You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
There is a problem with tags tourism=artwork and historic=memorial. They have subtags with the same meaning: artwork has artwork_type=sculpture;statue;bust and memorial has memorial=sculpture;statue;bust. A bust icon is rendered if you put historic=memorial+memorial=bust. But if you add tourism=artwork on the same node, it is rendered like a generic artwork . Even if you put:
it still doesn't render a bust.
In reality, all memorial=bust are also tourism=artwork, so it isn't wrong tagging.
In my opinion we should first decide which tag is stronger in case of different values, memorial=* or artwork_type=*. After that, just render whatever is in those tags, or in the stronger tag if there are both.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
Bust and stone are concerned. I propose to render for now artwork_type=bust with the current memorial=bust icon. It's a rapid fix. Icon of memorial=stone suggests an inscription so I propose for this one to wait for the rendering of natural=stone as node (#2616).
Using the icon for an entire building was for me confusing. This happens when artwork_type=architecture is applied. An example is the Siemens-Villa. Maybe you should make an exception for artwork_type=architecture.
There is a problem with tags tourism=artwork and historic=memorial. They have subtags with the same meaning: artwork has artwork_type=sculpture;statue;bust and memorial has memorial=sculpture;statue;bust. A bust icon is rendered if you put historic=memorial+memorial=bust. But if you add tourism=artwork on the same node, it is rendered like a generic artwork . Even if you put:
historic=memorial+memorial=bust+tourism=artwork+artwork_type=bust
it still doesn't render a bust.
In reality, all memorial=bust are also tourism=artwork, so it isn't wrong tagging.
In my opinion we should first decide which tag is stronger in case of different values, memorial=* or artwork_type=*. After that, just render whatever is in those tags, or in the stronger tag if there are both.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: