Skip to content

PR471 review: various fixes (1)#207

Merged
ConstanceBeguier merged 15 commits into
zcash_pr471_reviewfrom
pr471_various_fixes_1
Jan 6, 2026
Merged

PR471 review: various fixes (1)#207
ConstanceBeguier merged 15 commits into
zcash_pr471_reviewfrom
pr471_various_fixes_1

Conversation

@dmidem
Copy link
Copy Markdown

@dmidem dmidem commented Dec 29, 2025

Address the following review comments:

r2487851383
r2487857002
r2487858123
r2487968253
r2487968899
r2542305679
r2542359143
r2542360991
r2542333126
r2542371427 (see note)
r2542392826
r2542406328
r2542447228
r2542428312
r2542599948
r2542671834
r2542817988
r2542846302
r2542756837
r2543147318
r2543502871
r2543506591
r2543527521
r2543542313
r2543565714
r2549938764
r2542276487
r2542288774
r2550151848
r2550187398
r2550276814
r2550352041
r2550380193
r2550407188
r2550616659
r2542967008

Note: r2542371427 is only partially addressed: issuance-related modules were moved under crate::issuance::*, but the zsa-issuance feature has not been added to Cargo.toml yet, and issuance code is not yet gated behind cfg(feature = "zsa-issuance"). The feature flag gating (and related optional dependency changes) will be handled in a follow-up PR.

r2487851383
r2487857002
r2487858123
r2487968253
r2487968899
r2542305679
r2542313926
r2542359143
r2542360991
r2542333126
r2542371427 (see note)
r2542392826 (see note)
r2542406328
r2542447228
r2542428312
r2542599948
r2542671834
r2542817988
r2542846302
r2542756837
r2543147318
r2543502871
r2543506591
r2543527521
r2543542313 (see note)
r2543565714 (see note)
r2549938764
r2542276487
r2542288774
r2550151848
r2550187398
r2550276814
r2550352041
r2550380193
r2550407188
r2550616659

Note: r2542371427 is only partially addressed: issuance-related modules
were moved under crate::issuance::*, but the zsa-issuance feature has
not been added to Cargo.toml yet, and issuance code is not yet gated
behind cfg(feature = "zsa-issuance"). The feature flag gating (and
related optional dependency changes) will be handled in a follow-up PR.

Note: r2542392826 addressed except orchard_flavor changes.

Note: r2543542313 - changed pub to pub(crate) but needs to be discussed.

Note: r2543565714 - It's not completely clear from the comment, but the
doc comment for rseed_split_note has beed revomed in this commit and it
has been updated it for create_split_note - is that correct? Also kept
create_split_note pub, not pub(crate) - needs to be discussed.
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator

@ConstanceBeguier ConstanceBeguier left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

You can message me when you are available to discuss r2543542313 and r2543565714.

Comment thread .github/workflows/ci.yml Outdated
Comment thread .github/workflows/ci.yml Outdated
Comment thread src/circuit.rs Outdated
Comment thread src/circuit.rs Outdated
Comment thread book/src/design/actions.md
Comment thread src/lib.rs Outdated
Comment thread src/keys.rs Outdated
Comment thread src/keys.rs Outdated
Comment thread src/note.rs
Comment thread src/constants/sinsemilla.rs
@ConstanceBeguier ConstanceBeguier merged commit b5518f1 into zcash_pr471_review Jan 6, 2026
31 checks passed
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants