Post-Sonos speaker update, AirConnect no longer works

[bulbathor]

Been using AirConnect for several years on a Raspberry Pi without issues. Yesterday, after the Sonos app updated my speakers, AirConnect no longer works. My devices can see and briefly connect to the speakers, but no audio is played and it disconnects after about 10 seconds. Not sure if the Sonos update is a coincidence or if it broke something? Nothing else has changed on the network--same devices (tried with iPhone, iPad, Mac), same router, same Raspberry Pi (no firewall). I ended up formatting and starting over, but still have the same issue. When I run the debug, here's what I get when I try to connect:

airupnp log

[15:00:15.950588] main:1360 Starting airupnp version: v1.0.16 (Mar 22 2023 @ 17:46:08) [15:00:15.951072] main:1367 no config file, using defaults [15:00:16.005510] Start:1083 Binding to iface [email protected]:0 [15:00:16.573221] AddMRDevice:1009 [0x72a0a008]: adding renderer (Living Room) with mac BBBBC2266E3E [15:00:16.592486] MasterHandler:640 [0x72a0a008]: subscribe success [15:00:16.612120] ProcessEvent:445 [0x72a0a008]: UPnP Volume local change 31:31 (master) [15:00:16.620345] AddMRDevice:1009 [0x72a0c350]: adding renderer (Bedroom) with mac BBBB4E8395CA [15:00:16.632913] MasterHandler:640 [0x72a0c350]: subscribe success [15:00:16.647247] ProcessEvent:445 [0x72a0c350]: UPnP Volume local change 33:33 (master) [15:00:16.680712] AddMRDevice:1009 [0x72a0e698]: adding renderer (Kitchen) with mac BBBB568395CA [15:00:16.703084] MasterHandler:640 [0x72a0e698]: subscribe success [15:00:16.726928] ProcessEvent:445 [0x72a0e698]: UPnP Volume local change 11:11 (master) [15:00:16.729261] AddMRDevice:1009 [0x72a109e0]: adding renderer (Office) with mac BBBBCE9C07FD [15:00:16.745976] MasterHandler:640 [0x72a109e0]: subscribe success [15:00:16.760405] ProcessEvent:445 [0x72a109e0]: UPnP Volume local change 23:23 (master) [15:00:32.231732] rtsp_thread:322 got RTSP connection 16 [15:00:32.305744] handle_rtsp:369 [0x70e0e5f0]: challenge dhCk+KsJsaEH7eoHXm5LZg== [15:00:32.344704] handle_rtsp:363 [0x70e0e5f0]: received ANNOUNCE [15:00:32.401166] handle_rtsp:562 [0x70e0e5f0]: responding: RTSP/1.0 200 OK Audio-Jack-Status: connected; type=analog CSeq: 4

[15:00:32.405946] handle_rtsp:363 [0x70e0e5f0]: received SETUP
[15:00:32.415134] raopst_init:378 [0x7030e170]: UDP port-0 57755
[15:00:32.415418] raopst_init:378 [0x7030e170]: UDP port-1 53019
[15:00:32.415541] raopst_init:378 [0x7030e170]: UDP port-2 41863
[15:00:32.415692] raopst_init:396 [0x7030e170]: HTTP listening port 60871
[15:00:32.416505] handle_rtsp:562 [0x70e0e5f0]: responding:
RTSP/1.0 200 OK
Transport: RTP/AVP/UDP;unicast;mode=record;control_port=53019;timing_port=41863;server_port=57755
Session: DEADBEEF
Audio-Jack-Status: connected; type=analog
CSeq: 5

[15:00:32.421230] handle_rtsp:363 [0x70e0e5f0]: received RECORD
[15:00:32.421360] raopst_record:499 [0x7030e170]: record 0 0
[15:00:32.421427] HandleRAOP:288 [0x72a0c350]: Stream
[15:00:32.421728] handle_rtsp:562 [0x70e0e5f0]: responding:
RTSP/1.0 200 OK
Audio-Jack-Status: connected; type=analog
CSeq: 6

[15:00:32.426264] handle_rtsp:363 [0x70e0e5f0]: received SET_PARAMETER
[15:00:32.426490] handle_rtsp:528 [0x70e0e5f0]: SET PARAMETER volume -20.000000
[15:00:32.426611] CtrlSetVolume:232 [0x72a0c350]: uPNP volume 33 (cookie (nil))
[15:00:32.427162] HandleRAOP:365 [0x72a0c350]: Volume[0..100] 33:33
[15:00:32.427378] handle_rtsp:562 [0x70e0e5f0]: responding:
RTSP/1.0 200 OK
Audio-Jack-Status: connected; type=analog
CSeq: 7

[15:00:32.431242] rtp_thread_func:733 [0x7030e170]: 1st sync packet received
[15:00:32.457480] flac_init:195 [0x7030e170]: Using FLAC-0 (0x70d012b0)
[15:00:32.458019] buffer_put_packet:617 [0x7030e170]: fill [level:1] [W:33312 R:33312]
[15:00:32.748060] handle_rtsp:363 [0x70e0e5f0]: received FLUSH
[15:00:32.748496] raopst_flush:483 [0x7030e170]: flush 33312 1947071043
[15:00:32.748625] HandleRAOP:302 [0x72a0c350]: Flush
[15:00:32.748704] AVTStop:204 [0x72a0c350]: uPNP stop (cookie 0x1)
[15:00:32.749162] handle_rtsp:562 [0x70e0e5f0]: responding:
RTSP/1.0 200 OK
Audio-Jack-Status: connected; type=analog
CSeq: 8

[15:00:32.749511] flac_init:195 [0x7030e170]: Using FLAC-0 (0x70d012b0)
[15:00:33.270342] search_remote_cb:604 [0x70e0e5f0]: found ActiveRemote for 306E4E29325EF921 at 192.168.1.7:54960
[15:00:34.350800] handle_rtsp:363 [0x70e0e5f0]: received SET_PARAMETER
[15:00:34.351144] handle_rtsp:562 [0x70e0e5f0]: responding:
RTSP/1.0 200 OK
Audio-Jack-Status: connected; type=analog
CSeq: 9

[15:00:34.355710] handle_rtsp:363 [0x70e0e5f0]: received SET_PARAMETER
[15:00:34.355931] handle_rtsp:562 [0x70e0e5f0]: responding:
RTSP/1.0 200 OK
Audio-Jack-Status: connected; type=analog
CSeq: 10

[15:00:34.360787] handle_rtsp:363 [0x70e0e5f0]: received SET_PARAMETER
[15:00:34.360914] handle_rtsp:544 [0x70e0e5f0]: received metadata
artist: M83ascp
album: Fantasyasar
title: Water Deepastn
[15:00:34.361134] handle_rtsp:562 [0x70e0e5f0]: responding:
RTSP/1.0 200 OK
Audio-Jack-Status: connected; type=analog
CSeq: 11

[15:00:36.543013] buffer_put_packet:617 [0x7030e170]: fill [level:503] [W:33824 R:33322]
[15:00:36.632820] ActionHandler:513 [0x72a0c350]: uPNP stopped
[15:00:37.399843] AVTSetURI:78 [0x72a0c350]: uPNP setURI http://192.168.1.20:60871/stream-0.flc (cookie 0x4)
[15:00:37.400468] handle_rtsp:363 [0x70e0e5f0]: received SET_PARAMETER
[15:00:37.401144] AVTPlay:138 [0x72a0c350]: uPNP play (cookie 0x5)
[15:00:37.401515] handle_rtsp:544 [0x70e0e5f0]: received metadata
artist: M83ascp
album: Fantasyasar
title: Water Deepcaps
[15:00:37.401743] handle_rtsp:562 [0x70e0e5f0]: responding:
RTSP/1.0 200 OK
Audio-Jack-Status: connected; type=analog
CSeq: 14

[15:00:37.407424] handle_rtsp:363 [0x70e0e5f0]: received SET_PARAMETER
[15:00:37.407777] handle_rtsp:562 [0x70e0e5f0]: responding:
RTSP/1.0 200 OK
Audio-Jack-Status: connected; type=analog
CSeq: 15

[15:00:37.444437] http_thread_func:1055 [0x7030e170]: got HTTP connection 27 (silent frames 0)
[15:00:37.446700] handle_http:1230 [0x7030e170]: received GET HTTP/1.1
CONNECTION: close
Host: 192.168.1.20:60871
ACCEPT: /
USER-AGENT: Linux UPnP/1.0 Sonos/72.2-39150 (ZPS12)
X-Sonos-SWGen: 2
X-Sonos-Firmware: 72.2-39150
X-Sonos-Muse-Api: 1.33.2
X-Sonos-Id-Hash: gMtjDf33DYOHwzVOyM4mLk6PsdoIKC1i+0INzuG+D8I=

[15:00:37.447810] handle_http:1275 [0x7030e170]: responding: HTTP/1.0 200 OK
Server: HairTunes
Content-Type: audio/flac
Connection: close

[15:00:37.449083] _buffer_get_frame:954 [0x7030e170]: drain [level:614 gap:-3144] [W:33936 R:33322] [R:0 S:0 F:0]
[15:00:37.493659] _buffer_get_frame:954 [0x7030e170]: drain [level:108 gap:898] [W:33942 R:33834] [R:0 S:0 F:0]
[15:00:38.453250] handle_rtsp:363 [0x70e0e5f0]: received SET_PARAMETER
[15:00:38.453446] handle_rtsp:544 [0x70e0e5f0]: received metadata
artist: M83ascp
album: Fantasyasar
title: Water Deepcaps
[15:00:38.453770] handle_rtsp:562 [0x70e0e5f0]: responding:
RTSP/1.0 200 OK
Audio-Jack-Status: connected; type=analog
CSeq: 16

[15:00:38.459559] handle_rtsp:363 [0x70e0e5f0]: received SET_PARAMETER
[15:00:38.460592] handle_rtsp:562 [0x70e0e5f0]: responding:
RTSP/1.0 200 OK
Audio-Jack-Status: connected; type=analog
CSeq: 17

[15:00:40.630618] buffer_put_packet:617 [0x7030e170]: fill [level:1] [W:34336 R:34336]
[15:00:40.711655] _buffer_get_frame:954 [0x7030e170]: drain [level:0 gap:1765] [W:34346 R:34346] [R:0 S:0 F:0]
[15:00:42.134388] ActionHandler:508 [0x72a0c350]: uPNP transition
[15:00:44.740895] buffer_put_packet:617 [0x7030e170]: fill [level:7] [W:34848 R:34842]
[15:00:44.800737] _buffer_get_frame:954 [0x7030e170]: drain [level:0 gap:1763] [W:34858 R:34858] [R:0 S:0 F:0]
[15:00:48.803730] buffer_put_packet:617 [0x7030e170]: fill [level:1] [W:35360 R:35360]
[15:00:48.888687] _buffer_get_frame:954 [0x7030e170]: drain [level:0 gap:1761] [W:35370 R:35370] [R:0 S:0 F:0]
[15:00:49.038422] http_read_line:775 fd: 27 read error: Connection reset by peer
[15:00:49.038662] http_parse_simple:698 cannot read method
[15:00:49.038825] http_thread_func:1074 HTTP close 27
[15:00:49.038964] http_thread_func:1055 [0x7030e170]: got HTTP connection 27 (silent frames 0)
[15:00:49.041548] handle_http:1230 [0x7030e170]: received HEAD HTTP/1.1
CONNECTION: close
Host: 192.168.1.20:60871
USER-AGENT: Linux UPnP/1.0 Sonos/72.2-39150 (ZPS12)
X-Sonos-SWGen: 2
X-Sonos-Firmware: 72.2-39150
X-Sonos-Muse-Api: 1.33.2
X-Sonos-Id-Hash: gMtjDf33DYOHwzVOyM4mLk6PsdoIKC1i+0INzuG+D8I=

[15:00:49.041839] handle_http:1275 [0x7030e170]: responding: HTTP/1.0 200 OK
Server: HairTunes
Content-Type: audio/flac
Connection: close

[15:00:49.042169] http_thread_func:1074 HTTP close 27
[15:00:49.130100] ActionHandler:531 Error in action callback -- -204 (cookie 0x12)
[15:00:49.583810] UpdateThread:716 [0x72a0c350]: renderer bye-bye: Bedroom+
[15:00:49.593354] http_thread_func:1211 [0x7030e170]: terminating
[15:00:49.594374] rtp_thread_func:822 [0x7030e170]: terminating

If it's at all useful, both the older Play:1 speakers that aren't working are on Sonos OS: S2, Version 15.2 (build 72239150)

Any help would be appreciated!

[pwt]

Hi @philippe44: Unfortunately, I'm seeing what looks like the same issue with Sonos S2 (15.2): the 15.2 update happened overnight for me, and airupnp was working fine yesterday.

I'm currently running airupnp version: v1.0.14.

Sonos S1 (11.8) appears still to be working fine with airupnp.

Let me know if I can assist with any diagnostics.

[philippe44]

Can you try using mp3 or wav for the format of audio sent to the Sonos? You can also try to use chunked mode for http. But in general, this is what I was afraid of, that at some point, Sonos would do an update that would sc..w up the UPnP compatibility, because they don't care

[pwt]

But in general, this is what I was afraid of, that at some point, Sonos would do an update that would sc..w up the UPnP compatibility, because they don't care

Yep, me too. One day I'm sure they're going to break an entire ecosystem of open source usefulness.

It's possibly something minor in this case, though. My play_file action in SoCo-CLI is still working OK, and that operates by setting up a local HTTP server to serve an audio file and instructing Sonos to play its URI, which is not dissimilar to the Sonos end of AirConnect.

[bulbathor]

Chunked mode didn't help, sadly. Weirdly, regardless of what audio format I'm sending, it shows audio/flac for the content type. Tried an MP3 and WAV, in Quicktime, Apple Music, and on a system-wide level.

update to add: experimented and downgraded one of the speakers to S1 and it's working again, so to me that suggests something went sideways in the update.

[philippe44]

No, I mean it is an option on AirConnect command line or in the config file to tell it which codec it should use to re-encode the audio

[philippe44]

But in general, this is what I was afraid of, that at some point, Sonos would do an update that would sc..w up the UPnP compatibility, because they don't care

Yep, me too. One day I'm sure they're going to break an entire ecosystem of open source usefulness.

It's possibly something minor in this case, though. My play_file action in SoCo-CLI is still working OK, and that operates by setting up a local HTTP server to serve an audio file and instructing Sonos to play its URI, which is not dissimilar to the Sonos end of AirConnect.

What I'm afraid of is that they insist on getting the size of the encoded file (content-length), which of course I don't know and is not an HTTP mandatory parameter. But that would explain why regular webserver in SoCo-CLI works. Best way to check is to use WAV

[bulbathor]

No, I mean it is an option on AirConnect command line or in the config file to tell it which codec it should use to re-encode the audio

Oh I see, apologies for the misunderstanding. This fix works! Thank you!

edit to add: tested this last night and this morning for a couple hours. WAV works just fine on my two Play:1's, both on S2.

[Spy-1]

Strangely, in my system, the Play 3 (S2) do work, but the Play 1 (s2). do not work.

[pwt]

Best way to check is to use WAV

Thanks. Initial testing suggests that it does work with WAV.

I'm testing with Play:1 speakers, BTW. These are the only non-AirPlay devices I have running on S2.

[Spy-1]

MP3 converted to WAV is not working for me on my Play:1

[philippe44]

Can you describe what you do exactly?

[Spy-1]

I converted a mp3 to wav.

[philippe44]

I was afraid you did :-)

No you must change the parameter of AirConnect so that it sends WAV to your Sonos player. Look at the README, it explains how to change the format produced by AirConnect

[Spy-1]

OK! So this is really new for me.
I´m running airconnect in a docker Container.
I am able to access via putty /volume1/airconnect
but there are only one File -airconnect.conf and one directory -Log.
if i create a file named config.xlm witch and codec wav in this directory the changes will not have any effect.

[philippe44]

Best way to check is to use WAV

Thanks. Initial testing suggests that it does work with WAV.

I'm testing with Play:1 speakers, BTW. These are the only non-AirPlay devices I have running on S2.

It really seems that Sonos now refuses to handle FLAC files without knowing the size of the file. It's a shame and definitively a non-compliance to HTTP

[philippe44]

OK! So this is really new for me. I´m running airconnect in a docker Container. I am able to access via putty /volume1/airconnect but there are only one File -airconnect.conf and one directory -Log. if i create a file named config.xlm witch and codec wav in this directory the changes will not have any effect.

You can use -c wav on the command line and don't have to create a config file

[philippe44]

BTW, can one of you try and http_length in the config file of say 2000000000 and use flac to see if it works?

[Diacius]

(I am also affected by this)
How can I do that, do I just do -g 0 and then a number or does it have to be done in config?
EDIT: never mind I found the details in the readme

[Diacius]

Default format (flac) does not appear to work with -g 0 however if I use -c wav to encode to wav the audio plays fine!
edit: mp3 also works although it adds a lot of delay

[philippe44]

I have no idea what Sonos did. Is this to their flac decoder or to the http... My flac decoder is the official one, maybe one version below the latest and I use the "streamable" subformat which is supposed to be the most compatible one.

[Diacius]

I have no idea what Sonos did. Is this to their flac decoder or to the http... My flac decoder is the official one, maybe one version below the latest and I use the "streamable" subformat which is supposed to be the most compatible one.

I suspect that they changed their flac decoder and the new one needs the file size to work, or the change is completely unintentional and is just a result of something else.

[Spy-1]

next strange thing for me:
-c wav is working only on iPhone, iPad with both speakerts play:1 and play:3.
With iTunes for Windows i can´t stream to the play:1, but play:3 works ???

[philippe44]

I don't think it's related to wav. These are two very separated items. Are you 1000000% sure that this exact combination of iTunes and Sonos worked before? Like absolutely sure?

[Spy-1]

Sorry for this.
Itˋs working now.
A restart of airconnect did it.

[chucklebrother]

BTW, can one of you try and http_length in the config file of say 2000000000 and use flac to see if it works?

I think this is the same as -g 0 on the comand line:

Use -g -3|-1|0| to tweak http transfer mode where -3 = chunked, -1 = no content-length and 0 = fixed (dummy) length (see "HTTP content-length" below)"

Unfortunately this did not help, unless there is something else I'm missing about specifyng an arbtraty dumy length via the config file?

In any case, use WAV format instead of FLAC does fix the issue. Thanks for the advice/workaround.

This is with a Sonos PLAY:1 using Airconnect v1.0.17 (Apr 2 2023 @ 12:01:07)

[wickens]

I had the same issue, after finding this thread,I changed <codec>flu</codec> to <codec>wav</codec> in the config file, and it started working.
My setup: 2 Sonos 1 (from 2017) setup as a stereo pair. Using Apple Music on Mac/iPhone.

[eizedev]

For me with Sonos 15.3 and airupnp 1.1.0 now everything works again (Sonos Play 1) with the original Flac codec. Can you please also test it?

[Spy-1]

It´s working for me too with flac codec!

[philippe44]

I'll close this one then

[Spy-1]

Now, with latest Sonos System Update flac does not work for me with my Play3 anymore.

[philippe44]

Looks like great SW quality control on their side

[Diacius]

it never started working for me!

[stephenjharrington]

Changing my config back (as per previous workaround) to:-

<codec>wav</codec>

gets it going again for me...

Groundhog Day?

:-)

[Spy-1]

The workaround is working for me too but only with my play1.
My play3 are not discovered.

[philippe44]

Discovery and audio format for playback are really not correlated. Are you sure it was discovered, it is not anymore and nothing in your network has changed?

[Spy-1]

No changes. It was working before latest sonosupdate.
When I generate the config.xml only the play1 are found.