Move the device list into a separate scroll area #1680
Conversation
Scrolling the device list alongside all other user info is not a very great UX, so I've fixed it.
|
This was originally done so that on mobile you can scroll the device list without the profile taking up screen space. Are you sure we should revert that? |
|
Hm, that is a good point. However, I feel like the current design is a significant departure from both our overall UI choices (e.g. the members list) and general consensus in most apps' UI choices. Also, I think that most people rarely need to check a device list anyway, so this isn't a huge problem to start with. |
|
It is pretty common on mobile apps to have this in one scrollable section and I think Element used to do that as well, so I am not sure it is that much of a departure? |
|
Well, you can abandon this change if you want, but personally I think it is a little strange that this is the only dialog in nheko where the entire dialog content scrolls rather than just the list content. Maybe there is a better way to solve this though. |
|
It isn't the only dialog, is it? Both the userprofile and the room profile scroll and are similar in design for me? |
|
I'm of the opinion that the only part that should scroll is the actual 'data' that needs to be scrolled... not extraneous additional data on the same page. That being said, the argument for screen real estate on a mobile device is a good one. Perhaps it could be done the existing way on mobile and this new way on desktop? |
Scrolling the device list alongside all other user info is not
a very great UX, so I've fixed it.