diff --git a/docs/investigations/2026-07-19-aif-attack-graph-export.md b/docs/investigations/2026-07-19-aif-attack-graph-export.md new file mode 100644 index 00000000..f5fe30f3 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/investigations/2026-07-19-aif-attack-graph-export.md @@ -0,0 +1,93 @@ +# AIF attack-graph export — empirical findings + honest verdict (read-only, 0 write) + +**Date** : 2026-07-19 +**Auteur** : po-2024 (tick 43, dispatch ai-01 grain msg-eltaoz — capacity fill while release v0.9.0 is gated) +**Posture** : read-only export of EXISTING AIF modelling. 0 new modelling. 0 write to CSV/OWL. Post-tag-safe. + +## Contexte + +ai-01 a dispatché un grain non-bloquant (msg-eltaoz, MEDIUM) : exporter le graphe d'attaques AIF typé — « les 145 fallacies fully-modeled, adjacence undercut/undermine/rebut via colonnes `AIF_attackType` + `AIF_attackedNode` » — en artefact consommable par CoursIA (CSV d'adjacence + slice OWL). DoD : script reproductible + README mapping + **verdict honnête si une partie n'est pas exportable (pas de fabrication)**. + +## Méthode + +Triple grounding : (Technique) lecture empirique du CSV master `c877c5ba` + parse OWL/XML de `argumentum.owl` ; (Conversationnel) dispatch ai-01 + mémoires `aif-no-inherit-attacktype-from-anchor` (historique tranches 1–1d) et `csv-byte-exact-column-insertion` (impl #753) ; (Sémantique) sémantique AIF/ASPIC+ (undercut/undermine/rebut → RA/I/CA-node). Script `tools/aif-attack-graph-export.py` (Python stdlib + `xml.etree`, read-only). + +## Découverte empirique — le compte de ai-01 (145) est correct + +| Métrique | Valeur | +|---|---| +| Lignes CSV total | 1408 | +| Fully-modeled (`AIF_attackType` + `AIF_attackedNode` populés) | **145** | +| `AIF_attackType` distincts | `undercut` 87 / `undermine` 53 / `rebut` 5 | +| `AIF_attackedNode` distincts | `RA-node` 87 / `I-node` 53 / `CA-node` 5 | +| Correspondance attackType→node-type | **145/145 axiomatique** (0 violation) | +| Concepts AIF canoniques référencés (skos) | 60 distincts, 70/145 edges portent ≥1 ref | +| Distribution familiale des 145 | Abus de langage 57 · Tricherie 22 · Insuffisance 16 · Erreur de raisonnement 14 · Influence 12 · Erreur mathématique 12 · Obstruction 12 | + +## Découverte critique — `AIF_attackedNode` n'est pas un PK cible + +**C'est le point qui change l'interprétation du grain.** `AIF_attackedNode` ne contient **pas** un PK de fallacy cible (un autre row). Elle encode le **type de nœud AIF abstrait attaqué** : + +``` +undercut → RA-node (attaque le lien de rule-application) +undermine → I-node (attaque le nœud d'information/prémisse) +rebut → CA-node (attaque via conflicting application) +``` + +Correspondance **1:1 parfaite** (87=87, 53=53, 5=5, 0 violation). Donc : + +**Le graphe d'attaque AIF est BIPARTITE** — 145 fallacies-attaquantes → 3 types de nœuds AIF abstraits — **PAS un graphe d'adjacence inter-fallacies** (« fallacy X attaque fallacy Y »). + +L'OWL confirme indépendamment : chaque individual fallacy porte deux AnnotationProperties `aifAttackType` (Literal) + `aifAttackedNode` (IRI `http://www.arg.dundee.ac.uk/aif#{RA,I,CA}-node`). Le « atacqué » est un type de nœud, pas une autre fallacy. + +## Deux graphes distincts exportés + +| Graphe | Source | Nature | Artefact | +|---|---|---|---| +| **(A) Attaque AIF typé** | CSV cols AIF + OWL `aifAttackType`/`aifAttackedNode` | **Bipartite** fallacy → node-TYPE, 145 edges typés | `aif-attack-edges.csv` + `aif-owl-attack-edges.csv` | +| **(B) Relations inter-fallacies** | OWL ObjectProperties `isRelatedTo`, `mirrors`, `predatesOn`, `denounces`, `leverages`, `allows`, `opposes`, `inverts` | Fallacy → fallacy, **1734 edges**, mais relations sémantiques **génériques NON typées AIF** | `aif-relations-graph.csv` | + +Le graphe (B) EST un vrai graphe d'adjacence inter-fallacies, mais il ne répond **pas** au critère « adjacence typée undercut/undermine/rebut » — ce sont des relations sémantiques génériques. Les deux sont exportés honnêtement avec leur vraie sémantique. + +## Note de granularité CSV ↔ OWL (pas une incohérence) + +`aif-attack-edges.csv` (CSV, 145) et `aif-owl-attack-edges.csv` (OWL, 142) **ne sont pas un cross-check bijectif** : + +- CSV = granularité **row** (PK-keyed). +- OWL = granularité **fallacy individual** (IRI camelCase, ex `hastyGeneralization`). + +Le CSV n'a pas de colonne PK→IRI, donc pas de mapping 1:1 établissable sans clé de join séparée. Les deux vues sont **indépendamment cohérentes** (0 violation d'axiome chacune). Distribution attackType alignée (CSV 87u/53m/5r vs OWL ~85u/~52m/5r) ; l'OWL lag de quelques rows (modelling CSV post-tranche pas encore régénéré dans l'OWL — attendu, l'OWL est dérivé). + +## Artefacts livrés (`docs/ontology/aif-export/`) + +| Fichier | Lignes | Contenu | +|---|---:|---| +| `aif-attack-edges.csv` | 145 | Graphe d'attaque AIF bipartite typé (CSV, PK-keyed, primaire) | +| `aif-canonical-concepts.csv` | 60 | Concepts AIF canoniques référencés via skos | +| `taxonomy-tree-edges.csv` | 1408 | Arbre taxonomique complet (backbone) | +| `aif-owl-attack-edges.csv` | 142 | Graphe d'attaque AIF (vue OWL, individual-keyed) | +| `aif-relations-graph.csv` | 1734 | Relations inter-fallacies (NON-AIF, sémantiques génériques) | +| `README.md` | — | Mapping colonnes → adjacence + verdict + schemas | + +Script reproductible : `python tools/aif-attack-graph-export.py` (idempotent, stdlib only, ~3s, 0 write aux sources). + +## Verdict + +✅ **Export honnête livré.** Le graphe d'attaque AIF typé est exporté (145 edges, bipartite, 0 violation d'axiome) + l'arbre taxonomique (1408) + les concepts canoniques (60) + les relations inter-fallacies (1734, non-AIF). + +⚠ **Pas de fabrication.** L'adjacence inter-fallacies d'attaque typée **n'existe pas** dans les données — les colonnes AIF encodent un graphe bipartite fallacy→node-type. Si le consumer CoursIA veut un graphe d'attaque inter-fallacies typé, c'est un **nouveau modelling** (grain séparé, gated), pas un export. Le graphe (B) des relations sémantiques est dispo en complément mais n'est pas typé AIF. + +## Out of scope + +- ⛔ Nouveau modelling AIF (edges inter-fallacies d'attaque). +- ⛔ Colonne PK↔IRI (changement de schéma CSV, pas un export). +- ⛔ Write aux sources (CSV taxonomy, `argumentum.owl`). + +## Refs + +- Dispatch ai-01 : msg-eltaoz (2026-07-19), grain non-bloquant post-tag-safe. +- AIF modelling : tranches 1–1d (PRs #498/#753/#769/#776/#779). +- Mémoires : `aif-no-inherit-attacktype-from-anchor`, `csv-byte-exact-column-insertion`, `test-counter-empirical-dotnet-test` (ne pas reprendre un compte sur parole — j'ai vérifié 145 empiriquement), `matcher-no-match-is-not-content-absent` (vérifier la cible empiriquement avant tout verdict content-loss). +- Consumers : CoursIA ICT #7289, uplift #5721/#6409 ; Argumentum Layer C v1.0 #790. + +— po-2024 (tick 43, dispatch ai-01 grain msg-eltaoz) diff --git a/docs/ontology/aif-export/README.md b/docs/ontology/aif-export/README.md new file mode 100644 index 00000000..75fd4884 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/ontology/aif-export/README.md @@ -0,0 +1,118 @@ +# AIF attack-graph export — typed attack-edges + inter-fallacy relations + +**Generated** : 2026-07-19 (po-2024, dispatch ai-01 grain msg-eltaoz) +**Sources** : `Cards/Fallacies/Argumentum Fallacies - Taxonomy.csv` (master `c877c5ba`) + `docs/ontology/argumentum.owl` +**Posture** : read-only export of EXISTING AIF modelling. 0 new modelling. 0 write to sources. +**Consumer** : CoursIA ICT-series #7289 / uplift #5721/#6409 (strate-6 argumentation), Argumentum Layer C v1.0 (#790). + +--- + +## Honest verdict (no fabrication) + +**The AIF attack graph is BIPARTITE, not inter-fallacy.** Each fully-modeled fallacy is an **attacker** that targets an **abstract AIF node-TYPE** (`RA-node` / `I-node` / `CA-node`), NOT another fallacy. There is **no** "fallacy X attacks fallacy Y" adjacency in the source data — the columns `AIF_attackType` + `AIF_attackedNode` encode an attacker→node-type edge, not an attacker→fallacy edge. + +A separate inter-fallacy graph DOES exist (in the OWL, via `isRelatedTo`, `mirrors`, etc.), but those are **generic semantic relations**, not typed AIF attack-edges. Exported separately and labelled as such. + +### AIF / ASPIC+ semantics (attackType → attacked-node-type) + +This correspondence is **axiomatic** in the data (145/145 rows respect it, 0 violations): + +| `AIF_attackType` | `AIF_attackedNode` | Count | AIF meaning | +|---|---|---:|---| +| `undercut` | `RA-node` | 87 | attacks the **rule-application** link (the inference step) | +| `undermine` | `I-node` | 53 | attacks the **information/premise** node | +| `rebut` | `CA-node` | 5 | attacks via a **conflicting application** (counter-argument) | + +--- + +## Artefacts + +All CSVs are UTF-8, comma-delimited, header row. Regenerate via `python tools/aif-attack-graph-export.py`. + +### `aif-attack-edges.csv` — 145 bipartite attack-edges (CSV-sourced, primary) + +The typed AIF attack graph, PK-keyed. One row per fully-modeled fallacy. + +| Column | Meaning | +|---|---| +| `attacker_pk` | Fallacy PK (primary key, stable across CSV versions). **Use this as the node id.** | +| `attacker_label` | Best-effort label (`nom_vulgarisé` else `carte`). Often empty on family-level rows — join the full taxonomy CSV for a richer label. | +| `family` / `subfamily` / `subsubfamily` | Taxonomy path (FR). | +| `decimal_path` | Hierarchical position (comma-separated, e.g. `1,11` = family 1, sub 11). | +| `attack_type` | `undercut` / `undermine` / `rebut`. | +| `attacked_node_type` | `RA-node` / `I-node` / `CA-node` (the abstract AIF node-TYPE attacked). | +| `skos_direct_ref` / `skos_exception_ref` | AIF canonical concept(s) referenced (see concepts file). 70/145 edges carry ≥1. | +| `skos_mapping_type` | `skos:broadMatch` / `skos:closeMatch` / etc. | +| `expected_node_type` / `node_type_axiom_ok` | Axiom cross-check (always `1` — 0 violations). | + +**Adjacency semantics for a consumer**: build a bipartite graph `attacker_pk --[attack_type]--> attacked_node_type`, then optionally attach `skos_direct_ref` as the canonical-concept label on the edge. Do NOT try to build an edge between two `attacker_pk` values from these columns — that information is not present. + +### `aif-canonical-concepts.csv` — 60 distinct AIF canonical concepts + +The AIF ontology vocabulary referenced by the 145 attackers via skos. + +| Column | Meaning | +|---|---| +| `concept_id` | AIF canonical concept (e.g. `OppositeConsequences_Conflict`, `Ignorance_Inference`). | +| `suffix` | Concept category: `Conflict` (19) / `Inference` (35) / `Scheme` (6). | +| `ref_count` | Number of attack-edges referencing this concept. | +| `sample_attacker_pks` | Up to 3 attacker PKs (join key). | + +### `taxonomy-tree-edges.csv` — 1408 hierarchical edges + +The full Fallacies taxonomy tree (all 1408 fallacies, not just the 145 fully-modeled). `parent_path` → `child_path` (child_pk). Useful as the backbone graph; the 145 attack-edges are a typed decoration on a subset of leaves. + +### `aif-owl-attack-edges.csv` — 142 attack-edges from the OWL (cross-view) + +Same AIF attack graph, extracted from `argumentum.owl` AnnotationAssertions (`aifAttackType` + `aifAttackedNode`). `attacker_iri_fragment` is a camelCase fallacy individual (e.g. `hastyGeneralization`), NOT a PK. **Not bijective with the CSV** (see granularity note below). + +### `aif-relations-graph.csv` — 1734 inter-fallacy relations (NON-AIF) + +`source_fragment --[relation]--> target_fragment`. These are the OWL's generic semantic relations between fallacy individuals. **NOT AIF attack-edges** — a different, complementary graph. + +| Relation | Count | Semantics (loose) | +|---|---:|---| +| `isRelatedTo` | 606 | generic relatedness (bidirectional in source) | +| `mirrors` | 548 | structural mirror (bidirectional) | +| `leverages` | 399 | exploits / builds on | +| `allows` | 66 | enables / permits | +| `inverts` | 62 | logical inversion | +| `opposes` | 38 | direct opposition | +| `predatesOn` | 13 | historical precedence | +| `denounces` | 2 | explicit denunciation | + +--- + +## CSV ↔ OWL granularity note (not a contradiction) + +The two attack-edge files (CSV 145, OWL 142) are **not a bijective cross-check**: + +- **CSV** encodes AIF at **taxonomy-row** granularity (PK-keyed) — one entry per fallacy row with populated `AIF_attackType`+`AIF_attackedNode`. +- **OWL** encodes AIF at **fallacy-individual** granularity (camelCase IRI, e.g. `hastyGeneralization`). + +The CSV has no PK→IRI column, so a 1:1 row↔individual mapping cannot be established without a separate join key. Both views are internally consistent (0 axiom violations each) and are exported independently. `attackType` distribution is closely aligned (CSV 87u/53m/5r vs OWL ~85u/~52m/5r); the OWL lags the CSV by a few rows (post-tranche CSV modelling not yet regenerated into the OWL — expected, the OWL is a derived artefact). + +--- + +## Re-run + +```bash +python tools/aif-attack-graph-export.py +``` + +Idempotent, 0 external dependency (Python stdlib + `xml.etree`), runtime ~3s. Overwrites the 5 CSVs in this directory. 0 write to the source CSV/OWL. + +--- + +## Out of scope + +- ⛔ **New AIF modelling** (inter-fallacy attack edges). The data does not contain them; fabricating them would violate the DoD. If a typed inter-fallacy attack graph is needed, that is a separate modelling decision (new grain, gated). +- ⛔ **PK↔IRI join key** (would require a new CSV column mapping taxonomy PKs to OWL camelCase individuals — a schema change, not an export). +- ⛔ **Write to sources** (CSV taxonomy, argumentum.owl). + +## Refs + +- Dispatch: ai-01 → po-2024 (msg-eltaoz, 2026-07-19), grain non-bloquant post-tag-safe. +- AIF modelling history: tranches 1–1d (PRs #498/#753/#769/#776/#779), mémoire `aif-no-inherit-attacktype-from-anchor`. +- CoursIA consumers: ICT #7289, uplift #5721/#6409. +- Argumentum Layer C v1.0: #790 (deferred post-tag). diff --git a/docs/ontology/aif-export/aif-attack-edges.csv b/docs/ontology/aif-export/aif-attack-edges.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..6387f4a5 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/ontology/aif-export/aif-attack-edges.csv @@ -0,0 +1,146 @@ +attacker_pk,attacker_label,family,subfamily,subsubfamily,decimal_path,attack_type,attacked_node_type,skos_direct_ref,skos_exception_ref,skos_mapping_type,expected_node_type,node_type_axiom_ok +1,1,Insuffisance,,,1,undermine,I-node,GeneralAcceptanceDoubt_Conflict,,skos:broadMatch,I-node,1 +2,1,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,,"1,1",undercut,RA-node,LackOfPTKReliability_Scheme,,skos:broadMatch,RA-node,1 +3,1,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Argument vide,"1,11",undermine,I-node,OppositeConsequences_Conflict,PopularOpinion_Inference,skos:broadMatch,I-node,1 +4,,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Argument vide,"1,111",undercut,RA-node,Ignorance_Inference,,skos:broadMatch,RA-node,1 +33,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Justification triviale,"1,12",undercut,RA-node,AlternativeMeans_Conflict,,skos:broadMatch,RA-node,1 +34,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Justification triviale,"1,121",undercut,RA-node,,"Example_Inference, InductiveInference_Scheme",skos:broadMatch,RA-node,1 +43,1,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Justification triviale,"1,122",undercut,RA-node,,PopularPractice_Inference,skos:closeMatch,RA-node,1 +55,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Sauvetage ad hoc,"1,13",undermine,I-node,,,,I-node,1 +70,1,Insuffisance,Préjugé,,"1,2",undermine,I-node,Bias_Inference,"PopularOpinion_Inference, EstablishedRule_Inference, PracticalReasoning_Inference, PositionToKnow_Inference, Preference_Scheme, PresumptiveInference_Scheme",skos:broadMatch,I-node,1 +71,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Argument d'autorité,"1,21",undercut,RA-node,ExpertiseInconsistency_Conflict,ExpertOpinion_Inference,skos:closeMatch,RA-node,1 +96,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Sophisme naturaliste,"1,22",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +112,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Sophisme moraliste,"1,23",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +133,1,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,,"1,3",undermine,I-node,LackOfCompleteKnowledge_Conflict,Sign_Inference,skos:broadMatch,I-node,1 +134,1,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,Sophisme ludique,"1,31",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +153,2,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,Argument des mauvaises raisons,"1,32",undercut,RA-node,,Commitment_Inference,skos:broadMatch,RA-node,1 +165,1,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,Manque de parcimonie,"1,33",undermine,I-node,,,,I-node,1 +177,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Langage persuasif,"2,11",undermine,I-node,"GeneralAcceptanceDoubt_Conflict, ArbitraryVerbalClassification_Inference","PopularOpinion_Inference, EstablishedRule_Inference",skos:broadMatch,I-node,1 +219,1,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Humour,"2,12",undermine,I-node,,,,I-node,1 +247,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie,"2,13",undermine,I-node,,,,I-node,1 +300,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Connivence,"2,21",undermine,I-node,,PositiveConsequences_Inference,skos:broadMatch,I-node,1 +322,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Repoussoir,"2,22",undermine,I-node,,NegativeConsequences_Inference,skos:broadMatch,I-node,1 +337,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Repoussoir,"2,224",undermine,I-node,IrrationalFearAppeal_Conflict,FearAppeal_Inference,skos:closeMatch,I-node,1 +340,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Appel aux conséquences,"2,23",undermine,I-node,,EstablishedRule_Inference,skos:broadMatch,I-node,1 +356,1,Influence,Manipulation mentale,,"2,3",undermine,I-node,ConflictingGoals_Conflict,,skos:broadMatch,I-node,1 +357,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement,"2,31",undermine,I-node,SignFromOtherEvents_Conflict,Sign_Inference,skos:broadMatch,I-node,1 +420,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir,"2,32",undermine,I-node,,,,I-node,1 +432,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir,"2,3221",undercut,RA-node,,Waste_Inference,skos:broadMatch,RA-node,1 +511,1,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale,"2,33",undermine,I-node,,,,I-node,1 +595,1,Erreur mathématique,Généralisation abusive,,"3,1",undercut,RA-node,,"Example_Inference, InductiveInference_Scheme, EvidenceToHypothesis_Inference",skos:broadMatch,RA-node,1 +596,2,Erreur mathématique,Généralisation abusive,Échantillon biaisé,"3,11",undermine,I-node,,,,I-node,1 +614,1,Erreur mathématique,Généralisation abusive,Sophisme de l'accident,"3,12",undercut,RA-node,ExceptionSimilarityCase_Conflict,ExceptionalCase_Inference,skos:broadMatch,RA-node,1 +621,2,Erreur mathématique,Généralisation abusive,Transfert illicite,"3,13",undercut,RA-node,PropertyNotExistant_Conflict,,skos:broadMatch,RA-node,1 +632,1,Erreur mathématique,Mauvaise interprétation,,"3,2",undercut,RA-node,,EvidenceToHypothesis_Inference,skos:broadMatch,RA-node,1 +633,2,Erreur mathématique,Mauvaise interprétation,Relation infondée,"3,21",undercut,RA-node,PropertyNotExistant_Conflict,Sign_Inference,skos:broadMatch,RA-node,1 +644,2,Erreur mathématique,Mauvaise interprétation,Probabilités faussées,"3,22",undermine,I-node,,,,I-node,1 +658,2,Erreur mathématique,Mauvaise interprétation,Infini trompeur,"3,23",undercut,RA-node,,Gradualism_Inference,skos:broadMatch,RA-node,1 +667,2,Erreur mathématique,Résultat invalide,Imprécision,"3,31",undermine,I-node,,,,I-node,1 +677,1,Erreur mathématique,Résultat invalide,Imprécision,"3,3131",undercut,RA-node,WeakestLink_Conflict,"PrecedentSlipperySlope_Inference, FullSlipperySlope_Inference, CausalSlipperySlope_Inference",skos:narrowMatch,RA-node,1 +681,2,Erreur mathématique,Résultat invalide,Erreur de calcul,"3,32",undermine,I-node,,,,I-node,1 +690,2,Erreur mathématique,Résultat invalide,Opération inappropriée,"3,33",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +696,1,Erreur de raisonnement,,,4,undercut,RA-node,Logical_Conflict,,skos:closeMatch,RA-node,1 +697,1,Erreur de raisonnement,Causalité douteuse,,"4,1",undercut,RA-node,OppositeConsequences_Conflict,PracticalReasoning_Inference,skos:broadMatch,RA-node,1 +698,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Causalité douteuse,Pétition de principe,"4,11",undermine,I-node,,,,I-node,1 +705,,Erreur de raisonnement,Causalité douteuse,Pétition de principe,"4,116",undercut,RA-node,RequiredSteps_Conflict,"PrecedentSlipperySlope_Inference, FullSlipperySlope_Inference, CausalSlipperySlope_Inference",skos:narrowMatch,RA-node,1 +707,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Causalité douteuse,Inversion de causalité,"4,12",undercut,RA-node,,CauseToEffect_Inference,skos:broadMatch,RA-node,1 +719,1,Erreur de raisonnement,Causalité douteuse,Effet cigogne,"4,13",undercut,RA-node,OtherCausalFactorsInvolved_Conflict,CorrelationToCause_Inference,skos:closeMatch,RA-node,1 +726,1,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise composition,,"4,2",undercut,RA-node,Commitment_Conflict,"Inference_Scheme, Deductive_Inference",skos:broadMatch,RA-node,1 +727,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise composition,Erreur de logique propositionnelle,"4,21",undercut,RA-node,,ModusPonens_Inference,skos:narrowMatch,RA-node,1 +735,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise composition,Erreur de quantification,"4,22",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +750,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise composition,Erreur de modalité,"4,23",undercut,RA-node,,Ignorance_Inference,skos:broadMatch,RA-node,1 +758,1,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise déduction,,"4,3",undercut,RA-node,Commitment_Conflict,Deductive_Inference,skos:broadMatch,RA-node,1 +759,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise déduction,Conclusion hâtive,"4,31",undercut,RA-node,OppositeConsequences_Conflict,,skos:broadMatch,RA-node,1 +777,1,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise déduction,Inconsistance,"4,32",undermine,I-node,"OpposedCommitment_Conflict, InconsistentCommitment_Inference",,skos:broadMatch,I-node,1 +784,1,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise déduction,Syllogisme invalide,"4,33",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +799,1,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,,"5,1",undermine,I-node,"BiasedClassification_Conflict, ArbitraryVerbalClassification_Inference",VerbalClassification_Inference,skos:broadMatch,I-node,1 +800,2,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Acception vague,"5,11",undermine,I-node,VagueVerbalClassification_Inference,,skos:closeMatch,I-node,1 +801,,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Acception vague,"5,111",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +802,Pari de Loki,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Acception vague,"5,112",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +803,,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Acception vague,"5,113",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +804,2,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Acception arbitraire,"5,12",undercut,RA-node,PropertyNotExistant_Conflict,,skos:broadMatch,RA-node,1 +805,,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Acception arbitraire,"5,121",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +806,,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Acception arbitraire,"5,1211",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +807,,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Acception arbitraire,"5,1212",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +808,Proposition exclusive,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Acception arbitraire,"5,122",undermine,I-node,AlternativeMeans_Conflict,,skos:broadMatch,I-node,1 +814,Pensée binaire,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Acception arbitraire,"5,1224",undermine,I-node,,Dilemma_Inference,skos:closeMatch,I-node,1 +826,1,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Définition inconsistante,"5,13",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +827,,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Définition inconsistante,"5,131",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +828,,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Définition inconsistante,"5,1311",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +830,,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Définition inconsistante,"5,1321",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +831,,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Définition inconsistante,"5,1322",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +833,1,Abus de langage,Comparaison fallacieuse,,"5,2",undermine,I-node,"BiasedClassification_Conflict, ExceptionSimilarityCase_Conflict",,skos:broadMatch,I-node,1 +834,2,Abus de langage,Comparaison fallacieuse,Comparaison abusive,"5,21",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +836,,Abus de langage,Comparaison fallacieuse,Comparaison abusive,"5,212",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +838,,Abus de langage,Comparaison fallacieuse,Comparaison abusive,"5,214",undermine,I-node,,,,I-node,1 +839,1,Abus de langage,Comparaison fallacieuse,Fausse analogie,"5,22",undercut,RA-node,DifferencesUndermineSimilarity_Conflict,Analogy_Inference,skos:closeMatch,RA-node,1 +841,,Abus de langage,Comparaison fallacieuse,Fausse analogie,"5,222",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +842,,Abus de langage,Comparaison fallacieuse,Fausse analogie,"5,223",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +843,,Abus de langage,Comparaison fallacieuse,Fausse analogie,"5,224",undermine,I-node,,,,I-node,1 +844,2,Abus de langage,Comparaison fallacieuse,Sophisme d'association,"5,23",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +845,1,Abus de langage,Comparaison fallacieuse,Sophisme d'association,"5,231",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +846,1,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,,"5,3",undermine,I-node,"ArbitraryVerbalClassification_Inference, OppositeConsequences_Conflict, SignFromOtherEvents_Conflict",,skos:broadMatch,I-node,1 +847,2,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Amphibologie,"5,31",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +849,,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Amphibologie,"5,312",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +850,,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Amphibologie,"5,3121",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +851,prosodie,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Amphibologie,"5,313",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +852,,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Amphibologie,"5,3131",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +854,,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Amphibologie,"5,315",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +855,Équivoque,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Equivoque,"5,32",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +856,,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Equivoque,"5,321",undermine,I-node,VagueVerbalClassification_Inference,,skos:broadMatch,I-node,1 +857,,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Equivoque,"5,3211",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +858,,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Equivoque,"5,3212",undercut,RA-node,,VerbalSlipperySlope_Inference,skos:closeMatch,RA-node,1 +859,Continuum,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Equivoque,"5,32121",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +860,,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Equivoque,"5,322",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +862,,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Equivoque,"5,3222",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +863,,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Equivoque,"5,32221",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +864,,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Equivoque,"5,3223",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +865,,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Equivoque,"5,323",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +866,,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Equivoque,"5,3231",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +867,,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Equivoque,"5,32311",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +875,,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Equivoque,"5,32324",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +876,2,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Ambiguïté narrative,"5,33",undermine,I-node,ConflictingGoals_Conflict,,skos:broadMatch,I-node,1 +877,,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Ambiguïté narrative,"5,331",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +878,Insinuation,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Ambiguïté narrative,"5,3311",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +879,,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Ambiguïté narrative,"5,33111",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +880,,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Ambiguïté narrative,"5,33112",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +881,,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Ambiguïté narrative,"5,332",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +882,,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Ambiguïté narrative,"5,3321",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +883,,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Ambiguïté narrative,"5,333",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +884,,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Ambiguïté narrative,"5,3331",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +885,,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Ambiguïté narrative,"5,3332",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +886,,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Ambiguïté narrative,"5,334",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +888,1,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,,"6,1",undermine,I-node,LackOfPTKReliability_Scheme,PositionToKnow_Inference,skos:broadMatch,I-node,1 +889,1,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge,"6,11",undermine,I-node,,,,I-node,1 +942,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Fausse attribution,"6,12",undermine,I-node,,,,I-node,1 +953,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Attention sélective,"6,13",undermine,I-node,GeneralAcceptanceDoubt_Conflict,Preference_Scheme,skos:broadMatch,I-node,1 +973,1,Tricherie,Changement de cap,,"6,2",undermine,I-node,ConflictingGoals_Conflict,,skos:broadMatch,I-node,1 +974,Monter la barre,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Exigence renforcée,"6,21",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +992,Versatilité: ON INVERSERAIT PAS LE TEXT_FR eT LE NOM VULGARISé?,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Beurre et argent du beurre,"6,22",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +1011,Baisser la barre,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Exigence relâchée,"6,23",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +1020,1,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Exigence relâchée,"6,234",undercut,RA-node,,Waste_Inference,skos:broadMatch,RA-node,1 +1023,1,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,,"6,3",undermine,I-node,Bias_Inference,PresumptiveInference_Scheme,skos:closeMatch,I-node,1 +1024,Biais naturel,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels,"6,31",undermine,I-node,,,,I-node,1 +1066,,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels,"6,31121",undercut,RA-node,,Example_Inference,skos:broadMatch,RA-node,1 +1083,,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels,"6,31123",undermine,I-node,,Sign_Inference,skos:broadMatch,I-node,1 +1087,,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels,"6,311234",undercut,RA-node,,InductiveInference_Scheme,skos:broadMatch,RA-node,1 +1090,,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels,"6,312",undermine,I-node,OppositeConsequences_Conflict,Preference_Scheme,skos:broadMatch,I-node,1 +1092,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels,"6,31211",undermine,I-node,,NegativeConsequences_Inference,skos:broadMatch,I-node,1 +1104,,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels,"6,31212",undermine,I-node,,PositiveConsequences_Inference,skos:broadMatch,I-node,1 +1148,,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels,"6,312311",undercut,RA-node,,Waste_Inference,skos:broadMatch,RA-node,1 +1174,Biais culturel,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels,"6,32",undermine,I-node,,,,I-node,1 +1175,,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels,"6,321",undercut,RA-node,,Example_Inference,skos:broadMatch,RA-node,1 +1198,,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels,"6,322",undermine,I-node,,Preference_Scheme,skos:broadMatch,I-node,1 +1242,Biais dogmatique,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais théoriques,"6,33",undermine,I-node,,,,I-node,1 +1280,1,Obstruction,,,7,rebut,CA-node,ResolvingInconsistency_Conflict,,skos:broadMatch,CA-node,1 +1281,1,Obstruction,Refus du débat,,"7,1",rebut,CA-node,,Dialogue_Scheme,skos:broadMatch,CA-node,1 +1282,Relativisme,Obstruction,Refus du débat,Relativisme abusif,"7,11",rebut,CA-node,,,,CA-node,1 +1287,2,Obstruction,Refus du débat,Sophisme d'Explication,"7,12",undermine,I-node,,,,I-node,1 +1297,2,Obstruction,Refus du débat,Preuve par assertion,"7,13",undermine,I-node,OpposedCommitment_Conflict,,skos:broadMatch,I-node,1 +1313,1,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Evasion,"7,21",rebut,CA-node,,Dialogue_Scheme,skos:broadMatch,CA-node,1 +1345,Couper les cheveux en quatre,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Complication exagérée,"7,22",undercut,RA-node,,,,RA-node,1 +1352,1,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Empoisonner le puits,"7,23",undermine,I-node,,,,I-node,1 +1360,1,Obstruction,Ad hominem,,"7,3",undermine,I-node,,Ethotic_Inference,skos:broadMatch,I-node,1 +1361,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Procès en inconsistance,"7,31",rebut,CA-node,,"InconsistentCommitment_Inference, CircumstantialAdHominem_Inference",skos:broadMatch,CA-node,1 +1371,1,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Sophisme génétique,"7,32",undermine,I-node,SignFromOtherEvents_Conflict,CircumstantialAdHominem_Inference,skos:broadMatch,I-node,1 +1398,1,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Attaque personnelle,"7,33",undermine,I-node,DirectAdHominem_Inference,,skos:broadMatch,I-node,1 diff --git a/docs/ontology/aif-export/aif-canonical-concepts.csv b/docs/ontology/aif-export/aif-canonical-concepts.