[Spec] Define #EDITION & add #TAGS or #KEYWORDS

[marwin89]

Suggestion

SUMMARY / VOTE NOW 📈 ✋

Present situation: users use #EDITION for different things (Album, decade, topic etc.) in usdb, its inconsistent. There was no official definition for that attribute in format.

We need to define #EDITION. There was a long discussion in discord that I summarize here.

Here are the voting options.

Please vote for this issue till 31th oct 2023 with emoticon 🎉 / 🚀 / ❤️ .

🚀 A: deprecate #EDITION at all

🎉 B: define #EDITION only for "Editions of games" like SingStar - Pop Hits, GuitarHero Live, Rockband vol.4, Let's Sing 2020

❤️ C: define #EDITION only for "Editions of games" like SingStar - Pop Hits, GuitarHero Live, Rockband vol.4, Let's Sing 2020

AND add a new attribute #TAGS (with multiple entries) that can contain "any reasonable keyword" for this song to be found like topic, mood, etc.: for example: Love Songs , Movie , 80s
AND write the "version of a song" into #TITLE with ( )

👀 D: define #EDITION only for the "version of a song": "live version", "Explicit", "Video Version", "Remix", "12inch version", "Album version"

AND add a new attribute #TAGS (with multiple entries) that can contain "any reasonable keyword" for this song to be found like topic, mood, etc.: for example: Eurovision Song Contest , Glam Rock , Pride

Use case

Why?

• users in usdb don't know how to use #EDITION, its inconsistent
• we need a clear definition, #GENRE seems to be not enough for different keywords

Extra info/examples/attachments

Examples:

A:

B:

#EDITION: Rockband vol.4

C:

#TITLE: Final Countdown (live) 
#EDITION: Rockband vol.4
#TAGS: Love Songs , Movie , 80s

D:

#EDITION: "Explicit", "12inch version"
#TAGS: Eurovision Song Contest , Glam Rock , Pride

Spreadsheet for defining common #TAGS/#KEYWORDS for USDB/Tools

[marwin89]

SUMMARY / FINAL RESULT 🚩

Thanks for voting. Here are the final results for this issue.

We introduce #TAGS and use #EDITION only for music games.

❤ 5 🚀 0 🎉 0 👀 : 1

Details

• #EDITION is only for "Editions of games" like SingStar - Pop Hits, GuitarHero Live, Rockband vol.4, Let's Sing 2020
• add a new attribute #TAGS (with multiple entries) that can contain "any reasonable keyword" for this song to be found like topic, mood, place etc.: for example: Love Songs , Movie , 80s
• write the "version of a song" into #TITLE with ( )
• Song Editors have a auto complete function in GUI that adds these common keywords into #TAGS:
  Party, Feel-Good, Charts, Cover Songs, Summer, Pride / LGBTQ, Love Songs, Heartbreak / Sadness, Guilty Pleasure, Disney, Underrated, Christmas, Halloween, Eurovision Song Contest [YEAR], Club / Dancefloor, Viral Hit, Relaxed, Special Interest, Funny, Underground, Mainstream, Slow

Why?

• users in usdb don't know how to use #EDITION, its inconsistent
• we need a clear definition, #GENRE seems to be not enough for different keywords

Examples:

#TITLE: Final Countdown (live) 
#EDITION: Rockband vol.4
#TAGS: Love Songs , Movie , 80s

---

Text on Website

#TAGS allows you to add any reasonable keyword for this song to be found like topic, mood etc. You can add multiple tags and seperate them with comma.

#TAGS: Summer, Cover Songs, Charts