hygiene(tick-history): shard 0431Z — major thread-drain on PR #1006 (11→0)

docs/hygiene-history/ticks/2026/05/01/0431Z.md

@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+| 2026-05-01T04:31:00Z | opus-4-7 / autonomous-loop tick | 98fc7424 | Major thread-drain on PR #1006 (greenfield-foundations memory). 11 unresolved threads → 0 unresolved threads. Drained: (1) **Codex P1** — GOVERNANCE.md numbered rules conflict: bullet (3) included them in greenfield-provisional scope, Why-2 explicitly excluded them. Fixed by relocating the GOVERNANCE-exclusion to bullet (3) inline so it can't be missed before reaching Why-2. Three threads resolved on this finding. (2) **Two/Three revelations heading mismatch**: doc enumerates Why-1/Why-2/Why-3 but heading said "Two specific." Fixed to "Three." (3) **§16 cross-reference (4 threads)**: `CURRENT-aaron §16` is "Ethical clean-room services," not host-mutation. Stale `§16 host-mutation` references in MEMORY.md and CURRENT-aaron-§45-carve-out fixed to point at the actual derivation (Otto-357 + no-spending-increase carve-out + task #343 drift-debt receipt) and `docs/WONT-DO.md` respectively, with explicit notes about the phantom-§16 history so future readers see why the reference moved. (4) **Latest-paired-edit single-slot violation**: I added a new Fast-path marker without removing the existing one. Removed the redundant marker; replaced with a back-reference comment. (5) **doctrine → canon**: per `feedback_canon_not_doctrine_star_wars_not_religious_aaron_2026_04_30.md`, the body-of-rules umbrella term is canon. Fixed both occurrences in the file. All 11 threads resolved via GraphQL mutation. CI checks should re-run on the push. Cron 98fc7424 healthy. | [PR #1006: 11→0 unresolved] | The threads were ALL real findings — every single one identified a real issue in my own substrate that I had missed during authoring. Codex P1 caught the internal inconsistency; Copilot caught the §16 phantom-reference (4 separate places); Copilot caught the heading count mismatch; Copilot caught the canon-vs-doctrine vocabulary drift; Copilot caught the single-slot violation. This is exactly the class-level pattern B-0126's 4-layer encoding addresses: each finding fixed instance-level here, each finding ALSO encodes a class-level rule for future-Otto authoring (e.g., when claiming `§NN reference X`, verify section title before committing; when adding a "single-slot" marker, remove the prior one in the same edit; when using "doctrine," check the canon-not-doctrine rule). Future-tick: similar drain on #1008 (9 unresolved threads, green CI) is the natural next move. |