From 3f48d48ee604430bca1d11d248d98229a5ccc704 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: seathatflowsinourveins <234074349+seathatflowsinourveins@users.noreply.github.com> Date: Tue, 6 Oct 2026 14:17:54 -0400 Subject: [PATCH 1/4] Record the CC north-star start line and corrected forecast --- .../2026-10-06-north-star-start-line.md | 58 ++++ .../2026-10-06-ns2604-native-bar-recount.md | 2 + .../ns2604-native-bar-20261006/README.md | 12 +- .../ns2604-native-bar-20261006/board.json | 277 ++++++++++++++++-- 4 files changed, 323 insertions(+), 26 deletions(-) create mode 100644 docs/decisions/2026-10-06-north-star-start-line.md diff --git a/docs/decisions/2026-10-06-north-star-start-line.md b/docs/decisions/2026-10-06-north-star-start-line.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..5a78a0384 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/decisions/2026-10-06-north-star-start-line.md @@ -0,0 +1,58 @@ +# North-star R&D start line — October 6, 2026 + +The command center selects an independently reviewed, adjudicated S4 on the same 80 native-bar slots as the R&D start line. This records the CC's evidence-led delegated decision; it paraphrases the reported user delegation and contains no verbatim user quotation. It does not declare that the start line has been met. + +The current board partitions into **27 recorded operational closures, 40 currently open foundation prerequisites, 12 open interim rows, and one upstream distribution hold**. The 40 are the remaining prerequisite rows, not a replacement denominator: all 80 stay in S4. There are 68 foundation-prerequisite flags across the full inventory, including the closed rows and distribution hold. + +Before the CC opens a new R&D wave: + +- The 40 remaining prerequisite rows must be READY, BY_DESIGN, or covered by an accepted dated exclusion; prior closures and unresolved critic corrections are also reviewed in S4. +- Memory-owner and the 11 token rows may be INTERIM, each with a dated plan to finish alongside R&D. Required plans are not claimed fulfilled: token comparison run dates are still unverified. +- Base-distribution keeps its upstream-release hold. +- The CC adjudicates the independent review of the complete same-80-slot S4. Installation, a PR merge, tool visibility or an unsigned aggregate is insufficient. + +The interim token set is context-supply, command-output, output-compression, code-index, code-graph, repo-packing, structured-data, doc-conversion, api-docs, trace-viewer and token-lane-carriers. Memory is the twelfth interim row. ccusage and statusline remain prerequisite rows. + +## Corrected forecast and alternative + +**Earliest: Friday, October 9, 6:00 PM EDT (22:00Z)**, on the organic path, only if every step succeeds on its first attempt. **Likely: Tuesday, October 13, 6:00 PM EDT (22:00Z)**; reported range **October 12–14**, with low confidence. These are conditional R&D-start forecasts, not a measured delivery date or an owner commitment. + +The adversarial refuter requires the tools-wave relaunch, organic observation, queue/repair/application work, valid #786 evidence, prerequisite closure, then independent S4 review and CC adjudication. The new window is October 6, 8:30 PM EDT (00:30Z on October 7). The paper heavy-work blackout remains October 6, 3:50–8:10 PM EDT (19:50Z–00:10Z next day). Future windows and actual quotas must be checked before any run. + +The alternative is to require full **79/80 before R&D**. It has **no evidence-based date**: memory and token comparisons have separate unfinished plans, and the token A/B has no established run date. The old board's October 8 lower bound and October 9 full-readiness target are superseded as a forecast. Full 79/80 remains a separate objective; the 80th distribution row stays externally gated. + +This decision is overturned by an independently reviewed S4 that fails a required predicate, a CC ruling reopening a recorded closure, evidence that an interim capability is indispensable to the next R&D task without a dated completion plan, or a new evidence-bound CC decision changing the start criteria. A revised date requires measured progress and a new adversarial dependency/throughput review. + +## Pulled-forward prerequisite and critic rulings + +Betterleaks' accountable board owner is **github-ci-finalize**. After GO-RELAUNCH, that owner must complete the authorized P1 swap test before October 9 or record an accepted dated exclusion. Use **October 8, 8:00 PM EDT (2026-10-09T00:00Z)** as the conservative exclusive UTC boundary for the pull-forward, rather than the ambiguous legacy month-day-only gate. This records the dispatch requirement, not a run or an exclusion. + +Two counted closures require a CC ruling. Preserve the operational 27 pending that ruling: + +| Slot | Critic issue and current counterevidence | +| --- | --- | +| credential-guard | Rebaseline critic lines 20–21 required the designed fresh Codex canary or a ruling on one-leg evidence. The later retained job-1 result lines 3–7 supplies Codex item exit 0, canary absent, an explicit-present control exit 1 and launcher-presence exit 0. CC must bind it with the separate Claude evidence and decide whether the gate is met. | +| convergence-validators | Critic lines 25–26 identifies a conflict between the infrastructure definition and the adjudication's session-invocation rationale. CC must justify the intended CI-only consumer with evidence or require the model-chosen per-script organic proof. Passing local tests do not settle this classification. | + +No autonomous demotion or readiness promotion follows this documentary record. + +## Closed user-item batch, with execution still distinguished + +The CC reports git identity resolved by global, main-checkout and lane-worktree readbacks using the intended GitHub identity and a GitHub noreply address. The older plan identity is stale. This removes a user-decision dependency, not git's native operation/use gates. + +D01 and D04 have authorization under the prior comprehensive-resolution direction. Apply and readback are still CC-owned and pending. The private exact-step packet names D01's supported native plugin removal and D04's reviewed additive profile writer; current main's create-only profile step cannot be claimed to fill an existing profile. The source prerequisite is explicit. No host change is performed by this PR. + +ccusage is **offline-only**, the monitoring plan's G6 cross-check; it needs no new sign-in. Retain its offline acceptance, controls and accounting boundaries. + +Playwright site sign-ins receive a dated **start-line exclusion**, because the other web tools cover web retrieval. This does not exclude every browser modality or establish native browser acceptance. Chrome system-package installation is covered by the reported workstation authorization; the CC/operator owns any apply action. This lane performs no sudo operation. + +Existing Wave 1 proceeds only as runtime-qualification evidence under its own gates. Draft-only preparation explicitly permitted by the CC remains separate. No new R&D wave begins before this start line. Evidence is carried to the trading home through the already selected setup path. + +## Evidence and publication + +Primary authority: command-center item `task-ns2604-coop-20261006T175007Z`, SHA256 `9d251e3416ec4081ad1889c52493e592372ab70fd159b63d9f1aa8f6763e3f2f`. The supporting workflow `wf_f004715f-5a4` has SHA256 `dc294eb428aaabfcf2070208cb6f65edf8c1f01ca5744b1b81e4b03e6fbb3f70`; its refuter and 23-finding completeness critic are retained. These are source-review/adjudication records, not new acceptance execution. + +The [board](../../evidence/artifacts/ns2604-native-bar-20261006/board.json) records the new start-line forecast separately from the unknown full-79 date, named dispatches, scoped user-item resolutions and unresolved critic rulings. Historical 30/80 and unmeasured final S4 remain separate. Root has no installation, provider, trial or configuration authority from this source change. + +Publish through the co-op GPT read, CC acknowledgment and 5f queue. Registry and dashboard checkpoint stay in the last commit. Native dashboard generation readback remains a separate CC/co-op step. + diff --git a/docs/decisions/2026-10-06-ns2604-native-bar-recount.md b/docs/decisions/2026-10-06-ns2604-native-bar-recount.md index e4ade24df..b3f79fe9b 100644 --- a/docs/decisions/2026-10-06-ns2604-native-bar-recount.md +++ b/docs/decisions/2026-10-06-ns2604-native-bar-recount.md @@ -15,3 +15,5 @@ A new accepted per-slot native receipt, landed dated scope decision or CC-applie CC item task-ns2604-coop-20261006T140508Z holds client-side installs/re-wiring for semble, codebase-memory, jcodemunch, qmd, headroom, SocratiCode and the Codex RTK hook while workflow wf_8703c159-c6d prepares the ordered install plan and names step owners. Backend, index and PR work continues. The hold includes MCP registrations, hooks/trust, instruction files, P2-9 and P0-1 grant diffs. Operational owner acceptance does not override that client-change hold or grant configuration authority. The later accepted overlap-codenav closure transfers Serena and structural-search to readiness-runner with both closed=false. Their contract map and original controls/exposure/AST coverage conditions remain, and Serena joins its separate plan hold wf_5e8f452c-484. Consume only the authorized frozen #786 v1.1/G13 and named install-owner evidence when supplied; no independent trials. Exclusion is conjunctive per client: full-run zero organic choice, a chosen complete-task covering owner, and one upstream-native fix/rerun changing nothing. An uncovered class remains NOT-READY. #780 is frozen at50bf3c544db95c5121efd3229938148e21763b67 with no push/rebase/close until CC revival; #758 remains co-op/5f custody. No count changes follow this scope transfer. + +The later [north-star start-line decision](2026-10-06-north-star-start-line.md) supersedes this record's calendar forecast: conditional R&D start earliestOctober9/likelyOctober13, while full79/80 has no evidence-based date. It retains all80slots, currentreported27 and finalS4unknown; two critic corrections awaitCCruling. NewR&Dwaves wait for the selected reviewed/adjudicated S4, while existingWave1 is runtimequalification. No historical numerator or source receipt is rewritten. diff --git a/evidence/artifacts/ns2604-native-bar-20261006/README.md b/evidence/artifacts/ns2604-native-bar-20261006/README.md index 874567ccd..d8b08f6f6 100644 --- a/evidence/artifacts/ns2604-native-bar-20261006/README.md +++ b/evidence/artifacts/ns2604-native-bar-20261006/README.md @@ -6,7 +6,7 @@ Recorded at 2026-10-06T15:47:07Z against main `0d5e6506434fab598dee861c749a22e62 The exact durable census reported at 06:47Z supplies all 80 identifiers and the inherited native 26 baseline. PR #715 publishes custody's dated policy exclusion, resolving that row's publication gate. The historical #700 result remains 30/80. This board does not claim a fresh same-80-slot E2E, post-reboot native execution or final S4 qualification; that qualified count is unknown. -The north-star action is US-equities research and historical simulation on a finished native foundation. Trading research and paper operation retain their separate authorization and acceptance. +The north-star action is US-equities research and historical simulation on an evidence-bound foundation. The CC's new start-line decision gates new R&D waves on reviewed/adjudicated same-80-slot S4; existing Wave1 is runtime qualification only. Paper operation keeps its separate scope. | State | Slots | | --- | ---: | @@ -123,14 +123,20 @@ Hcom's bounded native terminal/hook/delivery observation, agentsview's successfu ## ETA and next refresh -Planning lower bound: **October 8, 6:00 PM EDT (22:00Z)**. Working target: **October 9, 6:00 PM EDT (22:00Z)**, with low confidence. This refresh removes the security queue blocker and custody publication gate, but retains the earlier lower bound. The Friday time is a planning target, not a newly measured or owner-committed completion date. +The CC's [north-star start line](../../../docs/decisions/2026-10-06-north-star-start-line.md) requires independently reviewed/adjudicated S4 on all80 slots:40 currently open prerequisites ready/by-design/dated-exclusion, memory+11token rows interim with dated completion plans, and the distribution hold retained. The full partition is27 recorded closures+40open prerequisites+12interim+1distribution=80; no denominator shrinks. Required interim dates are not claimed already fulfilled. -The path is individual handoff acknowledgment, scoped fixes or accepted dated exclusions, CC application/readbacks, exact-head reviews and 5f landings, then independently reviewed organic counts and S4. Account quotas and a held configuration freeze are unresolved inputs. No heavy phase runs from **October 6, 3:50 PM EDT to 8:10 PM EDT (19:50Z–00:10Z on October 7)**. Future paper windows need current confirmation. +Conditional **R&D start**: earliest **October9,6PM EDT(22:00Z)**, organic path/all steps first-time; likely **October13,6PM EDT(22:00Z)**, reported rangeOctober12–14, lowconfidence. **Full79/80 has no evidence-based date.** The old full-readiness forecast is superseded; these dates do not forecast79/80 or declare S4 complete. + +The path is individual handoff acknowledgment, scoped fixes or accepted dated exclusions, CC application/readbacks, exact-head reviews and 5f landings, then independently reviewed organic counts and CC-adjudicated S4. Betterleaks ownergithub-ci-finalize must pull its P1 test before2026-10-09 afterGO or obtain a dated exclusion. Two counted closures (credential-guard and convergence-validators) carry critic corrections for CC ruling; the later guard canary counterevidence is retained. Reported27 remainspending those rulings. Account quotas and a held configuration freeze are unresolved inputs. No heavy phase runs from **October 6, 3:50 PM EDT to 8:10 PM EDT (19:50Z–00:10Z on October 7)**. Future paper windows need current confirmation. The CC's workflow `wf_8703c159-c6d` holds client-side installs and re-wiring for semble, codebase-memory, jcodemunch, qmd, headroom, SocratiCode and the Codex RTK hook. MCP registrations, hooks/trust, instruction files, P2-9 and P0-1 grant diffs wait for that plan to name step owners. Backend, index and PR work continues. This board grants no client-change authority. On each landing or accepted configuration/decision change, readiness-runner updates only the affected rows from the new evidence, recalculates all 80 rows, keeps failed conditions and reviews intact, and refreshes the same checkpoint gate. A landing with no full-slot effect is recorded without increasing the numerator. No background poller or new monitor is introduced. +## Closed user-decision batch + +The CC reports git identity resolved by global/main/lane readback. D01/D04 authorization is resolved but CC apply/readback still awaits tonight's window and the reviewed D04 source prerequisite. ccusage is offline-only monitoringG6, with no new sign-in. Playwright site sign-ins are