MLLM-Bench

MLLM-Bench: Evaluating Multimodal LLMs with Per-sample Criteria

📃 Paper • 🌐 Website • 🤗 HuggingFace

🌈 Update

• [2024.4.27] V3 data, benchmark reuslts, leaderboard and arxiv paper are updated. We keep all the per-sample criteria at evaluation private. However, we provide a submission entry for FREE evaluations. Check it out!

• [2024.1.7] V2 data, reuslts and leaderboard are updated.

• [2023.11.18] 🎉🎉🎉 This repo is made public!🎉🎉🎉

Leaderboard

We present the results of voting using LLaVA-v1.5-13B as anchor. The numbers denote win/tie/lose of a benchmarked model over LLaVA-v1.5-13B. See more results of different evaluation protocols and anchors in our paper. The information of benchmarked models is here.

Rank	Models	Perception	Understanding	Applying	Analyzing	Evaluation	Creation	Win Rates over LLaVA-v1.5-13B
🏅️	GPT-4o	64/5/1	98/11/1	50/8/2	86/9/5	40/0/0	38/1/1	0.90
🥈	Claude-3	56/13/1	98/9/3	45/11/4	83/14/3	33/5/2	33/6/1	0.83
🥉	GPT-4V	56/10/4	101/6/3	29/12/19	73/22/5	33/2/5	2/0/38	0.70
4	LLaVA-v1.6-34B	46/17/7	78/22/10	36/15/9	61/28/11	33/3/4	24/10/6	0.66
5	LLaVA-v1.6-Vicuna-13B	40/21/9	65/33/12	35/19/6	51/26/23	33/5/2	27/9/4	0.60
6	LLaVA-v1.6-Vicuna-7B	31/25/14	56/37/17	26/23/11	40/31/29	22/10/8	19/10/11	0.46
7	ALLaVA-3B-Longer	22/21/27	57/30/23	23/17/20	44/30/26	16/10/14	17/12/11	0.43
8	Gemini-1.0-Pro	45/10/15	36/35/39	24/19/17	33/28/39	9/8/23	16/8/16	0.39
9	Qwen-VL-Chat	34/22/14	38/36/36	26/18/16	35/29/36	15/6/19	9/12/19	0.37
10	LVIS	22/28/20	32/39/39	11/27/22	33/36/31	14/9/17	9/16/15	0.29
11	mPLUG-Owl2	16/24/30	30/34/46	17/17/26	23/38/39	15/8/17	11/14/15	0.27
12	LLaVA-v1.5-7B	19/22/29	27/47/36	13/29/18	21/43/36	9/14/17	8/13/19	0.23
13	MiniGPT-v2	12/25/33	24/32/54	11/25/24	17/38/45	9/9/22	6/6/28	0.19
14	InstructBLIP	15/16/39	13/36/61	6/23/31	13/29/58	10/7/23	4/9/27	0.15
15	Cheetor	12/20/38	7/27/76	10/22/28	16/23/61	4/4/32	3/4/33	0.12
16	SEED-LLaMA	16/15/39	5/25/80	10/21/29	7/25/68	3/7/30	3/3/34	0.10
17	kosmos2	6/22/42	6/18/86	6/15/39	10/20/70	1/4/35	2/3/35	0.07
18	Yi-VL-6B	4/17/49	8/22/80	5/27/28	5/29/66	3/9/28	3/9/28	0.07
19	Fuyu-8B	7/19/44	7/27/76	6/14/40	4/22/74	3/7/30	0/6/34	0.06
20	LWM	2/18/50	5/15/90	4/21/35	2/18/80	3/2/35	2/6/32	0.04
21	OpenFlamingo	8/13/49	2/8/100	3/14/43	2/21/77	1/2/37	1/5/34	0.04
22	BLIP2	3/13/54	2/15/93	6/8/46	0/22/78	0/1/39	0/2/38	0.03

Usage

Environment Setup

Click to expand

Install required packages:

pip install -r requirements.txt

Update transformers (we used 4.36.0.dev0):

pip install git+https://github.com/huggingface/transformers

Answer Generation

Click to expand

• Configurate accelerate settings. We use bf16 inference by default. If this is not supported by your device, set downcast_bf16 to false and mixed_precision to fp16.

• Add model information in configs/model_configs.yaml

• Create a model worker in workers/model_workers.py. The worker should inherit BaseWorker. Rewrite init_components() and forward() method. Explanations of parameters and outputs of the two methods are in workers/baseworker.py.

• Run bash generate.sh.

Self-Evaluation

Click to expand

• Prepare the data in the format as shown in data/anchor.json, note that the key "unique_idx", "gen_model_id", and "answer" are required. Move your data under data folder.

• Modify the parameters in evaluate.sh, especially "model_name" and "model2_path".

• Put your OpenAI API key in evaluate.py, please make sure you have access to model "gpt-4-vision-preview".

• Run bash evaluate.sh.

• Run cd scripts & bash evaluate4elo.sh for elo rating.

• NOTE: The per sample criteria are not provided for self-evaluate and this self-evaluation process is just used for your reference. If you wish your results to be displayed on the leaderboard, please refer to Submission for Leaderboard.

Submission for Leaderboard

Refer to instructions here.

Citation

@misc{ge2024mllmbench,
      title={MLLM-Bench: Evaluating Multimodal LLMs with Per-sample Criteria}, 
      author={Wentao Ge and Shunian Chen and Guiming Hardy Chen and Zhihong Chen and Junying Chen and Shuo Yan and Chenghao Zhu and Ziyue Lin and Wenya Xie and Xinyi Zhang and Yichen Chai and Xiaoyu Liu and Nuo Chen and Dingjie Song and Xidong Wang and Anningzhe Gao and Zhiyi Zhang and Jianquan Li and Xiang Wan and Benyou Wang},
      year={2024},
      eprint={2311.13951},
      archivePrefix={arXiv},
      primaryClass={cs.CL}
}

Star History