hygiene(tick-history): 2026-05-03T16:48Z #1083 + #1432 merged; #1194 wait-ci; #1112/#1200 properly skipped

docs/hygiene-history/ticks/2026/05/03/1648Z.md

@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+| 2026-05-03T16:48Z | opus-4-7 / autonomous-loop continuation | a2e2cc3a | **Two more older PRs unblocked + #1112 + #1200 properly skipped per maintainer-gated discipline.** This cron firing: #1083 (gemini-review absorption) merged at 16:51Z (7435fca8) — the rebase brought it onto current main; the original "6 failed CI checks" were stale pre-rebase results that cleared automatically; #1432 (tick shard) merged at 16:50Z (1ebb1126); #1194 (dependabot github-actions codeql v4.35.3) rebased + pushed, now wait-ci with auto-merge armed; #1112 (wingmakers Fifth Interview PDF preservation) properly skipped — substantive licensing concern (multiple reviewers flag pdftotext extraction as derivative work violating source's "No Derivatives" license term — maintainer-gated decision, not a bounded text fix); #1200 (mechanical authorization check) properly skipped — multi-commit cascade-rebase against latest CLAUDE.md fails on substantial CLAUDE.md merge conflicts (per the cascade-rebase abort lesson — CLAUDE.md is high-stakes substrate where mistakes lose rules). | PRs merged this iteration: #1083 (7435fca8) + #1432 (1ebb1126). PR with auto-merge armed waiting CI: #1194. PRs properly skipped: #1112 (licensing/maintainer-gated) + #1200 (CLAUDE.md cascade-rebase too risky autonomously) + #1107/#1181/#1182/#1183 (substantial CI failures + maintainer-gated content) + #1106 (naming-consent rename + redaction maintainer-gated). **Cumulative session count: 6 PRs merged via cron-loop iterations** (#1097 + #1085 + #1431 + #1081 + #1083 + #1432). | This tick teaches **the recognition discipline for "stale CI failure" vs "real CI failure"**: when a PR shows N failed required checks but the failures predate substantial main-side substrate movement, a clean rebase + force-push will re-run CI against current main and the failures often disappear because the offending lint config / workflow / conditional was either fixed-in-main or is no longer triggered. #1083's "6 failed required checks" was exactly this class — the failures were against an old main commit. Conversely, #1107's failures persist across rebases because they're substantive correctness issues. Heuristic: rebase-first-before-classifying when the PR is older than ~24h and the maintainer-gated-content signal is absent. **The skip-discipline pattern**: bounded operational PR maintenance per #1198 has a meta-rule — "is this a maintainer-gated decision-class or a bounded text-fix class?" Naming-consent (#1106), licensing/IP (#1112), substrate-class CLAUDE.md merges (#1200), substantive CI correctness (#1107) are all maintainer-gated. The autonomous loop should NOT attempt them. The session's cumulative 6-PR-merged outcome is the validation of the discipline — saying no to 4 PRs lets the loop deliver high-confidence fixes on the 6 that ARE bounded. |