excluded from the start line for web retrieval; this is not blanket browser acceptance/exclusion. Chrome package authorization is reported settled; no sudo or host apply occurred here. See the dated decision and board fields for scope. + ## Dashboard publication The existing `new-wsl-distribution-20261002` gate links this complete board and summarizes the count/owner. It preserves the supported inventory: 118 entities, or 128 with all ten native Dagu runs. The table provides one linked summary, not 80 independent live rows or a new owner column. diff --git a/evidence/artifacts/ns2604-native-bar-20261006/board.json b/evidence/artifacts/ns2604-native-bar-20261006/board.json index 7d0c5de96..6a849bc9e 100644 --- a/evidence/artifacts/ns2604-native-bar-20261006/board.json +++ b/evidence/artifacts/ns2604-native-bar-20261006/board.json @@ -1,7 +1,7 @@ { "schema_version": 1, "kind": "native_bar_operational_recount", - "recorded_at_utc": "2026-10-06T15:47:07Z", + "recorded_at_utc": "2026-10-06T17:50:07Z", "host_scope": "NativeStack2604", "source_revision": "0d5e6506434fab598dee861c749a22e628beb75a", "north_star_action": "Finish the native foundation used for US-equities research and historical simulation; research and paper operation continue under their separate gates.", @@ -153,20 +153,14 @@ ] }, "eta_to_79": { - "assessment_at_utc": "2026-10-06T14:17:29Z", - "earliest_planning_bound_utc": "2026-10-08T22:00:00Z", - "working_planning_target_utc": "2026-10-09T22:00:00Z", - "confidence": "low", + "assessment_at_utc": "2026-10-06T17:50:07Z", + "earliest_planning_bound_utc": null, + "working_planning_target_utc": null, + "confidence": "no evidence-based date", "owner_committed_delivery": false, - "basis": "Refreshed dependency assessment after five landings and custody's policy closure. The prior earliest bound is retained; Friday 22:00Z is a planning target, not a measured or owner-committed completion time. No unsupported acceleration is inferred from landings. The co-op has now accepted the 18 owner handoffs; individual lane acknowledgment and the CC client-install plan remain separate dependencies.", - "constraints": [ - "52 additional operational closures and an independently reviewed same-80-slot S4 remain.", - "Individual lane handoff acceptance, D01/D04 and other CC scope/configuration readbacks must be resolved; seven named token tools remain under the CC client-wiring hold.", - "5f owns queued PR writes/landing; connector threads and exact-head reviews precede queues.", - "Organic counts, account quota gates and a held configuration freeze remain unmeasured dependencies.", - "No heavy phase from 2026-10-06T19:50:00Z through 2026-10-07T00:10:00Z; future paper windows need current confirmation.", - "Base-distribution stays externally blocked and is excluded only from the 79 ceiling, never from the 80 denominator." - ] + "basis": "CC start-line decision supersedes the old full-readiness forecast. Corrected October9/13 dates forecast conditional R&D start, not full79/80.", + "remaining_operational_closures": 52, + "final_s4_qualified_count": null }, "dashboard_delivery": { "route": "Replace the existing new-wsl-distribution-20261002 checkpoint gate with a summary and evidence link to this complete board.", @@ -401,6 +395,20 @@ "sha256": "170fb4618e7142b169d819c2b26dcff2eb4b27defee6550ef659bf981c5457d6", "evidence_class": "source_review", "scope": "Frozen accepted scope/custody transfer, exact input digests, separate native gates and conjunctive exclusion rule; no native execution." + }, + { + "id": "cc-start-line", + "locator": "coordination:command-center/ITEM-ns2604-coop-20261006T175007Z.md", + "sha256": "9d251e3416ec4081ad1889c52493e592372ab70fd159b63d9f1aa8f6763e3f2f", + "evidence_class": "source_review", + "scope": "CC start-line/closed user-decision batch; no new native acceptance by this publication." + }, + { + "id": "start-line-refutation", + "locator": "coordination:e2e-truth-20261006/north-star-eta-wf_f004715f-5a4.json", + "sha256": "dc294eb428aaabfcf2070208cb6f65edf8c1f01ca5744b1b81e4b03e6fbb3f70", + "evidence_class": "source_review", + "scope": "Synthesis, adversarial corrected R&D-start forecast and23-finding completeness critic." } ], "slots": [ @@ -422,7 +430,7 @@ "pointer": "/slots/native-clients~1claude-code" } ], - "remaining_gate": "D01 configuration/scope decision and native readback; fresh session proof." + "remaining_gate": "D01 authorization resolved; CC applies supported plugin/marketplace removal or its approved scope route and retains readback, then fresh intended-profile qualification. Ordinary F9 excludes this policy and does not alone close it." }, { "slot": "native-clients/codex", @@ -442,7 +450,7 @@ "pointer": "/slots/native-clients~1codex" } ], - "remaining_gate": "D04 stack-worker-route scope or approved configuration/readback; fresh session proof. The service-tier migration source alone does not close it." + "remaining_gate": "D04 authorization resolved; CC selects the reviewed additive profile source, applies codex-files with both-profile backups/readbacks and retains fresh stack-worker route proof after GO. Current-main create-only F9 is not claimed as a repair." }, { "slot": "agent-sdks/claude-agent-sdk", @@ -972,7 +980,12 @@ "scope": "Co-op accepted and is delivering the named handoff; individual lane acknowledgment is not independently verified." } ], - "remaining_gate": "User sudo consent and sign-ins, rerun after_sign_in; else dated exclusion for text retrieval (overlaps Codex web/run)" + "remaining_gate": "CC dated start-line exclusion covers site-sign-in web retrieval; other web tools cover that scope. Browser installation/exposure and any retained native modality gates remain distinct. Chrome package authorization is resolved for CC/operator; no new user prompt or sudo by this lane.", + "start_line_exclusion": { + "source": "cc-start-line", + "scope": "site-sign-in web retrieval requirement", + "native_whole_slot_closed": false + } }, { "slot": "web-research/web-search-provider", @@ -1036,7 +1049,7 @@ "scope": "Co-op accepted and is delivering the named handoff; individual lane acknowledgment is not independently verified." } ], - "remaining_gate": "PLAN:148: sign in or exclude; weak exclusion candidate (overlaps agentsview, OTel token metrics)" + "remaining_gate": "Offline-only monitoring G6 cross-check, no sign-in; retain positive offline reports, condition-absent controls and separate native/accounting scope evidence." }, { "slot": "token-efficiency/context-supply", @@ -1744,7 +1757,7 @@ "pointer": "/slots/git-github-automation~1git" } ], - "remaining_gate": "Upstream test or native operation at pin (RUL:12); user identity confirmation; lean-rules re-measure" + "remaining_gate": "Git identity is resolved by CC readback. Retain pinned upstream/native operation, controls and organic-use evidence; no new identity prompt." }, { "slot": "git-github-automation/gh-github-cli", @@ -2028,7 +2041,14 @@ "pointer": "/slots/secrets-credentials~1betterleaks" } ], - "remaining_gate": "Set hooksPath (gitleaks 8.30.1 via mise aqua, or betterleaks with cited equivalence); run P1 swap test by 10-20" + "remaining_gate": "After GO-RELAUNCH, github-ci-finalize runs the authorized P1 swap test before2026-10-09 or obtains an accepted dated exclusion; conservative exclusive cutoff2026-10-09T00:00Z. Preserve evidence/refutation; no test or exclusion is claimed by this source update.", + "pull_forward": { + "owner": "github-ci-finalize", + "exclusive_target_utc": "2026-10-09T00:00:00Z", + "target_basis": "Conservative UTC date boundary to remove legacy year/time-zone ambiguity", + "go_relaunch_required": true, + "execution_status": "unrun in this update" + } }, { "slot": "secrets-credentials/trufflehog", @@ -2093,7 +2113,8 @@ "pointer": "/slots/cross:credential-practice~1credential-guard" } ], - "remaining_gate": "None in this operational scope; retain its source boundary and reopen on contrary evidence." + "remaining_gate": "None in this operational scope; retain its source boundary and reopen on contrary evidence.", + "critic_ruling_status": "pending CC" }, { "slot": "recovery-portability/mise", @@ -2173,7 +2194,8 @@ "pointer": "/slots/cross:convergence-practice~1convergence-validators" } ], - "remaining_gate": "None in this operational scope; retain its source boundary and reopen on contrary evidence." + "remaining_gate": "None in this operational scope; retain its source boundary and reopen on contrary evidence.", + "critic_ruling_status": "pending CC" } ], "client_wiring_hold": { @@ -2215,5 +2237,214 @@ "allowed_changes": "none until CC revival" }, "not_owned_pr": 758 - } + }, + "eta_to_rd_start": { + "assessment_at_utc": "2026-10-06T17:50:07Z", + "earliest_utc": "2026-10-09T22:00:00Z", + "likely_utc": "2026-10-13T22:00:00Z", + "reported_range_dates": [ + "2026-10-12", + "2026-10-14" + ], + "confidence": "low", + "owner_committed_delivery": false, + "path": "Organic; earliest only if every step succeeds first time.", + "source": "cc-start-line", + "constraints": [ + "Tools-wave GO-RELAUNCH and valid organic observation", + "Forty currently open prerequisite rows ready/by-design/accepted dated exclusion", + "Memory and11token rows each with a dated interim completion plan; plan dates are not claimed fulfilled", + "Independently reviewed same80-slot S4 and CC adjudication, including unresolved critic corrections", + "Pulled-forward betterleaks P1 or accepted dated exclusion; no new user-item prompt", + "Queue/application/refutation/quota and current paper constraints" + ] + }, + "rd_start_line": { + "decider": "command center", + "decision": "docs/decisions/2026-10-06-north-star-start-line.md", + "same_slot_denominator": 80, + "current_partition": { + "recorded_operational_closed": 27, + "currently_open_prerequisites": 40, + "interim_required": 12, + "upstream_distribution_hold": 1 + }, + "open_prerequisite_slots": [ + "native-clients/claude-code", + "native-clients/codex", + "instructions-skills/trail-of-bits-security-skills-trailofbits-skills", + "instructions-skills/engineering-process-skills", + "instructions-skills/skill-discovery", + "instructions-skills/skill-authoring", + "instructions-skills/research-skill", + "mcp-surfaces/mcp-inspector", + "workers/agent-messaging", + "cross:gpt6-harnesses/gpt-gateway", + "cross:runtime-workers/agent-runtime-worker", + "cross:runtime-workers/research-harnesses", + "code-navigation/serena", + "code-navigation/structural-search", + "semantic-rag/code-search", + "semantic-rag/embedding-model", + "document-retrieval/tobi-qmd", + "document-retrieval/mineru", + "web-research/playwright-cli", + "token-efficiency/ccusage", + "token-efficiency/statusline", + "observation-inference/otel-collector-contrib", + "observation-inference/grafana", + "observation-inference/local-model-server", + "observation-inference/alerting", + "observation-inference/local-generation-model", + "observation-inference/session-analytics", + "quality-evaluation/inspect-ai", + "quality-evaluation/harbor-containerized-agent-e2e-runner", + "quality-evaluation/promptfoo", + "ci-supply-chain/syft", + "git-github-automation/git", + "git-github-automation/gh-github-cli", + "git-github-automation/worktrunk", + "git-github-automation/difftastic", + "git-github-automation/cross-family-review", + "scheduling-supervision/dagu", + "isolation/sandbox-runtime-srt", + "secrets-credentials/betterleaks", + "recovery-portability/mise" + ], + "interim_rows": [ + { + "slot": "durable-memory/memory-owner", + "owner": "memory-h2h", + "dated_plan_requirement": "Required before CC start-line adjudication; actual plan/run date not verified by this documentary update." + }, + { + "slot": "token-efficiency/context-supply", + "owner": "overlap-token", + "dated_plan_requirement": "Required before CC start-line adjudication; actual plan/run date not verified by this documentary update." + }, + { + "slot": "token-efficiency/command-output", + "owner": "overlap-token", + "dated_plan_requirement": "Required before CC start-line adjudication; actual plan/run date not verified by this documentary update." + }, + { + "slot": "token-efficiency/output-compression", + "owner": "overlap-token", + "dated_plan_requirement": "Required before CC start-line adjudication; actual plan/run date not verified by this documentary update." + }, + { + "slot": "token-efficiency/code-index", + "owner": "overlap-token", + "dated_plan_requirement": "Required before CC start-line adjudication; actual plan/run date not verified by this documentary update." + }, + { + "slot": "token-efficiency/code-graph", + "owner": "overlap-token", + "dated_plan_requirement": "Required before CC start-line adjudication; actual plan/run date not verified by this documentary update." + }, + { + "slot": "token-efficiency/repo-packing", + "owner": "overlap-token", + "dated_plan_requirement": "Required before CC start-line adjudication; actual plan/run date not verified by this documentary update." + }, + { + "slot": "token-efficiency/structured-data", + "owner": "overlap-token", + "dated_plan_requirement": "Required before CC start-line adjudication; actual plan/run date not verified by this documentary update." + }, + { + "slot": "token-efficiency/doc-conversion", + "owner": "overlap-token", + "dated_plan_requirement": "Required before CC start-line adjudication; actual plan/run date not verified by this documentary update." + }, + { + "slot": "token-efficiency/api-docs", + "owner": "codex-token-parity", + "dated_plan_requirement": "Required before CC start-line adjudication; actual plan/run date not verified by this documentary update." + }, + { + "slot": "token-efficiency/trace-viewer", + "owner": "overlap-token", + "dated_plan_requirement": "Required before CC start-line adjudication; actual plan/run date not verified by this documentary update." + }, + { + "slot": "token-efficiency/token-lane-carriers", + "owner": "overlap-token", + "dated_plan_requirement": "Required before CC start-line adjudication; actual plan/run date not verified by this documentary update." + } + ], + "final_s4_qualified_count": null, + "satisfied": false, + "distribution_hold": "Supported upstream release remains pending.", + "alternative": "Full79/80 before R&D; no evidence-based date.", + "new_rd_waves": "Not before CC-adjudicated start line; existing Wave1 only runtime qualification under its own gates." + }, + "user_item_batch": { + "authority": "cc-start-line", + "decision_status": "CC closed the user-decision batch; component execution/qualification remain separate.", + "git_identity": { + "status": "RESOLVED_BY_CC_READBACK", + "scopes": [ + "global", + "main-checkout", + "lane-worktree" + ], + "name": "seathatflowsinourveins", + "email_class": "users.noreply.github.com", + "legacy_plan_identity": "stale", + "new_execution_by_this_update": false + }, + "D01": { + "authorization": "resolved", + "apply_readback": "pending CC", + "step_packet": "coordination:ns2604-coop/readiness-20261005/jobs/NORTH-STAR-START-LINE-20261006/D01-D04-STEPS.md" + }, + "D04": { + "authorization": "resolved", + "apply_readback": "pending CC and reviewed additive