFK Sep 30, 2020
7146079
Refactor to move plugins into their own libraries and separate files.
wjuan-AFK Sep 30, 2020
7ab1132
Moving request_source_plugin_config_factory into its own folder.
wjuan-AFK Sep 30, 2020
72c23d0
Refactor to make it testonly.
wjuan-AFK Sep 30, 2020
2b1170c
Using references instead of making a copy of the option list.
wjuan-AFK Oct 1, 2020
9dc3c4b
Passing in a reference to api instead of apiptr.
wjuan-AFK Oct 1, 2020
b555a71
Renaming request_max to total_requests
wjuan-AFK Oct 1, 2020
3924eee
Updating comments and removing explicit.
wjuan-AFK Oct 1, 2020
75eca07
Fix format.
wjuan-AFK Oct 1, 2020
9c93ff9
Merge branch 'master' into AddingConfigFactory
wjuan-AFK Oct 1, 2020
e2af886
Clean up.
wjuan-AFK Oct 1, 2020
edae9be
Rename FilebasedConfigFactory to OptionListFromFileFactory
wjuan-AFK Oct 1, 2020
949d731
Improving Comments.
wjuan-AFK Oct 2, 2020
59d490f
Fix format.
wjuan-AFK Oct 2, 2020
078329a
More comment cleanup.
wjuan-AFK Oct 2, 2020
530cc9c
Adding proto request source factory.
wjuan-AFK Oct 7, 2020
22cc3f8
Merge branch 'master' into AddingProtoOnlyFactory
wjuan-AFK Oct 7, 2020
32489d0
Fix format.
wjuan-AFK Oct 7, 2020
324bb23
Fixing Clang tidy.
wjuan-AFK Oct 7, 2020
5d6bb26
Clarifying proto comments.
wjuan-AFK Oct 8, 2020
32ae13d
Rename, using optional, and moving functions in test.
wjuan-AFK Oct 8, 2020
12708ac
Need to stop forggetting to add blank lines or update the fix format …
wjuan-AFK Oct 8, 2020
eff2f4e
Replacing request with request1
wjuan-AFK Oct 8, 2020
b890df4
Renaming tests for clarity
wjuan-AFK Oct 8, 2020
a907913
Adding assertions for safety.
wjuan-AFK Oct 8, 2020
49a47a4
Clarifying comments on parameters
wjuan-AFK Oct 8, 2020
b711028
Fix format.
wjuan-AFK Oct 8, 2020
8a2d792
Renames based on feedback, and swapping to using uint32 instead of ui…
wjuan-AFK Oct 9, 2020
22b93aa
Fix format.
wjuan-AFK Oct 9, 2020
7b9c175
Cleaning up comments per feedback.
wjuan-AFK Oct 21, 2020
bab49fc
Clarifying comments.
wjuan-AFK Oct 21, 2020
fc7eda6
Removing implementation detail from comment.
wjuan-AFK Oct 22, 2020
49e6eec
Fix Format.
wjuan-AFK Oct 22, 2020
43de3d8
Merge branch 'master' into AddingProtoOnlyFactory
wjuan-AFK Oct 22, 2020
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
33 changes: 25 additions & 8 deletions api/request_source/request_source_plugin.proto
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -7,24 +7,41 @@ import "google/protobuf/wrappers.proto";
import "validate/validate.proto";
import "api/client/options.proto";

// Configuration for FileBasedPluginRequestSource (plugin name:
// "nighthawk.file-based-request-source-plugin")
// Configuration for OptionsListFromFileRequestSourceFactory (plugin name:
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

I think this should be FileBasedPluginRequestSource

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

I think that this naming better expresses that they're both making an optionsListRequestSource.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

I mean isn't this a typo? This appears to be the comment above FileBasedPluginConfig

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

OHHH I didn't see File in the middle of the name, never mind!

// "nighthawk.file-options-list-request-source-plugin")
// The factory will load the RequestOptionsList from the file, and then passes it to the
// requestSource it generates. The resulting request source will loop over the RequestOptionsList it
// is passed.
message FileBasedPluginConfig {
message FileBasedOptionsListRequestSourceConfig {
// The file_path is the path to a file that contains a RequestOptionList in json or yaml format.
// This field is required.
string file_path = 1;
// The pluginfactory makes requestSources that will generate requests from the RequestOptionList
// up to num_requests number of times. If num_requests exceeds the number of RequestOptions in the
// RequestOptionList located in the file at file_path, it will loop. num_requests = 0 means no
// limit on the number of requests to be produced.
google.protobuf.UInt32Value num_requests = 2 [(validate.rules).uint32 = {gte: 0, lte: 1000000}];
// The pluginfactory will load the file located in file_path as long as it is below max_file_size,
// if it's too large it will throw an error.
// RequestOptionList located in the file at file_path, it will loop. num_requests = 0 means it
// will loop indefinitely, though it will still terminate by normal mechanisms.
uint32 num_requests = 2;
// The pluginfactory will load the file located in file_path as long as it is below max_file_size
// in bytes, if it's too large it will throw an error. This field is optional with a default of
// 1000000.
google.protobuf.UInt32Value max_file_size = 3 [(validate.rules).uint32 = {lte: 1000000}];
}

// Configuration for OptionsListFromProtoRequestSourceFactory (plugin name:
// "nighthawk.in-line-options-list-request-source-plugin")
// The resulting request source will loop over the RequestOptionsList it
// is passed.
message InLineOptionsListRequestSourceConfig {
// The options_list will be used to generate Requests in the RequestSource. This field is
// required.
nighthawk.client.RequestOptionsList options_list = 1;
// The pluginfactory makes requestSources that will generate requests from the RequestOptionList
// up to num_requests number of times. If num_requests exceeds the number of RequestOptions in the
// options_list, it will loop. num_requests = 0 means it will loop indefinitely, though it will
// still terminate by normal mechanisms.
uint32 num_requests = 2;
}

// Configuration for StubPluginRequestSource (plugin name: "nighthawk.stub-request-source-plugin")
// The plugin does nothing. This is for testing and comparison of the Request Source Plugin Factory
// mechanism using a minimal version of plugin that does not require a more complicated proto or
Expand Down
65 changes: 49 additions & 16 deletions source/request_source/request_options_list_plugin_impl.cc
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -10,47 +10,79 @@
#include "common/request_source_impl.h"

namespace Nighthawk {
std::string OptionsListFromFileRequestSourceFactory::name() const {
std::string FileBasedOptionsListRequestSourceFactory::name() const {
return "nighthawk.file-based-request-source-plugin";
}

Envoy::ProtobufTypes::MessagePtr OptionsListFromFileRequestSourceFactory::createEmptyConfigProto() {
return std::make_unique<nighthawk::request_source::FileBasedPluginConfig>();
Envoy::ProtobufTypes::MessagePtr
FileBasedOptionsListRequestSourceFactory::createEmptyConfigProto() {
return std::make_unique<nighthawk::request_source::FileBasedOptionsListRequestSourceConfig>();
}

RequestSourcePtr OptionsListFromFileRequestSourceFactory::createRequestSourcePlugin(
RequestSourcePtr FileBasedOptionsListRequestSourceFactory::createRequestSourcePlugin(
const Envoy::Protobuf::Message& message, Envoy::Api::Api& api,
Envoy::Http::RequestHeaderMapPtr header) {
const auto& any = dynamic_cast<const Envoy::ProtobufWkt::Any&>(message);
nighthawk::request_source::FileBasedPluginConfig config;
nighthawk::request_source::FileBasedOptionsListRequestSourceConfig config;
Envoy::MessageUtil util;

uint32_t max_file_size = config.has_max_file_size() ? config.max_file_size().value() : 1000000;
util.unpackTo(any, config);
if (api.fileSystem().fileSize(config.file_path()) > config.max_file_size().value()) {
if (api.fileSystem().fileSize(config.file_path()) > max_file_size) {
throw NighthawkException("file size must be less than max_file_size");
}

// Locking to avoid issues with multiple threads reading the same file.
{
Envoy::Thread::LockGuard lock_guard(file_lock_);
// Reading the file only the first time.
if (options_list_.options_size() == 0) {
util.loadFromFile(config.file_path(), options_list_,
if (!options_list_.has_value()) {
nighthawk::client::RequestOptionsList loaded_list;
util.loadFromFile(config.file_path(), loaded_list,
Envoy::ProtobufMessage::getStrictValidationVisitor(), api, true);
options_list_ = loaded_list;
}
}
return std::make_unique<OptionsListRequestSource>(config.num_requests(), std::move(header),
options_list_.value());
}

REGISTER_FACTORY(FileBasedOptionsListRequestSourceFactory, RequestSourcePluginConfigFactory);

std::string InLineOptionsListRequestSourceFactory::name() const {
return "nighthawk.in-line-options-list-request-source-plugin";
}

Envoy::ProtobufTypes::MessagePtr InLineOptionsListRequestSourceFactory::createEmptyConfigProto() {
return std::make_unique<nighthawk::request_source::InLineOptionsListRequestSourceConfig>();
}