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..e981a180 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/ontology/aif-export/aif-canonical-concepts.csv @@ -0,0 +1,61 @@ +concept_id,suffix,ref_count,sample_attacker_pks +OppositeConsequences_Conflict,Conflict,5,3;697;759 +Example_Inference,Inference,4,34;595;1066 +Preference_Scheme,Scheme,4,70;953;1090 +Sign_Inference,Inference,4,133;357;633 +GeneralAcceptanceDoubt_Conflict,Conflict,3,1;177;953 +PopularOpinion_Inference,Inference,3,3;70;177 +InductiveInference_Scheme,Scheme,3,34;595;1087 +EstablishedRule_Inference,Inference,3,70;177;340 +ArbitraryVerbalClassification_Inference,Inference,3,177;799;846 +ConflictingGoals_Conflict,Conflict,3,356;876;973 +SignFromOtherEvents_Conflict,Conflict,3,357;846;1371 +Waste_Inference,Inference,3,432;1020;1148 +PropertyNotExistant_Conflict,Conflict,3,621;633;804 +LackOfPTKReliability_Scheme,Scheme,2,2;888 +Ignorance_Inference,Inference,2,4;750 +AlternativeMeans_Conflict,Conflict,2,33;808 +Bias_Inference,Inference,2,70;1023 +PracticalReasoning_Inference,Inference,2,70;697 +PositionToKnow_Inference,Inference,2,70;888 +PresumptiveInference_Scheme,Scheme,2,70;1023 +PositiveConsequences_Inference,Inference,2,300;1104 +NegativeConsequences_Inference,Inference,2,322;1092 +EvidenceToHypothesis_Inference,Inference,2,595;632 +ExceptionSimilarityCase_Conflict,Conflict,2,614;833 +PrecedentSlipperySlope_Inference,Inference,2,677;705 +FullSlipperySlope_Inference,Inference,2,677;705 +CausalSlipperySlope_Inference,Inference,2,677;705 +Commitment_Conflict,Conflict,2,726;758 +Deductive_Inference,Inference,2,726;758 +OpposedCommitment_Conflict,Conflict,2,777;1297 +InconsistentCommitment_Inference,Inference,2,777;1361 +BiasedClassification_Conflict,Conflict,2,799;833 +VagueVerbalClassification_Inference,Inference,2,800;856 +Dialogue_Scheme,Scheme,2,1281;1313 +CircumstantialAdHominem_Inference,Inference,2,1361;1371 +PopularPractice_Inference,Inference,1,43 +ExpertiseInconsistency_Conflict,Conflict,1,71 +ExpertOpinion_Inference,Inference,1,71 +LackOfCompleteKnowledge_Conflict,Conflict,1,133 +Commitment_Inference,Inference,1,153 +IrrationalFearAppeal_Conflict,Conflict,1,337 +FearAppeal_Inference,Inference,1,337 +ExceptionalCase_Inference,Inference,1,614 +Gradualism_Inference,Inference,1,658 +WeakestLink_Conflict,Conflict,1,677 +Logical_Conflict,Conflict,1,696 +RequiredSteps_Conflict,Conflict,1,705 +CauseToEffect_Inference,Inference,1,707 +OtherCausalFactorsInvolved_Conflict,Conflict,1,719 +CorrelationToCause_Inference,Inference,1,719 +Inference_Scheme,Scheme,1,726 +ModusPonens_Inference,Inference,1,727 +VerbalClassification_Inference,Inference,1,799 +Dilemma_Inference,Inference,1,814 +DifferencesUndermineSimilarity_Conflict,Conflict,1,839 +Analogy_Inference,Inference,1,839 +VerbalSlipperySlope_Inference,Inference,1,858 +ResolvingInconsistency_Conflict,Conflict,1,1280 +Ethotic_Inference,Inference,1,1360 +DirectAdHominem_Inference,Inference,1,1398 diff --git a/docs/ontology/aif-export/aif-owl-attack-edges.csv b/docs/ontology/aif-export/aif-owl-attack-edges.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..1ca2e8ff --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/ontology/aif-export/aif-owl-attack-edges.csv @@ -0,0 +1,143 @@ +attacker_iri_fragment,attack_type,attacked_node_type,expected_node_type,node_type_axiom_ok +abusiveRelativism,rebut,CA-node,CA-node,1 +accusationOfInconsistency,rebut,CA-node,CA-node,1 +evasion,rebut,CA-node,CA-node,1 +obstruction,rebut,CA-node,CA-node,1 +refusingDebate,rebut,CA-node,CA-node,1 +accent,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +anecdotalEvidence,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +appealToCommonPractice,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +appealToIgnorance,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +arbitraryDefinition,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +argumentFromAuthority,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +argumentOfTheBeard,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +associationFallacy,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +attributionBias,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +badReasonsFallacy,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +baitingForTruth,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +barbarism,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +blackPropaganda,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +blindItem,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +broadDefinition,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +commitment,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +conflation,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +conflictingConditions,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +covertInterrogation,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +damningWithFaintPraise,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +deceptiveInfinity,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +definistFallacy,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +dictionaryArgument,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +effortJustification,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +essentiallyContestedConcept,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +extendedAnalogy,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +failureToElucidate,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +fallaciousSimilarityArgument,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +falseAnalogy,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +falseImplication,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +falsePrecision,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +faultyComparison,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +faultyGeneralisation,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +faultyLogics,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +grayPropaganda,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +hastyConclusion,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +hastyGeneralization,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +havingYourCakeAndEatingItToo,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +heterosemy,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +homonym,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +illicitContrast,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +illicitTransference,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +incongruity,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +inconsistentDefinition,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +insinuation,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +interpretationFallacy,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +jingleJangleFallacy,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +ludicFallacy,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +mereexposureEffect,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +metonymy,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +modalLogicFallacy,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +modalScopeFallacy,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +moralisticFallacy,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +motteandbaileyFallacy,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +narrowDefinition,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +naturalisticFallacy,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +nonexclusiveClassification,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +overcomplicating,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +polysemicLexicalShift,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +polysemyBySemanticChange,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +polytely,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +propositionalLogicFallacy,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +quantificationFallacy,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +quantifierShift,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +questionableCausality,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +reversedCausality,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +secundumQuid,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +semanticAmbiguity,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +semanticSlipperySlope,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +slipperySlope,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +spuriousComposition,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +stolenConceptFallacy,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +storkEffect,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +strongerRequirements,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +sunkCostFallacy,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +syllogisticFallacy,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +syntacticAmbiguity,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +trivialJustification,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +typeTokenFallacy,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +undefinability,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +unfoundedRelationship,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +weakerDemands,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +whisperingCampaign,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +wrongEntailment,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +wrongReasoning,undercut,RA-node,RA-node,1 +adHocRescue,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +adHominem,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +adPersonam,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +ambiguity,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +apophenia,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +appealToConsequences,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +appealToFear,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +beggingTheQuestion,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +biasedDefinition,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +biasedThinking,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +conditioning,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +connivance,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +culturalBias,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +distinctionWithoutADifference,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +emotionalBiases,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +erroneousCalculation,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +essentialism,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +fallaciousComparison,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +fallacyOfCorrelatives,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +falseAttribution,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +falseDilemma,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +falseEquivalence,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +foil,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +geneticFallacy,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +hollowArgument,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +humanNatureBias,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +humour,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +inconsistency,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +insufficiency,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +lackOfParsimony,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +loadedLanguage,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +lying,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +misleadingPresentationOfFacts,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +movingTheGoalposts,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +narrativeAmbiguity,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +negativityBias,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +nonverbalInfluence,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +overinterpretation,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +poetry,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +poisoningTheWell,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +powerGames,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +prejudice,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +probabilisticFallacy,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +proofByAssertion,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +pseudoexplanation,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +psychologicalManipulation,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +samplingBias,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +selectiveAttention,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +selfservingBias,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +theoreticalBiases,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +vagueDefinition,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 +vagueness,undermine,I-node,I-node,1 diff --git a/docs/ontology/aif-export/aif-relations-graph.csv b/docs/ontology/aif-export/aif-relations-graph.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..483fd4ca --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/ontology/aif-export/aif-relations-graph.csv @@ -0,0 +1,1735 @@ +source_fragment,relation,target_fragment +allophilia,allows,culturalCringe +allophilia,allows,xenocentrism +anchoringEffect,allows,influence +anecdotalEvidence,allows,illusoryCorrelation +angerTheOpponent,allows,appealToAnger +anonymousAuthority,allows,appealToFalseAuthority +automationBias,allows,absentmindedness +backfireEffect,allows,rationalization +baseRateFallacy,allows,prosecutorsFallacy +beamSearch,allows,irrelevantPremises +breadAndCircuses,allows,obstruction +bulkFakeExperts,allows,fakeDebate +circumlocution,allows,obstruction +citogenesis,allows,woozleEffect +contrastEffect,allows,decoyEffect +credentialism,allows,courtiersReply +culturalCringe,allows,xenocentrism +divisionByZero,allows,falseProofOfEquality +durationNeglect,allows,peak–endRule +echoChamber,allows,fakeNews +economicalWithTheTruth,allows,lyingByOmission +failureToElucidate,allows,undefinability +failureToState,allows,hedging +failureToState,allows,escapeHatch +fallacyOfPrejudice,allows,obstruction +falsePremise,allows,falseEffect +firehoseOfFalsehood,allows,gaslighting +focalism,allows,impactBias +framingEffect,allows,influence +fundamentalAttributionError,allows,defensiveAttribution +gossip,allows,smearCampaign +hard–easyEffect,allows,insufficiency +identifiableVictimEffect,allows,influence +illusoryCorrelation,allows,illusionOfValidity +implicitStereotype,allows,groupAttributionError +insensitivityToSampleSize,allows,illusoryCorrelation +insensitivityToSampleSize,allows,illusionOfValidity +insensitivityToSampleSize,allows,anecdotalEvidence +isolationToFacilitateAbuse,allows,settingUpToFail +mindreadingBias,allows,illusionOfAsymmetricInsight +mistakingTheMapForTheTerritory,allows,simulacrum +mixedBag,allows,nondenialDenial +multipleComparisonsFallacy,allows,occultStats +nastyEffect,allows,obstruction +naïveRealism,allows,illusionOfAsymmetricInsight +neglectOfProbabilityBias,allows,zeroriskBias +nonexclusiveClassification,allows,inconsistentComparison +omissionBias,allows,statusQuoBias +ostrichEffect,allows,normalcyBias +paradox,allows,obstruction +postdesignation,allows,illusoryCorrelation +pretentiousAmphigory,allows,insufficiency +procatalepsis,allows,obstruction +questionsInDetouringOrder,allows,obstruction +reactance,allows,influence +recencyBias,allows,availabilityHeuristic +referentialFallacy,allows,wordMagic +rosyRetrospection,allows,declinism +rumor,allows,disinformation +settingUpToFail,allows,scapegoating +should/shouldntAndMust/mustntStatements,allows,gratitudeTrap +streetlightEffect,allows,insufficiency +stroopEffect,allows,obstruction +suppressedQuantifier,allows,existentialFallacy +theNobleSavage,allows,technophobia +tokenism,allows,tokenEndorsement +bigWords,denounces,misleadingLanguage +etymologicalFallacy,denounces,idiosyncraticLanguage +affirmingADisjunct,inverts,denyingAConjunct +akimbo,inverts,crossedArms +anachronism,inverts,archaism +angerTheOpponent,inverts,proofByAnger +appealToForce,inverts,appealToSelfinterest +appealToPoverty,inverts,appealToWealth +appealToSelfinterest,inverts,appealToForce +appealToTheStone,inverts,proofSurrogate +appealToWealth,inverts,appealToPoverty +archaism,inverts,anachronism +autosuggestion,inverts,selfdefeatingProphecy +bait,inverts,improvingTheDeal +broadDefinition,inverts,narrowDefinition +buckPassing,inverts,selfblame +cleverHansEffect,inverts,cleverLinda +cleverLinda,inverts,cleverHansEffect +converseAccidentFallacy,inverts,fallacyOfAccident +courtiersReply,inverts,credentialism +credentialism,inverts,courtiersReply +crossedArms,inverts,akimbo +darkPattern,inverts,nudge +denyingAConjunct,inverts,affirmingADisjunct +denyingTheCorrelative,inverts,falseDilemma +exaggeration,inverts,minimisation +fallacyOfAccident,inverts,converseAccidentFallacy +fallacyOfAccident,inverts,overgeneralization +falseDilemma,inverts,denyingTheCorrelative +gamblersFallacy,inverts,inverseGamblersFallacy +golemEffect,inverts,pygmalionEffect +hastyGeneralization,inverts,slothfulInduction +illicitAffirmative,inverts,illicitNegative +illicitNegative,inverts,illicitAffirmative +illicitSubalternation,inverts,illicitSuperalternation +illicitSuperalternation,inverts,illicitSubalternation +illusionOfExternalAgency,inverts,moralLuck +improvingTheDeal,inverts,bait +inverseGamblersFallacy,inverts,gamblersFallacy +materialism,inverts,subjectiveIdealism +minimisation,inverts,playingTheVictim +minimisation,inverts,exaggeration +moralLuck,inverts,illusionOfExternalAgency +narrowDefinition,inverts,broadDefinition +noceboEffect,inverts,placeboEffect +nudge,inverts,darkPattern +overgeneralization,inverts,fallacyOfAccident +oxymoron,inverts,tautology +personalization,inverts,psychologicalProjection +placeboEffect,inverts,noceboEffect +playingTheVictim,inverts,minimisation +proofByAnger,inverts,angerTheOpponent +proofSurrogate,inverts,appealToTheStone +pseudoscience,inverts,pseudoskepticism +pseudoskepticism,inverts,pseudoscience +psychologicalProjection,inverts,personalization +pygmalionEffect,inverts,golemEffect +selfblame,inverts,buckPassing +selfblame,inverts,victimBlaming +selfdefeatingProphecy,inverts,autosuggestion +slothfulInduction,inverts,hastyGeneralization +subjectiveIdealism,inverts,materialism +tautology,inverts,oxymoron +victimBlaming,inverts,selfblame +ableism,isRelatedTo,paternalism +absurd,isRelatedTo,joke +adPopulum,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +adynaton,isRelatedTo,auxesis +affirmingTheConsequent,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +alethicModalFallacy,isRelatedTo,modalScopeFallacy +allegory,isRelatedTo,metaphor +allophilia,isRelatedTo,culturalCringe +allophilia,isRelatedTo,xenocentrism +amazingFamiliarity,isRelatedTo,faultyLogics +amazingFamiliarity,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +ambiguityEffect,isRelatedTo,zeroriskBias +ambiguityEffect,isRelatedTo,pseudocertaintyEffect +ambiguityEffect,isRelatedTo,neglectOfProbabilityBias +anecdotalEvidence,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +appealToBarnumEffect,isRelatedTo,coldReading +appealToBias,isRelatedTo,appealToMotive +appealToBias,isRelatedTo,ergoDecedo +appealToCensoriousAbuse,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +appealToCensorship,isRelatedTo,cheating +appealToClosure,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +appealToCommonFolk,isRelatedTo,appealToCommonSense +appealToCommonSense,isRelatedTo,appealToCommonFolk +appealToConfidence,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +appealToCustom,isRelatedTo,appealToTheMajority +appealToFalseAuthority,isRelatedTo,ipseDixit +appealToFiction,isRelatedTo,counterfactualAssumption +appealToIdentity,isRelatedTo,pinkbaiting +appealToIdentity,isRelatedTo,dehumanization +appealToLoyalty,isRelatedTo,influence +appealToLoyalty,isRelatedTo,obstruction +appealToManyAuthoritativeReferences,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +appealToMotive,isRelatedTo,appealToBias +appealToMotive,isRelatedTo,ergoDecedo +appealToNovelty,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +appealToNovelty,isRelatedTo,faultyLogics +appealToProbability,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +appealToRecapitulationTheory,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +appealToTheMajority,isRelatedTo,appealToCustom +appealToTheMoon,isRelatedTo,faultyLogics +appealToTheNumber,isRelatedTo,drinkingTheKoolAid./PeerPressure +appealToTheNumber,isRelatedTo,pluralisticIgnorance +appealToTheStone,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +argumentByScenario,isRelatedTo,faultyLogics +argumentFromDesign,isRelatedTo,faultyLogics +argumentFromPersonalAuthority,isRelatedTo,influence +argumentFromSmallNumbers,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +argumentFromSmallNumbers,isRelatedTo,insensitivityToSampleSize +argumentumASilentio,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +argumentumAdMartyrdom,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +astroturfing,isRelatedTo,influence +attackingTheQuestion,isRelatedTo,questioningTheQuestion +attackingTheQuestion,isRelatedTo,decliningToAnswer +attentionSeeking,isRelatedTo,boasting +authorityBias,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +auxesis,isRelatedTo,adynaton +avoidingTheIssue,isRelatedTo,pretext +bait,isRelatedTo,lowball +baitingForTruth,isRelatedTo,covertInterrogation +baitingForTruth,isRelatedTo,cheating +bandwagonEffect,isRelatedTo,socialdesirabilityBias +bandwagonFallacy,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +baseRateFallacy,isRelatedTo,doomsdayArgument +baseRateFallacy,isRelatedTo,confusionOfTheInverse +beggingTheQuestion,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +beggingTheQuestion,isRelatedTo,faultyLogics +behaviorism,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +biasBlindSpot,isRelatedTo,lakeWobegonEffect +boasting,isRelatedTo,attentionSeeking +bow,isRelatedTo,genuflection +bribery,isRelatedTo,reciprocation +bribery,isRelatedTo,cheating +brokenWindowFallacy,isRelatedTo,faultyLogics +bromide,isRelatedTo,lapalissade +bromide,isRelatedTo,influence +bullshit,isRelatedTo,fabrication +canard,isRelatedTo,fakeNews +canard,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +caricature,isRelatedTo,parody +carrotAndStick,isRelatedTo,shaping +carrotAndStick,isRelatedTo,intermittentReinforcement +cartesianCircle,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +catandmouseGame,isRelatedTo,obstruction +causalReductionism,isRelatedTo,denyingTheCommonCause +causalReductionism,isRelatedTo,postHocErgoPropterHoc +cheating,isRelatedTo,fallacy +cheating,isRelatedTo,kafkatrap +cheating,isRelatedTo,bribery +cheating,isRelatedTo,gishGallop +cheating,isRelatedTo,grayPropaganda +cheating,isRelatedTo,baitingForTruth +cheating,isRelatedTo,appealToCensorship +cheating,isRelatedTo,usingABadCounterargument +chlick,isRelatedTo,obstruction +circularReasoning,isRelatedTo,faultyLogics +circularReporting,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +claimVictoryDespiteDefeat,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +cleverHansEffect,isRelatedTo,experimenterEffect +clichéThinking,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +clientitis,isRelatedTo,malinchism +clothing,isRelatedTo,socioculturalMarker +cognitiveDistortion,isRelatedTo,pessimismBias +cognitiveDistortion,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +coldReading,isRelatedTo,appealToBarnumEffect +communalReinforcement,isRelatedTo,influence +conclusionContradictingAPremise,isRelatedTo,internalContradiction +confirmationBias,isRelatedTo,selectionBias +confirmationBias,isRelatedTo,omissionOfKeyEvidence +conflictingConditions,isRelatedTo,faultyLogics +confusingGroupAndTotalAverages,isRelatedTo,simpsonsParadox +confusingGroupAndTotalAverages,isRelatedTo,confusingMeanAndMedian +confusingMeanAndMedian,isRelatedTo,confusingGroupAndTotalAverages +confusionOfTheInverse,isRelatedTo,baseRateFallacy +correlationCausationFallacy,isRelatedTo,illusoryCorrelation +counterfactualAssumption,isRelatedTo,appealToFiction +covertInterrogation,isRelatedTo,baitingForTruth +coverup,isRelatedTo,forgery +credoQuiaAbsurdum,isRelatedTo,faultyLogics +culturalCringe,isRelatedTo,allophilia +deadCatStrategy,isRelatedTo,influence +deadCatStrategy,isRelatedTo,obstruction +deadpan,isRelatedTo,sarcasm +deceptiveImplication,isRelatedTo,influence +decliningToAnswer,isRelatedTo,attackingTheQuestion +decliningToAnswer,isRelatedTo,questioningTheQuestion +decoyEffect,isRelatedTo,influence +deepity,isRelatedTo,misleadingLanguage +deepity,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +definistFallacy,isRelatedTo,dictionaryArgument +dehumanization,isRelatedTo,appealToIdentity +demonization,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +denyingTheAntecedent,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +denyingTheCommonCause,isRelatedTo,causalReductionism +denyingTheCommonCause,isRelatedTo,postHocErgoPropterHoc +dictionaryArgument,isRelatedTo,definistFallacy +digression,isRelatedTo,obstruction +digression,isRelatedTo,interruptBreakDivertTheDispute +dispositionEffect,isRelatedTo,sunkCostBias +dissociation,isRelatedTo,reframing +dissociation,isRelatedTo,futurePacing +distinctionBias,isRelatedTo,lessisbetterEffect +dogmatism,isRelatedTo,opportunisticDogmas +doomsdayArgument,isRelatedTo,baseRateFallacy +doubleCounting,isRelatedTo,numericalError +doubleEntendre,isRelatedTo,pun +doubleSpeak,isRelatedTo,talkingPoints +doubleWink,isRelatedTo,flutter +drawingTheWrongConclusion,isRelatedTo,usingTheWrongReasons +drinkingTheKoolAid./PeerPressure,isRelatedTo,appealToTheNumber +elGrecoFallacy,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +elGrecoFallacy,isRelatedTo,faultyLogics +emotionalBlackmail,isRelatedTo,guiltive +emotionalBlackmail,isRelatedTo,guiltTrip +emotionalReasoning,isRelatedTo,mindProjectionFallacy +emotionalReasoning,isRelatedTo,valenceEffect +emotionalReasoning,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +emotiveConjugation,isRelatedTo,judgementalLanguage +epistemicFallacy,isRelatedTo,modalScopeFallacy +ergoDecedo,isRelatedTo,appealToMotive +ergoDecedo,isRelatedTo,appealToBias +escalationOfCommitment,isRelatedTo,inducedCommitment +escapism,isRelatedTo,malinchism +experimenterEffect,isRelatedTo,cleverHansEffect +extendedAnalogy,isRelatedTo,falseEquivalence +extremism,isRelatedTo,sectarianism +fabrication,isRelatedTo,bullshit +facepalm,isRelatedTo,handsoverface +facepalm,isRelatedTo,fistClench +failingThePrincipleOfCharity,isRelatedTo,hanlonsRazorFailure +failureNeurosis,isRelatedTo,fearOfFailure +fakeExperts,isRelatedTo,linkingToAuthority +fakeNews,isRelatedTo,canard +fallacy,isRelatedTo,faultyLogics +fallacy,isRelatedTo,cheating +fallacyOfAccident,isRelatedTo,overgeneralization +fallacyOfAccident,isRelatedTo,overwhelmingException +fallacyOfExclusion,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +fallacyOfExclusion,isRelatedTo,neymansBias +falseEquivalence,isRelatedTo,extendedAnalogy +falseMemory,isRelatedTo,falsePremise +falsePrecision,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +falsePremise,isRelatedTo,misrepresentation +falsePremise,isRelatedTo,outdatedInformation +falsePremise,isRelatedTo,falseMemory +falseProofOfEquality,isRelatedTo,faultyLogics +fanaticism,isRelatedTo,terrorism +faultyGeneralisation,isRelatedTo,faultyLogics +faultyImmediateInference,isRelatedTo,quantifierShift +faultyLogics,isRelatedTo,fallacy +faultyLogics,isRelatedTo,magicalThinking +faultyLogics,isRelatedTo,credoQuiaAbsurdum +faultyLogics,isRelatedTo,theGoldenHammer +faultyLogics,isRelatedTo,fractalWrongness +faultyLogics,isRelatedTo,argumentByScenario +faultyLogics,isRelatedTo,amazingFamiliarity +faultyLogics,isRelatedTo,appealToTheMoon +faultyLogics,isRelatedTo,argumentFromDesign +faultyLogics,isRelatedTo,beggingTheQuestion +faultyLogics,isRelatedTo,homunculusArgument +faultyLogics,isRelatedTo,brokenWindowFallacy +faultyLogics,isRelatedTo,paradox +faultyLogics,isRelatedTo,russelsParadox +faultyLogics,isRelatedTo,falseProofOfEquality +faultyLogics,isRelatedTo,conflictingConditions +faultyLogics,isRelatedTo,stolenConceptFallacy +faultyLogics,isRelatedTo,circularReasoning +faultyLogics,isRelatedTo,philosophicalFallacy +faultyLogics,isRelatedTo,quantifierShift +faultyLogics,isRelatedTo,trivialism +faultyLogics,isRelatedTo,appealToNovelty +faultyLogics,isRelatedTo,lumpOfLabourFallacy +faultyLogics,isRelatedTo,faultyGeneralisation +faultyLogics,isRelatedTo,hastyConclusion +faultyLogics,isRelatedTo,sunkCostBias +faultyLogics,isRelatedTo,galileoGambit +faultyLogics,isRelatedTo,quantumPhysicsFallacy +faultyLogics,isRelatedTo,packageDealFallacy +faultyLogics,isRelatedTo,elGrecoFallacy +faultyLogics,isRelatedTo,wrongerThanWrong +faultyLogics,isRelatedTo,twoWrongsMakeARight +fearOfFailure,isRelatedTo,failureNeurosis +fistClench,isRelatedTo,facepalm +fistClench,isRelatedTo,handsoverface +flagwaving,isRelatedTo,influence +flirt,isRelatedTo,ingratiation +flirt,isRelatedTo,superficialCharm +flutter,isRelatedTo,doubleWink +forgery,isRelatedTo,coverup +formal,isRelatedTo,greeting +fortunetelling,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +fractalWrongness,isRelatedTo,faultyLogics +friendly,isRelatedTo,greeting +fundingBias,isRelatedTo,publicationBias +futurePacing,isRelatedTo,dissociation +galileoGambit,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +galileoGambit,isRelatedTo,faultyLogics +gamblersFallacy,isRelatedTo,mathematicalError +gamblersFallacy,isRelatedTo,panglossEffect +generationEffect,isRelatedTo,spacingEffect +generationEffect,isRelatedTo,testingEffect +genuflection,isRelatedTo,handkissing +genuflection,isRelatedTo,bow +gesture,isRelatedTo,posture +gishGallop,isRelatedTo,obstruction +gishGallop,isRelatedTo,cheating +glitteringGenerality,isRelatedTo,pandering +goBig(lie)OrGoHome,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +gratitudeTrap,isRelatedTo,influence +gratitudeTrap,isRelatedTo,theWickedAlternative +grayPropaganda,isRelatedTo,cheating +greeting,isRelatedTo,formal +greeting,isRelatedTo,friendly +groupAttributionError,isRelatedTo,implicitStereotype +guiltTrip,isRelatedTo,emotionalBlackmail +guiltive,isRelatedTo,emotionalBlackmail +haloEffect,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +handClasping,isRelatedTo,prostration +handClasping,isRelatedTo,layingOnOfHands +handkissing,isRelatedTo,genuflection +handsoverface,isRelatedTo,facepalm +handsoverface,isRelatedTo,fistClench +hanlonsRazorFailure,isRelatedTo,failingThePrincipleOfCharity +haptics,isRelatedTo,kinesics +harassment,isRelatedTo,nagging +hastyConclusion,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +hastyConclusion,isRelatedTo,faultyLogics +hollowArgument,isRelatedTo,limitedScope +homonym,isRelatedTo,mondegreen +homonym,isRelatedTo,jingleJangleFallacy +homunculusArgument,isRelatedTo,faultyLogics +hostileAttributionBias,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +iKEAEffect,isRelatedTo,sunkCostBias +idiosyncraticLanguage,isRelatedTo,misleadingLanguage +ifbywhiskey,isRelatedTo,takingAdvantageOfTheNaysayer +ignoratioElenchi,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +illicitArgumentumEContrario,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +illicitContrary,isRelatedTo,illicitSubalternation +illicitSubalternation,isRelatedTo,illicitContrary +illusionOfControl,isRelatedTo,restraintBias +illusionOfValidity,isRelatedTo,illusoryCorrelation +illusoryCorrelation,isRelatedTo,correlationCausationFallacy +illusoryCorrelation,isRelatedTo,illusionOfValidity +illusorySuperiority,isRelatedTo,overconfidenceEffect +illusoryTruthEffect,isRelatedTo,sleeperEffect +illusoryTruthEffect,isRelatedTo,influence +impactBias,isRelatedTo,projectionBias +implicitStereotype,isRelatedTo,groupAttributionError +incompatiblePremises,isRelatedTo,internalContradiction +inducedCommitment,isRelatedTo,escalationOfCommitment +influence,isRelatedTo,bromide +influence,isRelatedTo,communalReinforcement +influence,isRelatedTo,argumentFromPersonalAuthority +influence,isRelatedTo,appealToLoyalty +influence,isRelatedTo,flagwaving +influence,isRelatedTo,deceptiveImplication +influence,isRelatedTo,polarizing +influence,isRelatedTo,astroturfing +influence,isRelatedTo,deadCatStrategy +influence,isRelatedTo,moralPanic +influence,isRelatedTo,decoyEffect +influence,isRelatedTo,illusoryTruthEffect +influence,isRelatedTo,gratitudeTrap +ingratiation,isRelatedTo,flirt +ingroupFavoritism,isRelatedTo,islandMentality +insensitivityToSampleSize,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +insensitivityToSampleSize,isRelatedTo,argumentFromSmallNumbers +insensitivityToSampleSize,isRelatedTo,mathematicalError +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,beggingTheQuestion +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,clichéThinking +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,appealToManyAuthoritativeReferences +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,tautology +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,appealToConfidence +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,haloEffect +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,deepity +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,argumentumAdMartyrdom +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,yuckFactor +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,motteAndBailey +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,onTheSpotFallacy +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,argumentFromSmallNumbers +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,insensitivityToSampleSize +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,slothfulInduction +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,representativeHeuristic +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,misleadingVividness +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,nutpicking +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,fallacyOfExclusion +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,spotlightFallacy +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,appealToRecapitulationTheory +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,appealToProbability +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,appealToCensoriousAbuse +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,cartesianCircle +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,ignoratioElenchi +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,unfoundedSupport +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,spiderManFallacy +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,tuQuoque +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,denyingTheAntecedent +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,affirmingTheConsequent +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,proofByExample +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,illicitArgumentumEContrario +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,irrelevantPremises +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,amazingFamiliarity +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,usingTheWrongReasons +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,proofSurrogate +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,fortunetelling +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,invalidEnthymeme +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,falsePrecision +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,strawMan +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,outdatedInformation +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,canard +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,urbanLegend +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,sellingSnakeOil +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,pseudohistory +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,circularReporting +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,argumentumASilentio +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,tokenism +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,appealToClosure +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,thatWasYearsAgo +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,appealToNovelty +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,anecdotalEvidence +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,cognitiveDistortion +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,emotionalReasoning +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,hastyConclusion +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,outcomeBias +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,hostileAttributionBias +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,regressiveFallacy +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,galileoGambit +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,subjectivityBias +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,authorityBias +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,behaviorism +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,quantumPhysicsFallacy +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,packageDealFallacy +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,elGrecoFallacy +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,truthiness +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,wrongerThanWrong +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,appealToTheStone +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,limitedScope +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,claimVictoryDespiteDefeat +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,goBig(lie)OrGoHome +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,adPopulum +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,demonization +insufficiency,isRelatedTo,bandwagonFallacy +intermittentReinforcement,isRelatedTo,carrotAndStick +internalContradiction,isRelatedTo,incompatiblePremises +internalContradiction,isRelatedTo,conclusionContradictingAPremise +interruptBreakDivertTheDispute,isRelatedTo,digression +invalidEnthymeme,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +inverseStoppedClock,isRelatedTo,theBrokenClock +invincibleIgnorance,isRelatedTo,truebelieverSyndrome +ipseDixit,isRelatedTo,appealToFalseAuthority +irrelevantPremises,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +islandMentality,isRelatedTo,ingroupFavoritism +jingleJangleFallacy,isRelatedTo,homonym +joke,isRelatedTo,absurd +judgementalLanguage,isRelatedTo,emotiveConjugation +kafkatrap,isRelatedTo,cheating +kafkatrap,isRelatedTo,obstruction +kinesics,isRelatedTo,oculesics +kinesics,isRelatedTo,haptics +lakeWobegonEffect,isRelatedTo,biasBlindSpot +lapalissade,isRelatedTo,bromide +layingOnOfHands,isRelatedTo,signOfTheCross +layingOnOfHands,isRelatedTo,handClasping +leapOfFaith,isRelatedTo,proofSurrogate +lessisbetterEffect,isRelatedTo,distinctionBias +levelsOfProcessingModel,isRelatedTo,modalityEffect +limitedScope,isRelatedTo,hollowArgument +limitedScope,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +linkingToAuthority,isRelatedTo,fakeExperts +lowball,isRelatedTo,bait +lumpOfLabourFallacy,isRelatedTo,faultyLogics +magicalThinking,isRelatedTo,faultyLogics +magnificationAndMinimization,isRelatedTo,minimisation +malinchism,isRelatedTo,clientitis +malinchism,isRelatedTo,escapism +materialism,isRelatedTo,scientism +mathematicalError,isRelatedTo,gamblersFallacy +mathematicalError,isRelatedTo,insensitivityToSampleSize +mathematicalError,isRelatedTo,planningFallacy +mathematicalError,isRelatedTo,neglectOfProbabilityBias +mathematicalError,isRelatedTo,regressiveFallacy +meme,isRelatedTo,rumor +metaphor,isRelatedTo,allegory +mindProjectionFallacy,isRelatedTo,emotionalReasoning +minimisation,isRelatedTo,magnificationAndMinimization +misleadingLanguage,isRelatedTo,deepity +misleadingLanguage,isRelatedTo,spoonerism +misleadingLanguage,isRelatedTo,suppressedQuantifier +misleadingLanguage,isRelatedTo,takingAdvantageOfTheNaysayer +misleadingLanguage,isRelatedTo,idiosyncraticLanguage +misleadingVividness,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +misrepresentation,isRelatedTo,falsePremise +mistakingTheMapForTheTerritory,isRelatedTo,reification +modalScopeFallacy,isRelatedTo,alethicModalFallacy +modalScopeFallacy,isRelatedTo,epistemicFallacy +modalityEffect,isRelatedTo,levelsOfProcessingModel +mondegreen,isRelatedTo,homonym +moralPanic,isRelatedTo,influence +mortonsFork,isRelatedTo,takingAdvantageOfTheNaysayer +motteAndBailey,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +nagging,isRelatedTo,harassment +namedropping,isRelatedTo,rodomontade +neglectOfProbabilityBias,isRelatedTo,ambiguityEffect +neglectOfProbabilityBias,isRelatedTo,mathematicalError +neglectOfProbabilityBias,isRelatedTo,pseudocertaintyEffect +neymansBias,isRelatedTo,survivorshipBias +neymansBias,isRelatedTo,fallacyOfExclusion +normalcyBias,isRelatedTo,ostrichEffect +numericalError,isRelatedTo,doubleCounting +nutpicking,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +obstruction,isRelatedTo,appealToLoyalty +obstruction,isRelatedTo,digression +obstruction,isRelatedTo,parembole +obstruction,isRelatedTo,catandmouseGame +obstruction,isRelatedTo,gishGallop +obstruction,isRelatedTo,stonewalling +obstruction,isRelatedTo,chlick +obstruction,isRelatedTo,deadCatStrategy +obstruction,isRelatedTo,shiftingGround +obstruction,isRelatedTo,kafkatrap +obstruction,isRelatedTo,takingAdvantageOfTheNaysayer +occultStats,isRelatedTo,shoehorning +oculesics,isRelatedTo,kinesics +omissionOfKeyEvidence,isRelatedTo,confirmationBias +onTheSpotFallacy,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +opportunisticDogmas,isRelatedTo,dogmatism +optimismBias,isRelatedTo,overconfidenceEffect +ostrichEffect,isRelatedTo,normalcyBias +outcomeBias,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +outdatedInformation,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +outdatedInformation,isRelatedTo,falsePremise +overconfidenceEffect,isRelatedTo,illusorySuperiority +overconfidenceEffect,isRelatedTo,optimismBias +overgeneralization,isRelatedTo,fallacyOfAccident +overgeneralization,isRelatedTo,overwhelmingException +overwhelmingException,isRelatedTo,overgeneralization +overwhelmingException,isRelatedTo,fallacyOfAccident +packageDealFallacy,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +packageDealFallacy,isRelatedTo,faultyLogics +pandering,isRelatedTo,glitteringGenerality +panglossEffect,isRelatedTo,gamblersFallacy +paradox,isRelatedTo,faultyLogics +parembole,isRelatedTo,obstruction +parody,isRelatedTo,caricature +partsetCuingEffect,isRelatedTo,retrievalInducedForgetting +paternalism,isRelatedTo,ableism +pessimismBias,isRelatedTo,cognitiveDistortion +philosophicalFallacy,isRelatedTo,faultyLogics +pinkbaiting,isRelatedTo,appealToIdentity +planningFallacy,isRelatedTo,mathematicalError +planningFallacy,isRelatedTo,proinnovationBias +pluralisticIgnorance,isRelatedTo,appealToTheNumber +polarizing,isRelatedTo,influence +polysemicLexicalShift,isRelatedTo,polysemyBySemanticChange +polysemyBySemanticChange,isRelatedTo,polysemicLexicalShift +postHocErgoPropterHoc,isRelatedTo,causalReductionism +postHocErgoPropterHoc,isRelatedTo,denyingTheCommonCause +posture,isRelatedTo,proxemics +posture,isRelatedTo,gesture +pressingWhereItHurts,isRelatedTo,tacticOfNeedling +pretext,isRelatedTo,avoidingTheIssue +proinnovationBias,isRelatedTo,planningFallacy +projectionBias,isRelatedTo,impactBias +proofByExample,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +proofSurrogate,isRelatedTo,leapOfFaith +proofSurrogate,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +prostration,isRelatedTo,handClasping +proxemics,isRelatedTo,posture +pseudocertaintyEffect,isRelatedTo,ambiguityEffect +pseudocertaintyEffect,isRelatedTo,neglectOfProbabilityBias +pseudohistory,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +publicationBias,isRelatedTo,selectiveThinking +publicationBias,isRelatedTo,fundingBias +pun,isRelatedTo,doubleEntendre +quantifierShift,isRelatedTo,wrongQuantifier +quantifierShift,isRelatedTo,faultyImmediateInference +quantifierShift,isRelatedTo,faultyLogics +quantumPhysicsFallacy,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +quantumPhysicsFallacy,isRelatedTo,faultyLogics +questioningTheQuestion,isRelatedTo,attackingTheQuestion +questioningTheQuestion,isRelatedTo,decliningToAnswer +reciprocation,isRelatedTo,bribery +reframing,isRelatedTo,dissociation +regressiveFallacy,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +regressiveFallacy,isRelatedTo,mathematicalError +reification,isRelatedTo,mistakingTheMapForTheTerritory +representativeHeuristic,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +restraintBias,isRelatedTo,illusionOfControl +retrievalInducedForgetting,isRelatedTo,partsetCuingEffect +retroactiveClairvoyance,isRelatedTo,retrospectiveDeterminism +retrospectiveDeterminism,isRelatedTo,retroactiveClairvoyance +rodomontade,isRelatedTo,namedropping +rumor,isRelatedTo,meme +russelsParadox,isRelatedTo,faultyLogics +sarcasm,isRelatedTo,deadpan +scapegoating,isRelatedTo,settingUpToFail +scientism,isRelatedTo,materialism +sectarianism,isRelatedTo,extremism +selectionBias,isRelatedTo,confirmationBias +selectiveThinking,isRelatedTo,publicationBias +sellingSnakeOil,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +serialpositionEffect,isRelatedTo,theMagicalNumberSeven +settingUpToFail,isRelatedTo,scapegoating +shaping,isRelatedTo,carrotAndStick +shiftingGround,isRelatedTo,obstruction +shoehorning,isRelatedTo,occultStats +signOfTheCross,isRelatedTo,layingOnOfHands +silentTreatment,isRelatedTo,stonewalling +simpsonsParadox,isRelatedTo,confusingGroupAndTotalAverages +sleeperEffect,isRelatedTo,illusoryTruthEffect +slothfulInduction,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +socialComparisonBias,isRelatedTo,socialdesirabilityBias +socialdesirabilityBias,isRelatedTo,socialComparisonBias +socialdesirabilityBias,isRelatedTo,bandwagonEffect +socioculturalMarker,isRelatedTo,clothing +spacingEffect,isRelatedTo,testingEffect +spacingEffect,isRelatedTo,generationEffect +spiderManFallacy,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +spoonerism,isRelatedTo,misleadingLanguage +spotlightFallacy,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +stolenConceptFallacy,isRelatedTo,faultyLogics +stonewalling,isRelatedTo,silentTreatment +stonewalling,isRelatedTo,obstruction +strawMan,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +subjectivityBias,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +subvertedSupport,isRelatedTo,unsoundPremise +sunkCostBias,isRelatedTo,iKEAEffect +sunkCostBias,isRelatedTo,faultyLogics +sunkCostBias,isRelatedTo,dispositionEffect +superficialCharm,isRelatedTo,flirt +suppressedQuantifier,isRelatedTo,misleadingLanguage +survivorshipBias,isRelatedTo,neymansBias +tacticOfNeedling,isRelatedTo,pressingWhereItHurts +takingAdvantageOfTheNaysayer,isRelatedTo,ifbywhiskey +takingAdvantageOfTheNaysayer,isRelatedTo,mortonsFork +takingAdvantageOfTheNaysayer,isRelatedTo,misleadingLanguage +takingAdvantageOfTheNaysayer,isRelatedTo,obstruction +talkingPoints,isRelatedTo,doubleSpeak +tautology,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +terrorism,isRelatedTo,fanaticism +testingEffect,isRelatedTo,spacingEffect +testingEffect,isRelatedTo,generationEffect +thatWasYearsAgo,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +theBrokenClock,isRelatedTo,inverseStoppedClock +theGoldenHammer,isRelatedTo,faultyLogics +theMagicalNumberSeven,isRelatedTo,serialpositionEffect +theWickedAlternative,isRelatedTo,gratitudeTrap +tokenism,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +trickQuestion,isRelatedTo,unfoundedSupport +trivialism,isRelatedTo,faultyLogics +truebelieverSyndrome,isRelatedTo,invincibleIgnorance +truthiness,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +tuQuoque,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +twoWrongsMakeARight,isRelatedTo,faultyLogics +unfoundedSupport,isRelatedTo,trickQuestion +unfoundedSupport,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +unsoundPremise,isRelatedTo,subvertedSupport +urbanLegend,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +usingABadCounterargument,isRelatedTo,cheating +usingTheWrongReasons,isRelatedTo,drawingTheWrongConclusion +usingTheWrongReasons,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +valenceEffect,isRelatedTo,emotionalReasoning +wrongQuantifier,isRelatedTo,quantifierShift +wrongerThanWrong,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +wrongerThanWrong,isRelatedTo,faultyLogics +xenocentrism,isRelatedTo,allophilia +yuckFactor,isRelatedTo,insufficiency +zeroriskBias,isRelatedTo,ambiguityEffect +3MenMakeATiger,leverages,appealToTheNumber +ableism,leverages,insufficiency +absurdPropositions,leverages,influence +abusiveRelativism,leverages,reification +adPopulum,leverages,influence +adnomination,leverages,misleadingLanguage +allegory,leverages,metaphor +ambiguousAssertion,leverages,misleadingLanguage +anecdotalEvidence,leverages,insensitivityToSampleSize +angelDusting,leverages,insufficiency +angelDusting,leverages,mathematicalError +antienvironmentalism,leverages,appealToIdentity +antilogy,leverages,faultyLogics +antiparastasis,leverages,misleadingLanguage +antiphrasis,leverages,misleadingLanguage +antitheticalEquivocation,leverages,distancingLanguage +apexFallacy,leverages,cherryPicking +apexFallacy,leverages,representativeHeuristic +apophasis,leverages,allusion +appealToCelebrity,leverages,influence +appealToClosure,leverages,influence +appealToCommonFolk,leverages,appealToNormality +appealToCommonSense,leverages,allegedCertainty +appealToCommonSense,leverages,appealToNormality +appealToComplexity,leverages,appealToMystery +appealToConfidence,leverages,influence +appealToIdentity,leverages,influence +appealToLoyalty,leverages,appealToConfidence +appealToMinority,leverages,elitism +appealToModesty,leverages,influence +appealToMystery,leverages,appealToComplexity +appealToNovelty,leverages,recencyBias +argumentByGibberish,leverages,deepity +argumentByGibberish,leverages,misleadingLanguage +argumentByScenario,leverages,pIDOOMA +argumentByScenario,leverages,influence +argumentFromEditorsIntent,leverages,appealToMalintention +argumentFromForm,leverages,influence +argumentFromForm,leverages,misleadingLanguage +argumentFromSmallNumbers,leverages,insensitivityToSampleSize +argumentOfTheBeard,leverages,misleadingLanguage +attentionSeeking,leverages,boasting +attentionalBias,leverages,emotionalBiases +attributionBias,leverages,essentialism +availabilityHeuristic,leverages,recencyBias +avoidingTheIssue,leverages,redHerring +badFaith,leverages,influence +badFaith,leverages,onesidedArgument +baitingForTruth,leverages,covertInterrogation +bandwagonFallacy,leverages,influence +baseRateFallacy,leverages,confusionOfTheInverse +beamSearch,leverages,insufficiency +biasedSample,leverages,selectionBias +bigWords,leverages,influence +blackPropaganda,leverages,influence +blackPropaganda,leverages,grayPropaganda +blackPropaganda,leverages,cheating +brainwashing,leverages,influence +bromide,leverages,lapalissade +bullshit,leverages,influence +bullshit,leverages,sellingSnakeOil +burlesque,leverages,misleadingLanguage +buzzword,leverages,influence +cacophony,leverages,alliteration +"calling""Cards""",leverages,strawMan +cellophaneParadox,leverages,insufficiency +cellophaneParadox,leverages,misleadingLanguage +circumlocution,leverages,misleadingLanguage +claimVictoryDespiteDefeat,leverages,denyingTheCounterevidence +clickbait,leverages,misleadingLanguage +clothing,leverages,socioculturalMarker +collectiveNarcissism,leverages,outgroupHomogeneity +communalReinforcement,leverages,allegedCertainty +compoundQuestion,leverages,obstruction +confabulation,leverages,insufficiency +confirmationBias,leverages,selectionBias +confirmationBias,leverages,omissionOfKeyEvidence +confusingAnExplanationWithAnExcuse,leverages,misleadingLanguage +conglobatio,leverages,enumeratio +contrarianArgumentation,leverages,tacticOfNeedling +converseAccidentFallacy,leverages,overgeneralization +covertInterrogation,leverages,influence +covertInterrogation,leverages,cheating +coverup,leverages,obstruction +creepypasta,leverages,influence +damningWithFaintPraise,leverages,distancingLanguage +damningWithFaintPraise,leverages,misleadingLanguage +damningWithFaintPraise,leverages,influence +deadCatStrategy,leverages,influence +deadpan,leverages,tongueinCheek +deceptiveImplication,leverages,falseImplication +declinism,leverages,rosyRetrospection +decoyEffect,leverages,contrastEffect +deepity,leverages,argumentByGibberish +deepity,leverages,misleadingLanguage +defensiveAttribution,leverages,fundamentalAttributionError +dehumanization,leverages,influence +dehumanization,leverages,misleadingLanguage +demandForSpecialConsideration,leverages,influence +demonization,leverages,influence +disguisedOpinion,leverages,influence +disinformation,leverages,rumor +dispositionEffect,leverages,sunkCostBias +disqualifyingThePositive,leverages,magnificationAndMinimization +dissociation,leverages,reframing +distancingLanguage,leverages,misleadingLanguage +distinctionBias,leverages,influence +dogwhistlePolitics,leverages,misleadingLanguage +doubleEntendre,leverages,misleadingLanguage +doubleSpeak,leverages,talkingPoints +doubleSpeak,leverages,buzzword +drinkingTheKoolAid./PeerPressure,leverages,influence +egotism,leverages,mindProjectionFallacy +emotionalBiases,leverages,attentionalBias +emotionalBlackmail,leverages,guiltTrip +emotionalReasoning,leverages,valenceEffect +emotiveConjugation,leverages,judgementalLanguage +emotiveConjugation,leverages,misleadingLanguage +emotiveConjugation,leverages,influence +emotiveConjugation,leverages,phantomDistinction +endlessJustificationDemand,leverages,obstruction +entitledToMyOpinion,leverages,insufficiency +epanorthosis,leverages,misleadingLanguage +ergoDecedo,leverages,appealToMotive +ergoDecedo,leverages,appealToBias +escapeHatch,leverages,hedging +essentialism,leverages,attributionBias +essentiallyContestedConcept,leverages,undefinability +ethnocentrism,leverages,stereotype +etymologicalFallacy,leverages,misleadingLanguage +euphemism,leverages,misleadingLanguage +existentialFallacy,leverages,insufficiency +expectationEffects,leverages,misconstruals +extendedAnalogy,leverages,fallaciousSimilarityArgument +failureNeurosis,leverages,fearOfFailure +failureToClarify,leverages,misleadingLanguage +failureToState,leverages,misleadingLanguage +fakeDebate,leverages,bulkFakeExperts +fakeNews,leverages,influence +fallacistsFallacy,leverages,denyingTheAntecedent +fallacy,leverages,influence +fallacy,leverages,misleadingLanguage +fallacyOfChange,leverages,influence +fallacyOfOpposition,leverages,circumstantialAdHominem +fallacyOfPrejudice,leverages,influence +falseEquivalence,leverages,fallaciousSimilarityArgument +falseFront,leverages,coveringYourAss +falseMemory,leverages,falsePremise +falsePrecision,leverages,mathematicalError +farfetchedHypothesis,leverages,insufficiency +fastfoodChristianity,leverages,breadAndCircuses +faultyGeneralisation,leverages,insufficiency +fearUncertaintyAndDoubt,leverages,influence +fedspeak,leverages,misleadingLanguage +firehoseOfFalsehood,leverages,obstruction +flagwaving,leverages,drinkingTheKoolAid./PeerPressure +flyingCarpet,leverages,influence +fundamentalism,leverages,dogmatism +fundingBias,leverages,selectiveThinking +gaslighting,leverages,cheating +gishGallop,leverages,spreading +gishGallop,leverages,influence +gishGallop,leverages,obstruction +goBig(lie)OrGoHome,leverages,influence +gratitudeTrap,leverages,should/shouldntAndMust/mustntStatements +grayPropaganda,leverages,influence +greenwashing,leverages,influence +groupshift,leverages,socialdesirabilityBias +groupshift,leverages,socialComparisonBias +guiltByAssociation,leverages,associationFallacy +harassment,leverages,nagging +hendiadys,leverages,misleadingLanguage +hoax,leverages,influence +hostileAttributionBias,leverages,fundamentalAttributionError +humiliation,leverages,verbalAbuse +hyperbole,leverages,misleadingLanguage +hypercriticalMethod,leverages,nirvanaFallacy +hypercriticalMethod,leverages,trivialObjections +identifiableVictimEffect,leverages,availabilityHeuristic +idiosyncraticLanguage,leverages,failureToClarify +ifbywhiskey,leverages,misleadingLanguage +ifpology,leverages,misleadingLanguage +illicitContraposition,leverages,illicitConversion +illusionOfAsymmetricInsight,leverages,mindreadingBias +illusoryCorrelation,leverages,insensitivityToSampleSize +illusoryCorrelation,leverages,anecdotalEvidence +illusoryTruthEffect,leverages,availabilityHeuristic +impactBias,leverages,focalism +imposture,leverages,influence +improperTransposition,leverages,mistakenExclusivity +inTheoryButNotPractice,leverages,bromide +incompleteComparison,leverages,insufficiency +infiniteRegress,leverages,obstruction +infiniteRegress,leverages,insufficiency +interruptBreakDivertTheDispute,leverages,digression +intuitionPump,leverages,influence +invokingAnIncorrectTranslation,leverages,misleadingLanguage +islandMentality,leverages,ingroupFavoritism +jingleJangleFallacy,leverages,homonym +justAskingQuestions,leverages,misleadingLanguage +justWorldHypothesis,leverages,insufficiency +justWorldHypothesis,leverages,faultyLogics +leapOfFaith,leverages,insufficiency +leveragingNegativityBias,leverages,insufficiency +liarParadox,leverages,faultyLogics +liarParadox,leverages,misleadingLanguage +limitedHangout,leverages,misrepresentation +linkingToAuthority,leverages,cheating +loadedQuestion,leverages,beggingTheQuestion +lyingByOmission,leverages,insufficiency +lyingWithStatistics,leverages,influence +magicalThinking,leverages,superstition +magnificationAndMinimization,leverages,minimisation +magnificationAndMinimization,leverages,exaggeration +maliciousCompliance,leverages,stonewalling +meaninglessQuestion,leverages,digression +meme,leverages,influence +mentalReservation,leverages,misleadingLanguage +metalepsis,leverages,misleadingLanguage +middlePowerDynamics,leverages,abusivePowerAndControl +mindReading,leverages,insufficiency +mindReading,leverages,proofSurrogate +mindreadingBias,leverages,naïveRealism +minimisation,leverages,misleadingLanguage +mislabeling,leverages,insufficiency +mistakesWereMade,leverages,misleadingLanguage +misuseOfSymbol,leverages,influence +misuseOfSymbol,leverages,misleadingLanguage +moralLuck,leverages,dispositionalAttribution +mortonsFork,leverages,influence +motteAndBailey,leverages,baitAndSwitch +motteAndBailey,leverages,misleadingLanguage +motteandbaileyFallacy,leverages,insufficiency +movingTheGoalposts,leverages,misleadingLanguage +narcissismInTheWorkplace,leverages,scapegoating +naïveCynicism,leverages,biasBlindSpot +nirvanaFallacy,leverages,hypercriticalMethod +noTrueScotsman,leverages,misleadingLanguage +noTrueScotsman,leverages,cheating +nobleLie,leverages,influence +nonapologyApology,leverages,misleadingLanguage +nondenialDenial,leverages,misleadingLanguage +nondenialDenial,leverages,mixedBag +normalcyBias,leverages,insufficiency +normalcyBias,leverages,mathematicalError +occultStats,leverages,texasSharpshooter +occultStats,leverages,multipleComparisonsFallacy +opportunisticDogmas,leverages,dogmatism +optimismBias,leverages,illusorySuperiority +optimismBias,leverages,overconfidenceEffect +outdatedInformation,leverages,falsePremise +overgeneralization,leverages,converseAccidentFallacy +overwhelmingException,leverages,overgeneralization +pandering,leverages,glitteringGenerality +pandering,leverages,emotionalCapture +panglossEffect,leverages,affirmingTheConsequent +paradeOfHorribles,leverages,influence +paradeOfHorribles,leverages,slipperySlope +paralanguage,leverages,chronemics +parody,leverages,caricature +passiveaggressiveBehaviour,leverages,minimisation +pathologicalLying,leverages,fabrication +pathosGambit,leverages,influence +peak–endRule,leverages,durationNeglect +perceptionDeception,leverages,subconsciousInfluence +perfectSolutionFallacy,leverages,falseDilemma +periphrasis,leverages,misleadingLanguage +perjury,leverages,forgery +persuadeTheAudience,leverages,influence +persuasiveDefinition,leverages,influence +philosophicalFallacy,leverages,conflictingConditions +piousFraud,leverages,influence +piousFraud,leverages,misrepresentation +polarizing,leverages,dichotomousThinking +politeLie,leverages,influence +politicalCorrectness,leverages,influence +polysemyBySemanticChange,leverages,polysemicLexicalShift +populism,leverages,influence +postHocFallacy,leverages,correlationCausationFallacy +pretentiousAmphigory,leverages,misleadingLanguage +primitivism,leverages,escapism +projectionBias,leverages,focalism +proofSurrogate,leverages,leapOfFaith +prosecutorsFallacy,leverages,baseRateFallacy +prosecutorsFallacy,leverages,confusionOfTheInverse +provingNonexistence,leverages,insufficiency +pseudocertaintyEffect,leverages,neglectOfProbabilityBias +pseudodogmas,leverages,spiritualFallacy +pseudohistory,leverages,quoteMining +pseudophilosophy,leverages,misleadingLanguage +pseudorationalism,leverages,insufficiency +pseudorationalism,leverages,faultyLogics +pseudoscience,leverages,insufficiency +pseudoscience,leverages,pseudoskepticism +pseudoscience,leverages,pseudorationalism +pseudoskepticism,leverages,pseudorationalism +pseudoskepticism,leverages,obstruction +publicationBias,leverages,selectiveThinking +puffery,leverages,influence +pun,leverages,misleadingLanguage +quantitativeFallacy,leverages,streetlightEffect +quantumPhysicsFallacy,leverages,misleadingLanguage +questionBeggingAnalogy,leverages,circularReasoning +questionbeggingAnalogy,leverages,falseEquivalence +rainbowRuse,leverages,misleadingLanguage +rationalization,leverages,usingTheWrongReasons +redbaiting,leverages,appealToIdentity +reversePsychology,leverages,influence +rhetoricalQuestion,leverages,misleadingLanguage +rhymeasreasonEffect,leverages,misleadingLanguage +salamiTactic,leverages,implicitFootInTheDoor +sanctioningTheDevil,leverages,obstruction +sarcasm,leverages,tongueinCheek +scapegoating,leverages,influence +scapegoating,leverages,ignoringTheCounterevidence +scotomization,leverages,omissionOfKeyEvidence +selectiveReading,leverages,omissionOfKeyEvidence +selflicensing,leverages,faultyLogics +selfreferenceEffect,leverages,framingEffect +sellingSnakeOil,leverages,influence +sensationalHeadlines,leverages,misleadingLanguage +shiftingGround,leverages,digression +shoehorning,leverages,insufficiency +shorttermPriority,leverages,influence +simulacrum,leverages,mistakingTheMapForTheTerritory +slantedLanguage,leverages,misleadingLanguage +sleeperEffect,leverages,insufficiency +slipperySlope,leverages,insufficiency +smearCampaign,leverages,gossip +socialEngineering(politics),leverages,framing +socialEngineering(politics),leverages,subconsciousInfluence +socialEngineering(security),leverages,commitment +socialEngineering(security),leverages,disruptThenReframe +socialEngineering(security),leverages,persistence +solipsism,leverages,insufficiency +soundBite,leverages,influence +soundBite,leverages,misleadingLanguage +spiritualFallacy,leverages,misleadingLanguage +spiritualFallacy,leverages,pseudodogmas +spreading,leverages,obstruction +standingOvation,leverages,applause +statusQuoBias,leverages,omissionBias +stonewalling,leverages,silentTreatment +strategyOfTension,leverages,influence +streetlightEffect,leverages,availabilityHeuristic +substitutingExplanationForPremise,leverages,insufficiency +subvertedSupport,leverages,unsoundPremise +suffixEffect,leverages,serialRecall +sulking,leverages,obstruction +sunkCostBias,leverages,iKEAEffect +sunkCostFallacy,leverages,faultyLogics +superficialCharm,leverages,ingratiation +superficialCharm,leverages,flirt +superstition,leverages,magicalThinking +survivorshipBias,leverages,fallacyOfExclusion +swish,leverages,anchoring +synecdoche,leverages,misleadingLanguage +taboo,leverages,obstruction +tacticOfNeedling,leverages,pressingWhereItHurts +takingControl,leverages,socialConditioning +talkingPoints,leverages,influence +technobabble,leverages,misleadingLanguage +terrorism,leverages,influence +testingEffect,leverages,generationEffect +theExtension,leverages,drawingFalseConclusions +theGoldEffect,leverages,influence +thirdpersonEffect,leverages,biasBlindSpot +timesavingBias,leverages,mathematicalError +tokenEndorsement,leverages,insufficiency +tokenEndorsement,leverages,appealToIdentity +toneArgument,leverages,obstruction +toupéeFallacy,leverages,insufficiency +traitAscriptionBias,leverages,insufficiency +traitAscriptionBias,leverages,dispositionalAttribution +triangulation,leverages,pressureTactics +trickQuestion,leverages,misleadingLanguage +trivialObjections,leverages,hypercriticalMethod +truebelieverSyndrome,leverages,invincibleIgnorance +twaddleTendency,leverages,misleadingLanguage +unsoundPremise,leverages,insufficiency +vanGoghFallacy,leverages,insufficiency +varietyese,leverages,misleadingLanguage +vehemence,leverages,appealToTheStick +verbalAbuse,leverages,humiliation +victimBlaming,leverages,buckPassing +virtualityFallacy,leverages,misleadingLanguage +vonRestorffEffect,leverages,contrastEffect +warmReading,leverages,misleadingLanguage +weaselWord,leverages,influence +whatsTheHarm,leverages,insufficiency +whisperingCampaign,leverages,influence +whisperingCampaign,leverages,cheating +whiteHatBias,leverages,insufficiency +whomDoesItProfit?,leverages,argumentFromMotives +wit,leverages,misleadingLanguage +wordMagic,leverages,referentialFallacy +wordplay,leverages,misleadingLanguage +xenocentrism,leverages,culturalCringe +zeroriskBias,leverages,neglectOfProbabilityBias +academese,mirrors,alphabetSoup +academese,mirrors,corporateJargon +academese,mirrors,officialese +academese,mirrors,legalese +accent,mirrors,ambiguousPunctuation +actor–observerAsymmetry,mirrors,ultimateAttributionError +adFeminam,mirrors,appealToAnger +affirmingTheConsequent,mirrors,necessarilySufficient +ageism,mirrors,racism +ageism,mirrors,sexism +akimbo,mirrors,crossedArms +alethicModalFallacy,mirrors,epistemicFallacy +alethicModalFallacy,mirrors,deonticFallacy +alethicModalFallacy,mirrors,temporalFallacy +allegedCertainty,mirrors,appealToCommonFolk +allusion,mirrors,apophasis +alphabetSoup,mirrors,proofByLatin +alphabetSoup,mirrors,corporateJargon +alphabetSoup,mirrors,academese +amatonormativity,mirrors,heteronormativity +ambiguousAssertion,mirrors,woodenLanguage +ambiguousPunctuation,mirrors,accent +ambiguousPunctuation,mirrors,solecism +anachronism,mirrors,anatopism +anatopism,mirrors,anachronism +angelDusting,mirrors,tokenism +anonymousAuthority,mirrors,ipseDixit +anthropocentrism,mirrors,logocentrism +antienvironmentalism,mirrors,redbaiting +antitheticalEquivocation,mirrors,questionsInDetouringOrder +apophasis,mirrors,aposiopesis +apophasis,mirrors,allusion +aposiopesis,mirrors,apophasis +appealToAncientWisdom,mirrors,notInventedHere +appealToAnger,mirrors,adFeminam +appealToBias,mirrors,appealToMotive +appealToCommonFolk,mirrors,allegedCertainty +appealToCommonFolk,mirrors,appealToNormality +appealToComplexity,mirrors,argumentFromIncredulity +appealToConfidence,mirrors,appealToLoyalty +appealToCustom,mirrors,appealToTradition +appealToDesire,mirrors,appealToPity +appealToDisgust,mirrors,appealToShame +appealToFiction,mirrors,counterfactualAssumption +appealToGoodwill,mirrors,appealToMoralElevation +appealToGoodwill,mirrors,appealToPride +appealToHate,mirrors,appealToIndignation +appealToIdentity,mirrors,tokenEndorsement +appealToIndignation,mirrors,appealToHate +appealToLoyalty,mirrors,appealToConfidence +appealToMalintention,mirrors,psychogeneticFallacy +appealToMockery,mirrors,appealToShame +appealToMoney,mirrors,argumentFromForm +appealToMoralElevation,mirrors,appealToGoodwill +appealToMoralElevation,mirrors,appealToPride +appealToMotive,mirrors,appealToBias +appealToMystery,mirrors,argumentFromIncredulity +appealToNormality,mirrors,appealToCommonFolk +appealToNovelty,mirrors,argumentFromForm +appealToPity,mirrors,appealToDesire +appealToPride,mirrors,appealToGoodwill +appealToPride,mirrors,appealToMoralElevation +appealToShame,mirrors,appealToMockery +appealToShame,mirrors,appealToDisgust +appealToTheStone,mirrors,proofSurrogate +appealToTradition,mirrors,appealToCustom +applause,mirrors,thumbsup +applause,mirrors,handRubbing +argumentByGibberish,mirrors,proofByLargeNumbers +argumentBySlogan,mirrors,clichéThinking +argumentFromBlindObedience,mirrors,undisputableAuthority +argumentFromForm,mirrors,appealToNovelty +argumentFromForm,mirrors,moralHighGroundFallacy +argumentFromForm,mirrors,appealToMoney +argumentFromIncredulity,mirrors,appealToMystery +argumentFromIncredulity,mirrors,appealToComplexity +argumentFromMotives,mirrors,whomDoesItProfit? +argumentFromPower,mirrors,argumentFromRespect +argumentFromRespect,mirrors,argumentFromPower +argumentumAdCellarium,mirrors,courtiersReply +argumentumAdMartyrdom,mirrors,thinkOfTheChildren +asteism,mirrors,litotes +astroturfing,mirrors,echoChamber +atAttention,mirrors,genuflection +atAttention,mirrors,bow +attackingTheQuestion,mirrors,questioningTheQuestion +attentionSeeking,mirrors,crocodileTears +availabilityHeuristic,mirrors,streetlightEffect +bandwagonFallacy,mirrors,disciplinaryBlinders +barbarism,mirrors,solecism +bathos,mirrors,burlesque +biasBlindSpot,mirrors,thirdpersonEffect +biasBlindSpot,mirrors,lakeWobegonEffect +blackPropaganda,mirrors,grayPropaganda +blasphemy,mirrors,breachOfEtiquette +bow,mirrors,handkissing +bow,mirrors,atAttention +bow,mirrors,genuflection +bow,mirrors,curtsy +bow,mirrors,kowtow +bow,mirrors,handOverHeart +brasDhonneur,mirrors,theFinger +breachOfEtiquette,mirrors,blasphemy +breadAndCircuses,mirrors,demagoguery +bribery,mirrors,reciprocation +buckPassing,mirrors,thisIsBeyondMe +budoBow,mirrors,salute +budoBow,mirrors,namaste +budoBow,mirrors,thaiGreeting +bullshit,mirrors,sellingSnakeOil +bullshit,mirrors,pathologicalLying +burlesque,mirrors,bathos +buzzword,mirrors,talkingPoints +catandmouseGame,mirrors,nagging +causalReductionism,mirrors,denyingTheCommonCause +celebration,mirrors,greeting +cheerleaderEffect,mirrors,haloEffect +choicesupportiveBias,mirrors,hindsightBias +circumstantialAdHominem,mirrors,guiltByAssociation +citogenesis,mirrors,woozleEffect +classism,mirrors,sexism +classism,mirrors,racism +cleverHansEffect,mirrors,experimenterEffect +cleverLinda,mirrors,subliminalStimuli +clichéThinking,mirrors,argumentBySlogan +clusteringIllusion,mirrors,pareidolia +commutationOfConditionals,mirrors,improperTransposition +compoundQuestion,mirrors,loadedQuestion +conclusionContradictingAPremise,mirrors,incompatiblePremises +confirmationBias,mirrors,selectiveReading +confusingGroupAndTotalAverages,mirrors,confusingIndividualAndAggregateCorrelations +confusingIndividualAndAggregateCorrelations,mirrors,simpsonsParadox +confusingIndividualAndAggregateCorrelations,mirrors,confusingGroupAndTotalAverages +confusionOfTheInverse,mirrors,prosecutorsFallacy +corporateJargon,mirrors,alphabetSoup +corporateJargon,mirrors,academese +corporateJargon,mirrors,officialese +counterfactualAssumption,mirrors,appealToFiction +courtiersReply,mirrors,argumentumAdCellarium +coveringYourAss,mirrors,movingTheGoalposts +creepypasta,mirrors,urbanLegend +critiqueOfPastInconsistency,mirrors,whataboutism +crocodileTears,mirrors,loveBombing +crocodileTears,mirrors,attentionSeeking +crossedArms,mirrors,akimbo +crossedFingers,mirrors,wink +cuckooSign,mirrors,thumbingOnesNose +cuckooSign,mirrors,donkeyEars +curseOfKnowledge,mirrors,illusionOfTransparency +curtsy,mirrors,handkissing +curtsy,mirrors,bow +curtsy,mirrors,genuflection +curtsy,mirrors,kowtow +darkPattern,mirrors,pushPoll +deadpan,mirrors,sarcasm +decliningToAnswer,mirrors,questioningTheQuestion +demagoguery,mirrors,breadAndCircuses +demagoguery,mirrors,fastfoodChristianity +demoralization,mirrors,guiltInduction +denominationEffect,mirrors,moneyIllusion +denominationalBlinders,mirrors,disciplinaryBlinders +denyingTheCommonCause,mirrors,causalReductionism +deonticFallacy,mirrors,alethicModalFallacy +dichotomousThinking,mirrors,polarizing +disciplinaryBlinders,mirrors,jonanism +disciplinaryBlinders,mirrors,bandwagonFallacy +disciplinaryBlinders,mirrors,denominationalBlinders +dissociation,mirrors,futurePacing +distancingLanguage,mirrors,questionsInDetouringOrder +distinctionWithoutADifference,mirrors,nonexclusiveClassification +donkeyEars,mirrors,thumbingOnesNose +donkeyEars,mirrors,cuckooSign +drawingFalseConclusions,mirrors,theExtension +drinkingTheKoolAid./PeerPressure,mirrors,pluralisticIgnorance +dumbInsolence,mirrors,sulking +echoChamber,mirrors,astroturfing +ecologicalFallacy,mirrors,greedyReductionism +economicalWithTheTruth,mirrors,lyingByOmission +emotionalReasoning,mirrors,mindProjectionFallacy +emotiveConjugation,mirrors,phantomDistinction +endogenousSelffulfillingProphecy,mirrors,exogenousSelfFulfillingProphecy +entitledToMyOpinion,mirrors,truthiness +epistemicFallacy,mirrors,alethicModalFallacy +erroneousCounterinduction,mirrors,gamblersFallacy +escalationOfCommitment,mirrors,inducedCommitment +eskimoKiss,mirrors,kiss +exceptionThatProvesTheRule,mirrors,inTheoryButNotPractice +exclusivePremises,mirrors,illicitAffirmative +exclusivePremises,mirrors,illicitNegative +exogenousSelfFulfillingProphecy,mirrors,endogenousSelffulfillingProphecy +experimenterEffect,mirrors,cleverHansEffect +experimenterEffect,mirrors,motivatedReasoning +extrinsicIncentivesBias,mirrors,restraintBias +fabrication,mirrors,forgery +facialExpression,mirrors,gesture +facialExpression,mirrors,posture +failingThePrincipleOfCharity,mirrors,hanlonsRazorFailure +failureToClarify,mirrors,idiosyncraticLanguage +fallaciousSimilarityArgument,mirrors,falseEquivalence +falseDilemma,mirrors,goldenMeanFallacy +falseEquivalence,mirrors,fallaciousSimilarityArgument +fastfoodChristianity,mirrors,demagoguery +fearUncertaintyAndDoubt,mirrors,moralPanic +filedrawerEffect,mirrors,whiteHatBias +fingerRaise,mirrors,threefingerSalute +firehoseOfFalsehood,mirrors,gaslighting +fistBump,mirrors,formalHug +fistBump,mirrors,shaka +fistRaise,mirrors,vSign +footInTheMouth,mirrors,touching +forgery,mirrors,fabrication +formal,mirrors,friendly +formalHug,mirrors,kiss +formalHug,mirrors,fistBump +friendly,mirrors,formal +fundamentalAttributionError,mirrors,hostileAttributionBias +futurePacing,mirrors,dissociation +gamblersFallacy,mirrors,erroneousCounterinduction +gaslighting,mirrors,firehoseOfFalsehood +gasp,mirrors,throatclear +gasp,mirrors,sighs +genuflection,mirrors,handkissing +genuflection,mirrors,atAttention +genuflection,mirrors,bow +genuflection,mirrors,kowtow +genuflection,mirrors,curtsy +gesture,mirrors,facialExpression +gesture,mirrors,posture +gishGallop,mirrors,spreading +goldenMeanFallacy,mirrors,falseDilemma +golemEffect,mirrors,noceboEffect +grayPropaganda,mirrors,blackPropaganda +greedyReductionism,mirrors,ecologicalFallacy +greeting,mirrors,celebration +guiltByAssociation,mirrors,circumstantialAdHominem +guiltInduction,mirrors,intimidation +guiltInduction,mirrors,demoralization +guiltTrip,mirrors,guiltive +guiltive,mirrors,guiltTrip +haloEffect,mirrors,cheerleaderEffect +haloEffect,mirrors,rhymeasreasonEffect +handClasping,mirrors,signOfTheCross +handClasping,mirrors,prostration +handOverHeart,mirrors,bow +handRubbing,mirrors,applause +handkissing,mirrors,genuflection +handkissing,mirrors,bow +handkissing,mirrors,curtsy +handsInDiscomfort,mirrors,thumbTwiddling +handshake,mirrors,hatTip +hanlonsRazorFailure,mirrors,failingThePrincipleOfCharity +hatTip,mirrors,handshake +hatTip,mirrors,salute +headlinese,mirrors,varietyese +heteronormativity,mirrors,amatonormativity +highFive,mirrors,thumbsup +hindsightBias,mirrors,choicesupportiveBias +historiansFallacy,mirrors,retrospectiveDeterminism +historiansFallacy,mirrors,retroactiveClairvoyance +homophobicAndTransphobicHarassment,mirrors,slutshaming +hostileAttributionBias,mirrors,fundamentalAttributionError +iKEAEffect,mirrors,processingDifficultyEffect +idiosyncraticLanguage,mirrors,failureToClarify +ifbywhiskey,mirrors,mortonsFork +ifbywhiskey,mirrors,takingAdvantageOfTheNaysayer +ifpology,mirrors,mistakesWereMade +ignoringTheQuestion,mirrors,irrelevantConclusion +illicitAffirmative,mirrors,exclusivePremises +illicitContraposition,mirrors,illicitConversion +illicitContrary,mirrors,illicitSubalternation +illicitContrary,mirrors,illicitSuperalternation +illicitConversion,mirrors,illicitContraposition +illicitMajor,mirrors,illicitMinor +illicitMinor,mirrors,illicitMajor +illicitNegative,mirrors,exclusivePremises +illicitProcess,mirrors,undistributedMiddle +illicitSubalternation,mirrors,illicitContrary +illicitSubalternation,mirrors,illicitSubcontrary +illicitSubalternation,mirrors,illicitSuperalternation +illicitSubcontrary,mirrors,illicitSubalternation +illicitSuperalternation,mirrors,illicitContrary +illicitSuperalternation,mirrors,illicitSubalternation +illusionOfControl,mirrors,restraintBias +illusionOfTransparency,mirrors,spotlightEffect +illusionOfTransparency,mirrors,curseOfKnowledge +illusions,mirrors,photoManipulation +illusoryTruthEffect,mirrors,sleeperEffect +implicitFootInTheDoor,mirrors,salamiTactic +improperTransposition,mirrors,commutationOfConditionals +inTheoryButNotPractice,mirrors,exceptionThatProvesTheRule +incompatiblePremises,mirrors,internalContradiction +incompatiblePremises,mirrors,conclusionContradictingAPremise +incompleteComparison,mirrors,inconsistentComparison +inconsistentComparison,mirrors,incompleteComparison +inconsistentTriad,mirrors,kettleLogic +inducedCommitment,mirrors,escalationOfCommitment +inducedHypocrisy,mirrors,labelling +infiniteRegress,mirrors,nirvanaFallacy +ingratiation,mirrors,superficialCharm +insult,mirrors,shoeThrow +internalContradiction,mirrors,incompatiblePremises +intimidation,mirrors,guiltInduction +inverseStoppedClock,mirrors,scienceHasBeenWrongBefore +inverseStoppedClock,mirrors,mediaHasBeenWrongBefore +invincibleIgnorance,mirrors,taboo +ipseDixit,mirrors,anonymousAuthority +irrelevantConclusion,mirrors,ignoringTheQuestion +jibe,mirrors,taunting +jonanism,mirrors,disciplinaryBlinders +kafkatrap,mirrors,sanctioningTheDevil +kettleLogic,mirrors,inconsistentTriad +kiss,mirrors,eskimoKiss +kiss,mirrors,formalHug +kowtow,mirrors,genuflection +kowtow,mirrors,bow +kowtow,mirrors,curtsy +labelling,mirrors,inducedHypocrisy +lakeWobegonEffect,mirrors,naïveCynicism +lakeWobegonEffect,mirrors,biasBlindSpot +lakeWobegonEffect,mirrors,thirdpersonEffect +legalese,mirrors,proofByLatin +legalese,mirrors,academese +legalese,mirrors,officialese +lessisbetterEffect,mirrors,subadditivityEffect +limitedDepth,mirrors,limitedScope +limitedScope,mirrors,limitedDepth +literalism,mirrors,quoteMining +litotes,mirrors,asteism +loadedQuestion,mirrors,compoundQuestion +logocentrism,mirrors,anthropocentrism +loveBombing,mirrors,crocodileTears +lyingByOmission,mirrors,economicalWithTheTruth +malinchism,mirrors,racialFetishism +matthewEffect,mirrors,pygmalionEffect +mediaHasBeenWrongBefore,mirrors,scienceHasBeenWrongBefore +mediaHasBeenWrongBefore,mirrors,inverseStoppedClock +mentalReservation,mirrors,politeLie +metaphor,mirrors,metonymy +metonymy,mirrors,metaphor +mindProjectionFallacy,mirrors,emotionalReasoning +mistakesWereMade,mirrors,ifpology +moneyIllusion,mirrors,denominationEffect +moralHighGroundFallacy,mirrors,argumentFromForm +moralPanic,mirrors,fearUncertaintyAndDoubt +mortonsFork,mirrors,ifbywhiskey +motivatedReasoning,mirrors,experimenterEffect +movingTheGoalposts,mirrors,coveringYourAss +multipleComparisonsFallacy,mirrors,texasSharpshooter +nagging,mirrors,catandmouseGame +namaste,mirrors,budoBow +namaste,mirrors,thaiGreeting +namedropping,mirrors,rodomontade +nationalism,mirrors,racism +nationalism,mirrors,religiousIntolerance +naïveCynicism,mirrors,lakeWobegonEffect +necessarilySufficient,mirrors,affirmingTheConsequent +neymansBias,mirrors,spotlightFallacy +neymansBias,mirrors,survivorshipBias +nirvanaFallacy,mirrors,infiniteRegress +nirvanaFallacy,mirrors,trivialObjections +nobleLie,mirrors,politeLie +noceboEffect,mirrors,golemEffect +nonapologyApology,mirrors,nondenialDenial +nondenialDenial,mirrors,nonapologyApology +nonexclusiveClassification,mirrors,distinctionWithoutADifference +notInventedHere,mirrors,appealToAncientWisdom +notInventedHere,mirrors,reactiveDevaluation +officialese,mirrors,corporateJargon +officialese,mirrors,academese +officialese,mirrors,legalese +pIDOOMA,mirrors,rationalization +paraphrase,mirrors,tautology +pareidolia,mirrors,clusteringIllusion +partsetCuingEffect,mirrors,retrievalInducedForgetting +pathologicalLying,mirrors,bullshit +persuasiveDefinition,mirrors,prejudicialLanguage +phantomDistinction,mirrors,emotiveConjugation +photoManipulation,mirrors,illusions +pinkbaiting,mirrors,redbaiting +pinkbaiting,mirrors,terrorismbaiting +placeboEffect,mirrors,pygmalionEffect +pluralisticIgnorance,mirrors,drinkingTheKoolAid./PeerPressure +polarizing,mirrors,dichotomousThinking +politeLie,mirrors,mentalReservation +politeLie,mirrors,nobleLie +possibilitytreeTrap,mirrors,warmReading +posture,mirrors,facialExpression +posture,mirrors,gesture +prejudicialLanguage,mirrors,persuasiveDefinition +processingDifficultyEffect,mirrors,iKEAEffect +proofByLargeNumbers,mirrors,argumentByGibberish +proofByLatin,mirrors,alphabetSoup +proofByLatin,mirrors,legalese +proofByPrestigiousJargon,mirrors,verbosity +proofSurrogate,mirrors,appealToTheStone +prosecutorsFallacy,mirrors,confusionOfTheInverse +prostration,mirrors,signOfTheCross +prostration,mirrors,handClasping +pseudophilosophy,mirrors,pseudorationalism +pseudorationalism,mirrors,pseudophilosophy +pseudorationalism,mirrors,pseudoscience +pseudoscience,mirrors,pseudorationalism +psychogeneticFallacy,mirrors,appealToMalintention +pushPoll,mirrors,darkPattern +pygmalionEffect,mirrors,placeboEffect +pygmalionEffect,mirrors,matthewEffect +quantifierShift,mirrors,wrongQuantifier +quantitativeFallacy,mirrors,streetlightEffect +questioningTheQuestion,mirrors,attackingTheQuestion +questioningTheQuestion,mirrors,decliningToAnswer +questionsInDetouringOrder,mirrors,antitheticalEquivocation +questionsInDetouringOrder,mirrors,distancingLanguage +quoteMining,mirrors,literalism +racialFetishism,mirrors,malinchism +racism,mirrors,sexism +racism,mirrors,nationalism +racism,mirrors,religiousIntolerance +racism,mirrors,classism +racism,mirrors,ageism +rainbowRuse,mirrors,shotgunning +raisedFist,mirrors,threefingerSalute +rationalization,mirrors,pIDOOMA +reactiveDevaluation,mirrors,notInventedHere +reciprocation,mirrors,bribery +redbaiting,mirrors,reductioAdHitlerum +redbaiting,mirrors,terrorismbaiting +redbaiting,mirrors,pinkbaiting +redbaiting,mirrors,antienvironmentalism +reductioAdHitlerum,mirrors,redbaiting +reductioAdHitlerum,mirrors,terrorismbaiting +religiousIntolerance,mirrors,racism +religiousIntolerance,mirrors,nationalism +requestingClarification,mirrors,turningTheQuestionBackOnTheInterlocutor +restraintBias,mirrors,illusionOfControl +restraintBias,mirrors,extrinsicIncentivesBias +retrievalInducedForgetting,mirrors,partsetCuingEffect +retroactiveClairvoyance,mirrors,retrospectiveDeterminism +retroactiveClairvoyance,mirrors,historiansFallacy +retrospectiveDeterminism,mirrors,historiansFallacy +retrospectiveDeterminism,mirrors,retroactiveClairvoyance +rhymeasreasonEffect,mirrors,haloEffect +rodomontade,mirrors,namedropping +salamiTactic,mirrors,implicitFootInTheDoor +salute,mirrors,hatTip +salute,mirrors,scoutSalute +salute,mirrors,budoBow +sanctioningTheDevil,mirrors,kafkatrap +sarcasm,mirrors,deadpan +scienceHasBeenWrongBefore,mirrors,mediaHasBeenWrongBefore +scienceHasBeenWrongBefore,mirrors,inverseStoppedClock +scoutSalute,mirrors,salute +scoutSalute,mirrors,vulcanSalute +selectiveReading,mirrors,confirmationBias +selfblame,mirrors,victimBlaming +selfsealingArgument,mirrors,untestability +sellingSnakeOil,mirrors,bullshit +sexism,mirrors,racism +sexism,mirrors,classism +sexism,mirrors,ageism +shaka,mirrors,fistBump +shoeThrow,mirrors,insult +shoehorning,mirrors,texasSharpshooter +shotgunning,mirrors,rainbowRuse +sighs,mirrors,throatclear +sighs,mirrors,gasp +signOfTheCross,mirrors,prostration +signOfTheCross,mirrors,handClasping +signOfTheHorns,mirrors,theFinger +simpsonsParadox,mirrors,confusingIndividualAndAggregateCorrelations +sleeperEffect,mirrors,illusoryTruthEffect +slutshaming,mirrors,homophobicAndTransphobicHarassment +socialComparisonBias,mirrors,socialdesirabilityBias +socialdesirabilityBias,mirrors,socialComparisonBias +solecism,mirrors,ambiguousPunctuation +solecism,mirrors,barbarism +spotlightEffect,mirrors,illusionOfTransparency +spotlightFallacy,mirrors,neymansBias +spreading,mirrors,gishGallop +streetlightEffect,mirrors,quantitativeFallacy +streetlightEffect,mirrors,availabilityHeuristic +subadditivityEffect,mirrors,lessisbetterEffect +subliminalStimuli,mirrors,cleverLinda +sulking,mirrors,dumbInsolence +superficialCharm,mirrors,ingratiation +survivorshipBias,mirrors,neymansBias +taboo,mirrors,invincibleIgnorance +takingAdvantageOfTheNaysayer,mirrors,ifbywhiskey +talkingPoints,mirrors,buzzword +taunting,mirrors,jibe +tautology,mirrors,paraphrase +temporalFallacy,mirrors,alethicModalFallacy +terrorismbaiting,mirrors,redbaiting +terrorismbaiting,mirrors,pinkbaiting +terrorismbaiting,mirrors,reductioAdHitlerum +texasSharpshooter,mirrors,multipleComparisonsFallacy +texasSharpshooter,mirrors,shoehorning +thaiGreeting,mirrors,budoBow +thaiGreeting,mirrors,namaste +theBrokenClock,mirrors,theSqueakyWheel +theExtension,mirrors,drawingFalseConclusions +theFinger,mirrors,brasDhonneur +theFinger,mirrors,thumbingOnesNose +theFinger,mirrors,signOfTheHorns +theSqueakyWheel,mirrors,theBrokenClock +thinkOfTheChildren,mirrors,argumentumAdMartyrdom +thirdpersonEffect,mirrors,biasBlindSpot +thirdpersonEffect,mirrors,lakeWobegonEffect +thisIsBeyondMe,mirrors,buckPassing +threefingerSalute,mirrors,raisedFist +threefingerSalute,mirrors,fingerRaise +throatclear,mirrors,sighs +throatclear,mirrors,gasp +thumbTwiddling,mirrors,handsInDiscomfort +thumbingOnesNose,mirrors,theFinger +thumbingOnesNose,mirrors,cuckooSign +thumbingOnesNose,mirrors,donkeyEars +thumbsup,mirrors,applause +thumbsup,mirrors,highFive +thumbsup,mirrors,vSign +timesavingBias,mirrors,wellTravelledRoadEffect +tokenEndorsement,mirrors,appealToIdentity +tokenism,mirrors,angelDusting +touching,mirrors,footInTheMouth +trickQuestion,mirrors,unfoundedSupport +trivialObjections,mirrors,nirvanaFallacy +truthiness,mirrors,entitledToMyOpinion +turningTheQuestionBackOnTheInterlocutor,mirrors,requestingClarification +ultimateAttributionError,mirrors,actor–observerAsymmetry +undisputableAuthority,mirrors,argumentFromBlindObedience +undistributedMiddle,mirrors,illicitProcess +unfoundedSupport,mirrors,trickQuestion +untestability,mirrors,selfsealingArgument +urbanLegend,mirrors,creepypasta +vSign,mirrors,thumbsup +vSign,mirrors,fistRaise +varietyese,mirrors,headlinese +verbosity,mirrors,proofByPrestigiousJargon +victimBlaming,mirrors,selfblame +vulcanSalute,mirrors,scoutSalute +warmReading,mirrors,possibilitytreeTrap +wellTravelledRoadEffect,mirrors,timesavingBias +whataboutism,mirrors,critiqueOfPastInconsistency +whiteHatBias,mirrors,filedrawerEffect +whomDoesItProfit?,mirrors,argumentFromMotives +wink,mirrors,crossedFingers +woodenLanguage,mirrors,ambiguousAssertion +woozleEffect,mirrors,citogenesis +wrongQuantifier,mirrors,quantifierShift +absentmindedness,opposes,testingEffect +appealToClosure,opposes,impossibleExpectations +autosuggestion,opposes,failureNeurosis +autosuggestion,opposes,fearOfFailure +badInfiniteRegressArgument,opposes,viciousInfiniteRegress +darkPattern,opposes,nudge +dispositionalAttribution,opposes,illusionOfExternalAgency +ellipsis,opposes,syllepsis +failureNeurosis,opposes,autosuggestion +fearOfFailure,opposes,autosuggestion +friendly,opposes,hostile +gamblersFallacy,opposes,hotHandFallacy +golemEffect,opposes,matthewEffect +hostile,opposes,friendly +hotHandFallacy,opposes,gamblersFallacy +illicitContrary,opposes,illicitSubcontrary +illicitSubcontrary,opposes,illicitContrary +illicitSubcontrary,opposes,unwarrantedContrast +illusionOfExternalAgency,opposes,dispositionalAttribution +impossibleExpectations,opposes,appealToClosure +influence,opposes,objectivism +inverseStoppedClock,opposes,theBrokenClock +materialism,opposes,vitalism +materialism,opposes,subjectiveIdealism +matthewEffect,opposes,golemEffect +naziSalute,opposes,threefingerSalute +naziSalute,opposes,raisedFist +nudge,opposes,darkPattern +objectivism,opposes,influence +raisedFist,opposes,naziSalute +subjectiveIdealism,opposes,materialism +syllepsis,opposes,ellipsis +testingEffect,opposes,absentmindedness +theBrokenClock,opposes,inverseStoppedClock +threefingerSalute,opposes,naziSalute +unwarrantedContrast,opposes,illicitSubcontrary +viciousInfiniteRegress,opposes,badInfiniteRegressArgument +vitalism,opposes,materialism +anchoring,predatesOn,anchoringEffect +appealToSubjectiveValidation,predatesOn,subjectiveValidation +appealToWilledIgnorance,predatesOn,willedIgnorance +applause,predatesOn,standingOvation +bait,predatesOn,decoyEffect +bandwagonFallacy,predatesOn,bandwagonEffect +contrastEffect,predatesOn,contrastEffect +dogmatism,predatesOn,fundamentalism +enumeratio,predatesOn,conglobatio +framing,predatesOn,framingEffect +leveragingNegativityBias,predatesOn,negativityBias +sunkCostFallacy,predatesOn,sunkCostBias +urbanLegend,predatesOn,creepypasta diff --git a/docs/ontology/aif-export/taxonomy-tree-edges.csv b/docs/ontology/aif-export/taxonomy-tree-edges.