Document why uv discards upper bounds on requires-python

docs/reference/internals/resolver.md

@@ -156,26 +156,62 @@ Windows, Linux and macOS.
 To ensure that a resolution with `requires-python = ">=3.9"` can actually be installed for the
 included Python versions, uv requires that all dependencies have the same minimum Python version.
 Package versions that declare a higher minimum Python version, e.g., `requires-python = ">=3.10"`,
-are rejected, because a resolution with that version can't be installed on Python 3.9. For
-simplicity and forward compatibility, only lower bounds in `requires-python` are respected. For
-example, if a package declares `requires-python = ">=3.8,<4"`, the `<4` marker is not propagated to
-the entire resolution.
-
-This default is a problem for packages that use the version-dependent C API of CPython, such as
-numpy. Each numpy release support 4 Python minor versions, e.g., numpy 2.0.0 has wheels for CPython
-3.9 through 3.12 and declares `requires-python = ">=3.9"`, while numpy 2.1.0 has wheels for CPython
-3.10 through 3.13 and declares `requires-python = ">=3.10"`. The means that when we resolve a
-`numpy>=2,<3` requirement in a project with `requires-python = ">=3.9"`, we resolve numpy 2.0.0 and
-the lockfile doesn't install on Python 3.13 or newer. To alleviate this, whenever we reject a
-version due to a too high Python requirement, we fork on that Python version. This behavior is
-controlled by `--fork-strategy`. In the example case, upon encountering numpy 2.1.0 we fork into
-Python versions `>=3.9,<3.10` and `>=3.10` and resolve two different numpy versions:
+are rejected, because a resolution with that version can't be installed on Python 3.9. This ensures
+that when you are on an old Python version, you can install old packages, instead of getting newer
+packages that require newer Python syntax or standard library features.
+
+uv ignores upper-bounds on `requires-python`, with special handling for packages with only
+ABI-specific wheels. For example, if a package declares `requires-python = ">=3.8,<4"`, the `<4`
+part is ignored. There is a detailed discussion with drawbacks and alternatives in
+[#4022](https://github.com/astral-sh/uv/issues/4022) and this
+[DPO thread](https://discuss.python.org/t/requires-python-upper-limits/12663), this section
+summarizes the aspects most relevant to uv's design.
+
+For most projects, it's not possible to determine whether they will be compatible with a new version
+before it's released, so blocking newer versions in advance would block users from upgrading or
+testing newer Python versions. The exceptions are packages which use the unstable C ABI or internals
+of CPython such as its bytecode format.
+
+Introducing a `requires-python` upper bound to a project that previously wasn't using one will not
+prevent the project from being used on a too recent Python version. Instead of failing, the resolver
+will pick an older version without the bound, circumventing the bound.
+
+For the resolution to be as universally installable as possible, uv ensures that the selected
+dependency versions are compatible with the `requires-python` range of the project. For example, for
+a project with `requires-python = ">=3.12"`, uv will not use a dependency version with
+`requires-python = ">=3.13"`, as otherwise the resolution is not installable on Python 3.12, which
+the project declares to support. Applying the same logic to upper bounds means that bumping the
+upper Python version bound on a project makes it compatible with less dependency versions,
+potentially failing to resolve when no version of a dependency supports the required range. (Bumping
+the lower Python version bound has the inverse effect, it only increases the set of supported
+dependency versions.)
+
+Note that this is different for Conda, as the Conda solver also determines the Python version, so it
+can choose a lower Python version instead. Conda can also change metadata after a release, so it can
+update compatibility for a new Python version, while metadata on PyPI cannot be changed once
+published.
+
+Ignoring an upper bound is a problem for packages such as numpy which use the version-dependent C
+API of CPython. As of writing, each numpy release support 4 Python minor versions, e.g., numpy 2.0.0
+has wheels for CPython 3.9 through 3.12 and declares `requires-python = ">=3.9"`, while numpy 2.1.0
+has wheels for CPython 3.10 through 3.13 and declares `requires-python = ">=3.10"`. The means that
+when uv resolves a `numpy>=2,<3` requirement in a project with `requires-python = ">=3.9"`, it
+selects numpy 2.0.0 and the lockfile doesn't install on Python 3.13 or newer. To alleviate this,
+whenever uv rejects a version that requires a newer Python version, we fork by splitting the
+resolution markers on that Python version. This behavior can be controlled by `--fork-strategy`. In
+the example case, upon encountering numpy 2.1.0 we fork into Python versions `>=3.9,<3.10` and
+`>=3.10` and resolve two different numpy versions:
 
 ```
 numpy==2.0.0; python_version >= "3.9" and python_version < "3.10"
 numpy==2.1.0; python_version >= "3.10"
 ```
 
+There's one case where uv does consider the upper bound: When the project uses an upper bound on
+requires Python, such as `requires-python = "==3.13.*"` for an application that only deploys to
+Python 3.13. uv prunes wheels from the lockfile that are outside the range (e.g., `cp312` and
+`cp314`) in a post-processing step, which does not influence the resolution itself.
+
 ## URL dependencies
 
 In uv, a dependency can either be a registry dependency, a package with a version specifier or the