RequestSourcePtr InLineOptionsListRequestSourceFactory::createRequestSourcePlugin(
const Envoy::Protobuf::Message& message, Envoy::Api::Api&,
Envoy::Http::RequestHeaderMapPtr header) {
const auto& any = dynamic_cast<const Envoy::ProtobufWkt::Any&>(message);
nighthawk::request_source::InLineOptionsListRequestSourceConfig config;
Envoy::MessageUtil::unpackTo(any, config);
// Locking to avoid issues with multiple threads calling this at the same time and trying to set
// the options_list_
{
Envoy::Thread::LockGuard lock_guard(options_list_lock_);
// Only loading the config into memory the first time.
if (!options_list_.has_value()) {
options_list_ = config.options_list();
}
}
return std::make_unique<RequestOptionsListRequestSource>(config.num_requests().value(),
std::move(header), options_list_);
return std::make_unique<OptionsListRequestSource>(config.num_requests(), std::move(header),
options_list_.value());
}

REGISTER_FACTORY(OptionsListFromFileRequestSourceFactory, RequestSourcePluginConfigFactory);
REGISTER_FACTORY(InLineOptionsListRequestSourceFactory, RequestSourcePluginConfigFactory);

RequestOptionsListRequestSource::RequestOptionsListRequestSource(
OptionsListRequestSource::OptionsListRequestSource(
const uint32_t total_requests, Envoy::Http::RequestHeaderMapPtr header,
const nighthawk::client::RequestOptionsList& options_list)
: header_(std::move(header)), options_list_(options_list), total_requests_(total_requests) {}

RequestGenerator RequestOptionsListRequestSource::get() {
RequestGenerator OptionsListRequestSource::get() {
request_count_.push_back(0);
uint32_t& lambda_counter = request_count_.back();
RequestGenerator request_generator = [this, lambda_counter]() mutable -> RequestPtr {
Expand All @@ -72,7 +104,8 @@ RequestGenerator RequestOptionsListRequestSource::get() {
header->setMethod(envoy::config::core::v3::RequestMethod_Name(request_option.request_method()));
const uint32_t content_length = request_option.request_body_size().value();
if (content_length > 0) {
header->setContentLength(content_length);
header->setContentLength(
content_length); // Content length is used later in stream_decoder to populate the body
}
for (const envoy::config::core::v3::HeaderValueOption& option_header :
request_option.request_headers()) {
Expand All @@ -84,6 +117,6 @@ RequestGenerator RequestOptionsListRequestSource::get() {
return request_generator;
}

void RequestOptionsListRequestSource::initOnThread() {}
void OptionsListRequestSource::initOnThread() {}

} // namespace Nighthawk
80 changes: 57 additions & 23 deletions source/request_source/request_options_list_plugin_impl.h
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -1,4 +1,4 @@
// Implementations of RequestSourceConfigFactories that make a RequestOptionsListRequestSource.
// Implementations of RequestSourceConfigFactories that make a OptionsListRequestSource.
#pragma once

#include "envoy/registry/registry.h"
Expand All @@ -25,14 +25,13 @@ namespace Nighthawk {
// RequestGenerator produced by get() will use options from the options_list to overwrite values in
// the default header, and create new requests. if total_requests is greater than the length of
// options_list, it will loop. This is not thread safe.
class RequestOptionsListRequestSource : public RequestSource {
class OptionsListRequestSource : public RequestSource {
public:
RequestOptionsListRequestSource(const uint32_t total_requests,
Envoy::Http::RequestHeaderMapPtr header,
const nighthawk::client::RequestOptionsList& options_list);
OptionsListRequestSource(const uint32_t total_requests, Envoy::Http::RequestHeaderMapPtr header,
const nighthawk::client::RequestOptionsList& options_list);

// This get function is not thread safe, because multiple threads calling get simultaneously will
// result in a collision as it attempts to update its request_count_.
// result in a collision.
RequestGenerator get() override;

// default implementation
Expand All @@ -45,40 +44,75 @@ class RequestOptionsListRequestSource : public RequestSource {
const uint32_t total_requests_;
};

// Factory that creates a RequestOptionsListRequestSource from a FileBasedPluginConfig proto.
// Registered as an Envoy plugin.
// Implementation of RequestSourceConfigFactory which produces a RequestSource that keeps an
// RequestOptionsList in memory, and loads it with the RequestOptions taken from a file. All plugins
// configuration are specified in the request_source_plugin.proto. This class is not thread-safe,
// because it loads its RequestOptionlist in memory from a file when first called.
// Usage: assume you are passed an appropriate Any type object called config, an Api object called
// api, and a default header called header. auto& config_factory =
// Factory that creates a OptionsListRequestSource from a FileBasedOptionsListRequestSourceConfig
// proto. Registered as an Envoy plugin. Implementation of RequestSourceConfigFactory which produces
// a RequestSource that keeps an RequestOptionsList in memory, and loads it with the RequestOptions
// taken from a file. All plugins configuration are specified in the request_source_plugin.proto.
// This class is thread-safe,
// Usage: assume you are passed an appropriate Any type object called config, an Api
// object called api, and a default header called header. auto& config_factory =
// Envoy::Config::Utility::getAndCheckFactoryByName<RequestSourcePluginConfigFactory>(
// "nighthawk.file-based-request-source-plugin");
// RequestSourcePtr plugin =
// config_factory.createRequestSourcePlugin(config, std::move(api), std::move(header));
class OptionsListFromFileRequestSourceFactory : public virtual RequestSourcePluginConfigFactory {
class FileBasedOptionsListRequestSourceFactory : public virtual RequestSourcePluginConfigFactory {
public:
std::string name() const override;

