Repository navigation
fix: reject stale Herdr endpoints after session resets - #41
Merged
Merged
Conversation
A herdr pane id recorded before a server restart or devcontainer rebuild can be reused by an unrelated pane in the fresh session. Liveness, delivery, control, relaunch and teardown read only the pane at the recorded id, so a foreign pane could be steered, adopted or closed as the task's endpoint. Bind the recorded endpoint to its task: a pane is foreign when its foreground cwd is outside the recorded worktree and its tab label is not fm-<id>. Foreign endpoints classify as missing so the existing relaunch path rebinds, and are never steered, interrupted, exited or killed. Records that cannot be checked keep working.
…ded task ownership
… process identity when comparing flat/projected metadata, remove three unused mocks, add callback-specific SC2329 annotations, and correct the shared-library source annotation because SC1091 fails the lint gate. Production identity, portable fallback, and response-owned cleanup behavior remain unchanged; ci-1 was untouched. The reported broken-pipe lines are unchanged from base and were left alone. Verification passed: full bounded ShellCheck 0.11.0 on all three changed files, complete backend behavior suite, remote-control suite, and a metadata-contract replay that fails before normalization and passes afterward while still rejecting missing identity fields and unrelated changes. The full real-Herdr presentation run was blocked before comparison by the local relative-socket/presentation-lock mismatch; it is not claimed as passing. Removed temporary diagnostics; only the three intended test files remain changed
…h: in-place restart-reclaim fixtures now explicitly use legacy records without process identities across primary, repeated, secondmate, and concurrent recovery paths. Primary cases first verify that identity-bearing records reject replacement shells. Production ownership guarantees remain unchanged. Reproduced the reported failure before the fix; focused real-Herdr verification of all edited recovery paths passes afterward. The complete backend behavior suite, ShellCheck, bash syntax check, and git diff --check pass. Full presentation verification stopped earlier at an unchanged focus-wave cleanup assertion on local Herdr 0.9.3, so it is not claimed passing. The portable Stop-hook timeout matches the previously declined pre-existing failure and was left untouched. Temporary diagnostics and test infrastructure were removed
cloud-practitioner
force-pushed
the
fm/fm-herdr-stale-session-endpoint
branch
from
October 6, 2026 23:50
b0254f7 to
e5f2386
Compare
This was referenced Oct 7, 2026
This file contains hidden or bidirectional Unicode text that may be interpreted or compiled differently than what appears below. To review, open the file in an editor that reveals hidden Unicode characters.
Learn more about bidirectional Unicode characters
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
1 participant
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.This suggestion is invalid because no changes were made to the code.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is closed.Suggestions cannot be applied while viewing a subset of changes.Only one suggestion per line can be applied in a batch.Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.Applying suggestions on deleted lines is not supported.You must change the existing code in this line in order to create a valid suggestion.Outdated suggestions cannot be applied.This suggestion has been applied or marked resolved.Suggestions cannot be applied from pending reviews.Suggestions cannot be applied on multi-line comments.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is queued to merge.Suggestion cannot be applied right now. Please check back later.
Intent
The devcontainer does not persist herdr's session state across rebuilds ("drop it, I only need firstmate and 2ndmates"). So after every devcontainer rebuild herdr starts a fresh session whose workspace and pane ids restart from w1 (they are counters: w1, w2, ... wB, ... w1B), while surviving firstmate records - in the main home and in second-mate homes, the
window=andherdr_pane_id=/herdr_workspace_id=/herdr_tab_id=fields ofstate/*.meta- still name the old ids. A recorded id could then match an unrelated new pane in the new herdr session.Task: first establish whether firstmate's herdr liveness and recovery already detect that a recorded endpoint belongs to a previous herdr session, so that it is reported dead and relaunched rather than treated as alive or steered. If it already does, report that with evidence and stop. If not, ship the narrow fix so such records are treated as stale after a fresh herdr session.
Out of scope: persisting herdr state, other backends (tmux, zellij, cmux, Orca), and crewmate slot leases.
What Changed
Risk Assessment
✅ Low: The Herdr-only change implements the amended ownership design, including portable optional identities, task-selected guards, and response-owned cleanup, with no additional material defects substantiated.
Testing
Three targeted suites passed, and real-product checks passed for reused endpoint IDs, ownership guards, preserved-data relaunch, cleanup and the edited recovery paths after correcting fixture setup. The bounded presentation run passed its metadata comparison but did not finish; focused recovery validation subsequently passed. Remote public-command integration remains deterministic-only because its fixed session violates the lab boundary. Evidence is CLI output and persisted metadata; no UI layout changed.
Evidence: Live reused-endpoint, liveness, relaunch and cleanup transcript
Source: Live reused-endpoint, liveness, relaunch and cleanup transcript
Evidence: Original persisted endpoint record
Source: Original persisted endpoint record
Evidence: Rebound persisted endpoint record
Source: Rebound persisted endpoint record
Evidence: Focused real-Herdr recovery results
Source: Focused real-Herdr recovery results
Evidence: Bounded presentation run, including metadata comparison
Source: Bounded presentation run, including metadata comparison
Evidence: Validation report, commands, setup corrections and limits
Source: Validation report, commands, setup corrections and limits
Pipeline
Updates from git push no-mistakes
✅ **intent** - passed
✅ No issues found.
✅ **Rebase** - passed
✅ No issues found.
🔧 **Review** - 4 issues found → auto-fixed (5) ✅
bin/backends/herdr.sh:2446- The ownership heuristic does not establish session identity. Equal task ids are supported across Firstmate homes (bin/fm-spawn.sh:284), so after a rebuild an old main-home taskminecan resolve to a secondmate's unrelatedminepane at the recycled address. Its cwd differs, but the new hunk[ "$label" != "fm-$id" ] || return 1accepts its matchingfm-minelabel; liveness returns alive and steering reaches that other task. Likewise, line 2443 accepts a newly opened unrelated shell in the surviving worktree. This leaves the failure covered by the required criterion "such records are treated as stale after a fresh herdr session" reachable; no short-term containment was authorized. Establish an incarnation binding at the shared endpoint guard rather than treating mutable labels or cwd as identity. A remedy requiring new durable metadata needs authorization, which is why this is ask-user. Shared affected sites: bin/backends/herdr.sh:2478 (liveness), :2520 (absence recheck), :3617 (close), :3705 (record removal); bin/fm-backend.sh:773/:811 (captures), :820/:838 (input), :907/:930 (classifiers), :964 (existence), :1018/:1027 (liveness forwarding). Task consumers: bin/fm-control-lib.sh:355; bin/fm-control.sh:360/:574; bin/fm-crew-state.sh:1301; bin/fm-spawn.sh:1769/:1771; bin/fm-task-inbox-lib.sh:358; bin/fm-teardown.sh:1180/:3292/:3293/:3739/:3769. The ownership guarantee in docs/herdr-backend.md:735 also needs correction.bin/fm-teardown.sh:3292- Forced secondmate cleanup checks child endpoints using the parent's state directory.child_metacomes from$home/state, but the new guard selects${FM_STATE_OVERRIDE:-$FM_HOME/state}(bin/backends/herdr.sh:2418), and neither changed call switches that context. With no parent record named for the child, the guard returns not-foreign and closes the recycled address even when its cwd and label both belong to an unrelated new pane. Bind both this close and the confirmation at bin/fm-teardown.sh:3293 toFM_STATE_OVERRIDE=$sub_state; preserve that context at every recursive descendant level. This needs only propagation of the already-known owning state directory.bin/fm-backend.sh:820- Active operations check ownership before starting the server, but do not check again afterward. Concrete sequence: the fresh post-rebuild session has reused the old task address for an unrelated pane, then that session is stopped with its new layout saved.fm-send <task> --key C-creaches this guard;pane getcannot run against the stopped server, so the guard permits continuation.fm_backend_herdr_send_keythen callstarget_ready, which starts and restores the server, and sends C-c to the unrelated pane. The source explicitly establishes that socket commands do not auto-start the server and that ensure restores layouts. Move or repeat the ownership decision after server readiness at the shared active-operation boundary, preserving task context. Sibling changed pre-read guards: bin/fm-backend.sh:773 (capture), :811 (visible capture), :838 (text submit), :907 (busy state), :930 (composer state); their adapter paths also ensure the server after this check.bin/backends/herdr.sh:2430- Task-specific liveness callers still omit the new expected-label argument, allowing another record to legitimize a stale task. For example, the previous session spawned secondmate B before A; after rebuilding, A is recovered first and its updated record claims B's old address. When B is probed, bin/fm-secondmate-liveness-lib.sh:217 supplies only backend and target. This loop examines both records, accepts A's matching cwd or label, and reports B alive, so bootstrap and watcher recovery leave B dead. Propagatefm-$idfrom each task-specific liveness caller instead of letting its verdict borrow another claimant's ownership. Shared changed sites where that identity must survive: bin/fm-backend.sh:1018/:1027 (state/alive forwarding), bin/backends/herdr.sh:2478/:2525 (state/alive classification). The automatic session-start path is bin/fm-bootstrap.sh:766, and the watcher uses the same secondmate probe.🔧 Fix applied.
7 errors still open:
bin/backends/herdr.sh:2446- The ownership heuristic does not establish session identity. Equal task ids are supported across Firstmate homes (bin/fm-spawn.sh:284), so after a rebuild an old main-home taskminecan resolve to a secondmate's unrelatedminepane at the recycled address. Its cwd differs, but the new hunk[ "$label" != "fm-$id" ] || return 1accepts its matchingfm-minelabel; liveness returns alive and steering reaches that other task. Likewise, line 2443 accepts a newly opened unrelated shell in the surviving worktree. This leaves the failure covered by the required criterion "such records are treated as stale after a fresh herdr session" reachable; no short-term containment was authorized. Establish an incarnation binding at the shared endpoint guard rather than treating mutable labels or cwd as identity. A remedy requiring new durable metadata needs authorization, which is why this is ask-user. Shared affected sites: bin/backends/herdr.sh:2478 (liveness), :2520 (absence recheck), :3617 (close), :3705 (record removal); bin/fm-backend.sh:773/:811 (captures), :820/:838 (input), :907/:930 (classifiers), :964 (existence), :1018/:1027 (liveness forwarding). Task consumers: bin/fm-control-lib.sh:355; bin/fm-control.sh:360/:574; bin/fm-crew-state.sh:1301; bin/fm-spawn.sh:1769/:1771; bin/fm-task-inbox-lib.sh:358; bin/fm-teardown.sh:1180/:3292/:3293/:3739/:3769. The ownership guarantee in docs/herdr-backend.md:735 also needs correction.bin/fm-teardown.sh:3292- Forced secondmate cleanup checks child endpoints using the parent's state directory.child_metacomes from$home/state, but the new guard selects${FM_STATE_OVERRIDE:-$FM_HOME/state}(bin/backends/herdr.sh:2418), and neither changed call switches that context. With no parent record named for the child, the guard returns not-foreign and closes the recycled address even when its cwd and label both belong to an unrelated new pane. Bind both this close and the confirmation at bin/fm-teardown.sh:3293 toFM_STATE_OVERRIDE=$sub_state; preserve that context at every recursive descendant level. This needs only propagation of the already-known owning state directory.bin/fm-backend.sh:820- Active operations check ownership before starting the server, but do not check again afterward. Concrete sequence: the fresh post-rebuild session has reused the old task address for an unrelated pane, then that session is stopped with its new layout saved.fm-send <task> --key C-creaches this guard;pane getcannot run against the stopped server, so the guard permits continuation.fm_backend_herdr_send_keythen callstarget_ready, which starts and restores the server, and sends C-c to the unrelated pane. The source explicitly establishes that socket commands do not auto-start the server and that ensure restores layouts. Move or repeat the ownership decision after server readiness at the shared active-operation boundary, preserving task context. Sibling changed pre-read guards: bin/fm-backend.sh:773 (capture), :811 (visible capture), :838 (text submit), :907 (busy state), :930 (composer state); their adapter paths also ensure the server after this check.bin/backends/herdr.sh:2430- Task-specific liveness callers still omit the new expected-label argument, allowing another record to legitimize a stale task. For example, the previous session spawned secondmate B before A; after rebuilding, A is recovered first and its updated record claims B's old address. When B is probed, bin/fm-secondmate-liveness-lib.sh:217 supplies only backend and target. This loop examines both records, accepts A's matching cwd or label, and reports B alive, so bootstrap and watcher recovery leave B dead. Propagatefm-$idfrom each task-specific liveness caller instead of letting its verdict borrow another claimant's ownership. Shared changed sites where that identity must survive: bin/fm-backend.sh:1018/:1027 (state/alive forwarding), bin/backends/herdr.sh:2478/:2525 (state/alive classification). The automatic session-start path is bin/fm-bootstrap.sh:766, and the watcher uses the same secondmate probe.bin/backends/herdr.sh:3735- The R1 fix round (011b6d2) makes successful teardown impossible for identity-bearing records. After an owned pane is successfully closed, its process-info read fails, so endpoint_foreign returns 2. This branch returns failure before checking structured pane presence, even when pane get would prove pane_not_found. Normal teardown therefore retains the task record, and rerunning cannot finish. Let authoritative pane absence confirm removal even when process identity cannot be read; continue refusing present or ambiguous panes. Affected consumers: bin/fm-teardown.sh:3769 (both flat and projected teardown) and :3293 (child removal confirmation). The new regression at tests/fm-backend-herdr.test.sh:5387 checks liveness after disappearance but does not exercise this removal verdict.bin/backends/herdr.sh:2606- The R1 fix round's new duplicate-tab guard still permits closing foreign shells. Concrete sequence: recovery detects a foreign same-label shell at p1, leaves it untouched, creates p2, and publishes p2's identity. After a subsequent server restart, p2's changed process identity triggers another rebind. When create_task examines the surviving foreign p1 shell, the guard skips the record because window now names p2 (bin/backends/herdr.sh:2438), returns not-foreign, and queues p1 for tab close at :2615/:2631. A sibling bypass occurs during secondmate respawn: bin/fm-spawn.sh:3802 shadows FM_HOME to the child home, although the identity record belongs to the parent's STATE; the guard finds no record and can close the same-label foreign shell immediately. At the shared create-task boundary, preserve unclaimed same-label panes when the task has an identity-bearing record, and carry the owning state directory separately from workspace-label context. Both creation callers must uphold this: bin/fm-spawn.sh:3610 (rebind) and :3802 (fresh/secondmate spawn). Correct the resulting overclaim in docs/herdr-backend.md:748.bin/fm-spawn.sh:4892- The R1 fix round introduces an unconditional Linux-only requirement for every Herdr spawn and relaunch, breaking the existing supported macOS path. On macOS, pane process-info can succeed, but bin/backends/herdr.sh:2405-2408 requires /proc; this call consequently exits before publishing or launching the worker, after endpoint creation and worktree setup. macOS usage is source-backed by bin/fm-install-herdr.sh:44/:48 and the active real-Herdr verification in docs/verification/runtime-backends.md:1113. The devcontainer fix did not authorize dropping that platform, and documenting the new restriction at docs/herdr-backend.md:741 does not resolve the regression. Preserve supported hosts with an equivalent process identity satisfying the approved invariants; if that cannot be established, follow the instruction to stop and report rather than shipping the platform restriction. Authorization is needed for any deliberate support reduction.🔧 Fix applied.
