EIP Editing Office Hour Meeting 60 (EIP+ERC) | May 13, 2025

[poojaranjan]

Date & Time

Tuesday, May 13, 2025 at 16:00 UTC

Info

• Zoom: Protocol Calendar on EthCatHerders Discord #eip-editors
• Recording: Playlist
• Editor: @SamWilsn
• Facilitator: @poojaranjan

Related Resources

• EIP-1: EIP Purpose and Guidelines
• RIP-7810: RIP Purpose and Guidelines
• EIP-5069: EIP Editor Handbook
• Sam's Rules for EIPs
• EIP Editors' Onboarding
• EIP editor "apprentice" handbook
• EIP Reviewers: Permissions, requirements, roles & responsibilities
• Workshop Presentation
• EIP Reviewers: Survey & Contribution Report
• EIP Editors' Workshop video
• EIP Reviewing Interest Form
• Office Hour Announcement Blogpost
  -

Agenda

• Visit Ethereum Improvement Proposals

To Final

• Update ERC-7837: Move to Final ERCs#1030
• Update EIP-7600: Move to Final EIPs#9740
• Update EIP-2935: Move to Final EIPs#9742
• Update EIP-6110: Move to Final EIPs#9746 and a typo fix Update EIP-6110: Fix typos in eip-6110.md EIPs#9767
• Update EIP-7002: Move to Final EIPs#9747 and a typo fix Update EIP-7002: fix variable name typo in withdrawal requests dequeue function EIPs#9768
• Update EIP-7251: Move to Final EIPs#9748
• Update EIP-7549: Move to Final EIPs#9749 and a typo fix Update EIP-7549: Update eip-7549.md EIPs#9769
• Update EIP-7623: Move to Final EIPs#9750
• Update EIP-7685: Move to Final EIPs#9751
• Update EIP-7691: Move to Final EIPs#9752
• Update EIP-7702: Move to Final EIPs#9753
• Update EIP-7840: Move to Final EIPs#9754

To Last Call

ERCs

• Update ERC-7743: Move to Last Call ERCs#918

To Review

• Update ERC-4337: Move to Review ERCs#1014
• Update ERC-7858: Move to Review ERCs#1023
• Update ERC-7291: Move to Review ERCs#887
• Update ERC-7878: Move to Review ERCs#1031
• Update ERC-7858: Move to Review ERCs#1023
• Update ERC-7634: Move to Review ERCs#983

Misc.

TBA

To Draft

EIPs

• Add EIP: Algorithmic Transaction Wrapper EIPs#9633

ERCs

• Add ERC: Margin Token Wrapper ERCs#979
• Add ERC: PermaLink Asset Bound Token ERCs#999
• Add ERC: Composite EIP-712 Signatures ERCs#993
• Add ERC: Sustainable collaborative NFT collections ERCs#752
• Add ERC: Interoperable Addresses ERCs#1002
• Add ERC: Decentralised User Profiles ERCs#861
• Add ERC: Instinct-Based Automatic Transactions ERCs#596
• Add ERC: Ethereum Network Configuration for DApps ERCs#1003
• Add ERC: DeFi Protocol Solvency Proof Mechanism ERCs#922

Additional Reviews

• PRs from Project Board?

Open Q&A

(Drop the Pull Request number to be added to the agenda.)

The EIP Editing Office Hour Meeting 61 (EIP) is scheduled for May 20, at 16:00 UTC with Editor Gajinder Singh

[poojaranjan]

Summary

• 9 out of 12 PRs reviewed were merged.
• Remaining PRs for Pectra EIPs moving to Final will be reviewed asynchronously.
• EIP process was explained at 21:18 timestamp.

Additional Highlights:

• Pooja initiated the meeting, welcomed attendees, and reviewed the agenda.
• Sam Wilson:
  • Walked through multiple EIP PRs and offered process guidance for finalization.
  • Offered to put ERC-7920 on the agenda for wallet dev call.
  • Reviewed a new NFT standard supporting multiple owners.
  • Discussed proposal progress with authors providing constructive feedback.
  • Reviewed draft proposals covering:
    • Algorithm standards
    • Transaction wrappers
    • Margin token wrappers
    • A unified wrapper contract for streamlined usaget were discussed.

Next steps

• Narcis to update the file name in PR # 999 on the ERC repository.
• Sam to add ERC-7920 to the agenda for the upcoming wallet devs call.
• Authors of EIP-7858 to update the last call deadline to the 27th and make formatting changes as suggested by Sam.
• Authors of EIP-7291 to address Sam's comments and make necessary changes before moving to Last Call.
• Authors of EIP-7634 to work on technical aspects of the proposal before moving to last call.
• Pooja to upload the agenda for the next meeting on the ethereum/pm repository.
   

[poojaranjan]

Closing in favor of #1542