Actions.login() doesn't work if login Scene has type='replace'

[bosung90]

Version

• react-native-router-flux v3.2.8
• react-native v0.23.1

Expected behaviour

<Scene key='login' component={LoginContainer} title='Login' panHandlers={null} type='replace'/>
Calling Actions.login() should switch scene to LoginContainer

Actual behaviour

<Scene key='login' component={LoginContainer} title='Login' panHandlers={null} type='replace'/>
Calling Actions.login() does not switch scene to LoginContainer

Steps to reproduce

1. Ensure your Scene key='login'
2. Ensure your Scene type='replace'
3. Call Actions.login() from some other Scene (For example, splash)

[sylvainbaronnet]

same issue with react-native v0.24.0-rc4

[paulbao]

I have the same issue and tried to reproduce it on Example app. However, I cannot reproduce it on the Example app which is so wired...

[aksonov]

Example app has replace action, could you check it?

[timzaak]

I have tried Example app with react-native v0.24.0-rc4. there is something odd. It does not work correctly.
the NavBar changes correctly, But the component in the Scene does not change.

[sylvainbaronnet]

Yes looks like the scene is loaded behind the current one

[codyhazelwood]

I see this same issue. It also seems to affect type="reset". Also here: #474

[evollu]

I'm using Switch to get around the problem and it works correctly with v0.24.0-rc3. "replace" doesn't work because NavigationView's animation depends on scene index and "replace" doesn't change the index

[sylvainbaronnet]

I guess the problem is in the reducer, here : https://github.com/aksonov/react-native-router-flux/blob/master/src/Reducer.js#L77
Edit : Looks fine, I don't think the problem is there

[sylvainbaronnet]

I made some test and I can confirm that the scene is loaded correctly but displayed under the current one

[sylvainbaronnet]

I think it's a problem with RN component <NavigationCard/> that use this style by default :

    bottom: 0,
    left: 0,
    position: 'absolute',
    right: 0,
    top: 0,

if I remove it my replace scene appear but then next one don't. I guess RN really need to support z-index now...

[aksonov]

#525! Also duplicate of #474

I've got same problem - replace not working, component gets created, render is called, but blank screen is shown. Used 23, now 24, so that may be an issue. Will wait until version 3 will wortk fine.

[ruettiger]

I have got the same problem.