5 errors still open:
bin/fm-teardown.sh:3292- Forced secondmate cleanup checks child endpoints using the parent's state directory.child_metacomes from$home/state, but the new guard selects${FM_STATE_OVERRIDE:-$FM_HOME/state}(bin/backends/herdr.sh:2418), and neither changed call switches that context. With no parent record named for the child, the guard returns not-foreign and closes the recycled address even when its cwd and label both belong to an unrelated new pane. Bind both this close and the confirmation at bin/fm-teardown.sh:3293 toFM_STATE_OVERRIDE=$sub_state; preserve that context at every recursive descendant level. This needs only propagation of the already-known owning state directory.bin/fm-backend.sh:820- Active operations check ownership before starting the server, but do not check again afterward. Concrete sequence: the fresh post-rebuild session has reused the old task address for an unrelated pane, then that session is stopped with its new layout saved.fm-send <task> --key C-creaches this guard;pane getcannot run against the stopped server, so the guard permits continuation.fm_backend_herdr_send_keythen callstarget_ready, which starts and restores the server, and sends C-c to the unrelated pane. The source explicitly establishes that socket commands do not auto-start the server and that ensure restores layouts. Move or repeat the ownership decision after server readiness at the shared active-operation boundary, preserving task context. Sibling changed pre-read guards: bin/fm-backend.sh:773 (capture), :811 (visible capture), :838 (text submit), :907 (busy state), :930 (composer state); their adapter paths also ensure the server after this check.bin/backends/herdr.sh:2430- Task-specific liveness callers still omit the new expected-label argument, allowing another record to legitimize a stale task. For example, the previous session spawned secondmate B before A; after rebuilding, A is recovered first and its updated record claims B's old address. When B is probed, bin/fm-secondmate-liveness-lib.sh:217 supplies only backend and target. This loop examines both records, accepts A's matching cwd or label, and reports B alive, so bootstrap and watcher recovery leave B dead. Propagatefm-$idfrom each task-specific liveness caller instead of letting its verdict borrow another claimant's ownership. Shared changed sites where that identity must survive: bin/fm-backend.sh:1018/:1027 (state/alive forwarding), bin/backends/herdr.sh:2478/:2525 (state/alive classification). The automatic session-start path is bin/fm-bootstrap.sh:766, and the watcher uses the same secondmate probe.bin/backends/herdr.sh:3735- The R1 fix round (011b6d2) makes successful teardown impossible for identity-bearing records. After an owned pane is successfully closed, its process-info read fails, so endpoint_foreign returns 2. This branch returns failure before checking structured pane presence, even when pane get would prove pane_not_found. Normal teardown therefore retains the task record, and rerunning cannot finish. Let authoritative pane absence confirm removal even when process identity cannot be read; continue refusing present or ambiguous panes. Affected consumers: bin/fm-teardown.sh:3769 (both flat and projected teardown) and :3293 (child removal confirmation). The new regression at tests/fm-backend-herdr.test.sh:5387 checks liveness after disappearance but does not exercise this removal verdict.bin/backends/herdr.sh:2606- The R1 fix round's new duplicate-tab guard still permits closing foreign shells. Concrete sequence: recovery detects a foreign same-label shell at p1, leaves it untouched, creates p2, and publishes p2's identity. After a subsequent server restart, p2's changed process identity triggers another rebind. When create_task examines the surviving foreign p1 shell, the guard skips the record because window now names p2 (bin/backends/herdr.sh:2438), returns not-foreign, and queues p1 for tab close at :2615/:2631. A sibling bypass occurs during secondmate respawn: bin/fm-spawn.sh:3802 shadows FM_HOME to the child home, although the identity record belongs to the parent's STATE; the guard finds no record and can close the same-label foreign shell immediately. At the shared create-task boundary, preserve unclaimed same-label panes when the task has an identity-bearing record, and carry the owning state directory separately from workspace-label context. Both creation callers must uphold this: bin/fm-spawn.sh:3610 (rebind) and :3802 (fresh/secondmate spawn). Correct the resulting overclaim in docs/herdr-backend.md:748.🔧 Fix applied.
5 issues (4 errors, 1 warning) still open:
bin/backends/herdr.sh:2430- Task-specific liveness callers still omit the new expected-label argument, allowing another record to legitimize a stale task. For example, the previous session spawned secondmate B before A; after rebuilding, A is recovered first and its updated record claims B's old address. When B is probed, bin/fm-secondmate-liveness-lib.sh:217 supplies only backend and target. This loop examines both records, accepts A's matching cwd or label, and reports B alive, so bootstrap and watcher recovery leave B dead. Propagatefm-$idfrom each task-specific liveness caller instead of letting its verdict borrow another claimant's ownership. Shared changed sites where that identity must survive: bin/fm-backend.sh:1018/:1027 (state/alive forwarding), bin/backends/herdr.sh:2478/:2525 (state/alive classification). The automatic session-start path is bin/fm-bootstrap.sh:766, and the watcher uses the same secondmate probe.bin/backends/herdr.sh:3735- The R1 fix round (011b6d2) makes successful teardown impossible for identity-bearing records. After an owned pane is successfully closed, its process-info read fails, so endpoint_foreign returns 2. This branch returns failure before checking structured pane presence, even when pane get would prove pane_not_found. Normal teardown therefore retains the task record, and rerunning cannot finish. Let authoritative pane absence confirm removal even when process identity cannot be read; continue refusing present or ambiguous panes. Affected consumers: bin/fm-teardown.sh:3769 (both flat and projected teardown) and :3293 (child removal confirmation). The new regression at tests/fm-backend-herdr.test.sh:5387 checks liveness after disappearance but does not exercise this removal verdict.bin/backends/herdr.sh:2606- The R1 fix round's new duplicate-tab guard still permits closing foreign shells. Concrete sequence: recovery detects a foreign same-label shell at p1, leaves it untouched, creates p2, and publishes p2's identity. After a subsequent server restart, p2's changed process identity triggers another rebind. When create_task examines the surviving foreign p1 shell, the guard skips the record because window now names p2 (bin/backends/herdr.sh:2438), returns not-foreign, and queues p1 for tab close at :2615/:2631. A sibling bypass occurs during secondmate respawn: bin/fm-spawn.sh:3802 shadows FM_HOME to the child home, although the identity record belongs to the parent's STATE; the guard finds no record and can close the same-label foreign shell immediately. At the shared create-task boundary, preserve unclaimed same-label panes when the task has an identity-bearing record, and carry the owning state directory separately from workspace-label context. Both creation callers must uphold this: bin/fm-spawn.sh:3610 (rebind) and :3802 (fresh/secondmate spawn). Correct the resulting overclaim in docs/herdr-backend.md:748.bin/fm-remote-secondmate-control.sh:131- Round 3 propagated task labels here but left the owning-state context behind. Remote endpoint records live in $TARGET_HOME/state/parent-route, while endpoint_foreign reads $TARGET_HOME/state because the remote worker supplies FM_HOME without FM_STATE_OVERRIDE. If a fresh session reuses the recorded address for another live pane, the guard finds no claiming record and permits it:statereports alive,launchreturns the stale route, andcapturereturns the unrelated pane's terminal contents despite the stored process identity differing. Bind endpoint operations to CONTROL_STATE at the shared remote-control boundary. Remaining siblings in bin/fm-remote-secondmate-control.sh:184 (launch classification), :191 (close), :306 (doorbell), :330 (capture), and :339 (observation); the key subprocess at :319 must also stop overriding that context with TARGET_HOME/state.bin/backends/herdr.sh:1015- Round 2 (011b6d2) added this unconditional ambient-record guard to a helper that also closes freshly created, response-derived panes. After a rebuild, let A.meta retain fmtest:w3:p2 with its old process identity; a fresh projected spawn of B receives w3:p2 and then fails worktree acquisition before metadata publication. Abort cleanup now judges B's freshly created pane foreign to A and silently leaves its disposable pane/workspace behind. The extra ambient-record check is not required for response-owned resources by the stale-record intent. Revert this part of the fix to the narrower form: retain task-selected ownership checks for recorded teardown/reclaim, but remove ambient-record lookup from same-process response-owned cleanup. Sibling paths in bin/backends/herdr.sh:1897 (seeded-pane prune), :2789 and :2791 (abort cleanup), and :2875 (replacement rollback); :2985 and bin/fm-teardown.sh:3732 still need recorded-task protection.🔧 Fix applied.
1 error still open:
bin/fm-remote-secondmate-control.sh:131- Round 3 propagated task labels here but left the owning-state context behind. Remote endpoint records live in $TARGET_HOME/state/parent-route, while endpoint_foreign reads $TARGET_HOME/state because the remote worker supplies FM_HOME without FM_STATE_OVERRIDE. If a fresh session reuses the recorded address for another live pane, the guard finds no claiming record and permits it:statereports alive,launchreturns the stale route, andcapturereturns the unrelated pane's terminal contents despite the stored process identity differing. Bind endpoint operations to CONTROL_STATE at the shared remote-control boundary. Remaining siblings in bin/fm-remote-secondmate-control.sh:184 (launch classification), :191 (close), :306 (doorbell), :330 (capture), and :339 (observation); the key subprocess at :319 must also stop overriding that context with TARGET_HOME/state.🔧 Fix applied.
✅ Re-checked - no issues remain.
✅ No issues found.
✅ No issues found.
bash .live-validation/live-scenarios.sh <evidence-directory>against real Herdr 0.9.3: session recreation, recycled addresses, capture/input guards, secondmate probes, stopped-server restoration, relaunch, legacy fallback, and projected abort cleanup.bash .live-validation/extra-scenarios.sh <evidence-directory>: real Claude process ownership, unreadable-identity guards, baseline-versus-target comparison, and forced recursive secondmate teardown.bash .live-validation/fresh-fallback.sh: real Treehouse allocation and fresh Claude launch with a deliberately failed portable process-identity read.Executed baselinefm_backend_agent_statefrom commit06a89438bead6193fd300248c5366941a30789d9against the same live pane and stale record: baseline returnedalive; target returnedmissing.Selected executable cases fromtests/fm-backend-herdr.test.sh: previous-session endpoints, matching-label/cwd collisions, portable identity, failed identity reads, response-owned abort cleanup, post-restore guards, secondmate claimant isolation, and descendant teardown.TMPDIR=<workspace-local-temp> bash tests/fm-remote-secondmate-control.test.sh.claude auth statusconfirmed the normal login is available;bwrapisolation was attempted but denied because unprivileged namespaces are unavailable.All live sessions were provisioned and torn down throughbin/fm-herdr-lab.sh; default-session tripwires remained unchanged. Removed disposable fixtures and verified a clean worktree.🚨 Approval is refused: the run worktree at ~/.no-mistakes/worktrees/450411b3e67c/01M47HX8Y8BQRSDDHWXNW190JH holds work no Test turn validated, and the steps after Test would commit and publish it. It holds uncommitted changes to .live-validation/, herdr/ (inspect with
git -C ~/.no-mistakes/worktrees/450411b3e67c/01M47HX8Y8BQRSDDHWXNW190JH statusandgit -C ~/.no-mistakes/worktrees/450411b3e67c/01M47HX8Y8BQRSDDHWXNW190JH diff). Respond with fix to validate it, or abort.🔧 No changes applied.
✅ Re-checked - no issues remain.
bash tests/fm-backend-herdr.test.sh— passed.bash tests/fm-remote-secondmate-control.test.sh— passed.bash tests/fm-teardown-endpoint-safety.test.sh— passed.bash tests/fm-backend-herdr-presentation-e2e.test.sh— bounded at 360 seconds; metadata comparison and preceding spawn/cleanup checks passed, but the complete suite is not claimed passing.Ranfocused-herdr-recovery.shthroughrun-lab-test.py— edited primary, repeated, secondmate-child and concurrent recovery cases passed against real Herdr and Treehouse.Ranlive-reused-endpoint.shthroughrun-lab-test.py— recreated a named session, verified reused IDs, ownership refusals, process-backed liveness, relaunch, preserved worktree data and cleanup.bin/fm-herdr-lab.sh provision fm-remote— confirmed the mandatory helper refuses the remote command's fixed non-lab session name.Tore down isolated labs, removed transient scratch and checkedgit status --porcelain— clean.✅ **Document** - passed
✅ No issues found.
✅ No issues found.
🔧 **Lint** - 1 issue found → auto-fixed ✅
🔧 Fix applied.
✅ Re-checked - no issues remain.
✅ No issues found.
✅ **Push** - passed
✅ No issues found.
✅ No issues found.