Should we have the ability to revoke unclaimed tokens?

[pabloruiz55]

Open Zeppelin's Vesting contract template offers the possibility of revoking unclaimed tokens.

This should be a MUST for founder / advisor tokens.

Right now, there's no way to stop vesting for the tokens an advisor/founder gets. You would need to do that in case they leave the company before the vesting fully completes.

[everhusk]

No it's okay, we have everything allocated so it's not an issue.

[pabloruiz55]

That's not what I mean.
Say you allocate 1000 tokens to me as a founder, which would get vested up to 4 years.
Right now I could call the transferTokens() function every now and then to get the share of tokens corresponding to the vesting.

The purpose of having a vesting scheme is that if I leave the company before the vesting period ends I don;t get all the tokens.

Right now, if I left the company on year 2, I could still claim the tokens for year 3 and 4 when the time comes.

Tokens MUST have the ability to be revoked, if not, people that leave the organization will still have access to them, which defeats the purpose of vesting.

[everhusk]

I understand, it's not a problem because the founder funds are going to a multisig wallet which will be distributed by head office if the founder is still in the company.

[pabloruiz55]

And what about advisors? Pablo Ruiz Solidity Developer - Ethereum Blockchain & Smart Contracts Consultant *Check out my latest ERCs (Ethereum Request for Comments):* - ERC: Separating Token Balance from Voting Rights #804 <ethereum/EIPs#804> - ERC : Sellable Contracts #798 <ethereum/EIPs#798> - ERC : Account Reputation System #810 <ethereum/EIPs#810> *Check out my latest articles on Medium: * - A Protocol for Sellable Smart Contracts <https://medium.freecodecamp.org/a-protocol-for-sellable-smart-contracts-829bc2ce02b3> - <https://medium.freecodecamp.org/how-i-built-a-multi-token-airdrop-central-to-distribute-erc20-tokens-cb70b6218b5c>How I built a multi-token Airdrop Central to distribute ERC20 tokens <https://medium.freecodecamp.org/how-i-built-a-multi-token-airdrop-central-to-distribute-erc20-tokens-cb70b6218b5c> - Hacking a Popular ICO Practice That Only Rewards the Richer <https://hackernoon.com/hacking-a-popular-ico-practice-that-only-rewards-the-richer-7d10b2019f1e> - Renting Items on the Blockchain <https://hackernoon.com/renting-items-on-the-blockchain-de4e2663dfc6> - Take Your Chances at the Ether Auction Game <https://hackernoon.com/take-your-chances-at-the-ether-auction-game-30f9df1ec80b> - Hey Baby, I think I Wanna Marry You (On the Blockchain) <https://medium.com/@pabloruiz55/hey-baby-i-think-i-wanna-marry-you-on-the-blockchain-3227ba3bdfe> - A Smart Contract for a Smart Car <https://medium.com/@pabloruiz55/a-smart-contract-for-a-smart-car-db08eda4bb4f> - Building a Raffle with Oraclize <https://medium.com/@pabloruiz55/building-a-raffle-contract-using-oraclize-e746e5edff6b> *My Ethereum StackExchange profile (Top 15 in 2017)* <https://ethereum.stackexchange.com/users/20200/pabloruiz55?tab=topactivity> *My Github Repository <https://github.com/pabloruiz55> <https://ethereum.stackexchange.com/users/20200/pabloruiz55?tab=topactivity>* 2018-01-03 10:52 GMT-03:00 Sukhveer Sanghera <[email protected]>:

…

I understand, it's not a problem because the founder funds are going to a multisig wallet which will be distributed by head office if the founder is still in the company. — You are receiving this because you authored the thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub <#18 (comment)>, or mute the thread <https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAgI3ryfIF_F0Jv1f774QALLkOtCugKCks5tG4Y2gaJpZM4RRr8d> .