From 6dfd3f2411ed90c5778d878adf460d5cb9203a9c Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Nikita Sobolev Date: Mon, 12 Feb 2024 14:59:58 +0300 Subject: [PATCH] gh-114785: Remove content from `Porting from Python2` how-to (GH-114805) Keep the page though, because people might still rely on it (the traffic shows that they do). Instead of our own manual we now give links to the 3rd-party ones. (cherry picked from commit 705c76d4a202f1faf41027d48d44eac0e76bb1f0) Co-authored-by: Nikita Sobolev Co-authored-by: Hugo van Kemenade <1324225+hugovk@users.noreply.github.com> --- Doc/howto/index.rst | 1 - Doc/howto/pyporting.rst | 429 ++-------------------------------------- README.rst | 9 - 3 files changed, 19 insertions(+), 420 deletions(-) diff --git a/Doc/howto/index.rst b/Doc/howto/index.rst index 6280f057716803..d0ce6fa7db8ab3 100644 --- a/Doc/howto/index.rst +++ b/Doc/howto/index.rst @@ -13,7 +13,6 @@ Currently, the HOWTOs are: .. toctree:: :maxdepth: 1 - pyporting.rst cporting.rst curses.rst descriptor.rst diff --git a/Doc/howto/pyporting.rst b/Doc/howto/pyporting.rst index 501b16d82d4d6f..d560364107bd12 100644 --- a/Doc/howto/pyporting.rst +++ b/Doc/howto/pyporting.rst @@ -1,3 +1,5 @@ +:orphan: + .. _pyporting-howto: ************************************* @@ -6,423 +8,30 @@ How to port Python 2 Code to Python 3 :author: Brett Cannon -.. topic:: Abstract - - Python 2 reached its official end-of-life at the start of 2020. This means - that no new bug reports, fixes, or changes will be made to Python 2 - it's - no longer supported. - - This guide is intended to provide you with a path to Python 3 for your - code, that includes compatibility with Python 2 as a first step. - - If you are looking to port an extension module instead of pure Python code, - please see :ref:`cporting-howto`. - - The archived python-porting_ mailing list may contain some useful guidance. - - -The Short Explanation -===================== - -To achieve Python 2/3 compatibility in a single code base, the basic steps -are: - -#. Only worry about supporting Python 2.7 -#. Make sure you have good test coverage (coverage.py_ can help; - ``python -m pip install coverage``) -#. Learn the differences between Python 2 and 3 -#. Use Futurize_ (or Modernize_) to update your code (e.g. ``python -m pip install future``) -#. Use Pylint_ to help make sure you don't regress on your Python 3 support - (``python -m pip install pylint``) -#. Use caniusepython3_ to find out which of your dependencies are blocking your - use of Python 3 (``python -m pip install caniusepython3``) -#. Once your dependencies are no longer blocking you, use continuous integration - to make sure you stay compatible with Python 2 and 3 (tox_ can help test - against multiple versions of Python; ``python -m pip install tox``) -#. Consider using optional :term:`static type checking ` - to make sure your type usage - works in both Python 2 and 3 (e.g. use mypy_ to check your typing under both - Python 2 and Python 3; ``python -m pip install mypy``). - -.. note:: - - Note: Using ``python -m pip install`` guarantees that the ``pip`` you invoke - is the one installed for the Python currently in use, whether it be - a system-wide ``pip`` or one installed within a - :ref:`virtual environment `. - -Details -======= - -Even if other factors - say, dependencies over which you have no control - -still require you to support Python 2, that does not prevent you taking the -step of including Python 3 support. - -Most changes required to support Python 3 lead to cleaner code using newer -practices even in Python 2 code. - - -Different versions of Python 2 ------------------------------- - -Ideally, your code should be compatible with Python 2.7, which was the -last supported version of Python 2. - -Some of the tools mentioned in this guide will not work with Python 2.6. - -If absolutely necessary, the six_ project can help you support Python 2.5 and -3 simultaneously. Do realize, though, that nearly all the projects listed in -this guide will not be available to you. - -If you are able to skip Python 2.5 and older, the required changes to your -code will be minimal. At worst you will have to use a function instead of a -method in some instances or have to import a function instead of using a -built-in one. - - -Make sure you specify the proper version support in your ``setup.py`` file --------------------------------------------------------------------------- - -In your ``setup.py`` file you should have the proper `trove classifier`_ -specifying what versions of Python you support. As your project does not support -Python 3 yet you should at least have -``Programming Language :: Python :: 2 :: Only`` specified. Ideally you should -also specify each major/minor version of Python that you do support, e.g. -``Programming Language :: Python :: 2.7``. - - -Have good test coverage ------------------------ - -Once you have your code supporting the oldest version of Python 2 you want it -to, you will want to make sure your test suite has good coverage. A good rule of -thumb is that if you want to be confident enough in your test suite that any -failures that appear after having tools rewrite your code are actual bugs in the -tools and not in your code. If you want a number to aim for, try to get over 80% -coverage (and don't feel bad if you find it hard to get better than 90% -coverage). If you don't already have a tool to measure test coverage then -coverage.py_ is recommended. - - -Be aware of the differences between Python 2 and 3 --------------------------------------------------- - -Once you have your code well-tested you are ready to begin porting your code to -Python 3! But to fully understand how your code is going to change and what -you want to look out for while you code, you will want to learn what changes -Python 3 makes in terms of Python 2. - -Some resources for understanding the differences and their implications for you -code: - -* the :ref:`"What's New" ` doc for each release of Python 3 -* the `Porting to Python 3`_ book (which is free online) -* the handy `cheat sheet`_ from the Python-Future project. - - -Update your code ----------------- - -There are tools available that can port your code automatically. - -Futurize_ does its best to make Python 3 idioms and practices exist in Python -2, e.g. backporting the ``bytes`` type from Python 3 so that you have -semantic parity between the major versions of Python. This is the better -approach for most cases. - -Modernize_, on the other hand, is more conservative and targets a Python 2/3 -subset of Python, directly relying on six_ to help provide compatibility. - -A good approach is to run the tool over your test suite first and visually -inspect the diff to make sure the transformation is accurate. After you have -transformed your test suite and verified that all the tests still pass as -expected, then you can transform your application code knowing that any tests -which fail is a translation failure. - -Unfortunately the tools can't automate everything to make your code work under -Python 3, and you will also need to read the tools' documentation in case some -options you need are turned off by default. - -Key issues to be aware of and check for: - -Division -++++++++ - -In Python 3, ``5 / 2 == 2.5`` and not ``2`` as it was in Python 2; all -division between ``int`` values result in a ``float``. This change has -actually been planned since Python 2.2 which was released in 2002. Since then -users have been encouraged to add ``from __future__ import division`` to any -and all files which use the ``/`` and ``//`` operators or to be running the -interpreter with the ``-Q`` flag. If you have not been doing this then you -will need to go through your code and do two things: - -#. Add ``from __future__ import division`` to your files -#. Update any division operator as necessary to either use ``//`` to use floor - division or continue using ``/`` and expect a float - -The reason that ``/`` isn't simply translated to ``//`` automatically is that if -an object defines a ``__truediv__`` method but not ``__floordiv__`` then your -code would begin to fail (e.g. a user-defined class that uses ``/`` to -signify some operation but not ``//`` for the same thing or at all). +Python 2 reached its official end-of-life at the start of 2020. This means +that no new bug reports, fixes, or changes will be made to Python 2 - it's +no longer supported: see :pep:`373` and +`status of Python versions `_. +If you are looking to port an extension module instead of pure Python code, +please see :ref:`cporting-howto`. -Text versus binary data -+++++++++++++++++++++++ +The archived python-porting_ mailing list may contain some useful guidance. -In Python 2 you could use the ``str`` type for both text and binary data. -Unfortunately this confluence of two different concepts could lead to brittle -code which sometimes worked for either kind of data, sometimes not. It also -could lead to confusing APIs if people didn't explicitly state that something -that accepted ``str`` accepted either text or binary data instead of one -specific type. This complicated the situation especially for anyone supporting -multiple languages as APIs wouldn't bother explicitly supporting ``unicode`` -when they claimed text data support. +Since Python 3.13 the original porting guide was discontinued. +You can find the old guide in the +`archive `_. -Python 3 made text and binary data distinct types that cannot simply be mixed -together. For any code that deals only with text or only binary data, this -separation doesn't pose an issue. But for code that has to deal with both, it -does mean you might have to now care about when you are using text compared -to binary data, which is why this cannot be entirely automated. -Decide which APIs take text and which take binary (it is **highly** recommended -you don't design APIs that can take both due to the difficulty of keeping the -code working; as stated earlier it is difficult to do well). In Python 2 this -means making sure the APIs that take text can work with ``unicode`` and those -that work with binary data work with the ``bytes`` type from Python 3 -(which is a subset of ``str`` in Python 2 and acts as an alias for ``bytes`` -type in Python 2). Usually the biggest issue is realizing which methods exist -on which types in Python 2 and 3 simultaneously (for text that's ``unicode`` -in Python 2 and ``str`` in Python 3, for binary that's ``str``/``bytes`` in -Python 2 and ``bytes`` in Python 3). +Third-party guides +================== -The following table lists the **unique** methods of each data type across -Python 2 and 3 (e.g., the ``decode()`` method is usable on the equivalent binary -data type in either Python 2 or 3, but it can't be used by the textual data -type consistently between Python 2 and 3 because ``str`` in Python 3 doesn't -have the method). Do note that as of Python 3.5 the ``__mod__`` method was -added to the bytes type. +There are also multiple third-party guides that might be useful: -======================== ===================== -**Text data** **Binary data** ------------------------- --------------------- -\ decode ------------------------- --------------------- -encode ------------------------- --------------------- -format ------------------------- --------------------- -isdecimal ------------------------- --------------------- -isnumeric -======================== ===================== +- `Guide by Fedora `_ +- `PyCon 2020 tutorial `_ +- `Guide by DigitalOcean `_ +- `Guide by ActiveState `_ -Making the distinction easier to handle can be accomplished by encoding and -decoding between binary data and text at the edge of your code. This means that -when you receive text in binary data, you should immediately decode it. And if -your code needs to send text as binary data then encode it as late as possible. -This allows your code to work with only text internally and thus eliminates -having to keep track of what type of data you are working with. -The next issue is making sure you know whether the string literals in your code -represent text or binary data. You should add a ``b`` prefix to any -literal that presents binary data. For text you should add a ``u`` prefix to -the text literal. (There is a :mod:`__future__` import to force all unspecified -literals to be Unicode, but usage has shown it isn't as effective as adding a -``b`` or ``u`` prefix to all literals explicitly) - -You also need to be careful about opening files. Possibly you have not always -bothered to add the ``b`` mode when opening a binary file (e.g., ``rb`` for -binary reading). Under Python 3, binary files and text files are clearly -distinct and mutually incompatible; see the :mod:`io` module for details. -Therefore, you **must** make a decision of whether a file will be used for -binary access (allowing binary data to be read and/or written) or textual access -(allowing text data to be read and/or written). You should also use :func:`io.open` -for opening files instead of the built-in :func:`open` function as the :mod:`io` -module is consistent from Python 2 to 3 while the built-in :func:`open` function -is not (in Python 3 it's actually :func:`io.open`). Do not bother with the -outdated practice of using :func:`codecs.open` as that's only necessary for -keeping compatibility with Python 2.5. - -The constructors of both ``str`` and ``bytes`` have different semantics for the -same arguments between Python 2 and 3. Passing an integer to ``bytes`` in Python 2 -will give you the string representation