source selection", + "source_gate": "Current main0d5e6506 is create-only; reviewed#716b63381f8 or reviewed successor must be selected before existing-profile repair.", + "step_packet": "coordination:ns2604-coop/readiness-20261005/jobs/NORTH-STAR-START-LINE-20261006/D01-D04-STEPS.md" + }, + "ccusage": { + "scope": "Offline-only monitoring G6 cross-check", + "sign_in_required": false, + "acceptance": "Offline outputs/controls/accounting still need evidence" + }, + "playwright_cli": { + "start_line_exclusion": "Site sign-ins for web retrieval", + "scope_boundary": "Not a blanket native browser capability exclusion or acceptance.", + "chrome_packages": "Covered by reported workstation authorization; CC/operator applies; no sudo by this lane." + } + }, + "critic_rulings_needed": [ + { + "slot": "cross:credential-practice/credential-guard", + "counted_state": "BY_DESIGN", + "status": "CC ruling pending; no autonomous demotion", + "critic": "coordination:ns2604-coop/organic-e2e-20261005/rebaseline-20261005/critic.json:20-21", + "critic_sha256": "e8230bb076d51ffa776bb4fc23113c00cce0afe80aef62ff403ff9cdd0ea515a", + "issue": "Upgrade required designed fresh Codex canary or ruling accepting one-leg evidence.", + "later_counterevidence": { + "result": "coordination:ns2604-coop/readiness-20261005/jobs/1/result.md:3-7", + "stream": "coordination:ns2604-coop/readiness-20261005/jobs/1/codex.jsonl:5", + "stream_sha256": "cb7ae0fdc416c2f0561170f53f3374de3d3ccf5452d02c46438a3c4a9b8ad509", + "native_item_exit": 0, + "present_control_exit": 1, + "launcher_presence_exit": 0 + }, + "requested_ruling": "Bind the retained later Codex proof with separate Claude/unchanged guard evidence and decide qualification." + }, + { + "slot": "cross:convergence-practice/convergence-validators", + "counted_state": "READY", + "status": "CC classification ruling pending; no autonomous demotion", + "critic": "coordination:ns2604-coop/organic-e2e-20261005/rebaseline-20261005/critic.json:25-26", + "issue": "Infrastructure definition conflicts with adjudication's session-invocation rationale.", + "corroboration": [ + "coordination:ns2604-coop/organic-e2e-20261005/rebaseline-20261005/INPUTS.md:9", + "coordination:ns2604-coop/organic-e2e-20261005/rebaseline-20261005/adjudication.json:731-737" + ], + "requested_ruling": "Justify intended CI-only consumer with evidence or require model-chosen per-script organic validation proof." + } + ] } From a431870fecc76e5263ec658a799618ceaa5a20fb Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: seathatflowsinourveins <234074349+seathatflowsinourveins@users.noreply.github.com> Date: Tue, 6 Oct 2026 14:22:00 -0400 Subject: [PATCH 2/4] Refresh start-line dashboard metadata and registry last --- manifests/evidence.json | 21 +++++++++++++-------- observability/grand-dashboard/state.json | 6 +++--- 2 files changed, 16 insertions(+), 11 deletions(-) diff --git a/manifests/evidence.json b/manifests/evidence.json index 09908e7cc..d2ebcbf72 100644 --- a/manifests/evidence.json +++ b/manifests/evidence.json @@ -17356,10 +17356,15 @@ "sha256": "c12885d5d078f88cf6784d539e5b8261545a759b7aba8ff1eba566fb5d6366fb", "bytes": 3660 }, + { + "path": "docs/decisions/2026-10-06-north-star-start-line.md", + "sha256": "3e8cbc6285f077efa1254900dfed3fbcb676cd7f205ba6a228748f94adc0607c", + "bytes": 7264 + }, { "path": "docs/decisions/2026-10-06-ns2604-native-bar-recount.md", - "sha256": "ae33012177b75f5caa1492cfe3dfc0c271b501a3d7785e2e5a0e88a2f67367a2", - "bytes": 4396 + "sha256": "88b7bf244cb671f115ff597e2bd9d47b5f4849b9c5c7a57e05a7d8185e28a80b", + "bytes": 4880 }, { "path": "docs/direct-results.md", @@ -40828,13 +40833,13 @@ }, { "path": "evidence/artifacts/ns2604-native-bar-20261006/README.md", - "sha256": "5db8e9134985ac3b8ccb252060d6498e580b0b81b6c9d0995b7bf830ddad1e8f", - "bytes": 15520 + "sha256": "ac169c28ac536a3e2ebe3b5d41d42eab920fffe9a98004876548999724ad1934", + "bytes": 16966 }, { "path": "evidence/artifacts/ns2604-native-bar-20261006/board.json", - "sha256": "56266ab0337ee86cbefbe9c4d97634cca45a44db993c9bf96d364e6177b83fe4", - "bytes": 87950 + "sha256": "5e0567fae4878dc3b90e089b4e0e039d9fe3526fe9a86d985e40677ebf6fbfca", + "bytes": 98713 }, { "path": "evidence/artifacts/ns2604-native-bar-20261006/code-navigation-map.json", @@ -53983,8 +53988,8 @@ }, { "path": "observability/grand-dashboard/state.json", - "sha256": "2822d4746cf4b99933a08e3b4030f9564365628dfe3d68e0eb6aae93860d5d8c", - "bytes": 23937 + "sha256": "7a424c0d8994461fb9570b021db246a56e243d81d477c8d77a6b34e3ad5e24fc", + "bytes": 23643 }, { "path": "observability/memory-scheduled-20260923.json", diff --git a/observability/grand-dashboard/state.json b/observability/grand-dashboard/state.json index 88a35ed50..3b0017ca5 100644 --- a/observability/grand-dashboard/state.json +++ b/observability/grand-dashboard/state.json @@ -1,7 +1,7 @@ { "schema_version": 1, - "recorded_at_utc": "2026-10-06T15:47:07Z", - "meaning": "Operational NativeStack2604 native-bar recount against main 0d5e6506434fab598dee861c749a22e628beb75a: 27 of 80 operational closures (13 inherited READY and 14 BY_DESIGN), including the landed custody policy decision; final S4 qualification remains unknown. The complete 80-row evidence/owner board is linked from the existing distribution gate, preserving the 128-entity cap. All 18 formerly proposed handoffs are accepted by the co-op; individual lane acknowledgment remains unverified. Seven token tools remain under the CC client-wiring hold pending its ordered install plan. All other lane/gate/worker entries retain their previous historical scope and evidence; this checkpoint is not a fresh native run or live process registry.", + "recorded_at_utc": "2026-10-06T17:50:07Z", + "meaning": "CC-selected north-star start line: reviewed/adjudicated same80-slot S4,40currentlyopen prerequisites plus12dated interim plans anddistributionhold. Corrected conditionalR&Dstart earliest2026-10-09T22:00Z, likely2026-10-13T22:00Z, rangeOctober12-14, lowconfidence; full79has no evidence-based date. Currentreportedoperational27 andall other historical checkpoint entries retain scope; critic corrections awaitCCruling. No new native qualification or live process claim.", "lanes": [ { "kind": "lane", @@ -366,7 +366,7 @@ "kind": "gate", "id": "new-wsl-distribution-20261002", "title": "NativeStack2604 native bar / readiness-runner", - "state": "operational 27 of 80 / native 26 / S4 unknown / 53 open / 18 handoffs accepted / client wiring held / ceiling 79 / owner readiness-runner", + "state": "reported 27 of 80 / S4 pending / RD earliest Oct9 likely Oct13 / full79 date unknown / owner readiness-runner", "evidence_ref": "evidence/artifacts/ns2604-native-bar-20261006/README.md" }, { From 9d824130cb47db8d0cbfc5e21b076b6b2f53bf2d Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: seathatflowsinourveins <234074349+seathatflowsinourveins@users.noreply.github.com> Date: Wed, 7 Oct 2026 04:17:44 -0400 Subject: [PATCH 3/4] docs: amend the fixed N1 research start line --- .../2026-10-06-north-star-start-line.md | 64 ++++++ .../interim-plans.json | 208 ++++++++++++++++++ 2 files changed, 272 insertions(+) create mode 100644 evidence/artifacts/ns2604-start-line-20261007/interim-plans.json diff --git a/docs/decisions/2026-10-06-north-star-start-line.md b/docs/decisions/2026-10-06-north-star-start-line.md index 5a78a0384..432b277e7 100644 --- a/docs/decisions/2026-10-06-north-star-start-line.md +++ b/docs/decisions/2026-10-06-north-star-start-line.md @@ -56,3 +56,67 @@ The [board](../../evidence/artifacts/ns2604-native-bar-20261006/board.json) reco Publish through the co-op GPT read, CC acknowledgment and 5f queue. Registry and dashboard checkpoint stay in the last commit. Native dashboard generation readback remains a separate CC/co-op step. +## Amendment (2026-10-07): date-certain review and opening unit + +This amendment supersedes the conditional start forecast and campaign-based waiting in the earlier sections. Their decided text and historical observations remain intact. The command center's START RULINGS, review-ns2604-coop-20261007T072919Z (SHA256 `6b0bde35825d0dbba8d55f1238cb0628621974eb41cb56b1f143580e7c3858e8`), govern the opening unit and the dated readings below. + +### Fixed review and adjudication + +The independent S4 review starts **no later than midnight EDT on October 8 (2026-10-08T04:00Z)**, on the same 80-slot board as it stands then. It does not wait for all open original gates to close. Each still-open original gate receives the CC's dated exclusion or removal from the start gate that day; this record adds no gate or regrouping. + +The CC adjudicates the start **by October 8, 6:00 PM EDT (2026-10-08T22:00Z)**. Only a **safety finding in the paper-engine path** or a **sign-in that only the owner can perform** may hold adjudication past that deadline. The authority is task-ns2604-coop-20261007T002252Z, point 1. This records a deadline and its two allowed holds, not a completed review or a declaration that R&D has started. + +S4 uses upstream evidence and clean upstream installation/configuration, the required integration smoke, and eligible organic client records. No local comparison campaign decides a row. Service, timer, dashboard and UI rows use their required one smoke; requested smokes are not organic counts. The interim completion plans are recorded separately below. + +### N1: data integrity, then N2 and N3 + +The unit opened by adjudication is **N1, the data-integrity unit**, owned by **rnd-r1**, with **5f's custody for trading-lane landings**. It applies Layer 1.5 in [the pinned trading rules](https://github.com/seathatflowsinourveins/native-agent-stack/blob/6e6df2372bf7f11bf5bf5289b8bb71828d601912/blueprints/us-equities/AGENTS.md#L35), landed by #827 at `6e6df2372bf7f11bf5bf5289b8bb71828d601912` (lines 35–46). + +1. Inventory what the selected platform repositories already provide for security identity, splits and corporate actions, and delisting and terminal prices. Each inventory entry names its repository/pin and exact source locator, plus the source's limitations. Inspect and use existing upstream features before proposing glue. Subjects include the selected NautilusTrader 2.0.0rc5 catalog/adjustment surfaces, EdgarTools identity maps, alpaca-py corporate actions, Lean map/factor files and an already entitled vendor feed. These are inventory subjects, not availability or acceptance evidence. +2. Produce the residual glue plan, with a maintained reference for each part and a demonstrated remaining gap. Foundation layers retain their upstream implementation; desk glue is confined to what the upstreams leave open. +3. Accept the unit through a **historical-data end-to-end backtest using the selected NautilusTrader 2.0.0rc5 on a known-answer set**. No strategy number is cited before that acceptance. The retained split-inversion and no-data research can inform that set; a newly supplied research package is not historical availability evidence. + +**N2**, after N1's inventory and its applicable data gates, is the **D1 prospective holdout**, whose validation window opens **2026-10-14**. **N3** is the **catalyst Wave 1 rerun** when its data gates permit it. The SPY `one_stress` mapping remains under its separate mapping condition; it is not the unit this start opens. These are unit definitions and ordering constraints, not new runs or completed data gates. + +### One canonical essential profile + +The essential profile is one planned **`north-star-rnd` entry in [adoption/manifest.json](../../adoption/manifest.json)**, a task-scoped projection of the finalized catalog. **grand-catalog** writes it on **#820's chain after J820-FIX2**. This record references that carrier; it creates no second essential-tool list and does not claim the entry is already published. + +Its **single profile base commit is `e712bae606e8d27f010af8e3c13ded6b7a7c207a`**, resolved from `essential-profile-wf_383f6a1e-0cd.json#/profile/base_commit` (record SHA256 `6685923cc99f4457d5c0afa35f0e48cb4295b568709519e2a12ad41bb678ab5c`). The later trading-rule and START RULINGS references above do not define additional profile bases. The profile is evaluated against N1's task requirements; rnd-r1 supplies their install/smoke state or exact gap, rather than treating catalog inclusion as acceptance. + +### Dated readings and exclusions, re-checked at S4 + +All of these readings are dated **2026-10-07** and re-checked at the fixed S4 review: + +| Reading or exclusion | Scope and control | Re-check or overturn | +| --- | --- | --- | +| N1 execution route | N1's executors are Codex CLI lanes using native sign-in. The gateway is not on N1's execution path and does not hold this start. Cross-family reads retain their established co-op GPT and 5f Claude routes under the dated deviation. | Re-check executor identity and the dated deviation at S4. Plan line 98 resumes for SDK-worker/research-runtime execution from N2 onward and after GW-ROUTE acceptance; this is not a general gateway waiver. | +| Research process isolation | Network and credential restrictions apply to backtest/data-job processes, not to reading upstream documentation. Before N1's first backtest, rnd-r1 with codex-token-parity names supported installed-client launch arguments and smokes one job: network off for the backtest, scrubbed environment with no broker credential pointer; any data pull is a separate job naming its vendor hosts. | Actual launch/smoke proof is required; no configuration or successful job is asserted here. R&D first-turn exposure must show zero `codex_apps` tools through the native feature setting, or carry a dated exclusion. A disable instruction alone is not exposure proof. | +| Landing distribution | 5f may land from the retiring distribution until retirement. Every landing requires the CC's individual ledger cue. | A landing without its cue overturns this reading; re-check custody and cue at S4. This lane performs no landing. | +| Trading output repository | N1 outputs land in this repository under `lane:trading`, with 5f's custody. A later repository move retains its separate gates. | Re-check repository policy and custody at S4; no repository move is performed. | +| Data entitlement | N1 uses sources already entitled or public. Paid additions remain the owner's decision and must be named. | Re-check every proposed source's entitlement and permitted observation; this is not a blanket purchase or provider-fetch approval. | + +Publication of this amendment follows the co-op's exact-head read with CI at that head, the CC's ACK and its slot ahead of the S4 review. It uses the existing #801 and changes no other PR. No early rebase, host action, native smoke, model/provider run or measured readiness promotion follows from this documentary amendment. + +#801's existing dependency on #791 is retained. The co-op's landing cue must reconcile that parent and T10's record-publication dependencies; this amendment does not authorize unstacking or changing queued #791. + +## Amendment (2026-10-07): dated interim completion bindings + +The original memory-plus-eleven-token interim membership remains. The [dated completion-plan bindings](../../evidence/artifacts/ns2604-start-line-20261007/interim-plans.json) name each existing source locator, source digest, accountable owner and next action. They are plans to finish alongside R&D, not completion evidence or an invented delivery date. ccusage and statusline remain outside this interim set. Re-check each plan at the fixed S4 review. + +| Interim slot | Accountable completion lane | Plan date | +| --- | --- | --- | +| `durable-memory/memory-owner` | memory-h2h / CC | 2026-10-06 | +| `token-efficiency/context-supply` | overlap-token | 2026-10-07 | +| `token-efficiency/command-output` | overlap-token / codex-token-parity | 2026-10-07 | +| `token-efficiency/output-compression` | overlap-token | 2026-10-07 | +| `token-efficiency/code-index` | overlap-token / codex-token-parity | 2026-10-07 | +| `token-efficiency/code-graph` | overlap-token / memory-h2h | 2026-10-07 | +| `token-efficiency/repo-packing` | overlap-token | 2026-10-07 | +| `token-efficiency/structured-data` | overlap-token | 2026-10-07 | +| `token-efficiency/doc-conversion` | overlap-token | 2026-10-07 | +| `token-efficiency/api-docs` | codex-token-parity | 2026-10-07 | +| `token-efficiency/trace-viewer` | overlap-token | 2026-10-07 | +| `token-efficiency/token-lane-carriers` | codex-token-parity / overlap-token | 2026-10-07 | + +The memory plan retains its upstream re-drive trigger; D3r4 steps 8 onward and local token comparison campaigns do not gate the start. Requested integration smokes, eligible native ordinary counters and independently reviewed S4 remain separate evidence classes. The trace-viewer plan preserves its recorded operational service/UI observation; retaining an interim plan is not a new promotion or demotion. These bindings do not duplicate the canonical `north-star-rnd` projection and add no gate. diff --git a/evidence/artifacts/ns2604-start-line-20261007/interim-plans.json b/evidence/artifacts/ns2604-start-line-20261007/interim-plans.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..6c33db946 --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/artifacts/ns2604-start-line-20261007/interim-plans.json @@ -0,0 +1,208 @@ +{ + "schema_version": 1, + "kind": "dated_interim_completion_plan_bindings", + "recorded_at_utc": "2026-10-07T07:59:19Z", + "authority": { + "item": "review-ns2604-coop-20261007T072919Z", + "sha256": "6b0bde35825d0dbba8d55f1238cb0628621974eb41cb56b1f143580e7c3858e8", + "scope": "interim dated plans, not a duplicate essential profile" + }, + "membership": "Original memory plus eleven token interim rows; ccusage and statusline are outside this set.", + "review_no_later_than_utc": "2026-10-08T04:00:00Z", + "completion_dates": "Not committed by these sources; keep unknown/pending rather than manufacture a delivery date.", + "rules": "Upstream evidence and clean release integration first; retained requested smokes are not organic. Eligible native use closes as observed; after a real working day an appropriately measured zero or CC dated exclusion is available. No local campaign gates the row.", + "rows": [ + { + "slot": "durable-memory/memory-owner", + "owner": "memory-h2h / CC", + "plan_date": "2026-10-06", + "sources": [ + { + "locator": "coordination:ns2604-coop/memory-slot-20261006/keep-ruling-and-smoke-plan.md", + "sha256": "61eca2af0cc508f9511b45acbb5ba5153c129fc3b74f212187f815c00e4aea73" + }, + { + "locator": "coordination:ns2604-coop/readiness-20261005/jobs/RUN-LIST-20261006/run-list.json#/b3_by_owner/2/rows/1", + "sha256": "676809a15197bfca6de3654e312367a42a89c5c7f08b78c235330f4b6f12443f" + } + ], + "next_action": "Retain KEEP ai-memory/Nemotron; document native ordinary-use and safe recovery evidence. Upstream re-drive follows the retained trigger, not a local comparison campaign.", + "completion_date_utc": null, + "evidence_boundary": "Dated plan and pending/source bindings; no new run, installation, usage count, acceptance or state change." + }, + { + "slot": "token-efficiency/context-supply", + "owner": "overlap-token", + "plan_date": "2026-10-07", + "sources": [ + { + "locator": "coordination:ns2604-coop/readiness-20261005/jobs/RUN-LIST-20261006/run-list.json#/b3_by_owner/4/rows/1", + "sha256": "676809a15197bfca6de3654e312367a42a89c5c7f08b78c235330f4b6f12443f" + } + ], + "next_action": "Bind matching upstream/install and retained consuming-client smoke; record eligible native counters or the ruled disposition without repeating the smoke.", + "completion_date_utc": null, + "evidence_boundary": "Dated plan and pending/source bindings; no new run, installation, usage count, acceptance or state change." + }, + { + "slot": "token-efficiency/command-output", + "owner": "overlap-token / codex-token-parity", + "plan_date": "2026-10-07", + "sources": [ + { + "locator": "coordination:ns2604-coop/readiness-20261005/jobs/RUN-LIST-20261006/run-list.json#/b3_by_owner/4/rows/3", + "sha256": "676809a15197bfca6de3654e312367a42a89c5c7f08b78c235330f4b6f12443f" + }, + { + "locator": "coordination:ns2604-coop/lanes/overlap-token-durable/tool-wiring-20261007/rtk-audit-dry-run-20261007.md", + "sha256": "5a553a4a397fa926b7f1f27affa09c5ef57f0cc6d17b31abd5e226b4e4e0be50" + } + ], + "next_action": "Qualify actual Codex hook application/firing and bind counters; explicit CLI filtering alone does not prove automatic hook use.", + "completion_date_utc": null, + "evidence_boundary": "Dated plan and pending/source bindings; no new run, installation, usage count, acceptance or state change." + }, + { + "slot": "token-efficiency/output-compression", + "owner": "overlap-token", + "plan_date": "2026-10-07", + "sources": [ + { + "locator": "coordination:ns2604-coop/lanes/overlap-token-durable/tool-wiring-20261007/headroom-window.md", + "sha256": "725b8871cbf52f4eb1d605dae9584378a663e45901952d278a96e790b6ec6d89" + } + ], + "next_action": "CC reviews route-preserving/protection binding, applies the prepared window item, then consuming-client integration and eligible ordinary use are recorded.", + "completion_date_utc": null, + "evidence_boundary": "Dated plan and pending/source bindings; no new run, installation, usage count, acceptance or state change." + }, + { + "slot": "token-efficiency/code-index", + "owner": "overlap-token / codex-token-parity", + "plan_date": "2026-10-07", + "sources": [ + { + "locator": "coordination:ns2604-coop/lanes/overlap-token-durable/tool-wiring-20261007/jcodemunch-window.md", + "sha256": "c3c6f306bbbba89a625bc8b92a80fd1870d12f2b631a8566aa4360d1a0da7bc7" + } + ], + "next_action": "Finish the named read-back helper/source binding, actual application and role exposure; retain requested smokes and subsequent native counters separately.", + "completion_date_utc": null, + "evidence_boundary": "Dated plan and pending/source bindings; no new run, installation, usage count, acceptance or state change." + }, + { + "slot": "token-efficiency/code-graph", + "owner": "overlap-token / memory-h2h", + "plan_date": "2026-10-07", + "sources": [ + { + "locator": "coordination:ns2604-coop/memory-slot-20261006/tool-wiring-20261007/window-items-20261007.md#CBM-W1", + "sha256": "6c715d56da73e3e5267975b9453b76e78eaf6582ab6a8341f2f29f1607a9d328" + } + ], + "next_action": "Verify the native hook/trust/output integration and graph coverage; repair only a demonstrated gap. Indexing and ordinary task evidence remain separately scoped.", + "completion_date_utc": null, + "evidence_boundary": "Dated plan and pending/source bindings; no new run, installation, usage count, acceptance or state