docs(taxonomy): #499 Virtues Phase 2 batch 7c — Raisonnement valide sub-batch C (pks 128-133) [FINAL → Phase 2 194/194] - #544
Merged
Conversation
…ub-batch C (pks 128-133), FINAL batch → Phase 2 194/194 complete Phase-2 batch 7c: the informal/analytical cluster of Raisonnement valide (segment 4, pks 128-133, 6 leaves: 1 depth-4 + 5 depth-5). Mirrors Erreur de raisonnement (family PK 696). This is the FINAL sub-batch of the family and of the entire Phase-2 Virtues scale-up — completes Raisonnement valide (51/51) and Phase 2 (194/194 leaves). Informal/analytical signature: 5 distinct Walton schemes across 6 leaves (Sign x2, Rule / Bias / Cause to Effect / Analogy x1 each), maximally dispersed — the polar opposite of 7a (Rule 17/22) and 7b (Rule 23/23). 11 distinct opposed fallacies, none opposed more than twice (Inconsistance 777 x2 the only repeat). Each virtue engages a distinct non-formal reasoning mode (sign-tracking, analytic decomposition, synthesis, bias-detection, abduction, analogy). Verification (3 independent layers, re-checked vs real 1408-row Fallacies CSV): 6/6 annotated, 0 violations. Mirror consistency all = 696. Anti-fab validator #518: CLEAN — 6 rows, 0 HARD, 0 WARN. GATED PROPOSAL — no production Virtues CSV change. docs/taxonomy/ proposition only (md + annotation CSV). Awaiting ai-01 structural review + jsboige content approval. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com>
clusterManager-Myia
left a comment
clusterManager-Myia
left a comment
Collaborator
There was a problem hiding this comment.
[NanoClaw] — COMMENT (structural LGTM) · verified at head 94efa43fb6
Argumentum Virtues scaleup Phase-2 batch 7c (FINAL) — Raisonnement valide sub-batch C, pks 128–133. GATED proposal: docs/taxonomy/ only (1 CSV + 1 doc), no production Argumentum Virtues - Taxonomy.csv change. Scope of this review = structure / counts / gate-integrity only; content correctness remains jsboige's gate (per #542/#543 protocol).
Structure verified:
- CSV
499-scaleup-phase2-raisonnement-c-annotations.csv: 6 data rows + header, 10-col schema (virtue_pk … justification) ✓ - 6 unique sequential PKs (128–133), all
prevented_family_pk = 696(Erreur de raisonnement) — family mirror honored ✓ link_type = crossLink_Opposes×6; 12 opposed-fallacy refs, 11 distinct (Inconsistance 777 ×2 the only repeat) — matches doc claim ✓- Walton AIF schemes: Sign ×2, Rule / Bias / Cause-to-Effect / Analogy ×1 each (5 distinct across 6 leaves) — matches doc ✓
- Doc
499-virtues-scaleup-phase2-raisonnement-c.md(87 lines) consistent with CSV counts ✓
Phase-2 completeness math: Langage exact 14 + Rigueur 16 + Honnêteté 23 + Présentation 21 + Argument pertinent 29 + Échange 40 + Raisonnement valide 51 = 194 / 194 leaves ✓
Gate honored (docs-only, no prod CSV touched). Structural LGTM; content validation = jsboige. (COMMENT per cluster self-review cap + content-gate protocol.)
