docs(taxonomy): #498 AIF scale-up phase 3 — Influence + Tricherie + Obstruction (27 fallacies, triple-AIF, rebut-type appears)

[jsboige]

#498 AIF Scale-up — Phase 3: Influence + Tricherie + Obstruction (27 fallacies, triple-AIF)

GATED PROPOSAL — docs/taxonomy/ only (md + annotation CSV). No production Fallacies CSV change. Bases on master, independent of phase 2 (#542) merge — reviewable on its own merits. Awaiting ai-01 structural review + jsboige content approval.

Scope

27 depth-3 fallacies = 9 leaves × 3 families (Influence pks 177–511, Tricherie pks 889–1242, Obstruction pks 1282–1398). These three families were entirely unannotated before this batch. With phases 1+2 (23 fallacies) + phase 3 (27), AIF depth-3 coverage reaches 50/63 (79%).

The rebut type finally appears (the headline)

Phases 1–2 (evidence/premise + rule families) produced rebut 0/23 — every fallacy was a bad premise (undermine) or inapplicable rule (undercut). Phase 3 introduces the rebut attack-type (3 cases), exactly where the rhetorical/divergence families license it:

pk	Fallacy	Type	CA_node
1282	Relativisme abusif	rebut → conclusion	CounterConclusionConflict
1313	Évasion	rebut → conclusion	IssueAvoidance
1361	Procès en incohérence	rebut → conclusion	TuQuoque

Distribution: undermine 20 / undercut 4 / rebut 3

Family	undermine	undercut	rebut	signature
Influence (9)	9	0	0	pure persuasion = loaded premise (schemes disperse across persuasion catalog)
Tricherie (9)	6	3	0	deception = false premise + double-standard rule shifts (special-pleading trio)
Obstruction (9)	5	1	3	derailment = source attacks + counter-claims/tu-quoque

Verification (3 independent layers, re-checked vs real 1408-row Fallacies CSV)

• 27/27 annotated, 0 violations. Ground-truth: all 27 present, unique, depth=3, correct family.
• ASPIC+ coherence (attack_type ↔ attacked_component): PASS.
• Anti-fab validator tools(taxonomy): reusable anti-fab validator for scale-up CSVs #518: ✓ CLEAN — 27 rows, 0 HARD, 0 WARN (kind=aif-scaleup).
• md ↔ CSV char-for-char: 0 issues (table built from CSV ground truth, curly apostrophes preserved — same paraphrase-bug guard as batches 7a/6b).

Files

• docs/taxonomy/498-aif-scaleup-phase3.md (proposal)
• docs/taxonomy/498-scaleup-phase3-annotations.csv (27-row annotation)

What this does NOT do

• ❌ Does not edit production Argumentum Fallacies - Taxonomy.csv.
• ❌ Does not complete depth-3 coverage — 13 stragglers remain (phase 4 mopup: 4 Abus langage + 3 Err raisonn + 3 Err math + 3 Insuffisance).

Phase progression (ASPIC+ prediction confirmed)

• Phase 1: undercut-dominant (rule/language families)
• Phase 2: undermine 6 / undercut 6 / rebut 0 (evidence/premise families)
• Phase 3: undermine 20 / undercut 4 / rebut 3 (rhetorical/divergence families) ← rebut appears here

🤖 Worker myia-po-2024