change." + }, + { + "slot": "token-efficiency/repo-packing", + "owner": "overlap-token", + "plan_date": "2026-10-07", + "sources": [ + { + "locator": "coordination:ns2604-coop/readiness-20261005/jobs/RUN-LIST-20261006/run-list.json#/b3_by_owner/4/rows/4", + "sha256": "676809a15197bfca6de3654e312367a42a89c5c7f08b78c235330f4b6f12443f" + } + ], + "next_action": "Bind the retained source/smoke and eligible native counters; no new comparison campaign.", + "completion_date_utc": null, + "evidence_boundary": "Dated plan and pending/source bindings; no new run, installation, usage count, acceptance or state change." + }, + { + "slot": "token-efficiency/structured-data", + "owner": "overlap-token", + "plan_date": "2026-10-07", + "sources": [ + { + "locator": "coordination:ns2604-coop/readiness-20261005/jobs/RUN-LIST-20261006/run-list.json#/b3_by_owner/4/rows/5", + "sha256": "676809a15197bfca6de3654e312367a42a89c5c7f08b78c235330f4b6f12443f" + } + ], + "next_action": "Bind retained source/smoke evidence and eligible native counters.", + "completion_date_utc": null, + "evidence_boundary": "Dated plan and pending/source bindings; no new run, installation, usage count, acceptance or state change." + }, + { + "slot": "token-efficiency/doc-conversion", + "owner": "overlap-token", + "plan_date": "2026-10-07", + "sources": [ + { + "locator": "coordination:ns2604-coop/readiness-20261005/jobs/RUN-LIST-20261006/run-list.json#/b3_by_owner/4/rows/6", + "sha256": "676809a15197bfca6de3654e312367a42a89c5c7f08b78c235330f4b6f12443f" + } + ], + "next_action": "Bind retained source/smoke evidence and eligible native counters.", + "completion_date_utc": null, + "evidence_boundary": "Dated plan and pending/source bindings; no new run, installation, usage count, acceptance or state change." + }, + { + "slot": "token-efficiency/api-docs", + "owner": "codex-token-parity", + "plan_date": "2026-10-07", + "sources": [ + { + "locator": "coordination:ns2604-coop/readiness-20261005/jobs/RUN-LIST-20261006/run-list.json#/b3_by_owner/5/rows/0", + "sha256": "676809a15197bfca6de3654e312367a42a89c5c7f08b78c235330f4b6f12443f" + }, + { + "locator": "coordination:ns2604-coop/readiness-20261005/jobs/REPLAN-BOARD-20261006/api-docs-consumer-addendum-20261007T032132Z.json#/row_delta", + "sha256": "6cd67bc4486ca29fbd6d3201399e9806a5bed278fb7bba99c67203ffacb81d1e" + } + ], + "next_action": "Codex-only consumer; preserve the retained chub smoke and measure eligible native use. No Claude leg is invented.", + "completion_date_utc": null, + "evidence_boundary": "Dated plan and pending/source bindings; no new run, installation, usage count, acceptance or state change." + }, + { + "slot": "token-efficiency/trace-viewer", + "owner": "overlap-token", + "plan_date": "2026-10-07", + "sources": [ + { + "locator": "coordination:ns2604-coop/readiness-20261005/jobs/RUN-LIST-20261006/run-list.json#/b3_by_owner/4/rows/7", + "sha256": "676809a15197bfca6de3654e312367a42a89c5c7f08b78c235330f4b6f12443f" + } + ], + "next_action": "Retain the existing operational service/UI-smoke observation and its original interim membership; S4 independently reviews the evidence, without a fresh READY increment.", + "completion_date_utc": null, + "evidence_boundary": "Dated plan and pending/source bindings; no new run, installation, usage count, acceptance or state change." + }, + { + "slot": "token-efficiency/token-lane-carriers", + "owner": "codex-token-parity / overlap-token", + "plan_date": "2026-10-07", + "sources": [ + { + "locator": "coordination:ns2604-coop/lanes/overlap-token-durable/tool-wiring-20261007/role-carrier-gaps-20261007.json#/role_grants_section", + "sha256": "92c77000c08779986ffb1dbc3640577c176094d79215b1964ac494e1013a64fb" + } + ], + "next_action": "Follow the retained carrier plan after #819; actual application, effective role exposure and eligible invocation remain unverified until their own read-back.", + "completion_date_utc": null, + "evidence_boundary": "Dated plan and pending/source bindings; no new run, installation, usage count, acceptance or state change." + } + ], + "profile_reference": { + "carrier": "adoption/manifest.json", + "entry": "north-star-rnd", + "owner": "grand-catalog", + "delivery": "#820 chain after J820-FIX2", + "single_base_commit": "e712bae606e8d27f010af8e3c13ded6b7a7c207a", + "source_record": "essential-profile-wf_383f6a1e-0cd.json#/profile/base_commit", + "source_sha256": "6685923cc99f4457d5c0afa35f0e48cb4295b568709519e2a12ad41bb678ab5c", + "publication": "pending; no second essential list created" + }, + "gating_rows_added": 0, + "existing_observations_changed": 0 +} From 79ada795b7e67f5eb802195b2ee80cfd82d4899d Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: seathatflowsinourveins <234074349+seathatflowsinourveins@users.noreply.github.com> Date: Wed, 7 Oct 2026 04:17:45 -0400 Subject: [PATCH 4/4] chore: register start-line amendments and checkpoint last --- manifests/evidence.json | 13 +++++++++---- observability/grand-dashboard/state.json | 4 ++-- 2 files changed, 11 insertions(+), 6 deletions(-) diff --git a/manifests/evidence.json b/manifests/evidence.json index d2ebcbf72..413d8cbaf 100644 --- a/manifests/evidence.json +++ b/manifests/evidence.json @@ -17358,8 +17358,8 @@ }, { "path": "docs/decisions/2026-10-06-north-star-start-line.md", - "sha256": "3e8cbc6285f077efa1254900dfed3fbcb676cd7f205ba6a228748f94adc0607c", - "bytes": 7264 + "sha256": "95157f78ee4e329445bada1634fd15adb5a790fab6cc8ef07c75401377035563", + "bytes": 16416 }, { "path": "docs/decisions/2026-10-06-ns2604-native-bar-recount.md", @@ -40891,6 +40891,11 @@ "sha256": "00677f5b1c5c7ad3f687e2a81bce64ccb8ec6822680a34a08feb03b1b7ea02ff", "bytes": 114093 }, + { + "path": "evidence/artifacts/ns2604-start-line-20261007/interim-plans.json", + "sha256": "0ed787ffd6f874fed8474845d9cf524691ad4de057df075a69c3716e6c8dc6d0", + "bytes": 10850 + }, { "path": "evidence/artifacts/observability-dashboard.png", "sha256": "3fd996f22320f31bd54decff339374be80f7d20fed07d83a66fa7eabaee59cd2", @@ -53988,8 +53993,8 @@ }, { "path": "observability/grand-dashboard/state.json", - "sha256": "7a424c0d8994461fb9570b021db246a56e243d81d477c8d77a6b34e3ad5e24fc", - "bytes": 23643 + "sha256": "701ba7a7e9aa8b93e5ddf1ef9556f679713fed9cd6dd09c718762e16a12cc7d6", + "bytes": 23681 }, { "path": "observability/memory-scheduled-20260923.json", diff --git a/observability/grand-dashboard/state.json b/observability/grand-dashboard/state.json index 3b0017ca5..1f128da0a 100644 --- a/observability/grand-dashboard/state.json +++ b/observability/grand-dashboard/state.json @@ -366,7 +366,7 @@ "kind": "gate", "id": "new-wsl-distribution-20261002", "title": "NativeStack2604 native bar / readiness-runner", - "state": "reported 27 of 80 / S4 pending / RD earliest Oct9 likely Oct13 / full79 date unknown / owner readiness-runner", + "state": "historical reported 27 of 80 / S4 review by Oct8 04Z / adjudication by Oct8 22Z / N1 data-integrity / full79 date unknown / owner readiness-runner", "evidence_ref": "evidence/artifacts/ns2604-native-bar-20261006/README.md" }, { @@ -422,7 +422,7 @@ "kind": "gate", "id": "two-host-architecture-20261002", "title": "Two-host architecture for North Star R and D (macOS and workstation)", - "state": "two-host design resolved / offline R and D starts with SPY one_stress mapping / 179 starter tests pass / workstation activation not attested", + "state": "two-host design resolved / N1 data-integrity opening unit under Oct7 amendment / 179 starter tests pass / workstation activation not attested", "evidence_ref": "docs/decisions/2026-10-02-two-host-north-star-architecture.md" }, {