Envoy::ProtobufTypes::MessagePtr createEmptyConfigProto() override;

// This implementation is not thread safe. Only the first call to createRequestSourcePlugin will
// load the file from memory and subsequent calls just make a copy of the options_list that was
// already loaded. The OptionsListFromFileRequestSourceFactory will not work with multiple
// different files for this reason.
// This method will also error if the file can not be loaded correctly, e.g. the file is too large
// or could not be found.
// This implementation is thread safe. There is currently a behaviour such that only the first
// call to createRequestSourcePlugin will load the options list into memory and subsequent calls
// just make a copy of the options_list that was already loaded. The
// FileBasedOptionsListRequestSourceFactory will not work with multiple different files for this
// reason.
// TODO: This memory saving is likely a premature optimization, and should be removed.
// This method will also error if the
// file can not be loaded correctly, e.g. the file is too large or could not be found.
RequestSourcePtr createRequestSourcePlugin(const Envoy::Protobuf::Message& message,
Envoy::Api::Api& api,
Envoy::Http::RequestHeaderMapPtr header) override;

private:
Envoy::Thread::MutexBasicLockable file_lock_;
nighthawk::client::RequestOptionsList options_list_;
absl::optional<nighthawk::client::RequestOptionsList> options_list_;
};

// This factory will be activated through RequestSourceFactory in factories.h
DECLARE_FACTORY(OptionsListFromFileRequestSourceFactory);
DECLARE_FACTORY(FileBasedOptionsListRequestSourceFactory);

// Factory that creates a OptionsListRequestSource from a InLineOptionsListRequestSourceConfig
// proto. Registered as an Envoy plugin. Implementation of RequestSourceConfigFactory which produces
// a RequestSource that keeps an RequestOptionsList in memory, and loads it with the RequestOptions
// passed to it from the config. All plugins configuration are specified in the
// request_source_plugin.proto.
// This class is thread-safe,
// Usage: assume you are passed an appropriate Any type object called
// config, an Api object called api, and a default header called header. auto& config_factory =
// Envoy::Config::Utility::getAndCheckFactoryByName<RequestSourcePluginConfigFactory>(
// "nighthawk.in-line-options-list-request-source-plugin");
// RequestSourcePtr plugin =
// config_factory.createRequestSourcePlugin(config, std::move(api), std::move(header));

class InLineOptionsListRequestSourceFactory : public virtual RequestSourcePluginConfigFactory {
public:
std::string name() const override;
Envoy::ProtobufTypes::MessagePtr createEmptyConfigProto() override;

// This implementation is thread safe. There is currently a behaviour such that only the first
// call to createRequestSourcePlugin will load the options list into memory and subsequent calls
// just make a copy of the options_list that was already loaded.
// TODO: This memory saving is likely a premature optimization, and should be removed.
RequestSourcePtr createRequestSourcePlugin(const Envoy::Protobuf::Message& message,
Envoy::Api::Api& api,
Envoy::Http::RequestHeaderMapPtr header) override;

private:
Envoy::Thread::MutexBasicLockable options_list_lock_;
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

If we are saying the class is not thread safe, why do we need a lock? Once we proclaim it thread-unsafe, nobody should be calling it from multiple threads.

If we do include a lock, we should use it to its intended purpose which is to make the class thread safe. Maybe I am misunderstanding it, but looks like we are in a hybrid state where we do pay the cost of locking for no benefit.

Taking a step back, we should probably first agree whether we need this class to be thread safe. If you think we do, can you help by describing a scenario where this needs to be accessed by multiple threads? Once we understand that, we can discuss how to design it to be compatible with the intended use.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

It should be thread safe. Sorry for the confusion.

absl::optional<nighthawk::client::RequestOptionsList> options_list_;
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Does this field need to be optional? When would we create an instance of InLineOptionsListRequestSourceFactory without an options_list_?

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

I made this optional to indicate the state before and after having saved the options_list_.

};

// This factory will be activated through RequestSourceFactory in factories.h
DECLARE_FACTORY(InLineOptionsListRequestSourceFactory);

} // namespace Nighthawk
Loading