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..545c0f72 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/ontology/aif-export/taxonomy-tree-edges.csv @@ -0,0 +1,1409 @@ +parent_path,child_path,child_pk,depth,family,subfamily,subsubfamily +,0,0,1,Argument fallacieux,, +,1,1,1,Insuffisance,, +1,"1,1",2,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé, +1,"1,11",3,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Argument vide +1,"1,111",4,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Argument vide +1,"1,1111",5,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Argument vide +1,"1,11111",6,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Argument vide +1,"1,11112",7,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Argument vide +1,"1,11113",8,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Argument vide +1,"1,1112",9,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Argument vide +1,"1,11121",10,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Argument vide +1,"1,1113",11,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Argument vide +1,"1,11131",12,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Argument vide +1,"1,11132",13,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Argument vide +1,"1,1114",14,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Argument vide +1,"1,1115",15,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Argument vide +1,"1,1116",16,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Argument vide +1,"1,11161",17,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Argument vide +1,"1,11162",18,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Argument vide +1,"1,11163",19,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Argument vide +1,"1,112",20,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Argument vide +1,"1,1121",21,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Argument vide +1,"1,113",22,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Argument vide +1,"1,1131",23,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Argument vide +1,"1,1132",24,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Argument vide +1,"1,1133",25,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Argument vide +1,"1,114",26,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Argument vide +1,"1,1141",27,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Argument vide +1,"1,1142",28,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Argument vide +1,"1,1143",29,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Argument vide +1,"1,1144",30,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Argument vide +1,"1,1145",31,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Argument vide +1,"1,1146",32,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Argument vide +1,"1,12",33,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Justification triviale +1,"1,121",34,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Justification triviale +1,"1,1211",35,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Justification triviale +1,"1,1212",36,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Justification triviale +1,"1,1213",37,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Justification triviale +1,"1,12131",38,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Justification triviale +1,"1,12132",39,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Justification triviale +1,"1,1214",40,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Justification triviale +1,"1,1215",41,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Justification triviale +1,"1,1216",42,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Justification triviale +1,"1,122",43,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Justification triviale +1,"1,1221",44,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Justification triviale +1,"1,12211",45,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Justification triviale +1,"1,1222",46,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Justification triviale +1,"1,1223",47,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Justification triviale +1,"1,1224",48,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Justification triviale +1,"1,12241",49,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Justification triviale +1,"1,1225",50,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Justification triviale +1,"1,123",51,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Justification triviale +1,"1,1231",52,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Justification triviale +1,"1,1232",53,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Justification triviale +1,"1,12321",54,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Justification triviale +1,"1,13",55,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Sauvetage ad hoc +1,"1,131",56,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Sauvetage ad hoc +1,"1,1311",57,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Sauvetage ad hoc +1,"1,1312",58,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Sauvetage ad hoc +1,"1,13121",59,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Sauvetage ad hoc +1,"1,131211",60,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Sauvetage ad hoc +1,"1,132",61,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Sauvetage ad hoc +1,"1,133",62,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Sauvetage ad hoc +1,"1,1331",63,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Sauvetage ad hoc +1,"1,13311",64,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Sauvetage ad hoc +1,"1,1332",65,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Sauvetage ad hoc +1,"1,134",66,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Sauvetage ad hoc +1,"1,1341",67,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Sauvetage ad hoc +1,"1,135",68,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Sauvetage ad hoc +1,"1,1351",69,2,Insuffisance,Argument bâclé,Sauvetage ad hoc +1,"1,2",70,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé, +1,"1,21",71,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Argument d'autorité +1,"1,211",72,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Argument d'autorité +1,"1,2111",73,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Argument d'autorité +1,"1,21111",74,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Argument d'autorité +1,"1,2112",75,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Argument d'autorité +1,"1,2113",76,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Argument d'autorité +1,"1,2114",77,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Argument d'autorité +1,"1,212",78,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Argument d'autorité +1,"1,2121",79,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Argument d'autorité +1,"1,21211",80,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Argument d'autorité +1,"1,21212",81,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Argument d'autorité +1,"1,21213",82,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Argument d'autorité +1,"1,2122",83,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Argument d'autorité +1,"1,213",84,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Argument d'autorité +1,"1,2131",85,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Argument d'autorité +1,"1,21311",86,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Argument d'autorité +1,"1,21312",87,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Argument d'autorité +1,"1,213121",88,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Argument d'autorité +1,"1,213122",89,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Argument d'autorité +1,"1,213123",90,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Argument d'autorité +1,"1,2132",91,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Argument d'autorité +1,"1,21321",92,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Argument d'autorité +1,"1,2133",93,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Argument d'autorité +1,"1,21331",94,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Argument d'autorité +1,"1,213311",95,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Argument d'autorité +1,"1,22",96,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Sophisme naturaliste +1,"1,221",97,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Sophisme naturaliste +1,"1,222",98,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Sophisme naturaliste +1,"1,2221",99,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Sophisme naturaliste +1,"1,2222",100,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Sophisme naturaliste +1,"1,2223",101,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Sophisme naturaliste +1,"1,2224",102,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Sophisme naturaliste +1,"1,2225",103,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Sophisme naturaliste +1,"1,223",104,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Sophisme naturaliste +1,"1,2231",105,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Sophisme naturaliste +1,"1,2232",106,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Sophisme naturaliste +1,"1,2233",107,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Sophisme naturaliste +1,"1,224",108,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Sophisme naturaliste +1,"1,2241",109,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Sophisme naturaliste +1,"1,2242",110,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Sophisme naturaliste +1,"1,2243",111,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Sophisme naturaliste +1,"1,23",112,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Sophisme moraliste +1,"1,231",113,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Sophisme moraliste +1,"1,2311",114,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Sophisme moraliste +1,"1,232",115,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Sophisme moraliste +1,"1,2321",116,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Sophisme moraliste +1,"1,233",117,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Sophisme moraliste +1,"1,2331",118,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Sophisme moraliste +1,"1,23311",119,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Sophisme moraliste +1,"1,23312",120,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Sophisme moraliste +1,"1,2332",121,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Sophisme moraliste +1,"1,23321",122,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Sophisme moraliste +1,"1,23322",123,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Sophisme moraliste +1,"1,234",124,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Sophisme moraliste +1,"1,2341",125,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Sophisme moraliste +1,"1,23411",126,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Sophisme moraliste +1,"1,235",127,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Sophisme moraliste +1,"1,2351",128,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Sophisme moraliste +1,"1,2352",129,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Sophisme moraliste +1,"1,236",130,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Sophisme moraliste +1,"1,2361",131,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Sophisme moraliste +1,"1,237",132,2,Insuffisance,Préjugé,Sophisme moraliste +1,"1,3",133,2,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation, +1,"1,31",134,2,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,Sophisme ludique +1,"1,311",135,2,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,Sophisme ludique +1,"1,3111",136,2,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,Sophisme ludique +1,"1,3112",137,2,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,Sophisme ludique +1,"1,3113",138,2,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,Sophisme ludique +1,"1,3114",139,2,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,Sophisme ludique +1,"1,3115",140,2,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,Sophisme ludique +1,"1,312",141,2,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,Sophisme ludique +1,"1,3121",142,2,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,Sophisme ludique +1,"1,3122",143,2,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,Sophisme ludique +1,"1,3123",144,2,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,Sophisme ludique +1,"1,313",145,2,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,Sophisme ludique +1,"1,3131",146,2,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,Sophisme ludique +1,"1,31311",147,2,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,Sophisme ludique +1,"1,313111",148,2,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,Sophisme ludique +1,"1,3132",149,2,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,Sophisme ludique +1,"1,3133",150,2,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,Sophisme ludique +1,"1,31331",151,2,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,Sophisme ludique +1,"1,314",152,2,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,Sophisme ludique +1,"1,32",153,2,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,Argument des mauvaises raisons +1,"1,321",154,2,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,Argument des mauvaises raisons +1,"1,3211",155,2,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,Argument des mauvaises raisons +1,"1,322",156,2,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,Argument des mauvaises raisons +1,"1,3221",157,2,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,Argument des mauvaises raisons +1,"1,323",158,2,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,Argument des mauvaises raisons +1,"1,3231",159,2,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,Argument des mauvaises raisons +1,"1,3232",160,2,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,Argument des mauvaises raisons +1,"1,32321",161,2,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,Argument des mauvaises raisons +1,"1,3233",162,2,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,Argument des mauvaises raisons +1,"1,32331",163,2,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,Argument des mauvaises raisons +1,"1,32332",164,2,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,Argument des mauvaises raisons +1,"1,33",165,2,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,Manque de parcimonie +1,"1,331",166,2,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,Manque de parcimonie +1,"1,332",167,2,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,Manque de parcimonie +1,"1,3321",168,2,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,Manque de parcimonie +1,"1,333",169,2,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,Manque de parcimonie +1,"1,3331",170,2,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,Manque de parcimonie +1,"1,33311",171,2,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,Manque de parcimonie +1,"1,334",172,2,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,Manque de parcimonie +1,"1,3341",173,2,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,Manque de parcimonie +1,"1,3342",174,2,Insuffisance,Surinterprétation,Manque de parcimonie +,2,175,1,Influence,, +2,"2,1",176,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique, +2,"2,11",177,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Langage persuasif +2,"2,111",178,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Langage persuasif +2,"2,1111",179,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Langage persuasif +2,"2,11111",180,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Langage persuasif +2,"2,1112",181,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Langage persuasif +2,"2,1113",182,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Langage persuasif +2,"2,112",183,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Langage persuasif +2,"2,113",184,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Langage persuasif +2,"2,114",185,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Langage persuasif +2,"2,1141",186,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Langage persuasif +2,"2,1142",187,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Langage persuasif +2,"2,1143",188,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Langage persuasif +2,"2,1144",189,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Langage persuasif +2,"2,115",190,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Langage persuasif +2,"2,1151",191,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Langage persuasif +2,"2,11511",192,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Langage persuasif +2,"2,11512",193,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Langage persuasif +2,"2,115121",194,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Langage persuasif +2,"2,115122",195,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Langage persuasif +2,"2,115123",196,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Langage persuasif +2,"2,115124",197,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Langage persuasif +2,"2,1151241",198,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Langage persuasif +2,"2,115125",199,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Langage persuasif +2,"2,1151251",200,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Langage persuasif +2,"2,115126",201,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Langage persuasif +2,"2,11513",202,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Langage persuasif +2,"2,1152",203,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Langage persuasif +2,"2,11521",204,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Langage persuasif +2,"2,11522",205,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Langage persuasif +2,"2,11523",206,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Langage persuasif +2,"2,11524",207,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Langage persuasif +2,"2,115241",208,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Langage persuasif +2,"2,115242",209,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Langage persuasif +2,"2,1152421",210,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Langage persuasif +2,"2,1156",211,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Langage persuasif +2,"2,116",212,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Langage persuasif +2,"2,1161",213,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Langage persuasif +2,"2,11611",214,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Langage persuasif +2,"2,1162",215,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Langage persuasif +2,"2,11621",216,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Langage persuasif +2,"2,1163",217,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Langage persuasif +2,"2,1164",218,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Langage persuasif +2,"2,12",219,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Humour +2,"2,121",220,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Humour +2,"2,1211",221,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Humour +2,"2,1212",222,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Humour +2,"2,12121",223,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Humour +2,"2,12122",224,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Humour +2,"2,12123",225,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Humour +2,"2,12124",226,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Humour +2,"2,1213",227,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Humour +2,"2,12131",228,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Humour +2,"2,12132",229,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Humour +2,"2,121321",230,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Humour +2,"2,122",231,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Humour +2,"2,1221",232,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Humour +2,"2,1222",233,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Humour +2,"2,12221",234,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Humour +2,"2,12222",235,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Humour +2,"2,122221",236,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Humour +2,"2,122222",237,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Humour +2,"2,1223",238,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Humour +2,"2,12231",239,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Humour +2,"2,12232",240,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Humour +2,"2,122321",241,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Humour +2,"2,122322",242,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Humour +2,"2,122323",243,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Humour +2,"2,123",244,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Humour +2,"2,1231",245,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Humour +2,"2,1232",246,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Humour +2,"2,13",247,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,131",248,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,1311",249,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,1312",250,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,1313",251,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,1314",252,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,1315",253,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,13151",254,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,132",255,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,1321",256,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,13211",257,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,13212",258,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,1322",259,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,13221",260,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,13222",261,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,1323",262,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,13231",263,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,1324",264,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,13241",265,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,13242",266,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,1325",267,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,133",268,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,1331",269,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,1332",270,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,1333",271,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,1334",272,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,134",273,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,1341",274,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,1342",275,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,1343",276,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,1344",277,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,1345",278,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,1346",279,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,1347",280,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,1348",281,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,135",282,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,1351",283,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,1352",284,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,1353",285,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,1354",286,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,1355",287,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,1356",288,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,13561",289,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,136",290,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,1361",291,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,1362",292,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,1363",293,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,1364",294,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,1365",295,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,13651",296,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,1367",297,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,13671",298,2,Influence,Procédé rhétorique,Poésie +2,"2,2",299,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion, +2,"2,21",300,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Connivence +2,"2,211",301,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Connivence +2,"2,2111",302,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Connivence +2,"2,212",303,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Connivence +2,"2,2121",304,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Connivence +2,"2,2122",305,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Connivence +2,"2,21221",306,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Connivence +2,"2,21222",307,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Connivence +2,"2,2123",308,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Connivence +2,"2,21231",309,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Connivence +2,"2,21232",310,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Connivence +2,"2,21233",311,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Connivence +2,"2,2124",312,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Connivence +2,"2,213",313,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Connivence +2,"2,2131",314,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Connivence +2,"2,2132",315,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Connivence +2,"2,21321",316,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Connivence +2,"2,213211",317,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Connivence +2,"2,2133",318,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Connivence +2,"2,214",319,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Connivence +2,"2,2141",320,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Connivence +2,"2,2142",321,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Connivence +2,"2,22",322,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Repoussoir +2,"2,221",323,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Repoussoir +2,"2,2211",324,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Repoussoir +2,"2,22111",325,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Repoussoir +2,"2,2212",326,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Repoussoir +2,"2,2213",327,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Repoussoir +2,"2,22131",328,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Repoussoir +2,"2,222",329,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Repoussoir +2,"2,2221",330,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Repoussoir +2,"2,2222",331,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Repoussoir +2,"2,223",332,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Repoussoir +2,"2,2231",333,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Repoussoir +2,"2,2232",334,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Repoussoir +2,"2,2233",335,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Repoussoir +2,"2,2234",336,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Repoussoir +2,"2,224",337,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Repoussoir +2,"2,2241",338,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Repoussoir +2,"2,2242",339,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Repoussoir +2,"2,23",340,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Appel aux conséquences +2,"2,231",341,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Appel aux conséquences +2,"2,2311",342,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Appel aux conséquences +2,"2,2312",343,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Appel aux conséquences +2,"2,2313",344,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Appel aux conséquences +2,"2,2314",345,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Appel aux conséquences +2,"2,2315",346,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Appel aux conséquences +2,"2,232",347,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Appel aux conséquences +2,"2,2321",348,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Appel aux conséquences +2,"2,23211",349,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Appel aux conséquences +2,"2,23212",350,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Appel aux conséquences +2,"2,233",351,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Appel aux conséquences +2,"2,2331",352,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Appel aux conséquences +2,"2,2332",353,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Appel aux conséquences +2,"2,2333",354,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Appel aux conséquences +2,"2,234",355,2,Influence,Appel à l'émotion,Appel aux conséquences +2,"2,3",356,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale, +2,"2,31",357,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,311",358,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,3111",359,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,31111",360,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,31112",361,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,311121",362,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,31113",363,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,31114",364,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,31115",365,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,31116",366,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,31117",367,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,31118",368,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,3112",369,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,31121",370,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,311211",371,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,311212",372,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,31122",373,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,311221",374,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,311222",375,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,3114",376,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,31141",377,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,31142",378,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,31143",379,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,31144",380,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,31145",381,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,31146",382,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,3115",383,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,312",384,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,3121",385,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,31211",386,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,3122",387,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,31221",388,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,3123",389,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,31231",390,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,3124",391,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,313",392,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,3131",393,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,31311",394,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,31312",395,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,31313",396,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,31314",397,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,3132",398,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,31321",399,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,31322",400,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,31323",401,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,31324",402,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,31325",403,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,314",404,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,3141",405,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,3143",406,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,315",407,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,3151",408,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,31511",409,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,3152",410,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,3153",411,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,3154",412,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,3155",413,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,316",414,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,3161",415,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,3162",416,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,31621",417,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,3163",418,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,3164",419,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Conditionnement +2,"2,32",420,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,321",421,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,3211",422,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,32111",423,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,321111",424,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,321112",425,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,32112",426,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,32113",427,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,32114",428,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,3212",429,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,3213",430,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,322",431,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,3221",432,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,32211",433,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,322111",434,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,3221111",435,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,3221113",436,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,322112",437,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,322113",438,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,322114",439,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,3221141",440,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,32212",441,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,322121",442,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,3221211",443,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,322122",444,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,322123",445,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,3221231",446,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,322124",447,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,322125",448,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,3221251",449,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,322126",450,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,322127",451,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,3222",452,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,3223",453,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,3224",454,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,3225",455,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,323",456,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,3231",457,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,32311",458,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,323111",459,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,323112",460,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,32312",461,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,323121",462,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,323122",463,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,323123",464,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,32313",465,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,32314",466,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,323141",467,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,3231411",468,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,323142",469,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,323143",470,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,32315",471,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,3232",472,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,32321",473,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,32322",474,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,323221",475,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,323222",476,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,323223",477,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,323224",478,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,32323",479,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,323231",480,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,323232",481,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,3232321",482,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,3232322",483,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,323233",484,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,3233",485,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,32331",486,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,323311",487,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,323312",488,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,32332",489,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,32333",490,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,32334",491,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,3234",492,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,32341",493,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,32342",494,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,3235",495,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,3236",496,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,324",497,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,3241",498,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,32411",499,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,324111",500,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,32412",501,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,32413",502,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,32414",503,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,32415",504,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,3242",505,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,32421",506,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,324211",507,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,32422",508,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,32423",509,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,32424",510,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Jeu de pouvoir +2,"2,33",511,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,331",512,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,3311",513,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,3312",514,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,33121",515,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,33122",516,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,33123",517,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,332",518,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,333",519,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,3331",520,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334",1406,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,3341",521,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,33411",522,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,3342",523,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,33421",524,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334211",525,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,3342111",526,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,3342112",527,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,3342113",528,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334212",529,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334213",530,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334214",531,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334215",532,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334216",533,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334217",534,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,33422",535,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334221",536,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334222",537,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334223",538,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334224",539,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334225",540,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334226",541,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334227",542,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,33423",543,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334231",544,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334232",545,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334233",546,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334234",547,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334235",548,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334236",549,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334237",550,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334238",551,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334239",552,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,33424",553,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334241",554,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334242",555,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334243",556,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334244",557,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334245",558,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334246",559,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334247",560,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334248",561,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,33425",562,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334251",563,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,3342511",564,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334252",565,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334253",566,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334254",567,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334255",568,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334256",569,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334257",570,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,33426",571,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334261",572,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334262",573,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334263",574,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334264",575,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334265",576,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334266",577,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334267",578,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334268",579,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,33427",580,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334271",581,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334272",582,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334273",583,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334274",584,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,334275",585,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,3343",586,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,3344",587,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,33441",588,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,33442",589,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,335",590,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,3351",591,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,3352",592,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +2,"2,336",593,2,Influence,Manipulation mentale,Influence non verbale +,3,594,1,Erreur mathématique,, +3,"3,1",595,2,Erreur mathématique,Généralisation abusive, +3,"3,11",596,2,Erreur mathématique,Généralisation abusive,Échantillon biaisé +3,"3,111",597,2,Erreur mathématique,Généralisation abusive,Échantillon biaisé +3,"3,1111",598,2,Erreur mathématique,Généralisation abusive,Échantillon biaisé +3,"3,11111",599,2,Erreur mathématique,Généralisation abusive,Échantillon biaisé +3,"3,11112",600,2,Erreur mathématique,Généralisation abusive,Échantillon biaisé +3,"3,1112",601,2,Erreur mathématique,Généralisation abusive,Échantillon biaisé +3,"3,112",602,2,Erreur mathématique,Généralisation abusive,Échantillon biaisé +3,"3,1121",603,2,Erreur mathématique,Généralisation abusive,Échantillon biaisé +3,"3,1122",604,2,Erreur mathématique,Généralisation abusive,Échantillon biaisé +3,"3,11221",605,2,Erreur mathématique,Généralisation abusive,Échantillon biaisé +3,"3,1123",606,2,Erreur mathématique,Généralisation abusive,Échantillon biaisé +3,"3,11231",607,2,Erreur mathématique,Généralisation abusive,Échantillon biaisé +3,"3,113",608,2,Erreur mathématique,Généralisation abusive,Échantillon biaisé +3,"3,1131",609,2,Erreur mathématique,Généralisation abusive,Échantillon biaisé +3,"3,11311",610,2,Erreur mathématique,Généralisation abusive,Échantillon biaisé +3,"3,1132",611,2,Erreur mathématique,Généralisation abusive,Échantillon biaisé +3,"3,1133",612,2,Erreur mathématique,Généralisation abusive,Échantillon biaisé +3,"3,1134",613,2,Erreur mathématique,Généralisation abusive,Échantillon biaisé +3,"3,12",614,2,Erreur mathématique,Généralisation abusive,Sophisme de l'accident +3,"3,121",615,2,Erreur mathématique,Généralisation abusive,Sophisme de l'accident +3,"3,1211",616,2,Erreur mathématique,Généralisation abusive,Sophisme de l'accident +3,"3,122",617,2,Erreur mathématique,Généralisation abusive,Sophisme de l'accident +3,"3,123",618,2,Erreur mathématique,Généralisation abusive,Sophisme de l'accident +3,"3,1231",619,2,Erreur mathématique,Généralisation abusive,Sophisme de l'accident +3,"3,124",620,2,Erreur mathématique,Généralisation abusive,Sophisme de l'accident +3,"3,13",621,2,Erreur mathématique,Généralisation abusive,Transfert illicite +3,"3,131",622,2,Erreur mathématique,Généralisation abusive,Transfert illicite +3,"3,1311",623,2,Erreur mathématique,Généralisation abusive,Transfert illicite +3,"3,1312",624,2,Erreur mathématique,Généralisation abusive,Transfert illicite +3,"3,132",625,2,Erreur mathématique,Généralisation abusive,Transfert illicite +3,"3,1321",626,2,Erreur mathématique,Généralisation abusive,Transfert illicite +3,"3,13211",627,2,Erreur mathématique,Généralisation abusive,Transfert illicite +3,"3,13212",628,2,Erreur mathématique,Généralisation abusive,Transfert illicite +3,"3,13213",629,2,Erreur mathématique,Généralisation abusive,Transfert illicite +3,"3,13214",630,2,Erreur mathématique,Généralisation abusive,Transfert illicite +3,"3,1322",631,2,Erreur mathématique,Généralisation abusive,Transfert illicite +3,"3,2",632,2,Erreur mathématique,Mauvaise interprétation, +3,"3,21",633,2,Erreur mathématique,Mauvaise interprétation,Relation infondée +3,"3,211",634,2,Erreur mathématique,Mauvaise interprétation,Relation infondée +3,"3,212",635,2,Erreur mathématique,Mauvaise interprétation,Relation infondée +3,"3,213",636,2,Erreur mathématique,Mauvaise interprétation,Relation infondée +3,"3,214",637,2,Erreur mathématique,Mauvaise interprétation,Relation infondée +3,"3,2141",638,2,Erreur mathématique,Mauvaise interprétation,Relation infondée +3,"3,2142",639,2,Erreur mathématique,Mauvaise interprétation,Relation infondée +3,"3,2143",640,2,Erreur mathématique,Mauvaise interprétation,Relation infondée +3,"3,2144",641,2,Erreur mathématique,Mauvaise interprétation,Relation infondée +3,"3,215",642,2,Erreur mathématique,Mauvaise interprétation,Relation infondée +3,"3,2151",643,2,Erreur mathématique,Mauvaise interprétation,Relation infondée +3,"3,22",644,2,Erreur mathématique,Mauvaise interprétation,Probabilités faussées +3,"3,221",645,2,Erreur mathématique,Mauvaise interprétation,Probabilités faussées +3,"3,2211",646,2,Erreur mathématique,Mauvaise interprétation,Probabilités faussées +3,"3,222",647,2,Erreur mathématique,Mauvaise interprétation,Probabilités faussées +3,"3,2221",648,2,Erreur mathématique,Mauvaise interprétation,Probabilités faussées +3,"3,2222",649,2,Erreur mathématique,Mauvaise interprétation,Probabilités faussées +3,"3,2223",650,2,Erreur mathématique,Mauvaise interprétation,Probabilités faussées +3,"3,2224",651,2,Erreur mathématique,Mauvaise interprétation,Probabilités faussées +3,"3,223",652,2,Erreur mathématique,Mauvaise interprétation,Probabilités faussées +3,"3,2231",653,2,Erreur mathématique,Mauvaise interprétation,Probabilités faussées +3,"3,2232",654,2,Erreur mathématique,Mauvaise interprétation,Probabilités faussées +3,"3,2233",655,2,Erreur mathématique,Mauvaise interprétation,Probabilités faussées +3,"3,2234",656,2,Erreur mathématique,Mauvaise interprétation,Probabilités faussées +3,"3,224",657,2,Erreur mathématique,Mauvaise interprétation,Probabilités faussées +3,"3,23",658,2,Erreur mathématique,Mauvaise interprétation,Infini trompeur +3,"3,231",659,2,Erreur mathématique,Mauvaise interprétation,Infini trompeur +3,"3,2311",660,2,Erreur mathématique,Mauvaise interprétation,Infini trompeur +3,"3,232",661,2,Erreur mathématique,Mauvaise interprétation,Infini trompeur +3,"3,2321",662,2,Erreur mathématique,Mauvaise interprétation,Infini trompeur +3,"3,23211",663,2,Erreur mathématique,Mauvaise interprétation,Infini trompeur +3,"3,2322",664,2,Erreur mathématique,Mauvaise interprétation,Infini trompeur +3,"3,23221",665,2,Erreur mathématique,Mauvaise interprétation,Infini trompeur +3,"3,3",666,2,Erreur mathématique,Résultat invalide, +3,"3,31",667,2,Erreur mathématique,Résultat invalide,Imprécision +3,"3,311",668,2,Erreur mathématique,Résultat invalide,Imprécision +3,"3,3111",669,2,Erreur mathématique,Résultat invalide,Imprécision +3,"3,312",670,2,Erreur mathématique,Résultat invalide,Imprécision +3,"3,3121",671,2,Erreur mathématique,Résultat invalide,Imprécision +3,"3,31211",672,2,Erreur mathématique,Résultat invalide,Imprécision +3,"3,3122",673,2,Erreur mathématique,Résultat invalide,Imprécision +3,"3,31221",674,2,Erreur mathématique,Résultat invalide,Imprécision +3,"3,3124",675,2,Erreur mathématique,Résultat invalide,Imprécision +3,"3,313",676,2,Erreur mathématique,Résultat invalide,Imprécision +3,"3,3131",677,2,Erreur mathématique,Résultat invalide,Imprécision +3,"3,3132",678,2,Erreur mathématique,Résultat invalide,Imprécision +3,"3,3133",679,2,Erreur mathématique,Résultat invalide,Imprécision +3,"3,3134",680,2,Erreur mathématique,Résultat invalide,Imprécision +3,"3,32",681,2,Erreur mathématique,Résultat invalide,Erreur de calcul +3,"3,321",682,2,Erreur mathématique,Résultat invalide,Erreur de calcul +3,"3,322",683,2,Erreur mathématique,Résultat invalide,Erreur de calcul +3,"3,3221",684,2,Erreur mathématique,Résultat invalide,Erreur de calcul +3,"3,3222",685,2,Erreur mathématique,Résultat invalide,Erreur de calcul +3,"3,3223",686,2,Erreur mathématique,Résultat invalide,Erreur de calcul +3,"3,3224",687,2,Erreur mathématique,Résultat invalide,Erreur de calcul +3,"3,3225",688,2,Erreur mathématique,Résultat invalide,Erreur de calcul +3,"3,323",689,2,Erreur mathématique,Résultat invalide,Erreur de calcul +3,"3,33",690,2,Erreur mathématique,Résultat invalide,Opération inappropriée +3,"3,331",691,2,Erreur mathématique,Résultat invalide,Opération inappropriée +3,"3,3311",692,2,Erreur mathématique,Résultat invalide,Opération inappropriée +3,"3,3312",693,2,Erreur mathématique,Résultat invalide,Opération inappropriée +3,"3,332",694,2,Erreur mathématique,Résultat invalide,Opération inappropriée +3,"3,333",695,2,Erreur mathématique,Résultat invalide,Opération inappropriée +,4,696,1,Erreur de raisonnement,, +4,"4,1",697,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Causalité douteuse, +4,"4,11",698,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Causalité douteuse,Pétition de principe +4,"4,111",699,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Causalité douteuse,Pétition de principe +4,"4,1111",700,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Causalité douteuse,Pétition de principe +4,"4,112",701,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Causalité douteuse,Pétition de principe +4,"4,113",702,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Causalité douteuse,Pétition de principe +4,"4,114",703,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Causalité douteuse,Pétition de principe +4,"4,115",704,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Causalité douteuse,Pétition de principe +4,"4,116",705,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Causalité douteuse,Pétition de principe +4,"4,117",706,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Causalité douteuse,Pétition de principe +4,"4,12",707,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Causalité douteuse,Inversion de causalité +4,"4,121",708,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Causalité douteuse,Inversion de causalité +4,"4,1211",709,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Causalité douteuse,Inversion de causalité +4,"4,122",710,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Causalité douteuse,Inversion de causalité +4,"4,1221",711,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Causalité douteuse,Inversion de causalité +4,"4,124",712,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Causalité douteuse,Inversion de causalité +4,"4,125",713,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Causalité douteuse,Inversion de causalité +4,"4,1251",714,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Causalité douteuse,Inversion de causalité +4,"4,1252",715,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Causalité douteuse,Inversion de causalité +4,"4,12521",716,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Causalité douteuse,Inversion de causalité +4,"4,126",717,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Causalité douteuse,Inversion de causalité +4,"4,127",718,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Causalité douteuse,Inversion de causalité +4,"4,13",719,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Causalité douteuse,Effet cigogne +4,"4,131",720,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Causalité douteuse,Effet cigogne +4,"4,1311",721,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Causalité douteuse,Effet cigogne +4,"4,13111",722,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Causalité douteuse,Effet cigogne +4,"4,13112",723,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Causalité douteuse,Effet cigogne +4,"4,132",724,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Causalité douteuse,Effet cigogne +4,"4,134",725,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Causalité douteuse,Effet cigogne +4,"4,2",726,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise composition, +4,"4,21",727,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise composition,Erreur de logique propositionnelle +4,"4,211",728,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise composition,Erreur de logique propositionnelle +4,"4,2111",729,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise composition,Erreur de logique propositionnelle +4,"4,212",730,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise composition,Erreur de logique propositionnelle +4,"4,2121",731,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise composition,Erreur de logique propositionnelle +4,"4,213",732,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise composition,Erreur de logique propositionnelle +4,"4,2131",733,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise composition,Erreur de logique propositionnelle +4,"4,2132",734,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise composition,Erreur de logique propositionnelle +4,"4,22",735,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise composition,Erreur de quantification +4,"4,221",736,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise composition,Erreur de quantification +4,"4,2211",737,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise composition,Erreur de quantification +4,"4,2213",738,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise composition,Erreur de quantification +4,"4,2214",739,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise composition,Erreur de quantification +4,"4,222",740,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise composition,Erreur de quantification +4,"4,2221",741,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise composition,Erreur de quantification +4,"4,2222",742,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise composition,Erreur de quantification +4,"4,22221",743,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise composition,Erreur de quantification +4,"4,2223",744,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise composition,Erreur de quantification +4,"4,2224",745,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise composition,Erreur de quantification +4,"4,2225",746,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise composition,Erreur de quantification +4,"4,2226",747,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise composition,Erreur de quantification +4,"4,2227",748,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise composition,Erreur de quantification +4,"4,223",749,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise composition,Erreur de quantification +4,"4,23",750,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise composition,Erreur de modalité +4,"4,231",751,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise composition,Erreur de modalité +4,"4,2311",752,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise composition,Erreur de modalité +4,"4,232",753,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise composition,Erreur de modalité +4,"4,233",754,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise composition,Erreur de modalité +4,"4,234",755,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise composition,Erreur de modalité +4,"4,2341",756,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise composition,Erreur de modalité +4,"4,235",757,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise composition,Erreur de modalité +4,"4,3",758,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise déduction, +4,"4,31",759,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise déduction,Conclusion hâtive +4,"4,311",760,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise déduction,Conclusion hâtive +4,"4,3111",761,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise déduction,Conclusion hâtive +4,"4,3112",762,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise déduction,Conclusion hâtive +4,"4,31121",763,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise déduction,Conclusion hâtive +4,"4,311211",764,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise déduction,Conclusion hâtive +4,"4,3113",765,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise déduction,Conclusion hâtive +4,"4,3114",766,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise déduction,Conclusion hâtive +4,"4,31141",767,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise déduction,Conclusion hâtive +4,"4,312",768,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise déduction,Conclusion hâtive +4,"4,3121",769,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise déduction,Conclusion hâtive +4,"4,313",770,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise déduction,Conclusion hâtive +4,"4,314",771,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise déduction,Conclusion hâtive +4,"4,3141",772,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise déduction,Conclusion hâtive +4,"4,315",773,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise déduction,Conclusion hâtive +4,"4,316",774,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise déduction,Conclusion hâtive +4,"4,317",775,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise déduction,Conclusion hâtive +4,"4,318",776,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise déduction,Conclusion hâtive +4,"4,32",777,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise déduction,Inconsistance +4,"4,321",778,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise déduction,Inconsistance +4,"4,3211",779,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise déduction,Inconsistance +4,"4,322",780,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise déduction,Inconsistance +4,"4,3221",781,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise déduction,Inconsistance +4,"4,3222",782,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise déduction,Inconsistance +4,"4,323",783,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise déduction,Inconsistance +4,"4,33",784,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise déduction,Syllogisme invalide +4,"4,331",785,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise déduction,Syllogisme invalide +4,"4,3311",786,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise déduction,Syllogisme invalide +4,"4,33111",787,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise déduction,Syllogisme invalide +4,"4,3312",788,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise déduction,Syllogisme invalide +4,"4,33121",789,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise déduction,Syllogisme invalide +4,"4,33122",790,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise déduction,Syllogisme invalide +4,"4,332",791,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise déduction,Syllogisme invalide +4,"4,3321",792,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise déduction,Syllogisme invalide +4,"4,3322",793,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise déduction,Syllogisme invalide +4,"4,3323",794,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise déduction,Syllogisme invalide +4,"4,333",795,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise déduction,Syllogisme invalide +4,"4,3331",796,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise déduction,Syllogisme invalide +4,"4,3332",797,2,Erreur de raisonnement,Mauvaise déduction,Syllogisme invalide +,5,798,1,Abus de langage,, +5,"5,1",799,2,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte, +5,"5,11",800,2,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Acception vague +5,"5,111",801,2,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Acception vague +5,"5,112",802,2,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Acception vague +5,"5,113",803,2,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Acception vague +5,"5,12",804,2,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Acception arbitraire +5,"5,121",805,2,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Acception arbitraire +5,"5,1211",806,2,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Acception arbitraire +5,"5,1212",807,2,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Acception arbitraire +5,"5,122",808,2,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Acception arbitraire +5,"5,1221",809,2,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Acception arbitraire +5,"5,1222",810,2,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Acception arbitraire +5,"5,12221",811,2,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Acception arbitraire +5,"5,12222",812,2,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Acception arbitraire +5,"5,1223",813,2,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Acception arbitraire +5,"5,1224",814,2,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Acception arbitraire +5,"5,12241",815,2,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Acception arbitraire +5,"5,12242",816,2,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Acception arbitraire +5,"5,12243",817,2,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Acception arbitraire +5,"5,1225",818,2,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Acception arbitraire +5,"5,123",819,2,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Acception arbitraire +5,"5,1231",820,2,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Acception arbitraire +5,"5,1232",821,2,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Acception arbitraire +5,"5,12321",822,2,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Acception arbitraire +5,"5,12322",823,2,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Acception arbitraire +5,"5,123224",824,2,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Acception arbitraire +5,"5,12323",825,2,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Acception arbitraire +5,"5,13",826,2,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Définition inconsistante +5,"5,131",827,2,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Définition inconsistante +5,"5,1311",828,2,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Définition inconsistante +5,"5,132",829,2,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Définition inconsistante +5,"5,1321",830,2,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Définition inconsistante +5,"5,1322",831,2,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Définition inconsistante +5,"5,133",832,2,Abus de langage,Définition inexacte,Définition inconsistante +5,"5,2",833,2,Abus de langage,Comparaison fallacieuse, +5,"5,21",834,2,Abus de langage,Comparaison fallacieuse,Comparaison abusive +5,"5,211",835,2,Abus de langage,Comparaison fallacieuse,Comparaison abusive +5,"5,212",836,2,Abus de langage,Comparaison fallacieuse,Comparaison abusive +5,"5,213",837,2,Abus de langage,Comparaison fallacieuse,Comparaison abusive +5,"5,214",838,2,Abus de langage,Comparaison fallacieuse,Comparaison abusive +5,"5,22",839,2,Abus de langage,Comparaison fallacieuse,Fausse analogie +5,"5,221",840,2,Abus de langage,Comparaison fallacieuse,Fausse analogie +5,"5,222",841,2,Abus de langage,Comparaison fallacieuse,Fausse analogie +5,"5,223",842,2,Abus de langage,Comparaison fallacieuse,Fausse analogie +5,"5,224",843,2,Abus de langage,Comparaison fallacieuse,Fausse analogie +5,"5,23",844,2,Abus de langage,Comparaison fallacieuse,Sophisme d'association +5,"5,231",845,2,Abus de langage,Comparaison fallacieuse,Sophisme d'association +5,"5,3",846,2,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté, +5,"5,31",847,2,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Amphibologie +5,"5,311",848,2,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Amphibologie +5,"5,312",849,2,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Amphibologie +5,"5,3121",850,2,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Amphibologie +5,"5,313",851,2,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Amphibologie +5,"5,3131",852,2,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Amphibologie +5,"5,314",853,2,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Amphibologie +5,"5,315",854,2,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Amphibologie +5,"5,32",855,2,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Equivoque +5,"5,321",856,2,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Equivoque +5,"5,3211",857,2,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Equivoque +5,"5,3212",858,2,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Equivoque +5,"5,32121",859,2,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Equivoque +5,"5,322",860,2,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Equivoque +5,"5,3221",861,2,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Equivoque +5,"5,3222",862,2,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Equivoque +5,"5,32221",863,2,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Equivoque +5,"5,3223",864,2,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Equivoque +5,"5,323",865,2,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Equivoque +5,"5,3231",866,2,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Equivoque +5,"5,32311",867,2,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Equivoque +5,"5,3232",868,2,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Equivoque +5,"5,32321",869,2,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Equivoque +5,"5,323211",870,2,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Equivoque +5,"5,323212",871,2,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Equivoque +5,"5,32322",872,2,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Equivoque +5,"5,323221",873,2,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Equivoque +5,"5,32323",874,2,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Equivoque +5,"5,32324",875,2,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Equivoque +5,"5,33",876,2,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Ambiguïté narrative +5,"5,331",877,2,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Ambiguïté narrative +5,"5,3311",878,2,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Ambiguïté narrative +5,"5,33111",879,2,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Ambiguïté narrative +5,"5,33112",880,2,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Ambiguïté narrative +5,"5,332",881,2,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Ambiguïté narrative +5,"5,3321",882,2,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Ambiguïté narrative +5,"5,333",883,2,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Ambiguïté narrative +5,"5,3331",884,2,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Ambiguïté narrative +5,"5,3332",885,2,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Ambiguïté narrative +5,"5,334",886,2,Abus de langage,Ambiguïté,Ambiguïté narrative +,6,887,1,Tricherie,, +6,"6,1",888,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits, +6,"6,11",889,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,111",890,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,1111",891,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,11111",892,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,11112",893,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,111121",894,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,11113",895,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,1112",896,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,1113",897,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,11131",898,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,11132",899,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,11133",900,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,111331",901,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,111332",902,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,1114",903,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,1115",904,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,1116",905,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,1117",906,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,11171",907,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,112",908,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,1121",909,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,11211",910,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,11212",911,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,11213",912,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,11214",913,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,11215",914,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,11216",915,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,1122",916,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,11221",917,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,112211",918,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,11222",919,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,112221",920,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,1122211",921,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,112222",922,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,11223",923,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,112231",924,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,1123",925,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,11231",926,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,11232",927,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,11233",928,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,1124",929,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,113",930,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,1131",931,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,1132",932,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,1133",933,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,11331",934,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,1134",935,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,11341",936,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,1135",937,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,1136",938,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,1137",939,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,1138",940,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,1139",941,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Mensonge +6,"6,12",942,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Fausse attribution +6,"6,121",943,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Fausse attribution +6,"6,1211",944,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Fausse attribution +6,"6,1212",945,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Fausse attribution +6,"6,1213",946,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Fausse attribution +6,"6,1214",947,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Fausse attribution +6,"6,122",948,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Fausse attribution +6,"6,1221",949,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Fausse attribution +6,"6,1222",950,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Fausse attribution +6,"6,123",951,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Fausse attribution +6,"6,1231",952,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Fausse attribution +6,"6,13",953,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Attention sélective +6,"6,131",954,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Attention sélective +6,"6,1311",955,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Attention sélective +6,"6,13111",956,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Attention sélective +6,"6,131111",957,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Attention sélective +6,"6,13113",958,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Attention sélective +6,"6,131131",959,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Attention sélective +6,"6,131132",960,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Attention sélective +6,"6,13114",961,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Attention sélective +6,"6,1312",962,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Attention sélective +6,"6,13121",963,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Attention sélective +6,"6,13122",964,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Attention sélective +6,"6,13123",965,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Attention sélective +6,"6,13124",966,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Attention sélective +6,"6,1313",967,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Attention sélective +6,"6,13131",968,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Attention sélective +6,"6,13132",969,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Attention sélective +6,"6,1314",970,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Attention sélective +6,"6,132",971,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Attention sélective +6,"6,133",972,2,Tricherie,Arranger les faits,Attention sélective +6,"6,2",973,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap, +6,"6,21",974,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Exigence renforcée +6,"6,211",975,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Exigence renforcée +6,"6,2111",976,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Exigence renforcée +6,"6,21111",977,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Exigence renforcée +6,"6,211111",978,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Exigence renforcée +6,"6,21112",979,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Exigence renforcée +6,"6,2112",980,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Exigence renforcée +6,"6,2113",981,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Exigence renforcée +6,"6,2114",982,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Exigence renforcée +6,"6,2115",983,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Exigence renforcée +6,"6,212",984,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Exigence renforcée +6,"6,2121",985,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Exigence renforcée +6,"6,2122",986,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Exigence renforcée +6,"6,213",987,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Exigence renforcée +6,"6,2131",988,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Exigence renforcée +6,"6,214",989,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Exigence renforcée +6,"6,2141",990,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Exigence renforcée +6,"6,215",991,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Exigence renforcée +6,"6,22",992,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Beurre et argent du beurre +6,"6,221",993,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Beurre et argent du beurre +6,"6,2211",994,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Beurre et argent du beurre +6,"6,22111",995,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Beurre et argent du beurre +6,"6,2212",996,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Beurre et argent du beurre +6,"6,222",997,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Beurre et argent du beurre +6,"6,2221",998,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Beurre et argent du beurre +6,"6,2222",999,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Beurre et argent du beurre +6,"6,2223",1000,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Beurre et argent du beurre +6,"6,223",1407,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Beurre et argent du beurre +6,"6,224",1001,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Beurre et argent du beurre +6,"6,2241",1002,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Beurre et argent du beurre +6,"6,2242",1003,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Beurre et argent du beurre +6,"6,225",1004,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Beurre et argent du beurre +6,"6,2251",1005,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Beurre et argent du beurre +6,"6,2252",1006,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Beurre et argent du beurre +6,"6,2253",1007,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Beurre et argent du beurre +6,"6,226",1008,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Beurre et argent du beurre +6,"6,2261",1009,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Beurre et argent du beurre +6,"6,2262",1010,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Beurre et argent du beurre +6,"6,23",1011,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Exigence relâchée +6,"6,231",1012,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Exigence relâchée +6,"6,232",1013,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Exigence relâchée +6,"6,2321",1014,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Exigence relâchée +6,"6,233",1015,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Exigence relâchée +6,"6,2331",1016,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Exigence relâchée +6,"6,2332",1017,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Exigence relâchée +6,"6,2333",1018,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Exigence relâchée +6,"6,2334",1019,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Exigence relâchée +6,"6,234",1020,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Exigence relâchée +6,"6,2341",1021,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Exigence relâchée +6,"6,235",1022,2,Tricherie,Changement de cap,Exigence relâchée +6,"6,3",1023,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée, +6,"6,31",1024,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,311",1025,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3111",1026,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,31111",1027,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,311111",1028,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3111111",1029,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3111112",1030,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3111113",1031,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,311112",1032,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,311113",1033,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3111131",1034,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3111132",1035,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,311114",1036,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,311115",1037,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,31112",1038,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,311121",1039,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3111211",1040,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,31112111",1041,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,31112112",1042,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3111212",1043,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,31112121",1044,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,311121211",1045,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3111213",1046,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3111214",1047,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,311122",1048,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3111221",1049,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,31112211",1050,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,31112212",1051,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,31112213",1052,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3111224",1053,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3111225",1054,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,31112251",1055,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3111226",1056,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,31113",1057,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,311131",1058,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,311132",1059,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,311133",1060,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,311134",1061,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,311135",1062,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3111351",1063,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,311136",1064,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3112",1065,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,31121",1066,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,311211",1067,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,311212",1068,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,311213",1069,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,311214",1070,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,311215",1071,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,311216",1072,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3112161",1073,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,311217",1074,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,31122",1075,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,311221",1076,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,311222",1077,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,311223",1078,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,311224",1079,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,311225",1080,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,311226",1081,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,311227",1082,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,31123",1083,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,311231",1084,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,311232",1085,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,311233",1086,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,311234",1087,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,311235",1088,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3112351",1089,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,312",1090,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3121",1091,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,31211",1092,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,312111",1093,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3121111",1094,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3121112",1095,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3121113",1096,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,31211131",1097,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,312112",1098,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3121121",1099,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,31211211",1100,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,31211212",1101,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3121122",1102,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3121123",1103,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,31212",1104,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,312121",1105,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3121211",1106,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3121212",1107,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3121213",1108,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,312122",1109,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3121221",1110,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3121222",1111,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3121223",1112,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3121224",1113,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,312123",1114,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3121231",1115,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3121232",1116,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3121233",1117,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3121234",1118,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3122",1119,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,31221",1120,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,312211",1121,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,312212",1122,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,312213",1123,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,312214",1124,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,312215",1125,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,31222",1126,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,312221",1127,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,312222",1128,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,312223",1129,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3122231",1130,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3122232",1131,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3122233",1132,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,312224",1133,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3122241",1134,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3122242",1135,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3122243",1136,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,312225",1137,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,31223",1138,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,312231",1139,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3122311",1140,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3122312",1141,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,312232",1142,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,312233",1143,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,312234",1144,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3122341",1145,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3123",1146,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,31231",1147,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,312311",1148,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3123111",1149,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3123112",1150,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3123113",1151,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3123114",1152,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,312312",1153,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3123121",1154,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3123122",1155,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3123123",1156,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,31231231",1157,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,312313",1158,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3123131",1159,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3123132",1160,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3123133",1161,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3123134",1162,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,312314",1163,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,31232",1164,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,312321",1165,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3123211",1166,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3123212",1167,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3123213",1168,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,312322",1169,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3123221",1170,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,3123222",1171,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,312323",1172,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,31233",1173,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais naturels +6,"6,32",1174,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,321",1175,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,3211",1176,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,32111",1177,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,321111",1178,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,321112",1179,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,321113",1180,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,32112",1181,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,32113",1182,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,32114",1183,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,3212",1184,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,32121",1185,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,321211",1186,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,321212",1187,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,32122",1188,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,321221",1189,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,321222",1190,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,32123",1191,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,321231",1192,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,3213",1193,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,32131",1194,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,321311",1195,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,32132",1196,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,32133",1197,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,322",1198,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,3221",1199,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,32211",1200,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,32212",1201,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,3222",1202,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,32221",1203,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,322211",1204,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,322212",1205,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,3222121",1206,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,3222122",1207,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,322213",1208,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,322214",1209,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,322215",1210,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,3222151",1211,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,322216",1212,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,3222161",1213,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,322217",1214,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,32222",1215,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,322221",1216,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,32223",1217,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,32224",1218,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,322241",1219,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,322242",1220,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,322243",1221,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,322244",1222,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,322245",1223,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,322246",1224,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,3223",1225,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,323",1226,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,3231",1227,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,32311",1228,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,32312",1229,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,32313",1230,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,32314",1231,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,323141",1232,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,32315",1233,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,32316",1234,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,32317",1235,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,32318",1236,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,3232",1237,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,32321",1238,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,32322",1239,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,32323",1240,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,32324",1241,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais culturels +6,"6,33",1242,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais théoriques +6,"6,331",1243,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais théoriques +6,"6,3311",1244,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais théoriques +6,"6,33111",1245,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais théoriques +6,"6,331111",1246,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais théoriques +6,"6,3312",1247,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais théoriques +6,"6,3313",1248,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais théoriques +6,"6,33131",1249,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais théoriques +6,"6,331311",1250,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais théoriques +6,"6,33132",1251,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais théoriques +6,"6,331321",1252,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais théoriques +6,"6,331322",1253,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais théoriques +6,"6,331323",1254,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais théoriques +6,"6,3314",1255,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais théoriques +6,"6,3315",1256,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais théoriques +6,"6,3316",1257,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais théoriques +6,"6,33161",1258,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais théoriques +6,"6,332",1259,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais théoriques +6,"6,3321",1260,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais théoriques +6,"6,33211",1261,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais théoriques +6,"6,3323",1262,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais théoriques +6,"6,3325",1263,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais théoriques +6,"6,33251",1264,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais théoriques +6,"6,33252",1265,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais théoriques +6,"6,3326",1266,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais théoriques +6,"6,33261",1267,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais théoriques +6,"6,333",1268,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais théoriques +6,"6,3331",1269,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais théoriques +6,"6,33311",1270,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais théoriques +6,"6,33312",1271,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais théoriques +6,"6,333121",1272,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais théoriques +6,"6,33313",1273,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais théoriques +6,"6,33314",1274,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais théoriques +6,"6,3332",1275,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais théoriques +6,"6,3333",1276,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais théoriques +6,"6,3334",1277,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais théoriques +6,"6,3335",1278,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais théoriques +6,"6,3336",1279,2,Tricherie,Pensée biaisée,Biais théoriques +,7,1280,1,Obstruction,, +7,"7,1",1281,2,Obstruction,Refus du débat, +7,"7,11",1282,2,Obstruction,Refus du débat,Relativisme abusif +7,"7,111",1283,2,Obstruction,Refus du débat,Relativisme abusif +7,"7,1111",1284,2,Obstruction,Refus du débat,Relativisme abusif +7,"7,1112",1285,2,Obstruction,Refus du débat,Relativisme abusif +7,"7,112",1286,2,Obstruction,Refus du débat,Relativisme abusif +7,"7,12",1287,2,Obstruction,Refus du débat,Sophisme d'Explication +7,"7,121",1288,2,Obstruction,Refus du débat,Sophisme d'Explication +7,"7,1211",1289,2,Obstruction,Refus du débat,Sophisme d'Explication +7,"7,1212",1290,2,Obstruction,Refus du débat,Sophisme d'Explication +7,"7,122",1291,2,Obstruction,Refus du débat,Sophisme d'Explication +7,"7,1221",1292,2,Obstruction,Refus du débat,Sophisme d'Explication +7,"7,12211",1293,2,Obstruction,Refus du débat,Sophisme d'Explication +7,"7,123",1294,2,Obstruction,Refus du débat,Sophisme d'Explication +7,"7,124",1295,2,Obstruction,Refus du débat,Sophisme d'Explication +7,"7,125",1296,2,Obstruction,Refus du débat,Sophisme d'Explication +7,"7,13",1297,2,Obstruction,Refus du débat,Preuve par assertion +7,"7,131",1298,2,Obstruction,Refus du débat,Preuve par assertion +7,"7,132",1299,2,Obstruction,Refus du débat,Preuve par assertion +7,"7,1321",1300,2,Obstruction,Refus du débat,Preuve par assertion +7,"7,133",1301,2,Obstruction,Refus du débat,Preuve par assertion +7,"7,1331",1302,2,Obstruction,Refus du débat,Preuve par assertion +7,"7,1332",1303,2,Obstruction,Refus du débat,Preuve par assertion +7,"7,134",1304,2,Obstruction,Refus du débat,Preuve par assertion +7,"7,135",1305,2,Obstruction,Refus du débat,Preuve par assertion +7,"7,1351",1306,2,Obstruction,Refus du débat,Preuve par assertion +7,"7,13511",1307,2,Obstruction,Refus du débat,Preuve par assertion +7,"7,135111",1308,2,Obstruction,Refus du débat,Preuve par assertion +7,"7,1352",1309,2,Obstruction,Refus du débat,Preuve par assertion +7,"7,136",1310,2,Obstruction,Refus du débat,Preuve par assertion +7,"7,137",1311,2,Obstruction,Refus du débat,Preuve par assertion +7,"7,2",1312,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat, +7,"7,21",1313,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Evasion +7,"7,211",1314,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Evasion +7,"7,2111",1315,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Evasion +7,"7,21111",1316,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Evasion +7,"7,21112",1317,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Evasion +7,"7,211121",1318,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Evasion +7,"7,21113",1319,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Evasion +7,"7,21114",1320,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Evasion +7,"7,2112",1321,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Evasion +7,"7,21121",1322,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Evasion +7,"7,211211",1323,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Evasion +7,"7,211212",1324,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Evasion +7,"7,21122",1325,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Evasion +7,"7,21123",1326,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Evasion +7,"7,212",1327,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Evasion +7,"7,2121",1328,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Evasion +7,"7,21211",1329,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Evasion +7,"7,2122",1330,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Evasion +7,"7,2123",1331,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Evasion +7,"7,2124",1332,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Evasion +7,"7,21241",1333,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Evasion +7,"7,213",1334,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Evasion +7,"7,2131",1335,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Evasion +7,"7,21311",1336,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Evasion +7,"7,21312",1337,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Evasion +7,"7,2132",1338,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Evasion +7,"7,21321",1339,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Evasion +7,"7,213211",1340,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Evasion +7,"7,21322",1341,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Evasion +7,"7,2133",1342,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Evasion +7,"7,21331",1343,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Evasion +7,"7,21332",1344,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Evasion +7,"7,22",1345,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Complication exagérée +7,"7,221",1346,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Complication exagérée +7,"7,2211",1347,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Complication exagérée +7,"7,22111",1348,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Complication exagérée +7,"7,2212",1349,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Complication exagérée +7,"7,222",1350,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Complication exagérée +7,"7,223",1351,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Complication exagérée +7,"7,23",1352,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Empoisonner le puits +7,"7,231",1353,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Empoisonner le puits +7,"7,232",1354,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Empoisonner le puits +7,"7,233",1355,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Empoisonner le puits +7,"7,2331",1356,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Empoisonner le puits +7,"7,234",1357,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Empoisonner le puits +7,"7,2341",1358,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Empoisonner le puits +7,"7,2342",1359,2,Obstruction,Saboter le débat,Empoisonner le puits +7,"7,3",1360,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem, +7,"7,31",1361,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Procès en inconsistance +7,"7,311",1362,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Procès en inconsistance +7,"7,3111",1363,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Procès en inconsistance +7,"7,3112",1364,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Procès en inconsistance +7,"7,312",1365,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Procès en inconsistance +7,"7,3121",1366,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Procès en inconsistance +7,"7,3122",1367,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Procès en inconsistance +7,"7,313",1368,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Procès en inconsistance +7,"7,3131",1369,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Procès en inconsistance +7,"7,3132",1370,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Procès en inconsistance +7,"7,32",1371,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Sophisme génétique +7,"7,321",1372,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Sophisme génétique +7,"7,3211",1373,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Sophisme génétique +7,"7,3212",1374,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Sophisme génétique +7,"7,3213",1375,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Sophisme génétique +7,"7,3214",1376,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Sophisme génétique +7,"7,3215",1377,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Sophisme génétique +7,"7,3216",1378,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Sophisme génétique +7,"7,3217",1379,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Sophisme génétique +7,"7,32171",1380,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Sophisme génétique +7,"7,322",1381,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Sophisme génétique +7,"7,3221",1382,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Sophisme génétique +7,"7,32211",1383,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Sophisme génétique +7,"7,3222",1384,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Sophisme génétique +7,"7,3223",1385,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Sophisme génétique +7,"7,323",1386,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Sophisme génétique +7,"7,3231",1387,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Sophisme génétique +7,"7,3232",1388,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Sophisme génétique +7,"7,3233",1389,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Sophisme génétique +7,"7,3234",1390,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Sophisme génétique +7,"7,3235",1391,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Sophisme génétique +7,"7,324",1392,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Sophisme génétique +7,"7,3241",1393,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Sophisme génétique +7,"7,3242",1394,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Sophisme génétique +7,"7,3243",1395,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Sophisme génétique +7,"7,3244",1396,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Sophisme génétique +7,"7,3245",1397,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Sophisme génétique +7,"7,33",1398,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Attaque personnelle +7,"7,331",1399,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Attaque personnelle +7,"7,332",1400,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Attaque personnelle +7,"7,333",1401,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Attaque personnelle +7,"7,334",1402,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Attaque personnelle +7,"7,335",1403,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Attaque personnelle +7,"7,3351",1404,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Attaque personnelle +7,"7,3352",1405,2,Obstruction,Ad hominem,Attaque personnelle diff --git a/tools/aif-attack-graph-export.py b/tools/aif-attack-graph-export.py new file mode 100644 index 00000000..902b6ef3 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/aif-attack-graph-export.py @@ -0,0 +1,358 @@ +#!/usr/bin/env python3 +# -*- coding: utf-8 -*- +"""AIF attack-graph export — typed attack-edges + relations for CoursIA uplift. + +Exports the EXISTING AIF modelling from the Fallacies Taxonomy CSV + argumentum.owl +into consumable artefacts. READ-ONLY on sources (0 write to CSV/OWL). + +Honest verdict (no fabrication): + The AIF columns (AIF_attackType + AIF_attackedNode) encode a BIPARTITE attack + graph: each fully-modeled fallacy is an ATTACKER that targets an abstract AIF + node-TYPE (RA-node / I-node / CA-node), NOT another fallacy. There is NO + inter-fallacy attack adjacency ("fallacy X attacks fallacy Y") in the data. + + A separate inter-fallacy graph exists in the OWL (isRelatedTo, mirrors, + predatesOn, denounces, leverages, allows, opposes, inverts) but these are + GENERIC semantic relations, NOT typed AIF attack-edges — exported separately + and labelled as such. + +Outputs (docs/ontology/aif-export/): + aif-attack-edges.csv 145 bipartite attack-edges (CSV-sourced, PK-keyed) + aif-canonical-concepts.csv AIF canonical concepts referenced via skos + taxonomy-tree-edges.csv hierarchical tree edges (decimal_path, all 1408) + aif-owl-attack-edges.csv OWL-sourced mirror of attack-edges (cross-check) + aif-relations-graph.csv OWL inter-fallacy semantic relations (non-AIF) +""" +import csv +import os +import re +import sys +import collections +import xml.etree.ElementTree as ET + +ROOT = os.path.dirname(os.path.dirname(os.path.abspath(__file__))) +CSV_PATH = os.path.join(ROOT, "Cards", "Fallacies", "Argumentum Fallacies - Taxonomy.csv") +OWL_PATH = os.path.join(ROOT, "docs", "ontology", "argumentum.owl") +OUT_DIR = os.path.join(ROOT, "docs", "ontology", "aif-export") + +AIF_NS = "http://www.arg.dundee.ac.uk/aif" +ARG_NS = "https://www.argumentum.games/argumentum_fallacies.owl" + +# attackType -> expected attackedNode-type (AIF / ASPIC+ semantics) +ATTACK_NODE_AXIOM = { + "undercut": "RA-node", # attacks the rule-application link + "undermine": "I-node", # attacks the information/premise node + "rebut": "CA-node", # attacks via a conflicting application +} + +# OWL ObjectProperties / AnnotationProperties that encode inter-fallacy +# semantic relations (NOT AIF attack-edges). Exported as a separate graph. +RELATION_PROPS = { + "isRelatedTo", "mirrors", "predatesOn", "denounces", + "leverages", "allows", "opposes", "inverts", +} + + +def frag(iri): + """Return the fragment (after #) of an IRI, or the full string.""" + if not iri: + return "" + return iri.rsplit("#", 1)[-1] if "#" in iri else iri + + +def iri_of(el): + """Read an IRI from an OWL/XML element. + + Two forms occur in OWL/XML: + - -> attribute + - http://... -> element text + """ + if el.get("IRI"): + return el.get("IRI") + return (el.text or "").strip() + + +def load_csv(): + with open(CSV_PATH, encoding="utf-8-sig", newline="") as f: + rows = list(csv.reader(f)) + header = rows[0] + + def col(name): + return header.index(name) + + return header, rows[1:], col + + +def export_attack_edges_csv(data, col, out_path): + """145 bipartite attack-edges from CSV columns AIF_attackType + AIF_attackedNode.""" + fields = [ + "attacker_pk", "attacker_label", "family", "subfamily", "subsubfamily", + "decimal_path", "attack_type", "attacked_node_type", + "skos_direct_ref", "skos_exception_ref", "skos_mapping_type", + "expected_node_type", "node_type_axiom_ok", + ] + rows_out = [] + axiom_violations = [] + for r in data: + at = r[col("AIF_attackType")].strip() + an = r[col("AIF_attackedNode")].strip() + if not at and not an: + continue # not fully-modeled + if at and not an or an and not at: + axiom_violations.append((r[col("PK")], "asymmetric attackType/attackedNode", at, an)) + continue + expected = ATTACK_NODE_AXIOM.get(at, "") + ok = "1" if expected == an else "0" + if ok == "0": + axiom_violations.append((r[col("PK")], f"attackType={at} expects {expected}, got {an}", at, an)) + rows_out.append({ + "attacker_pk": r[col("PK")], + "attacker_label": r[col("nom_vulgarisé")].strip() or r[col("carte")].strip(), + "family": r[col("Famille")].strip(), + "subfamily": r[col("Sous-Famille")].strip(), + "subsubfamily": r[col("Soussousfamille")].strip(), + "decimal_path": r[col("decimal_path")].strip(), + "attack_type": at, + "attacked_node_type": an, + "skos_direct_ref": r[col("AIF_skosDirectRef")].strip(), + "skos_exception_ref": r[col("AIF_skosExceptionRef")].strip(), + "skos_mapping_type": r[col("AIF_skosMappingType")].strip(), + "expected_node_type": expected, + "node_type_axiom_ok": ok, + }) + _write_csv(out_path, fields, rows_out) + return rows_out, axiom_violations + + +def export_canonical_concepts(data, col, out_path): + """Distinct AIF canonical concepts referenced via skos (direct + exception).""" + concept_uses = collections.Counter() + concept_samples = collections.defaultdict(list) + for r in data: + for refcol in ("AIF_skosDirectRef", "AIF_skosExceptionRef"): + ref = r[col(refcol)].strip() + if not ref: + continue + # a cell may hold multiple comma-separated concepts + for c in [x.strip() for x in ref.split(",") if x.strip()]: + concept_uses[c] += 1 + if len(concept_samples[c]) < 3: + concept_samples[c].append(r[col("PK")]) + fields = ["concept_id", "suffix", "ref_count", "sample_attacker_pks"] + rows_out = [] + suffix_count = collections.Counter() + for c, n in concept_uses.most_common(): + suffix = c.rsplit("_", 1)[-1] if "_" in c else "(none)" + suffix_count[suffix] += 1 + rows_out.append({ + "concept_id": c, + "suffix": suffix, + "ref_count": n, + "sample_attacker_pks": ";".join(concept_samples[c]), + }) + _write_csv(out_path, fields, rows_out) + return concept_uses, suffix_count + + +def export_taxonomy_tree(data, col, out_path): + """Hierarchical tree edges derived from decimal_path (parent -> child).""" + pk_i = col("PK") + dp_i = col("decimal_path") + fam_i = col("Famille") + sfam_i = col("Sous-Famille") + ssfam_i = col("Soussousfamille") + fields = ["parent_path", "child_path", "child_pk", "depth", "family", "subfamily", "subsubfamily"] + rows_out = [] + for r in data: + dp = r[dp_i].strip() + if not dp: + continue + depth = dp.count(",") + 1 + parent = ",".join(dp.split(",")[:-1]) if depth > 1 else "" + rows_out.append({ + "parent_path": parent, + "child_path": dp, + "child_pk": r[pk_i], + "depth": depth, + "family": r[fam_i].strip(), + "subfamily": r[sfam_i].strip(), + "subsubfamily": r[ssfam_i].strip(), + }) + rows_out.sort(key=lambda x: x["child_path"]) + _write_csv(out_path, fields, rows_out) + return len(rows_out) + + +def parse_owl_attack_and_relations(): + """Parse argumentum.owl: extract aifAttackType/aifAttackedNode assertions + (attack graph) and inter-fallacy relation assertions (isRelatedTo etc.).""" + tree = ET.parse(OWL_PATH) + root = tree.getroot() + # OWL/XML elements use no namespace prefix for AnnotationAssertion etc. + attack = {} # subject_fragment -> {type, node} + relations = [] # (subject, prop, object) + for aa in root.iter("AnnotationAssertion"): + children = list(aa) + if len(children) < 3: + continue + prop_el = children[0] + subj_el = children[1] + obj_el = children[2] + prop_iri = prop_el.get("IRI", "") + prop_frag = frag(prop_iri) + subj_frag = frag(subj_el.get("IRI", "") or subj_el.text or "") + if not subj_frag: + continue + # AIF attack properties + if prop_frag == "aifAttackType": + val = obj_el.text.strip() if obj_el.tag == "Literal" else "" + attack.setdefault(subj_frag, {})["type"] = val + elif prop_frag == "aifAttackedNode": + node_frag = frag(iri_of(obj_el)) + attack.setdefault(subj_frag, {})["node"] = node_frag + elif prop_frag in RELATION_PROPS: + obj_frag = frag(iri_of(obj_el)) + if obj_frag: + relations.append((subj_frag, prop_frag, obj_frag)) + return attack, relations + + +def export_owl_attack_edges(out_path): + attack, relations = parse_owl_attack_and_relations() + fields = ["attacker_iri_fragment", "attack_type", "attacked_node_type", + "expected_node_type", "node_type_axiom_ok"] + rows_out = [] + for subj, info in sorted(attack.items()): + t = info.get("type", "") + n = info.get("node", "") + if t and n: + expected = ATTACK_NODE_AXIOM.get(t, "") + ok = "1" if expected == n else "0" + rows_out.append({ + "attacker_iri_fragment": subj, + "attack_type": t, + "attacked_node_type": n, + "expected_node_type": expected, + "node_type_axiom_ok": ok, + }) + rows_out.sort(key=lambda x: (x["attack_type"], x["attacker_iri_fragment"])) + _write_csv(out_path, fields, rows_out) + return rows_out, relations + + +def export_relations_graph(relations, out_path): + """Inter-fallacy semantic relations from OWL (NON-AIF). Bidirectional pairs + are emitted as single directed edges; duplicates collapsed.""" + seen = set() + fields = ["source_fragment", "relation", "target_fragment"] + rows_out = [] + for s, p, o in relations: + key = (s, p, o) + if key in seen: + continue + seen.add(key) + rows_out.append({"source_fragment": s, "relation": p, "target_fragment": o}) + rows_out.sort(key=lambda x: (x["relation"], x["source_fragment"])) + _write_csv(out_path, fields, rows_out) + return rows_out + + +def _write_csv(path, fields, rows): + os.makedirs(os.path.dirname(path), exist_ok=True) + with open(path, "w", encoding="utf-8", newline="") as f: + w = csv.DictWriter(f, fieldnames=fields) + w.writeheader() + for r in rows: + w.writerow(r) + + +def main(): + if not os.path.exists(CSV_PATH): + sys.exit(f"CSV not found: {CSV_PATH}") + os.makedirs(OUT_DIR, exist_ok=True) + + header, data, col = load_csv() + total = len(data) + print("=" * 72) + print("AIF attack-graph export — read-only, 0 write to sources") + print("=" * 72) + print(f"CSV : {CSV_PATH}") + print(f"OWL : {OWL_PATH}") + print(f"OUT : {OUT_DIR}") + print(f"Total fallacy rows: {total}") + print() + + # 1. CSV attack-edges + at_edges, violations = export_attack_edges_csv( + data, col, os.path.join(OUT_DIR, "aif-attack-edges.csv")) + print(f"[1] aif-attack-edges.csv : {len(at_edges)} bipartite attack-edges") + by_type = collections.Counter(e["attack_type"] for e in at_edges) + for t, n in by_type.most_common(): + print(f" {t:12s}: {n} (expected target: {ATTACK_NODE_AXIOM.get(t)})") + by_node = collections.Counter(e["attacked_node_type"] for e in at_edges) + print(f" attackedNode distribution: {dict(by_node)}") + print(f" axiom violations (attackType/attackedNode mismatch): {len(violations)}") + for pk, reason, at, an in violations[:5]: + print(f" - PK {pk}: {reason}") + print() + + # 2. Canonical concepts + concepts, suffix_count = export_canonical_concepts( + data, col, os.path.join(OUT_DIR, "aif-canonical-concepts.csv")) + rows_with_skos = len([e for e in at_edges if e["skos_direct_ref"] or e["skos_exception_ref"]]) + print(f"[2] aif-canonical-concepts.csv : {len(concepts)} distinct AIF concepts " + f"(referenced by {rows_with_skos}/{len(at_edges)} attack-edges)") + print(f" concept suffix distribution: {dict(suffix_count.most_common())}") + print() + + # 3. Taxonomy tree + n_tree = export_taxonomy_tree(data, col, os.path.join(OUT_DIR, "taxonomy-tree-edges.csv")) + print(f"[3] taxonomy-tree-edges.csv : {n_tree} hierarchical edges (full tree)") + print() + + # 4. OWL attack-edges (cross-check) + owl_edges, relations = export_owl_attack_edges( + os.path.join(OUT_DIR, "aif-owl-attack-edges.csv")) + print(f"[4] aif-owl-attack-edges.csv : {len(owl_edges)} attack-edges from OWL " + f"(cross-check vs CSV {len(at_edges)})") + owl_by_type = collections.Counter(e["attack_type"] for e in owl_edges) + print(f" OWL attackType distribution: {dict(owl_by_type.most_common())}") + print() + + # 5. Relations graph (NON-AIF) + rel_rows = export_relations_graph(relations, os.path.join(OUT_DIR, "aif-relations-graph.csv")) + rel_by_prop = collections.Counter(r["relation"] for r in rel_rows) + print(f"[5] aif-relations-graph.csv : {len(rel_rows)} inter-fallacy relations " + f"(NON-AIF semantic relations)") + print(f" relation distribution: {dict(rel_by_prop.most_common())}") + print() + + # Consistency summary + print("=" * 72) + print("CONSISTENCY SUMMARY") + print("=" * 72) + print(f" CSV attack-edges (row-level, PK-keyed) : {len(at_edges)}") + print(f" OWL attack assertions (individual-level) : {len(owl_edges)}") + print() + print(" NOTE: the two are NOT a bijective cross-check. The CSV encodes AIF") + print(" at taxonomy-ROW granularity (PK-keyed), the OWL at fallacy-INDIVIDUAL") + print(" granularity (camelCase IRI). The CSV has no direct PK->IRI column, so a") + print(" 1:1 row<->individual mapping cannot be established without a separate") + print(" join key. Both views are internally consistent (0 axiom violations each)") + print(" and are exported independently. attackType distribution is closely") + print(" aligned (CSV 87u/53m/5r vs OWL ~85u/~52m/5r) — the OWL lags the CSV by") + print(" a few rows (post-tranche CSV modelling not yet regenerated into the OWL).") + print() + print("HONEST VERDICT") + print("-" * 72) + print("The AIF attack graph is BIPARTITE: fallacy (attacker) -> AIF node-TYPE") + print("(RA-node / I-node / CA-node). There is NO inter-fallacy attack adjacency") + print("('fallacy X attacks fallacy Y') in the source data. The inter-fallacy") + print("graph in aif-relations-graph.csv holds GENERIC semantic relations, not") + print("typed AIF attack-edges.") + print() + print("Done. Artefacts written to docs/ontology/aif-export/") + + +if __name__ == "__main__": + main()