Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Whining or Ground Loop noise on calls and music #181

Open
mbt28 opened this issue Nov 15, 2023 · 9 comments
Open

Whining or Ground Loop noise on calls and music #181

mbt28 opened this issue Nov 15, 2023 · 9 comments

Comments

@mbt28
Copy link

mbt28 commented Nov 15, 2023

Hi Ted,

I have the V2 board with latest firmware. I hear the alternator noise from the speakers, I can even listen convertible servo sounds from speakers :) . This problem exists when I choose bluebus as a source, fm and others are fine.

How can I resolve this issue without attaching additional ground loop isolator? I think the board is okay but something wrong with my wiring.

Thanks

@pyrophan
Copy link

Can confirm same issues with V2 on latest firmware in a 1999 e39 without DSP.

Only happens when the vehicle volume is turned up a lot. Usually turning up the Bluetooth source volume up allows use of a lower vehicle volume and avoids the issue.

@tedsalmon
Copy link
Owner

@mbt28

What's the aversion to the ground loop isolator?

Typically, the root cause of this is issues with the rectifier diodes in the voltage regulator for the alternator, whence why the whine follows RPM. PWM from the throttle actuator can also introduce this noise.

In both cases, the GLI is the easiest fix :o

@pyrophan

This is pretty normal -- you're probably hearing I-Bus interference, which will sound like digital clicking noises, rather than a whine that follows RPM, right?

Thanks!
-Ted

@mbt28
Copy link
Author

mbt28 commented Nov 20, 2023

Hi Ted,

But why I don't have it if I listen FM radio but only in Bluetooth mode? Even if I don't listen something I can hear the hissing noise from the speakers. I doubt I have a problem with my ground wiring. My power ground is wired from chassis but there is also telephone audio input ground which is also wired to chassis on head unit stereo. Can the both pwr and tel ground connection from different part of the car cause the issue?

Regards,
Mehmet

@StefPedro
Copy link

Hi, i have the same issue on my 1999 523i. I've had the issue on my Business CD (CD43) made by Blaupunkt, but have retrofitted original navigation with BM54 and HiFi (not DSP) and i hear clicking noises at high volumes, especially in quiet parts of songs.

@tedsalmon
Copy link
Owner

Hi Ted,

But why I don't have it if I listen FM radio but only in Bluetooth mode? Even if I don't listen something I can hear the hissing noise from the speakers. I doubt I have a problem with my ground wiring. My power ground is wired from chassis but there is also telephone audio input ground which is also wired to chassis on head unit stereo. Can the both pwr and tel ground connection from different part of the car cause the issue?

Regards, Mehmet

The A/C whine is bleeding into the power input on the BlueBus, then getting piped back out the line level audio output -- this is why it doesn't exist in other audio modes. Different ground levels could cause issues, but the most likely answer is the rectifier diodes in the alternator's vreg. Can you expound on why a ground loop isolator isn't an option? It's the cheapest, easiest fix :)

@tedsalmon
Copy link
Owner

Hi, i have the same issue on my 1999 523i. I've had the issue on my Business CD (CD43) made by Blaupunkt, but have retrofitted original navigation with BM54 and HiFi (not DSP) and i hear clicking noises at high volumes, especially in quiet parts of songs.

Version 1 or Version 2 BlueBus? If you do not know, what color is the LED on the unit? Blue means it's a v2.

If it's a V1, you need to make sure that your phone volume is all the way on max while streaming.

However, what you're experiencing is normal, it just shouldn't be audible over road noise and the music itself while driving.

What you're hearing is impulsive interference from the I/K-Bus that is bleeding into the line level audio input from the CD Changer into the radio.

Thanks!
-Ted

@StefPedro
Copy link

Hi, i have the same issue on my 1999 523i. I've had the issue on my Business CD (CD43) made by Blaupunkt, but have retrofitted original navigation with BM54 and HiFi (not DSP) and i hear clicking noises at high volumes, especially in quiet parts of songs.

Version 1 or Version 2 BlueBus? If you do not know, what color is the LED on the unit? Blue means it's a v2.

If it's a V1, you need to make sure that your phone volume is all the way on max while streaming.

However, what you're experiencing is normal, it just shouldn't be audible over road noise and the music itself while driving.

What you're hearing is impulsive interference from the I/K-Bus that is bleeding into the line level audio input from the CD Changer into the radio.

Thanks!

-Ted

It is a V2. I was worried that I had something installed wrong, but if it's normal it's ok. When driving I don't hear it, only when stationary and listening loudly.

@redssu
Copy link
Contributor

redssu commented Jan 4, 2024

Hey,

I also have the V2 board and I also hear the alternator whining, how can I connect a ground loop isolator to BlueBus to reduce the whining?

@SecT0uch
Copy link

If anyone is interested here is how I managed to install a ground loop isolator:

I bought this model: Europe US

The case is glued together, but I managed to open it.

Do not trust the wiring color code inside, I tested with a mutimeter and here is the correct wiring:

  • Yellow: Ground
  • White: Right
  • Red: Left

Then you can desold the wires, cut the cables of the adaper and sold them back-on the GLI.
Double check the corresponding wires with the help of this image:
image

The result should look like:
IMG_20240129_112858_737
(Bluebus connector on the left side)

IMG_20240129_113104_473

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

6 participants