of the integer: ``bytes(3) == '3'``. -But in Python 3, an integer argument to ``bytes`` will give you a bytes object -as long as the integer specified, filled with null bytes: -``bytes(3) == b'\x00\x00\x00'``. A similar worry is necessary when passing a -bytes object to ``str``. In Python 2 you just get the bytes object back: -``str(b'3') == b'3'``. But in Python 3 you get the string representation of the -bytes object: ``str(b'3') == "b'3'"``. - -Finally, the indexing of binary data requires careful handling (slicing does -**not** require any special handling). In Python 2, -``b'123'[1] == b'2'`` while in Python 3 ``b'123'[1] == 50``. Because binary data -is simply a collection of binary numbers, Python 3 returns the integer value for -the byte you index on. But in Python 2 because ``bytes == str``, indexing -returns a one-item slice of bytes. The six_ project has a function -named ``six.indexbytes()`` which will return an integer like in Python 3: -``six.indexbytes(b'123', 1)``. - -To summarize: - -#. Decide which of your APIs take text and which take binary data -#. Make sure that your code that works with text also works with ``unicode`` and - code for binary data works with ``bytes`` in Python 2 (see the table above - for what methods you cannot use for each type) -#. Mark all binary literals with a ``b`` prefix, textual literals with a ``u`` - prefix -#. Decode binary data to text as soon as possible, encode text as binary data as - late as possible -#. Open files using :func:`io.open` and make sure to specify the ``b`` mode when - appropriate -#. Be careful when indexing into binary data - - -Use feature detection instead of version detection -++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ - -Inevitably you will have code that has to choose what to do based on what -version of Python is running. The best way to do this is with feature detection -of whether the version of Python you're running under supports what you need. -If for some reason that doesn't work then you should make the version check be -against Python 2 and not Python 3. To help explain this, let's look at an -example. - -Let's pretend that you need access to a feature of :mod:`importlib` that -is available in Python's standard library since Python 3.3 and available for -Python 2 through importlib2_ on PyPI. You might be tempted to write code to -access e.g. the :mod:`importlib.abc` module by doing the following:: - - import sys - - if sys.version_info[0] == 3: - from importlib import abc - else: - from importlib2 import abc - -The problem with this code is what happens when Python 4 comes out? It would -be better to treat Python 2 as the exceptional case instead of Python 3 and -assume that future Python versions will be more compatible with Python 3 than -Python 2:: - - import sys - - if sys.version_info[0] > 2: - from importlib import abc - else: - from importlib2 import abc - -The best solution, though, is to do no version detection at all and instead rely -on feature detection. That avoids any potential issues of getting the version -detection wrong and helps keep you future-compatible:: - - try: - from importlib import abc - except ImportError: - from importlib2 import abc - - -Prevent compatibility regressions ---------------------------------- - -Once you have fully translated your code to be compatible with Python 3, you -will want to make sure your code doesn't regress and stop working under -Python 3. This is especially true if you have a dependency which is blocking you -from actually running under Python 3 at the moment. - -To help with staying compatible, any new modules you create should have -at least the following block of code at the top of it:: - - from __future__ import absolute_import - from __future__ import division - from __future__ import print_function - -You can also run Python 2 with the ``-3`` flag to be warned about various -compatibility issues your code triggers during execution. If you turn warnings -into errors with ``-Werror`` then you can make sure that you don't accidentally -miss a warning. - -You can also use the Pylint_ project and its ``--py3k`` flag to lint your code -to receive warnings when your code begins to deviate from Python 3 -compatibility. This also prevents you from having to run Modernize_ or Futurize_ -over your code regularly to catch compatibility regressions. This does require -you only support Python 2.7 and Python 3.4 or newer as that is Pylint's -minimum Python version support. - - -Check which dependencies block your transition ----------------------------------------------- - -**After** you have made your code compatible with Python 3 you should begin to -care about whether your dependencies have also been ported. The caniusepython3_ -project was created to help you determine which projects --- directly or indirectly -- are blocking you from supporting Python 3. There -is both a command-line tool as well as a web interface at -https://caniusepython3.com. - -The project also provides code which you can integrate into your test suite so -that you will have a failing test when you no longer have dependencies blocking -you from using Python 3. This allows you to avoid having to manually check your -dependencies and to be notified quickly when you can start running on Python 3. - - -Update your ``setup.py`` file to denote Python 3 compatibility --------------------------------------------------------------- - -Once your code works under Python 3, you should update the classifiers in -your ``setup.py`` to contain ``Programming Language :: Python :: 3`` and to not -specify sole Python 2 support. This will tell anyone using your code that you -support Python 2 **and** 3. Ideally you will also want to add classifiers for -each major/minor version of Python you now support. - - -Use continuous integration to stay compatible ---------------------------------------------- - -Once you are able to fully run under Python 3 you will want to make sure your -code always works under both Python 2 and 3. Probably the best tool for running -your tests under multiple Python interpreters is tox_. You can then integrate -tox with your continuous integration system so that you never accidentally break -Python 2 or 3 support. - -You may also want to use the ``-bb`` flag with the Python 3 interpreter to -trigger an exception when you are comparing bytes to strings or bytes to an int -(the latter is available starting in Python 3.5). By default type-differing -comparisons simply return ``False``, but if you made a mistake in your -separation of text/binary data handling or indexing on bytes you wouldn't easily -find the mistake. This flag will raise an exception when these kinds of -comparisons occur, making the mistake much easier to track down. - - -Consider using optional static type checking --------------------------------------------- - -Another way to help port your code is to use a :term:`static type checker` like -mypy_ or pytype_ on your code. These tools can be used to analyze your code as -if it's being run under Python 2, then you can run the tool a second time as if -your code is running under Python 3. By running a static type checker twice like -this you can discover if you're e.g. misusing binary data type in one version -of Python compared to another. If you add optional type hints to your code you -can also explicitly state whether your APIs use textual or binary data, helping -to make sure everything functions as expected in both versions of Python. - - -.. _caniusepython3: https://pypi.org/project/caniusepython3 -.. _cheat sheet: https://python-future.org/compatible_idioms.html -.. _coverage.py: https://pypi.org/project/coverage -.. _Futurize: https://python-future.org/automatic_conversion.html -.. _importlib2: https://pypi.org/project/importlib2 -.. _Modernize: https://python-modernize.readthedocs.io/ -.. _mypy: https://mypy-lang.org/ -.. _Porting to Python 3: http://python3porting.com/ -.. _Pylint: https://pypi.org/project/pylint - -.. _Python 3 Q & A: https://ncoghlan-devs-python-notes.readthedocs.io/en/latest/python3/questions_and_answers.html - -.. _pytype: https://github.com/google/pytype -.. _python-future: https://python-future.org/ .. _python-porting: https://mail.python.org/pipermail/python-porting/ -.. _six: https://pypi.org/project/six -.. _tox: https://pypi.org/project/tox -.. _trove classifier: https://pypi.org/classifiers - -.. _Why Python 3 exists: https://snarky.ca/why-python-3-exists diff --git a/README.rst b/README.rst index a5321cf3e20726..426b92324c5978 100644 --- a/README.rst +++ b/README.rst @@ -158,15 +158,6 @@ For information about building Python's documentation, refer to `Doc/README.rst `_. -Converting From Python 2.x to 3.x ---------------------------------- - -Significant backward incompatible changes were made for the release of Python -3.0, which may cause programs written for Python 2 to fail when run with Python -3. For more information about porting your code from Python 2 to Python 3, see -the `Porting HOWTO `_. - - Testing -------