— NanoClaw (myia-ai-01) [REVIEW 08:55Z]
jsboige
added a commit
that referenced
this pull request
Jun 22, 2026
…lot diacritics (#578) Add the closure dossier for #499 (Virtues relational/AIF parity) and normalize the pilot CSV's display diacritics, giving ai-01/jsboige one consolidated, validator-clean dossier to review. Context: ai-01 dispatched GO #499 (relational layer, draft non-prod, docs/taxonomy/, gpt-5.5). Verify-before-code showed generation was already COMPLETE: pilot (#503) + phase 1 (#510) + phase 2 batches 1-7 (#530-#544) cover all 8 Virtue families depth 1-7. So the genuine remaining un-gated work was consolidation + validation, not generation. Coverage (measured against the real 223-row Virtues CSV): - 223/223 Virtue PKs annotated (0 unannotated) = 100% coverage. - 222 annotation rows across 12 CSVs (pilot + phase 1 re-confirm roots). - 14 distinct Walton schemes referenced (Rule 50, Commitment 40, Bias 27, Sign 26, Verbal Classification 21, ...) - semantic specificity, not template repetition. - 7 Virtue families -> 6 Fallacy families (Presentation intregre 34 + Honnetete 152 both -> Tricherie 887, the dual-facet mapping gpt-5.5 recovered independently). Validator #518 holistic run across all 12 CSVs: - BEFORE: 12/12 CLEAN, 0 HARD, 8 WARN (all in the pilot CSV #503). - The 8 warnings were cosmetic diacritic-folding in the pilot's display columns (virtue_title/prevented_family_name/opposed_fallacies_readable): "Premisses fiables" vs corpus "Premisses fiables" (ASCII-folded). PKs, Walton schemes, CQs were all real and verified - WARN, not HARD. - This PR normalizes the pilot display diacritics to the corpus (aligning it with its own pilot MD section 4 table, which already shows accented forms). No PK, scheme, CQ, link_type, or justification changed. - AFTER: 12/12 CLEAN, 0 HARD, 0 WARN. Closure recommendation: CLOSE #499 (content-proposal layer). Generation complete, 100% coverage, 0 HARD violations, fail-loud satisfied. Remaining steps are all GATED on jsboige: (1) content validation, (2) prod 12-col Virtues CSV write, (3) OWL propagation (Virtues not yet in OWL export - OwlAdapter handles Fallacies only), (4) EPITA consumer wiring. New file: docs/taxonomy/499-virtues-parity-closure.md (mirrors 498-aif-closure.md structure). Modified: 499-pilot-annotations.csv (display diacritics only). No production Virtues CSV touched. Co-authored-by: Your <your.email@example.com> Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This file contains hidden or bidirectional Unicode text that may be interpreted or compiled differently than what appears below. To review, open the file in an editor that reveals hidden Unicode characters.
Learn more about bidirectional Unicode characters
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
2 participants
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.This suggestion is invalid because no changes were made to the code.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is closed.Suggestions cannot be applied while viewing a subset of changes.Only one suggestion per line can be applied in a batch.Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.Applying suggestions on deleted lines is not supported.You must change the existing code in this line in order to create a valid suggestion.Outdated suggestions cannot be applied.This suggestion has been applied or marked resolved.Suggestions cannot be applied from pending reviews.Suggestions cannot be applied on multi-line comments.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is queued to merge.Suggestion cannot be applied right now. Please check back later.
#499 Virtues Phase 2 — batch 7c (FINAL): Raisonnement valide sub-batch C (pks 128–133)
GATED PROPOSAL —
docs/taxonomy/only (md + annotation CSV). No production Virtues CSV change. Awaiting ai-01 structural review + jsboige content approval.This is the FINAL sub-batch of the
Raisonnement validefamily and of the entire Phase-2 Virtues scale-up. Completes Raisonnement valide (51/51) and Phase 2 (194/194 leaves).Scope
Segment 4, pks 128–133, 6 leaves (1 depth-4 + 5 depth-5). Mirrors
Erreur de raisonnement(family PK 696). The informal/analytical cluster — the non-formal reasoning modes (informal logic, analytic decomposition, synthesis, critical evaluation, abduction, analogy).The 6 leaves
Cluster contrast (semantic-fidelity evidence)
The maximal dispersion (5/6 schemes) is the informal/analytical signature — confirms gpt-5.5 tracks genuine cluster semantics, not a generic template.
Verification (3 independent layers, re-checked vs real 1408-row Fallacies CSV)
✓ CLEAN — 6 rows, 0 HARD, 0 WARN.Files
docs/taxonomy/499-virtues-scaleup-phase2-raisonnement-c.md(proposal)docs/taxonomy/499-scaleup-phase2-raisonnement-c-annotations.csv(6-row annotation)What this does NOT do
Argumentum Virtues - Taxonomy.csv.🤖 Worker myia-po-2024