Bug: Context.Consumer inside Suspense does not receive context updates while suspended
#19701
Labels
Comments
overlookmotel
added
the
Status: Unconfirmed
|
Can you turn this into a failing test, like we did for #17356? |
gaearon
added
Component: Reconciler
Type: Bug
and removed
Status: Unconfirmed
overlookmotel
added a commit
to overlookmotel/react
that referenced
this issue
Aug 26, 2020
overlookmotel
added a commit
to overlookmotel/react
that referenced
this issue
Aug 26, 2020
overlookmotel
added a commit
to overlookmotel/react
that referenced
this issue
Aug 26, 2020
|
@overlookmotel and @gaearon This is looking abandoned. Can I take a look at it? |
|
@engprodigy I've submitted PR #19702 with a failing test. Personally, I'd very much appreciate your input if you have any ideas for a fix. |
|
Sure @overlookmotel |
gaearon
pushed a commit
to gaearon/react
that referenced
this issue
Jan 11, 2022
gaearon
added a commit
that referenced
this issue
Jan 19, 2022
* Failing test for Context.Consumer in suspended Suspense See issue #19701. * Fix context propagation for offscreen trees * Address nits * Specify propagation root for Suspense too * Pass correct propagation root * Harden test coverage This test will fail if we remove propagation, or if we propagate with a root node like fiber.return or fiber.return.return. The additional DEV-only error helps detect a different kind of mistake, like if the thing being passed hasn't actually been encountered on the way up. However, we still leave the actual production loop to check against null so that there is no way we loop forever if the propagation root is wrong. * Remove superfluous warning Co-authored-by: overlookmotel <[email protected]>
zhengjitf
pushed a commit
to zhengjitf/react
that referenced
this issue
Apr 15, 2022
* Failing test for Context.Consumer in suspended Suspense See issue facebook#19701. * Fix context propagation for offscreen trees * Address nits * Specify propagation root for Suspense too * Pass correct propagation root * Harden test coverage This test will fail if we remove propagation, or if we propagate with a root node like fiber.return or fiber.return.return. The additional DEV-only error helps detect a different kind of mistake, like if the thing being passed hasn't actually been encountered on the way up. However, we still leave the actual production loop to check against null so that there is no way we loop forever if the propagation root is wrong. * Remove superfluous warning Co-authored-by: overlookmotel <[email protected]>
nevilm-lt
pushed a commit
to nevilm-lt/react
that referenced
this issue
Apr 22, 2022
* Failing test for Context.Consumer in suspended Suspense See issue facebook#19701. * Fix context propagation for offscreen trees * Address nits * Specify propagation root for Suspense too * Pass correct propagation root * Harden test coverage This test will fail if we remove propagation, or if we propagate with a root node like fiber.return or fiber.return.return. The additional DEV-only error helps detect a different kind of mistake, like if the thing being passed hasn't actually been encountered on the way up. However, we still leave the actual production loop to check against null so that there is no way we loop forever if the propagation root is wrong. * Remove superfluous warning Co-authored-by: overlookmotel <[email protected]>
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
A
<Context.Consumer>callback inside a suspended<Suspense>boundary does not receive updates when context value changes.This issue was originally found with React Router (remix-run/react-router#7137) but can be reproduced with React alone.
React version: 16.13.1 or 17.0.0-rc.0 (and at least some earlier versions too)
Steps To Reproduce
https://codesandbox.io/s/suspense-context-test-case-6jlsq
The current behavior
In the example above, clicking on the "About" button puts the
<Suspense>boundary into a suspended state. Clicking "Home" updates the context value, but the<Context.Consumer>callback is not called with this updated value. Therefore the page never navigates back to "Home".Please note that
Received context: homeis not logged after the "Home" button is pressed.The expected behavior
The
<Context.Consumer>callback should be called with value'home'when the value of the context is updated.Please note that the problem does not occur if any of:
Aboutfunction to verify).useContext()is used in place of<Context.Consumer>(substitute<SwitchWithUseContext />for<Switch />).Switchfunction is inlined within the<Suspense>rather than in a separate component.The last of these leads me to suspect that the problem may be related to #17356. In the example,
<Context.Consumer>is within aSwitchcomponent. But the<Switch>element inside<Suspense>never changes - so it's effectively memoized. I wonder if this is why it doesn't receive context updates?The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: