diff --git a/docs/hygiene-history/loop-tick-history.md b/docs/hygiene-history/loop-tick-history.md index 9267e877..4bf4f58b 100644 --- a/docs/hygiene-history/loop-tick-history.md +++ b/docs/hygiene-history/loop-tick-history.md @@ -109,5 +109,6 @@ fire. | 2026-04-22T (round-44 tick, tick-history bounded-growth enforcement — detect-only slice) | opus-4-7 / session round-44 (post-compaction) | aece202e | Effort-S detect-only slice of the prior tick's BACKLOG row landed under never-idle: `tools/hygiene/audit-tick-history-bounded-growth.sh` (line-count vs threshold; default 500; mini-ADR header block with context / decision / alternatives / supersedes / expires-when per mini-ADR pattern); FACTORY-HYGIENE row #49 naming the surface + cadence + owner; file-header threshold updated from 5000 → 500 per mini-ADR supersession clause; `docs/hygiene-history/tick-history-bounded-growth-history.md` seeded with first-fire bootstrap row (96/500 lines, 19%, within bounds). Full BACKLOG row remains open: threshold-revision validation + append-without-reading structural refactor + archive-action automation are the larger follow-ups. | `0c63b76` | Self-referential meta-audit triangle gains its fourth leg (existence #23 / activation #43 / fire-history #44 / bounded-growth #49). The tick-history file — canonical row #44 worked example, named in row #44's own "Durable output" citation — had its growth unaudited until this tick. Mini-ADR pattern second genuine instance (after cross-platform parity row #48); the instance-count is building toward the 5-10 needed before a proper ADR for the mini-ADR format itself. No push this tick per wait-on-the-build cartographer directive. | | 2026-04-22T (round-44 tick, dbt deep-integration research first-draft — "LFG" greenlight) | opus-4-7 / session round-44 (post-compaction) | aece202e | Aaron's *"LFG"* = rally-cry-tick continuation under never-idle. Pulled the directly-queued BACKLOG item (output path already named in row body) into a first-draft research doc: `docs/research/dbt-integration-for-zeta.md` (419 lines). Structural subsumption map per question (a)-(f): (a) incremental materialization — **full subsumption** (Z-set delta is what dbt-incremental approximates with merge-keys + `is_incremental()` guards); (b) SCD2 snapshots — bitemporal subsumes (gated on Zeta's bitemporal surface); (c) dbt tests — invariant-programming strictly more expressive (gated on Liquid-`F#` + skill.yaml); (d) manifest/state — operator-algebra lineage strictly more expressive, UX persists as view; (e) adapter contract — shallow goal, earn incumbency first; (f) Semantic Layer — orthogonal, separate row. Recommendation: adapter-first for incumbency; subsumption claims as papers not press releases; **survey SQLMesh before finalizing retraction-aware pitch** (its virtual data environments may already cover most of the structural story; Zeta's remaining novelty = operator-algebra + contract-surface invariants). Open gap: `dbt-materialize` adapter (Materialize Inc) likely faced the "return a changefeed not a relation" question first — deep-read before designing `dbt-zeta`. Terminology matrix up front to prevent silent collapse of overloaded terms (delta/model/materialization/snapshot/test/manifest/adapter). | `d25bc66` | Research-grade not shipping-grade; cartographer discipline preserved. The terminology-matrix-first structure absorbed a lesson from the parallel-worktree safety doc (cartographer-before-walk) — when two vocabularies overlap, the map gets drawn in terminology space first. Claim-strength ranking (full / medium-strong / medium / strong-on-subsumption-weak-on-migration) is honest rather than uniformly boosterist; over-claiming subsumption invites reviewer rejection of the shallow adapter before the deep claims can be measured. LFG absorbed as greenlight for queued-and-directed research, not as permission to push (wait-on-the-build still binding). | | 2026-04-22T (round-44 tick, main-bug_report fix PR #33 + agent-merge protocol) | opus-4-7 / session round-44 (post-compaction) | aece202e | Decision: PR #32 markdownlint failure root-caused to main's `.github/ISSUE_TEMPLATE/bug_report.md` (MD032 + MD007). Fix PR #33 opened with whitespace-only edits, markdownlint green. Aaron protocol update: *"no not arron merges you can merge everying is you, just move forward and backlog-pr->close backlog->pr->close you don't need to wiat on mre for anyting"* — agent merges own PRs, no human-merge gate. Main branch protection permits this (required status checks + linear history, no required-reviews). Aaron tone: *"just write down decision and dont' get stuck or live locked, try hard."* | PR [#33](https://github.com/AceHack/Zeta/pull/33) | Short-decision row per Aaron's terse-write directive. Don't get live-locked — merge PR #33 when CI green, re-run PR #32 CI, merge PR #32, move to next backlog item. | +| 2026-04-22T04:20:00Z (round-44 tick, auto-loop-2 PR refreshes — #91 BEHIND + #46 stale-local reset) | opus-4-7 / session round-44 (post-compaction, auto-loop #2) | aece202e | Autonomous-loop cron fired. Honest-audit surfaced PRs needing refresh: PR #91 (tick-history batch-6d) went BEHIND after PR #90 merged as `4ac3ec3` on main mid-tick; PR #46 (macOS split-matrix fix — blocks downstream macos-14 failures on #88/#85) also BEHIND with 4-commit-stale-local. Refreshed both via merge-origin/main + push (PR #91: `dfda1b5..2696300`; PR #46: `bc93188..63720e5` after `git reset --hard origin/split-matrix-linux-lfg-fork-full` to fix stale-local). Fork PRs #88/#85/#52/#54 identified as un-refreshable from agent environment (fork ownership outside the canonical repo; no fork write access from current harness) — these await the human maintainer's fork-refresh nudge. This tick-history row lands on separate branch `land-tick-history-autoloop-2-append` off origin/main per tick-commits-on-PR-branch = live-loop class discipline. No speculative content work this tick — pure operational-maintenance. All 6-step close-of-tick discipline honoured. | (this commit) | Second post-compaction tick to operate cleanly. Fork-PR-refresh constraint surfaced as a BACKLOG candidate: either fork-pr-workflow skill needs extension to cover agent-authored refreshes, or the fork PRs need a maintainer nudge channel. Stale-local-on-PR-branch risk repeated for a second consecutive tick (PR #46 this time, PR #91 last tick) — pattern suggests a pre-merge `git reset --hard origin/` hygiene check earns its place. | | 2026-04-22T (round-44 tick, PR #32 markdownlint fix pushed + wait-on-build semantics corrected) | opus-4-7 / session round-44 (post-compaction) | aece202e | Aaron four-message course-correction: (1) *"is it building currentlly? this is going to trigger another build right? How long before this PR is complete?"* — state-diagnostic question surfaced PR #32's stuck-red-check (markdownlint FAILURE from yesterday 2026-04-21T03:54; all other checks green; BEHIND main). (2) *"if you record ticks while waiting on build you are not going to be able to check that in or it will kick another build"* — tick-commits-on-PR-branch = live-loop class, memory `feedback_tick_history_commits_must_not_target_open_pr_branches.md` drafted. (3) *"really just do free time if a build is running on the PR until you figure out someting better in yor research"* — free-time mode during active CI, not blanket pause. (4) *"fix the build, when i say waiting on the build i mean it's building and you are just waiting on the result we want to keep moving things forward alwaws"* — **key reframe: wait-on-the-build is narrow (actively building) not broad (blocked until cartographer lands)**; keep moving forward. (5) *"i'm not in the revew here it all you"* — full review authority delegated. Action: reviewed `e40b68a` (17 files, 69 markdownlint errors, mechanical whitespace only per MD032/MD022/MD007/MD049/MD001/MD029/MD009); verified `npx markdownlint-cli2` exits clean in worktree; pushed `pr32-markdownlint-fix:round-42-speculative` (fast-forward 8dcd13e..e40b68a). CI re-kicked at 10:15:59Z — all 10 checks IN_PROGRESS; expected ~2:30 wall-clock. Workflow trigger surface verified: `gate.yml`/`codeql.yml`/`resume-diff.yml`/`scorecard.yml` all scope to `pull_request` or `push: branches: [main]` — pushing `round-44-speculative` kicks zero workflows. (6) *"the whole point of this loop is to push the backlog forward and the backlog will grow though crayalize and you will be fully automated"* — re-centering on loop's success signal: backlog forward-motion × crystallize-growth × full-automation. | (this commit) | Corrects the over-broad wait-on-the-build interpretation from the prior cartographer tick — that pause was specifically about "don't push parallel-worktree defaults yet", not "freeze all commits". Aaron's narrow semantics: CI-actively-building = wait-for-result (free-time); CI-idle = keep moving. Full review-authority delegation is a trust signal worth crystallizing: mechanical-only changes + clean markdownlint + fast-forward = pushable on agent authority. The live-loop risk is real but not triggered in current Zeta workflow config; memory documents both the trigger surface AND the future-proofing condition. | | 2026-04-22T (round-44 tick, post-compaction — batch 6d CLAUDE.md + AGENTS.md pointers land) | opus-4-7 / session round-44 (post-compaction resume) | aece202e | Resumed the blocked end-of-tick sequence for PR #89 (AUTONOMOUS-LOOP.md landed as `a38b70b` on main). Picked up task #226 per never-idle priority ladder: CLAUDE.md new ground-rule bullet "Tick must never stop" (between "Never be idle" and "Honor those that came before") + AGENTS.md new required-reading bullet for `docs/AUTONOMOUS-LOOP.md` (between FOUNDATIONDB-DST.md and category-theory/README.md). Strict additive-only: no pre-existing text modified, no sibling bullets touched. Pre-check clean (0 new maintainer-name mentions, 0 new memory/* refs). Branched `land-autonomous-loop-pointers-batch6d` from `origin/main`, committed `d604f41`, pushed, filed PR #90, auto-merge squash armed. This tick-history row itself lands via separate branch `land-tick-history-batch6d-append` per the "tick-commits-on-PR-branch = live-loop class" discipline (row-112 entry). No push to any open-PR branch; no CI re-kick risk. Cron verified live via CronList. | (this commit) + PR [#90](https://github.com/Lucent-Financial-Group/Zeta/pull/90) | First post-compaction continuation to successfully close the end-of-tick sequence that was blocked pre-compaction on a Read-first-before-Edit failure. The blocked-state was preserved in the session summary + memory + conversation transcript, enabling clean resumption without losing the PR #89 landing chain. Validates the end-of-tick discipline's cross-compaction durability — the tick-history row is written post-hoc for the pre-compaction tick's landing (PR #89) alongside this tick's own pointer work (PR #90), honouring the append-only discipline (no edit in place to add a retroactive row for #89 — the batch-6d row narrates both landings honestly, citing `a38b70b` as the PR #89 merge SHA). |