from_stop_id and to_stop_id not required for transfer_type 4 & 5 #1621
Labels
bug
Something isn't working (crash, a rule has a problem)
status: Ready
An issue that is ready to be worked on.
Milestone
Describe the bug
Hi!
The GTFS specification does not explicitly require that
from_stop_id
andto_stop_id
be provided for records intransfers.txt
with atransfer_type
of4
or5
. However, the validator reports amissing_required_field
error if these two fields are not provided.Steps/Code to Reproduce
Using the online GTFS validator, validate this file:
transcollines-qc-ca-fares-transfers.zip
(Ignore the other errors about translations and shape distances, those are known and being worked on)
Expected Results
Validator should not report a
missing_required_field
error iffrom_stop_id
andto_stop_id
are not provided intransfers.txt
iftransfer_type
=4
or5
Actual Results
Validator returns a
missing_required_field
error iffrom_stop_id
andto_stop_id
are not provided intransfers.txt
iftransfer_type
=4
or5
Screenshots
No response
Files used
transcollines-qc-ca-fares-transfers.zip
(Ignore other errors about translations and shape distances, those are known and are being worked on)
Validator version
4.2.1-SNAPSHOT
Operating system
(Web version of validator)
Java version
No response
Additional notes
No response
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: